arXiv:1502.02494 · Scientific Reports

Unraveling Quantum Annealers using Classical Hardness

Victor Martin-Mayor, Itay Hen

Published Oct 20, 2015• 61 citations

Abstract

Recent advances in quantum technology have led to the development and manufacturing of experimental programmable quantum annealing optimizers that contain hundreds of quantum bits. These optimizers, commonly referred to as 'D-Wave' chips, promise to solve practical optimization problems potentially faster than conventional 'classical' computers. Attempts to quantify the quantum nature of these chips have been met with both excitement and skepticism but have also brought up numerous fundamental questions pertaining to the distinguishability of experimental quantum annealers from their classical thermal counterparts. Inspired by recent results in spin-glass theory that recognize 'temperature chaos' as the underlying mechanism responsible for the computational intractability of hard optimization problems, we devise a general method to quantify the performance of quantum annealers on optimization problems suffering from varying degrees of temperature chaos: A superior performance of quantum annealers over classical algorithms on these may allude to the role that quantum effects play in providing speedup. We utilize our method to experimentally study the D-Wave Two chip on different temperature-chaotic problems and find, surprisingly, that its performance scales unfavorably as compared to several analogous classical algorithms. We detect, quantify and discuss several purely classical effects that possibly mask the quantum behavior of the chip.

DOI: 10.1038/srep15324

Related papers

Unraveling Quantum Annealers using Classical Hardness

Martín Mayor, Víctor, Itay Hen

Recent advances in quantum technology have led to the development and manufacturing of experimental programmable quantum annealing optimizers that contain hundreds of quantum bits. These optimizers, commonly referred to as 'D-Wave' chips, promise to solve practical optimization problems potentially faster than conventional 'classical' computers. Attempts to quantify the quantum nature of these chips have been met with both excitement and skepticism but have also brought up numerous fundamental questions pertaining to the distinguishability of experimental quantum annealers from their classical thermal counterparts. Inspired by recent results in spinglass theory that recognize 'temperature chaos' as the underlying mechanism responsible for the computational intractability of hard optimization problems, we devise a general method to quantify the performance of quantum annealers on optimization problems suffering from varying degrees of temperature chaos: A superior performance of quantum annealers over classical algorithms on these may allude to the role that quantum effects play in providing speedup. We utilize our method to experimentally study the D-Wave Two chip on different temperature-chaotic problems and find, surprisingly, that its performance scales unfavorably as compared to several analogous classical algorithms. We detect, quantify and discuss several purely classical effects that possibly mask the quantum behavior of the chip.

Oct 20, 201558 citations

A Medley of Ising Models; Monte Carlo Solutions and Machine Learning Applications

Demetrius Almada

Growing interest in quantum computers and artificial intelligence has fueled several innovations in recent years with regards to machine learning. With the construction of the first experimental quantum annealers by D-Wave, attaining the significant speedup provided by a quantum computer seems within reach. However, recent tests bring into question the degree to which these quantum effects are being utilized. The presence of temperature chaos when solving for the ground-state energy of a spin-glass system and the unfavorable scaling with classical hardness suggest that the D-Wave may really be a semiclassical machine. Using a state-of-the-art parallel tempering code and by using artificial neural networks and t-distributed stochastic neighbor embedding, we search for features in spin-glass instances that cause temperature chaos, and by extension attempt to gain some insight into the performance and scaling problems of the D-Wave quantum computer. As a result, we found that temperature chaos must be caused by structures deeper than the interactions themselves.

Jun 29, 20180 citations

Best-case performance of quantum annealers on native spin-glass benchmarks: How chaos can affect success probabilities

Zheng Zhu, Andrew J. Ochoa, Stefan Schnabel +2 more

Recent tests performed on the D-Wave Two quantum annealer have revealed no clear evidence of speedup over conventional silicon-based technologies. Here we present results from classical parallel-tempering Monte Carlo simulations combined with isoenergetic cluster moves of the archetypal benchmark problem---an Ising spin glass---on the native chip topology. Using realistic uncorrelated noise models for the D-Wave Two quantum annealer, we study the best-case resilience, i.e., the probability that the ground-state configuration is not affected by random fields and random-bond fluctuations found on the chip. We thus compute classical upper-bound success probabilities for different types of disorder used in the benchmarks and predict that an increase in the number of qubits will require either error correction schemes or a drastic reduction of the intrinsic noise found in these devices. We restrict this study to the exact ground state, however, the approach can be trivially extended to the inclusion of excited states if the success metric is relaxed. We outline strategies to develop robust, as well as hard benchmarks for quantum annealing devices, as well as any other (black box) computing paradigm affected by noise.

arXiv:1505.02278Physical Review AJan 11, 201675 citations

Nonstoquastic Hamiltonians and quantum annealing of an Ising spin glass

Layla Hormozi, Ethan Brown, Giuseppe Carleo +1 more

Quantum annealers are computing machines that utilize quantum effects to solve hard optimization problems. Understanding the circumstances under which quantum annealers are more efficient than other optimization methods is a challenging open problem. A clue to this conundrum comes from studying the complexity of quantum annealers. In general, the complexity of a physical system relates to how efficiently the system can be simulated by classical algorithms. One then asks: if some class of quantum annealers are hard to simulate classically, are they also more powerful optimization machines? Here, the authors study quantum annealers belonging to two different complexity classes: the so-called ``stoquastic'' systems, which can be efficiently simulated with classical algorithms, and ``nonstoquastic'' systems, currently with no efficient classical treatment. Applied to a prototypical optimization problem, the authors observe that, on average, the stoquastic systems perform better on easier instances of the problem, while the more complex nonstoquastic annealers show significant advantage when applied to the hardest instances. The authors conjecture that the performance of the nonstoquastic Hamiltonians is closely related to their internal structure during the annealing process and elucidate how properties such as magnetic frustration can play a key role in devising more powerful quantum annealers.

arXiv:1609.06558Physical review. B./Physical review. BMay 15, 201797 citations

Quantum Annealing: Research and Applications

Mayar Mohamed

This thesis studies several aspects of the quantum annealing (QA) computing approach. Quantum annealers' primary objective is to solve hard computational optimization problems. Because these optimization problems are in the NP-Hard complexity class, they are of great interest in several fields. One of the leading open questions concerning quantum annealers asks whether they will outperform other classical methods for solving these problems; Some aspects of this question are addressed in this thesis. The first part of the thesis investigates whether quantum annealing provides improved performance for solving a particular family of NP problems, called the Quadratic Knapsack Problem (QKP), using the D-Wave Quantum Annealer. The performance metrics used to assess QKP solving are the solution quality and the total runtime, and are benchmarked against other classical solvers. \n \nFurthermore, we extend our research on quantum annealers to propose two use cases for such systems. One is for Blockchain technology, and the second is in the area of quantum chaos. For the first use case of QA, an application for Blockchain's Proof of Work (PoW) is proposed, based on having hard optimization problems as an alternative to PoW hashing challenge, and using quantum annealers as solvers. For the second use case of QA, we propose simulating quantum chaos on the D-Wave Quantum Annealer to study the transition between the deep quantum realm and the classical limit in a chaotic system, and obtain insights into the “quantumness" of quantum annealers.

Sep 28, 20210 citations

Seeking Quantum Speedup Through Spin Glasses: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

Helmut G. Katzgraber, Firas Hamze, Zhu, Zheng +2 more

There has been considerable progress in the design and construction of quantum annealing devices. However, a conclusive detection of quantum speedup over traditional silicon-based machines remains elusive, despite multiple careful studies. In this work we outline strategies to design hard tunable benchmark instances based on insights from the study of spin glasses - the archetypal random benchmark problem for novel algorithms and optimization devices. We propose to complement head-to-head scaling studies that compare quantum annealing machines to state-of-the-art classical codes with an approach that compares the performance of different algorithms and/or computing architectures on different classes of computationally hard tunable spin-glass instances. The advantage of such an approach lies in having to only compare the performance hit felt by a given algorithm and/or architecture when the instance complexity is increased. Furthermore, we propose a methodology that might not directly translate into the detection of quantum speedup, but might elucidate whether quantum annealing has a "`quantum advantage" over corresponding classical algorithms like simulated annealing. Our results on a 496 qubit D-Wave Two quantum annealing device are compared to recently-used state-of-the-art thermal simulated annealing codes.

Jan 1, 201586 citations