Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1407.0994 · Physical Review B

Tensor network implementation of bulk entanglement spectrum

Timothy H. Hsieh, Liang Fu, Xiao-Liang Qi

Published Aug 25, 2014• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Many topologically nontrivial states of matter possess gapless degrees of freedom on the boundary, and when these boundary states delocalize into the bulk, a phase transition occurs, and the system becomes topologically trivial. We show that tensor networks provide a natural framework for analyzing such topological phase transitions in terms of the boundary degrees of freedom which mediate it. To do so, we make use of a correspondence between a topologically nontrivial ground state and its phase transition to a trivial phase established in T. Hsieh and L. Fu (arXiv:1305.1949). This involved computing the bulk entanglement spectrum (BES) of the ground state upon tracing out an extensive subsystem. This work implements BES via tensor network representations of ground states. In this framework, the universality class of the quantum critical entanglement Hamiltonian in $d$ spatial dimensions is either derived analytically or mapped to a classical statistical model in $d+1$ dimensions, which can be studied using Monte Carlo or tensor renormalization-group methods. As an example, we analytically derive the universality classes of topological phase transitions from the spin-1 chain Haldane phase and demonstrate that the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki (AKLT) wave function (and its generalizations) remarkably contains critical six-vertex (and, in general, eight-vertex) models within it.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.90.085137

Related papers

Symmetries & tensor networks in two-dimensional quantum physics

Henrik Dreyer

The most general description of a quantum many-body system is given by a wave- function that lives in a Hilbert space with dimension exponential in the number of particles. This makes it extremely hard to study strongly correlated phenomena like the fractional quantum Hall effect and high-temperature superconductivity. Whenever interactions are sufficiently local and temperature is low, the system does not explore the full Hilbert space, but its ground state resides in the small corner of Hilbert space described by the area law. Containing little entanglement, the states can then be expressed as tensor networks, a family of wavefunctions with a polynomial number of parameters. On the one hand, tensor networks can be used as a variational manifold in nu- merical computations. On the other hand, they allow building model wavefunctions much like locality allows writing down physically realistic Hamiltonians. Besides allowing for an analytical treatment, these models grant access both to the physical and the entanglement degrees of freedom. This is particularly useful in classifying phases of matter. A large number of phases can be explained in terms of Landau’s symmetry-breaking paradigm. This framework, however, is not complete, as exemplified by the existence of phases with intrinsic topological order in two dimensions. It was a major conceptual advance when tensor networks could explain (non-chiral) topological phases as those where the symmetry resides in the entanglement degrees of freedom. The symmetries corresponding to those topological phases act as discrete, finite groups on the virtual degrees of freedom. The purpose of this Thesis is to generalize this program to include other symmetries. We investigate a class of tensor networks with continuous symmetries and find that they cannot describe gapped physics with a unique ground state. The abelian case is found to describe a non-Lorentz invariant phase transition point into a topologically ordered phase. The physics of the non- abelian case is that of a plaquette state that spontaneously breaks the translation symmetry of the lattice. The non-abelian PEPS arises as the ground state of a local parent Hamiltonian whose ground state manifold is completely characterized by the tensor network. In both cases, we find two types of corrections to the entanglement entropy: first there is a correction that is logarithmic in the size of the boundary and independent of the shape. A further correction depends only on the shape of the partition, imposing further restrictions on regions that are suffciently thin. Finally, we investigate symmetries that mix the virtual with the physical degrees of freedom and are furthermore anisotropic. Their physics is described by subsystem symmetry protected topological order. In particular, we focus on the entanglement entropy in the cluster phase and show that there is a universal constant correction to the entropy throughout the phase. This is important in the program of establishing the entanglement entropy as a detection mechanism for topologically ordered phases. We put forward a numerical algorithm to compute the correction and use it to discover a novel phase of matter in which the cluster phase is embedded.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Decoding quantum criticality from fermionic/parafermionic topological states

Ziqi Wang, Guoyi Zhu, Guang-Ming Zhang

Under an appropriate symmetric bulk bipartition in a one-dimensional symmetry protected topological phase with the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki matrix product state wave function for the odd integer spin chains, a bulk critical entanglement spectrum can be obtained, describing the excitation spectrum of the critical point separating the topological phase from the trivial state with the same symmetry. Such a critical point is beyond the standard Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm for symmetry-breaking phase transitions. Recently, the framework of matrix product states for topological phases with Majorana fermions/parafermions has been established. Here we first generalize these fixed-point matrix product states with the zero correlation length to the more generic ground-state wave functions with a finite correlation length for the general one-dimensional interacting Majorana fermion/parafermion systems. Then we employ the previous method to decode quantum criticality to the interacting Majorana fermion/parafermion matrix product states. The obtained quantum critical spectra are described by the conformal field theories with central charge $c\ensuremath{\le}1$, characterizing the quantum critical theories separating the fermionic/parafermionic topological phase from the trivial phases with the same symmetry.

arXiv:1802.04542•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 25, 2018•4 citations

Topological Phenomena in Tensor Network States of Quantum Spin Systems

Mohsin Iqbal, Norbert Schuch, Stefan Weßel

The focus of our investigations in this thesis is quantum spin systems in two dimensions. We examine phase transitions between topologically distinct phases of quantum matter using the framework of tensor network states. We study the phenomena of anyon condensation and confinement in the context of tensor network states where these two notions offer a robust probe to characterize the universal features of quantum phase transitions. We do a comprehensive study of the numerical methods enabled by the tensor network formalism for the study of quantum phase transitions. We map out the phase diagram of certain exotic phases of quantum matter (namely the $D(\\mathbb{Z}_4)$ quantum double, the toric code, and the double semion model) and identify the order and the universality classes of the phase transitions between these distinct topological phases. We analyze the phase boundaries of the toric code and the double semion model which exhibit first and second order phase transitions. We investigate the class of $\\mathbb{Z}_2$-invariant tensor network states while taking in to account the spin rotation and lattice symmetries. The resulting tensor network states allow us to map the phase diagram of $\\mathbb{Z}_2$ spin liquids. The behavior of the system at the phase boundaries of $\\mathbb{Z}_2$ spin liquid is governed by the condensation of spinons and visions. We also present our preliminary findings regarding the $\\mathbb{Z}_4$-invariant tensors with $SU(2)$ symmetry. This approach enables us to study the spin liquid states of the toric code and the double semion model in a unified framework. We give a local tensor description for the approximate ground states of the Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice by using the variational manifolds of just three and five parameters in the gapped $\\mathbb{Z}_2$ spin liquid phase. The approximation of the ground states we construct have an energy density that is remarkably close to the results from the state-of-the-art density matrix renormalization group and the exact diagonalization method. By analyzing the deconfinement of anyonic excitations, we also present our findings regarding the vicinity of the variational ground state in gapped $\\mathbb{Z}_2$ spin liquid phase.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Critical-entanglement spectrum of one-dimensional symmetry-protected topological phases

Wen-Jia Rao, Xin Wan, Guang-Ming Zhang

Under an appropriate symmetric extensive bipartition in a one-dimensional symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phase, a bulk critical-entanglement spectrum can be obtained, resembling the excitation spectrum of the critical point separating the SPT phase from the trivial (vacuum) state. Such a critical point is beyond the standard Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm for symmetry-breaking phase transitions. For the $S=1$ SPT (Haldane) phase with the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki exact wave function, the resulting critical-entanglement spectrum has a residual entropy per lattice site ${s}_{r}=0.67602$, showing a delocalized version of the edge excitations in the SPT phase. From the wave function corresponding to the lowest entanglement energy level, the central charge of the critical point can be extracted $c\ensuremath{\approx}1.01\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.01$. The critical theory can be identified as the same effective field theory as the spin-1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain or the spin-1/2 Haldane-Shastry model with inverse-square long-range interaction.

arXiv:1406.7113•Physical Review B•Aug 28, 2014•25 citations

Tensor Network Representations for Intrinsically Mixed-State Topological Orders

Bader H. Aldossari, Blinov, Sergey, Zhu-Xi Luo

Tensor networks are an efficient platform for representing topological states of matter as well as computing both physical observables and information-theoretic quantities. We present a general protocol to construct tensor network representations for intrinsically mixed-state topological phases. Such phases naturally emerge in noisy long-range entangled quantum systems, and exhibit nontrivial topological phenomena without pure-state counterparts. The method exploits the isomorphism between anyon decoherence in the physical Hilbert space and anyon condensation in the corresponding Choi space. The protocol is applicable to a broad class of systems arising from decoherence of pure-state topological phases, where the incoherent noise creates excitations in the Choi space that have trivial monodromy with all excitations. Representative examples at renormalization group fixed points include $m^a e^b$ decoherence in the $\Z_N$ toric code, decohered non-Abelian quantum double of $S_3$ as well as pure $Z$/$X$ decoherence of arbitrary CSS codes. Another notable example is that of the mixed-state chiral semion, whose tensor network representation has no pure-state analogue. We then generalize the formalism beyond RG fixed points and, as an example, examine the decoherence transition in a $\mathbb{Z}_3$ toric code channel that suffers from sign problem when mapped to a statistical mechanical model. Together, these results establish tensor networks as a natural platform for analyzing noisy intrinsically mixed-state topological matter.

arXiv:2507.22989•Jul 30, 2025•0 citations

Entanglement spectrum of gapless topological phases: A case study with topological superconductors

Archi Banerjee, Meng Zeng

Using bulk gapless topological superconductors in both 1D and 2D as free fermion model examples, we demonstrate the power of subsystem correlation spectrum (the spectrum of correlation matrix), or equivalently the entanglement spectrum for the case of free fermions, in characterizing the topology of the nontrivial ground state. For the systems considered, we show that signatures of the low-energy spectrum, including both the edge modes and the bulk modes, appear in the correlation spectrum, albeit with different behaviors. This work generalizes the 2D Li-Haldane entanglement spectrum characterization of topological edge states to 2D topological systems with gapless bulk.

arXiv:2510.13045•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 22, 2026•1 citation
Many topologically nontrivial states of matter possess gapless degrees of freedom on the boundary, and when these boundary states delocalize into the bulk, a phase transition occurs, and the system becomes topologically trivial. We show that tensor networks provide a natural framework for analyzing such topological phase transitions in terms of the boundary degrees of freedom which mediate it. To do so, we make use of a correspondence between a topologically nontrivial ground state and its phase transition to a trivial phase established in T. Hsieh and L. Fu (arXiv:1305.1949). This involved computing the bulk entanglement spectrum (BES) of the ground state upon tracing out an extensive subsystem. This work implements BES via tensor network representations of ground states. In this framework, the universality class of the quantum critical entanglement Hamiltonian in ddd spatial dimensions is either derived analytically or mapped to a classical statistical model in d+1d+1d+1 dimensions, which can be studied using Monte Carlo or tensor renormalization-group methods. As an example, we analytically derive the universality classes of topological phase transitions from the spin-1 chain Haldane phase and demonstrate that the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki (AKLT) wave function (and its generalizations) remarkably contains critical six-vertex (and, in general, eight-vertex) models within it.
The most general description of a quantum many-body system is given by a wave- function that lives in a Hilbert space with dimension exponential in the number of particles. This makes it extremely hard to study strongly correlated phenomena like the fractional quantum Hall effect and high-temperature superconductivity. Whenever interactions are sufficiently local and temperature is low, the system does not explore the full Hilbert space, but its ground state resides in the small corner of Hilbert space described by the area law. Containing little entanglement, the states can then be expressed as tensor networks, a family of wavefunctions with a polynomial number of parameters. On the one hand, tensor networks can be used as a variational manifold in nu- merical computations. On the other hand, they allow building model wavefunctions much like locality allows writing down physically realistic Hamiltonians. Besides allowing for an analytical treatment, these models grant access both to the physical and the entanglement degrees of freedom. This is particularly useful in classifying phases of matter. A large number of phases can be explained in terms of Landau’s symmetry-breaking paradigm. This framework, however, is not complete, as exemplified by the existence of phases with intrinsic topological order in two dimensions. It was a major conceptual advance when tensor networks could explain (non-chiral) topological phases as those where the symmetry resides in the entanglement degrees of freedom. The symmetries corresponding to those topological phases act as discrete, finite groups on the virtual degrees of freedom. The purpose of this Thesis is to generalize this program to include other symmetries. We investigate a class of tensor networks with continuous symmetries and find that they cannot describe gapped physics with a unique ground state. The abelian case is found to describe a non-Lorentz invariant phase transition point into a topologically ordered phase. The physics of the non- abelian case is that of a plaquette state that spontaneously breaks the translation symmetry of the lattice. The non-abelian PEPS arises as the ground state of a local parent Hamiltonian whose ground state manifold is completely characterized by the tensor network. In both cases, we find two types of corrections to the entanglement entropy: first there is a correction that is logarithmic in the size of the boundary and independent of the shape. A further correction depends only on the shape of the partition, imposing further restrictions on regions that are suffciently thin. Finally, we investigate symmetries that mix the virtual with the physical degrees of freedom and are furthermore anisotropic. Their physics is described by subsystem symmetry protected topological order. In particular, we focus on the entanglement entropy in the cluster phase and show that there is a universal constant correction to the entropy throughout the phase. This is important in the program of establishing the entanglement entropy as a detection mechanism for topologically ordered phases. We put forward a numerical algorithm to compute the correction and use it to discover a novel phase of matter in which the cluster phase is embedded.
Under an appropriate symmetric bulk bipartition in a one-dimensional symmetry protected topological phase with the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki matrix product state wave function for the odd integer spin chains, a bulk critical entanglement spectrum can be obtained, describing the excitation spectrum of the critical point separating the topological phase from the trivial state with the same symmetry. Such a critical point is beyond the standard Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm for symmetry-breaking phase transitions. Recently, the framework of matrix product states for topological phases with Majorana fermions/parafermions has been established. Here we first generalize these fixed-point matrix product states with the zero correlation length to the more generic ground-state wave functions with a finite correlation length for the general one-dimensional interacting Majorana fermion/parafermion systems. Then we employ the previous method to decode quantum criticality to the interacting Majorana fermion/parafermion matrix product states. The obtained quantum critical spectra are described by the conformal field theories with central charge $c\ensuremath{\le}1$, characterizing the quantum critical theories separating the fermionic/parafermionic topological phase from the trivial phases with the same symmetry.
The focus of our investigations in this thesis is quantum spin systems in two dimensions. We examine phase transitions between topologically distinct phases of quantum matter using the framework of tensor network states. We study the phenomena of anyon condensation and confinement in the context of tensor network states where these two notions offer a robust probe to characterize the universal features of quantum phase transitions. We do a comprehensive study of the numerical methods enabled by the tensor network formalism for the study of quantum phase transitions. We map out the phase diagram of certain exotic phases of quantum matter (namely the D(mathbbZ4)D(\\mathbb{Z}_4)D(mathbbZ4​) quantum double, the toric code, and the double semion model) and identify the order and the universality classes of the phase transitions between these distinct topological phases. We analyze the phase boundaries of the toric code and the double semion model which exhibit first and second order phase transitions. We investigate the class of mathbbZ2\\mathbb{Z}_2mathbbZ2​-invariant tensor network states while taking in to account the spin rotation and lattice symmetries. The resulting tensor network states allow us to map the phase diagram of mathbbZ2\\mathbb{Z}_2mathbbZ2​ spin liquids. The behavior of the system at the phase boundaries of mathbbZ2\\mathbb{Z}_2mathbbZ2​ spin liquid is governed by the condensation of spinons and visions. We also present our preliminary findings regarding the mathbbZ4\\mathbb{Z}_4mathbbZ4​-invariant tensors with SU(2)SU(2)SU(2) symmetry. This approach enables us to study the spin liquid states of the toric code and the double semion model in a unified framework. We give a local tensor description for the approximate ground states of the Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice by using the variational manifolds of just three and five parameters in the gapped mathbbZ2\\mathbb{Z}_2mathbbZ2​ spin liquid phase. The approximation of the ground states we construct have an energy density that is remarkably close to the results from the state-of-the-art density matrix renormalization group and the exact diagonalization method. By analyzing the deconfinement of anyonic excitations, we also present our findings regarding the vicinity of the variational ground state in gapped mathbbZ2\\mathbb{Z}_2mathbbZ2​ spin liquid phase.
Under an appropriate symmetric extensive bipartition in a one-dimensional symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phase, a bulk critical-entanglement spectrum can be obtained, resembling the excitation spectrum of the critical point separating the SPT phase from the trivial (vacuum) state. Such a critical point is beyond the standard Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm for symmetry-breaking phase transitions. For the S=1S=1S=1 SPT (Haldane) phase with the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki exact wave function, the resulting critical-entanglement spectrum has a residual entropy per lattice site sr=0.67602{s}_{r}=0.67602sr​=0.67602, showing a delocalized version of the edge excitations in the SPT phase. From the wave function corresponding to the lowest entanglement energy level, the central charge of the critical point can be extracted $c\ensuremath{\approx}1.01\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.01$. The critical theory can be identified as the same effective field theory as the spin-1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain or the spin-1/2 Haldane-Shastry model with inverse-square long-range interaction.
Tensor networks are an efficient platform for representing topological states of matter as well as computing both physical observables and information-theoretic quantities. We present a general protocol to construct tensor network representations for intrinsically mixed-state topological phases. Such phases naturally emerge in noisy long-range entangled quantum systems, and exhibit nontrivial topological phenomena without pure-state counterparts. The method exploits the isomorphism between anyon decoherence in the physical Hilbert space and anyon condensation in the corresponding Choi space. The protocol is applicable to a broad class of systems arising from decoherence of pure-state topological phases, where the incoherent noise creates excitations in the Choi space that have trivial monodromy with all excitations. Representative examples at renormalization group fixed points include maebm^a e^bmaeb decoherence in the ZN\Z_NZN​ toric code, decohered non-Abelian quantum double of S3S_3S3​ as well as pure ZZZ/XXX decoherence of arbitrary CSS codes. Another notable example is that of the mixed-state chiral semion, whose tensor network representation has no pure-state analogue. We then generalize the formalism beyond RG fixed points and, as an example, examine the decoherence transition in a Z3\mathbb{Z}_3Z3​ toric code channel that suffers from sign problem when mapped to a statistical mechanical model. Together, these results establish tensor networks as a natural platform for analyzing noisy intrinsically mixed-state topological matter.
Using bulk gapless topological superconductors in both 1D and 2D as free fermion model examples, we demonstrate the power of subsystem correlation spectrum (the spectrum of correlation matrix), or equivalently the entanglement spectrum for the case of free fermions, in characterizing the topology of the nontrivial ground state. For the systems considered, we show that signatures of the low-energy spectrum, including both the edge modes and the bulk modes, appear in the correlation spectrum, albeit with different behaviors. This work generalizes the 2D Li-Haldane entanglement spectrum characterization of topological edge states to 2D topological systems with gapless bulk.