Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1403.0452 · Physical Review A

Ehrenfest principle and unitary dynamics of quantum-classical systems with general potential interaction

Milan Radonjić, Duska B Popovic, Slobodan Prvanović, Nikola Burić

Published Feb 28, 2014• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Representation of classical dynamics by unitary transformations has been used to develop a unified description of hybrid classical-quantum systems with a particular type of interaction, and to formulate abstract systems interpolating between classical and quantum ones. We solved the problem of a unitary description of two interpolating systems with general potential interaction. The general solution is used to show that with arbitrary potential interaction between the two interpolating systems the evolution of the so-called unobservable variables is decoupled from that of the observable ones if and only if the interpolation parameters in the two interpolating systems are equal.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.89.024104

Related papers

Hybrid quantum-classical dynamics of pure-dephasing systems *

Giovanni Manfredi, Antoine Rittaud, Cesare Tronci

Abstract We consider the interaction dynamics of a classical oscillator and a quantum two-level system for different pure-dephasing Hamiltonians of the type H ˆ ( q , p ) = H C ( q , p ) 1 + H I ( q , p ) σ ˆ z . This type of systems represents a severe challenge for popular hybrid quantum–classical descriptions. For example, in the case of the common Ehrenfest model, the classical density evolution is shown to decouple entirely from the pure-dephasing quantum dynamics. We focus on a recently proposed hybrid wave equation that is based on Koopman’s wavefunction description of classical mechanics. This model retains quantum–classical correlations whenever a coupling potential is present. Here, several benchmark problems are considered and the results are compared with those arising from fully quantum dynamics. A good agreement is found for a series of study cases involving harmonic oscillators with linear and quadratic coupling, as well as time-varying coupling parameters. In all these cases the classical evolution coincides exactly with the oscillator dynamics resulting from the fully quantum description. In the special case of time-independent coupling involving a classical oscillator with varying frequency, the quantum Bloch rotation exhibits peculiar features that escape from the hybrid description. In addition, nonlinear corrections to the harmonic Hamiltonian lead to an overall growth of decoherence at long times, which is absent in the fully quantum treatment.

arXiv:2303.04538•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Mar 7, 2023•18 citations

Effective nonlinear Ehrenfest hybrid quantum-classical dynamics

José L. Alonso, Carlos Bouthelier-Madre, Jesús Clemente-Gallardo +2 more

Abstract The definition of a consistent evolution equation for statistical hybrid quantum-classical systems is still an open problem. In this paper, we analyze the case of Ehrenfest dynamics on systems defined by a probability density and identify the relations of the nonlinearity of the dynamics with the obstructions to define a consistent dynamics for the first quantum moment of the distribution. This first quantum moment represents the physical states as a family of classically-parametrized density matrices $${\hat{\rho }}(\xi )$$ ρ ^ ( ξ ) , for $$\xi$$ ξ a classical point; and it is the most common representation of hybrid systems in the literature. Due to this obstruction, we consider higher order quantum moments, and argue that only a finite number of them are physically measurable. Because of this, we propose an effective solution for the hybrid dynamics problem based on approximating the distribution by those moments and representing the states by them.

arXiv:2308.14440•The European Physical Journal Plus•Jul 25, 2023•11 citations

Symmetric Hybrid Dynamics: A canonical formulation of coupled classical-quantum dynamics

Nuno Costa Dias, João Nuno Prata

A canonical formulation of coupled classical-quantum dynamics is presented. The theory is named symmetric hybrid dynamics. It is proved that under some general conditions its predictions are consistent with the full quantum ones. Moreover symmetric hybrid dynamics displays a fully consistent canonical structure. Namely, it is formulated over a Lie algebra of observables, time evolution is unitary and the solution of a hybrid type Schrödinger equation. A quantization prescription from classical mechanics to hybrid dynamics is presented. The quantization map is a Lie algebra isomorphism. Finally some possible applications of the theory are succinctly suggested.

arXiv:quant-ph/0005019•May 3, 2000•8 citations

The Ehrenfest picture and the geometry of Quantum Mechanics

Jesús Clemente-Gallardo, Giuseppe Marmo

In this paper we develop a picture of Quantum Mechanics based on the description of physical observables in terms of expectation value functions, generalizing thus the so called Ehrenfest theorems for quantum dynamics. Our basic technical ingredient is the set of tools which has been developed in the last years for the geometrical formulation of Quantum Mechanics. In the new picture, we analyze the problem of the dynamical equations, the uncertainty relations and interference and illustrate the construction with the simple case of a two-level system.

arXiv:1306.1453•Jun 6, 2013•7 citations

Quantum–Classical Hybrid Systems and Ehrenfest’s Theorem

Alessandro Sergi, Daniele Lamberto, Agostino Migliore +1 more

The conceptual analysis of quantum mechanics brings to light that a theory inherently consistent with observations should be able to describe both quantum and classical systems, i.e., quantum-classical hybrids. For example, the orthodox interpretation of measurements requires the transient creation of quantum-classical hybrids. Despite its limitations in defining the classical limit, Ehrenfest's theorem makes the simplest contact between quantum and classical mechanics. Here, we generalized the Ehrenfest theorem to bipartite quantum systems. To study quantum-classical hybrids, we employed a formalism based on operator-valued Wigner functions and quantum-classical brackets. We used this approach to derive the form of the Ehrenfest theorem for quantum-classical hybrids. We found that the time variation of the average energy of each component of the bipartite system is equal to the average of the symmetrized quantum dissipated power in both the quantum and the quantum-classical case. We expect that these theoretical results will be useful both to analyze quantum-classical hybrids and to develop self-consistent numerical algorithms for Ehrenfest-type simulations.

Entropy•Apr 1, 2023•15 citations

Quantum Dynamics and Pictures

Z. Ficek

This chapter demonstrates how one can find the time evolution of the operators from the knowledge of the time evolution of the state vector, and vice versa. It introduces a unitary operator and discusses the concept of a unitary transformation to show how one could transfer the time dependence from the state vectors to the operators. The possibility that either the state vectors or the operators can depend explicitly on time will lead to introduce the Schrodinger, Heisenberg, and interaction pictures. The chapter discusses the fundamental differences between these pictures. It also discusses the Ehrenfest theorem, which shows under which conditions quantum mechanics predicts the same results for measured physical quantities as classical physics. It illustrates unitary transformations of an arbitrary operator Â(t) which can depend explicitly on time. Quantum mechanics produces the same result as classical mechanics for a system in which particles are represented by well-localized wave functions.

•Mar 3, 2017•0 citations
Representation of classical dynamics by unitary transformations has been used to develop a unified description of hybrid classical-quantum systems with a particular type of interaction, and to formulate abstract systems interpolating between classical and quantum ones. We solved the problem of a unitary description of two interpolating systems with general potential interaction. The general solution is used to show that with arbitrary potential interaction between the two interpolating systems the evolution of the so-called unobservable variables is decoupled from that of the observable ones if and only if the interpolation parameters in the two interpolating systems are equal.
Abstract We consider the interaction dynamics of a classical oscillator and a quantum two-level system for different pure-dephasing Hamiltonians of the type H ˆ ( q , p ) = H C ( q , p ) 1 + H I ( q , p ) σ ˆ z . This type of systems represents a severe challenge for popular hybrid quantum–classical descriptions. For example, in the case of the common Ehrenfest model, the classical density evolution is shown to decouple entirely from the pure-dephasing quantum dynamics. We focus on a recently proposed hybrid wave equation that is based on Koopman’s wavefunction description of classical mechanics. This model retains quantum–classical correlations whenever a coupling potential is present. Here, several benchmark problems are considered and the results are compared with those arising from fully quantum dynamics. A good agreement is found for a series of study cases involving harmonic oscillators with linear and quadratic coupling, as well as time-varying coupling parameters. In all these cases the classical evolution coincides exactly with the oscillator dynamics resulting from the fully quantum description. In the special case of time-independent coupling involving a classical oscillator with varying frequency, the quantum Bloch rotation exhibits peculiar features that escape from the hybrid description. In addition, nonlinear corrections to the harmonic Hamiltonian lead to an overall growth of decoherence at long times, which is absent in the fully quantum treatment.
Abstract The definition of a consistent evolution equation for statistical hybrid quantum-classical systems is still an open problem. In this paper, we analyze the case of Ehrenfest dynamics on systems defined by a probability density and identify the relations of the nonlinearity of the dynamics with the obstructions to define a consistent dynamics for the first quantum moment of the distribution. This first quantum moment represents the physical states as a family of classically-parametrized density matrices ρ^(ξ){\hat{\rho }}(\xi )ρ^​(ξ) ρ ^ ( ξ ) , for ξ\xiξ ξ a classical point; and it is the most common representation of hybrid systems in the literature. Due to this obstruction, we consider higher order quantum moments, and argue that only a finite number of them are physically measurable. Because of this, we propose an effective solution for the hybrid dynamics problem based on approximating the distribution by those moments and representing the states by them.
A canonical formulation of coupled classical-quantum dynamics is presented. The theory is named symmetric hybrid dynamics. It is proved that under some general conditions its predictions are consistent with the full quantum ones. Moreover symmetric hybrid dynamics displays a fully consistent canonical structure. Namely, it is formulated over a Lie algebra of observables, time evolution is unitary and the solution of a hybrid type Schrödinger equation. A quantization prescription from classical mechanics to hybrid dynamics is presented. The quantization map is a Lie algebra isomorphism. Finally some possible applications of the theory are succinctly suggested.
In this paper we develop a picture of Quantum Mechanics based on the description of physical observables in terms of expectation value functions, generalizing thus the so called Ehrenfest theorems for quantum dynamics. Our basic technical ingredient is the set of tools which has been developed in the last years for the geometrical formulation of Quantum Mechanics. In the new picture, we analyze the problem of the dynamical equations, the uncertainty relations and interference and illustrate the construction with the simple case of a two-level system.
The conceptual analysis of quantum mechanics brings to light that a theory inherently consistent with observations should be able to describe both quantum and classical systems, i.e., quantum-classical hybrids. For example, the orthodox interpretation of measurements requires the transient creation of quantum-classical hybrids. Despite its limitations in defining the classical limit, Ehrenfest's theorem makes the simplest contact between quantum and classical mechanics. Here, we generalized the Ehrenfest theorem to bipartite quantum systems. To study quantum-classical hybrids, we employed a formalism based on operator-valued Wigner functions and quantum-classical brackets. We used this approach to derive the form of the Ehrenfest theorem for quantum-classical hybrids. We found that the time variation of the average energy of each component of the bipartite system is equal to the average of the symmetrized quantum dissipated power in both the quantum and the quantum-classical case. We expect that these theoretical results will be useful both to analyze quantum-classical hybrids and to develop self-consistent numerical algorithms for Ehrenfest-type simulations.
This chapter demonstrates how one can find the time evolution of the operators from the knowledge of the time evolution of the state vector, and vice versa. It introduces a unitary operator and discusses the concept of a unitary transformation to show how one could transfer the time dependence from the state vectors to the operators. The possibility that either the state vectors or the operators can depend explicitly on time will lead to introduce the Schrodinger, Heisenberg, and interaction pictures. The chapter discusses the fundamental differences between these pictures. It also discusses the Ehrenfest theorem, which shows under which conditions quantum mechanics predicts the same results for measured physical quantities as classical physics. It illustrates unitary transformations of an arbitrary operator Â(t) which can depend explicitly on time. Quantum mechanics produces the same result as classical mechanics for a system in which particles are represented by well-localized wave functions.