Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1501.06961 · Physical Review A

Mutual information and spontaneous symmetry breaking

Alioscia Hamma, S. M. Giampaolo, Fabrizio Illuminati

Published Jan 4, 2016• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that the metastable, symmetry-breaking ground states of quantum many-body Hamiltonians have vanishing quantum mutual information between macroscopically separated regions and are thus the most classical ones among all possible quantum ground states. This statement is obvious only when the symmetry-breaking ground states are simple product states, e.g., at the factorization point. On the other hand, symmetry-breaking states are in general entangled along the entire ordered phase, and to show that they actually feature the least macroscopic correlations compared to their symmetric superpositions is highly nontrivial. We prove this result in general, by considering the quantum mutual information based on the two-R\'enyi entanglement entropy and using a locality result stemming from quasiadiabatic continuation. Moreover, in the paradigmatic case of the exactly solvable one-dimensional quantum $XY$ model, we further verify the general result by considering also the quantum mutual information based on the von Neumann entanglement entropy.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.93.012303

Related papers

Spontaneous symmetry breaking and macroscopic entanglement

Alioscia Hamma, S. M. Giampaolo, Fabrizio Illuminati

In the presence of interactions with the environment, decoherence selects stable classical states, the pointer states, while suppressing arbitrary macroscopic coherent superpositions. In close analogy, the metastable symmetry-breaking ground states of many-body Hamiltonians should be the ones with the least macroscopic entanglement and thus the most classical ones among all possible quantum ground states. By considering the mutual information based on the 2-Renyi entanglement entropy and using a locality result, we show that symmetry-breaking states have the least macroscopic entanglement and, consequently, that they are the ones selected in real world by environmental decoherence.

•Jan 28, 2015•0 citations

Classical nature of ordered quantum phases and origin of spontaneous symmetry breaking

Marco Cianciaruso, S. M. Giampaolo, Ferro, L. +4 more

We analyse the nature of spontaneous symmetry breaking in complex quantum systems by investigating the long-standing conjecture that the maximally symmetry-breaking quantum ground states are the most classical ones corresponding to a globally ordered phase. We make this argument quantitatively precise by comparing different local and global indicators of classicality and quantumness, respectively in symmetry-breaking and symmetry-preserving quantum ground states. We first discuss how naively comparing local, pairwise entanglement and discord apparently leads to the opposite conclusion. Indeed, we show that in symmetry-preserving ground states the two-body entanglement captures only a modest portion of the total two-body quantum correlations, while, on the contrary, in maximally symmetry-breaking ground states it contributes the largest amount to the total two-body quantum correlations. We then put to test the conjecture by looking at the global, macroscopic correlation properties of quantum ground states. We prove that the ground states which realize the maximum breaking of the Hamiltonian symmetries, associated to a globally ordered phase, are the only ones that: I) are always locally convertible, i.e. can be obtained from all other ground states by only applying LOCC transformations (local operations and classical communication), while the reverse is never possible; II) minimize the monogamy inequality on the globally shared, macroscopic bipartite entanglement.

arXiv:1604.06403•Apr 21, 2016•0 citations

Classical nature of ordered phases: origin of spontaneous symmetry breaking

Marco Cianciaruso, Ferro, L., S. M. Giampaolo +2 more

We investigate the nature of spontaneous symmetry breaking in complex quantum systems by conjecturing that the maximally symmetry breaking quantum ground states are the most classical ones corresponding to an ordered phase. We make this argument quantitatively precise by showing that the ground states which realize the maximum breaking of the Hamiltonian symmetries are the only ones that: I) are always locally convertible, i.e. can be obtained from all other ground states by local operations and classical communication, while the reverse is never possible; II) minimize the monogamy inequality for bipartite entanglement; III) minimize quantum correlations, as measured by the quantum discord, for all pairs of dynamical variables and are the only ground states for which the pairwise quantum correlations vanish asymptotically with the intra-pair distance.

arXiv:1408.1412•Aug 6, 2014•2 citations

Symmetry Breaking and Finite Size Effects in Quantum Many-Body Systems 1

Tohru Koma, Hal Tasaki

We consider a quantum many-body system on a lattice which exhibits a spontaneous symmetry breaking in its infinite volume ground states, but in which the corresponding order operator does not commute with the Hamiltonian. Typical examples are the Heisenberg antiferromagnet with a Néel order, and the Hubbard model with a (superconducting) off-diagonal long range order. In the corresponding finite system, the symmetry breaking is usually “obscured ” by “quantum fluctuation ” and one gets a symmetric ground state with a long range order. In such a situation, Horsch and von der Linden proved that the finite system has a low-lying eigenstate whose excitation energy is not more than of order N −1, where N denotes the number of the sites in the lattice. Here we study the situation where the broken symmetry is a continuous one. For a particular set of states (which are orthogonal to the ground state and with each other), we prove bounds for their energy expectation values. The bounds establish that there exist ever increasing numbers of low-lying eigenstates whose excitation energies are bounded by a constant times N −1. A crucial feature of the particular low-lying

•Jan 1, 1997•51 citations

Entanglement patterns and generalized correlation functions in quantum many-body systems

Gergely Barcza, R. M. Noack, Jenő Sólyom +1 more

We introduce transition operators that in a given basis of the single-site states of a many-body system have a single nonvanishing matrix element and introduce their correlation functions. We show that they fall into groups that decay with the same rate. The mutual information defined in terms of the von Neumann entropy between two sites is given in terms of these so-called generalized correlation functions. We confirm numerically that the long-distance decay of the mutual information follows the square of that of the most slowly decaying generalized correlation function. The main advantage of our procedure is that, in order to identify the most relevant physical processes, there is no need to know a priori the nature of the ordering in the system, i.e., no need to explicitly construct particular physical correlation functions. We explore the behavior of the mutual information and the generalized correlation functions for comformally invariant models and for the $\text{SU}(n)$ Hubbard model with $n=2,3,4$, and 5, which are, in general, not conformally invariant. In this latter case, we show that for filling $f=1/q$ and $q<n$, the ground state consists of highly entangled $q$-site units that are further entangled by single bonds. In addition, we extend the picture of the two-site mutual information and the corresponding generalized correlation functions to the $n$-site case.

arXiv:1406.6643•Physical Review B•Sep 22, 2015•38 citations

Dynamics of quantum many-body systems out of equilibrium

Konstantinos Chalas

The characterization of the dynamical structure of quantum many-body systems is an important and very active endeavor both experimentally and theoretically. Several tools, such as quantum-information theoretic observables and spectral measures, provide a powerful lens for characterizing correlations and their dynamics in quantum many-body systems. These quantities can reveal important features of experimentally realizable systems and provide insight into their control and dynamical behaviour. This thesis investigates nonequilibrium settings in which the spreading and redistribution of quantum correlations exhibit unconventional behaviour, with particular emphasis on the role of extended-range correlations. We consider two main classes of systems: lattice models undergoing quantum quenches and central-spin models motivated by experimental applications. For lattice systems, we study the dynamics of entanglement and local symmetry breaking in free fermionic and bosonic models, interacting integrable systems, and quantum circuits. We first investigate symmetry restoration following quenches from ground states of long-range fermionic Hamiltonians. We show that two states undergoing symmetry restoration can exhibit multiple inversions, manifested through multiple crossings of the distance measure, implying either the evasion of the quantum Mpemba effect or a more intricate route to its occurrence. This demonstrates that anomalous relaxation is not restricted to short times and can be understood through the momentum-dependent distribution and velocities of quasiparticle excitations. We then study quenches from initial states possessing extensive, spatially organized entanglement, moving beyond the conventional setting of weakly entangled initial states. For crosscap states, characterized by antipodal correlations and volume-law entanglement entropy, we uncover unconventional entanglement dynamics and formulate an antipodal quasiparticle picture in which initially entangled degrees of freedom originate from macroscopically separated points. We subsequently generalize this construction to entangled multipodal states, whose polygon-like correlation structure produces richer equilibrium and dynamical entanglement patterns. We further investigate charge-deformed crosscap states and show that their local symmetry-breaking dynamics can display the unusual phenomenon of dynamical symmetry breaking under symmetry-preserving evolution. Finally, we extend the crosscap construction to bosonic systems and describe the dynamics of the entanglement entropy, mutual information, and logarithmic negativity within a corresponding quasiparticle framework. The second class of systems considered concerns central-spin models and their application to quantum memories in semiconductor quantum dots. We investigate how disorder in couplings and frequencies modifies collective many-body dynamics and affects the storage and retrieval of quantum information. Using spectral, dynamical, and information-theoretic diagnostics, we characterize the resulting dynamical regimes and relate the loss of collectivity and the spreading of information through the spin bath to the performance of quantum-memory protocols. Overall, the results demonstrate how extended-range correlations, whether encoded in an initial state or generated by the interaction structure, can qualitatively reshape entanglement spreading, symmetry dynamics, and information retention in nonequilibrium quantum many-body systems.

•Sep 21, 2026•0 citations
We show that the metastable, symmetry-breaking ground states of quantum many-body Hamiltonians have vanishing quantum mutual information between macroscopically separated regions and are thus the most classical ones among all possible quantum ground states. This statement is obvious only when the symmetry-breaking ground states are simple product states, e.g., at the factorization point. On the other hand, symmetry-breaking states are in general entangled along the entire ordered phase, and to show that they actually feature the least macroscopic correlations compared to their symmetric superpositions is highly nontrivial. We prove this result in general, by considering the quantum mutual information based on the two-R'enyi entanglement entropy and using a locality result stemming from quasiadiabatic continuation. Moreover, in the paradigmatic case of the exactly solvable one-dimensional quantum XYXYXY model, we further verify the general result by considering also the quantum mutual information based on the von Neumann entanglement entropy.
In the presence of interactions with the environment, decoherence selects stable classical states, the pointer states, while suppressing arbitrary macroscopic coherent superpositions. In close analogy, the metastable symmetry-breaking ground states of many-body Hamiltonians should be the ones with the least macroscopic entanglement and thus the most classical ones among all possible quantum ground states. By considering the mutual information based on the 2-Renyi entanglement entropy and using a locality result, we show that symmetry-breaking states have the least macroscopic entanglement and, consequently, that they are the ones selected in real world by environmental decoherence.
We analyse the nature of spontaneous symmetry breaking in complex quantum systems by investigating the long-standing conjecture that the maximally symmetry-breaking quantum ground states are the most classical ones corresponding to a globally ordered phase. We make this argument quantitatively precise by comparing different local and global indicators of classicality and quantumness, respectively in symmetry-breaking and symmetry-preserving quantum ground states. We first discuss how naively comparing local, pairwise entanglement and discord apparently leads to the opposite conclusion. Indeed, we show that in symmetry-preserving ground states the two-body entanglement captures only a modest portion of the total two-body quantum correlations, while, on the contrary, in maximally symmetry-breaking ground states it contributes the largest amount to the total two-body quantum correlations. We then put to test the conjecture by looking at the global, macroscopic correlation properties of quantum ground states. We prove that the ground states which realize the maximum breaking of the Hamiltonian symmetries, associated to a globally ordered phase, are the only ones that: I) are always locally convertible, i.e. can be obtained from all other ground states by only applying LOCC transformations (local operations and classical communication), while the reverse is never possible; II) minimize the monogamy inequality on the globally shared, macroscopic bipartite entanglement.
We investigate the nature of spontaneous symmetry breaking in complex quantum systems by conjecturing that the maximally symmetry breaking quantum ground states are the most classical ones corresponding to an ordered phase. We make this argument quantitatively precise by showing that the ground states which realize the maximum breaking of the Hamiltonian symmetries are the only ones that: I) are always locally convertible, i.e. can be obtained from all other ground states by local operations and classical communication, while the reverse is never possible; II) minimize the monogamy inequality for bipartite entanglement; III) minimize quantum correlations, as measured by the quantum discord, for all pairs of dynamical variables and are the only ground states for which the pairwise quantum correlations vanish asymptotically with the intra-pair distance.
We consider a quantum many-body system on a lattice which exhibits a spontaneous symmetry breaking in its infinite volume ground states, but in which the corresponding order operator does not commute with the Hamiltonian. Typical examples are the Heisenberg antiferromagnet with a Néel order, and the Hubbard model with a (superconducting) off-diagonal long range order. In the corresponding finite system, the symmetry breaking is usually “obscured ” by “quantum fluctuation ” and one gets a symmetric ground state with a long range order. In such a situation, Horsch and von der Linden proved that the finite system has a low-lying eigenstate whose excitation energy is not more than of order N −1, where N denotes the number of the sites in the lattice. Here we study the situation where the broken symmetry is a continuous one. For a particular set of states (which are orthogonal to the ground state and with each other), we prove bounds for their energy expectation values. The bounds establish that there exist ever increasing numbers of low-lying eigenstates whose excitation energies are bounded by a constant times N −1. A crucial feature of the particular low-lying
We introduce transition operators that in a given basis of the single-site states of a many-body system have a single nonvanishing matrix element and introduce their correlation functions. We show that they fall into groups that decay with the same rate. The mutual information defined in terms of the von Neumann entropy between two sites is given in terms of these so-called generalized correlation functions. We confirm numerically that the long-distance decay of the mutual information follows the square of that of the most slowly decaying generalized correlation function. The main advantage of our procedure is that, in order to identify the most relevant physical processes, there is no need to know a priori the nature of the ordering in the system, i.e., no need to explicitly construct particular physical correlation functions. We explore the behavior of the mutual information and the generalized correlation functions for comformally invariant models and for the SU(n)\text{SU}(n)SU(n) Hubbard model with n=2,3,4n=2,3,4n=2,3,4, and 5, which are, in general, not conformally invariant. In this latter case, we show that for filling f=1/qf=1/qf=1/q and q<nq<nq<n, the ground state consists of highly entangled qqq-site units that are further entangled by single bonds. In addition, we extend the picture of the two-site mutual information and the corresponding generalized correlation functions to the nnn-site case.
The characterization of the dynamical structure of quantum many-body systems is an important and very active endeavor both experimentally and theoretically. Several tools, such as quantum-information theoretic observables and spectral measures, provide a powerful lens for characterizing correlations and their dynamics in quantum many-body systems. These quantities can reveal important features of experimentally realizable systems and provide insight into their control and dynamical behaviour. This thesis investigates nonequilibrium settings in which the spreading and redistribution of quantum correlations exhibit unconventional behaviour, with particular emphasis on the role of extended-range correlations. We consider two main classes of systems: lattice models undergoing quantum quenches and central-spin models motivated by experimental applications. For lattice systems, we study the dynamics of entanglement and local symmetry breaking in free fermionic and bosonic models, interacting integrable systems, and quantum circuits. We first investigate symmetry restoration following quenches from ground states of long-range fermionic Hamiltonians. We show that two states undergoing symmetry restoration can exhibit multiple inversions, manifested through multiple crossings of the distance measure, implying either the evasion of the quantum Mpemba effect or a more intricate route to its occurrence. This demonstrates that anomalous relaxation is not restricted to short times and can be understood through the momentum-dependent distribution and velocities of quasiparticle excitations. We then study quenches from initial states possessing extensive, spatially organized entanglement, moving beyond the conventional setting of weakly entangled initial states. For crosscap states, characterized by antipodal correlations and volume-law entanglement entropy, we uncover unconventional entanglement dynamics and formulate an antipodal quasiparticle picture in which initially entangled degrees of freedom originate from macroscopically separated points. We subsequently generalize this construction to entangled multipodal states, whose polygon-like correlation structure produces richer equilibrium and dynamical entanglement patterns. We further investigate charge-deformed crosscap states and show that their local symmetry-breaking dynamics can display the unusual phenomenon of dynamical symmetry breaking under symmetry-preserving evolution. Finally, we extend the crosscap construction to bosonic systems and describe the dynamics of the entanglement entropy, mutual information, and logarithmic negativity within a corresponding quasiparticle framework. The second class of systems considered concerns central-spin models and their application to quantum memories in semiconductor quantum dots. We investigate how disorder in couplings and frequencies modifies collective many-body dynamics and affects the storage and retrieval of quantum information. Using spectral, dynamical, and information-theoretic diagnostics, we characterize the resulting dynamical regimes and relate the loss of collectivity and the spreading of information through the spin bath to the performance of quantum-memory protocols. Overall, the results demonstrate how extended-range correlations, whether encoded in an initial state or generated by the interaction structure, can qualitatively reshape entanglement spreading, symmetry dynamics, and information retention in nonequilibrium quantum many-body systems.