Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1402.6797 · Physical Review B

Chalker scaling, level repulsion, and conformal invariance in critically delocalized quantum matter: Disordered topological superconductors and artificial graphene

Yang-Zhi Chou, Matthew S. Foster

Published Apr 30, 2014• 28 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We numerically investigate critically delocalized wave functions in models of two-dimensional Dirac fermions, subject to vector potential disorder. These describe the surface states of three-dimensional topological superconductors, and can also be realized through long-range correlated bond randomness in artificial materials like molecular graphene. A ``frozen'' regime can occur for strong disorder in these systems, wherein a single wave function presents a few localized peaks separated by macroscopic distances. Despite this rarefied spatial structure, we find robust correlations between eigenstates at different energies, at both weak and strong disorder. The associated level statistics are always approximately Wigner-Dyson. The system shows generalized Chalker (quantum critical) scaling, even when individual states are quasilocalized in space. We confirm analytical predictions for the density of states and multifractal spectra. For a single Dirac valley, we establish that finite energy states show universal multifractal spectra consistent with the integer quantum Hall plateau transition. A single Dirac fermion at finite energy can therefore behave as a ``Quantum Hall critical metal.'' For the case of two valleys and non-Abelian disorder, we verify predictions of conformal field theory. Our results for the non-Abelian case imply that both delocalization and conformal invariance are topologically protected for multivalley topological superconductor surface states.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.89.165136

Related papers

Critical Percolation without Fine-Tuning on the Surface of a Topological Superconductor

Sayed Ali Akbar Ghorashi, Yunxiang Liao, Matthew S. Foster

We present numerical evidence that most two-dimensional surface states of a bulk topological superconductor (TSC) sit at an integer quantum Hall plateau transition. We study TSC surface states in class CI with quenched disorder. Low-energy (finite-energy) surface states were expected to be critically delocalized (Anderson localized). We confirm the low-energy picture, but find instead that finite-energy states are also delocalized, with universal statistics that are independent of the TSC winding number, and consistent with the spin quantum Hall plateau transition (percolation).

arXiv:1711.03972•Physical Review Letters•Jul 6, 2018•15 citations

Percolation (almost) all the way down on the surface of a topological superconductor

Sayed Ali Akbar Ghorashi, Yunxiang Liao, Matthew S. Foster

We present numerical evidence that most two-dimensional surface states of a bulk topological superconductor (TSC) sit at an integer quantum Hall plateau transition. We study TSC surface states in class CI with quenched disorder. Low-energy (finite-energy) surface states were expected to be critically delocalized (Anderson localized). We confirm the low-energy picture, but find instead that finite-energy states are also delocalized, with universal statistics that are independent of the TSC winding number, and consistent with the spin quantum Hall plateau transition (percolation).

•Nov 10, 2017•0 citations

Disorder-enhanced topological protection and universal quantum criticality in a spin- 32 topological superconductor

Sayed Ali Akbar Ghorashi, Seth Davis, Matthew S. Foster

We study the Majorana surface states of higher-spin topological superconductors (TSCs) that could be realized in ultracold atomic systems or doped semimetals with spin-orbit coupling. As a paradigmatic example, we consider a model with $p$-wave pairing of spin-3/2 fermions that generalizes $^{3}\mathrm{He}\ensuremath{-}B$. This model has coexisting linear and cubic dispersing Majorana surface bands. We show that these are unstable to interactions, which can generate a spontaneous surface thermal quantum Hall effect (TQHE). By contrast, nonmagnetic quenched disorder induces a surface conformal field theory (CFT) that is stable against weak interactions: topological protection is enhanced by disorder. Gapless surface states of higher-spin TSCs could therefore be robustly realized in solid-state systems, where disorder is inevitable. The surface CFT is characterized by universal signatures that depend only on the bulk topological winding number, and they include power-law scaling of the density of states, a universal multifractal spectrum of local density of states fluctuations, and a quantized ratio of the longitudinal thermal conductivity ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{xx}$ divided by temperature $T$. By contrast, ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{xx}/T$ for the clean surface without TQHE order would diverge as $T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$. Since disorder stabilizes the conducting Majorana surface fluid and quantizes thermal transport, our results suggest a close analogy between bulk TSCs and the integer quantum Hall effect.

arXiv:1701.02787•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 3, 2017•29 citations

Spectrum-Wide Quantum Criticality at the Surface of Class AIII Topological Phases: An “Energy Stack” of Integer Quantum Hall Plateau Transitions

Björn Sbierski, Jonas F. Karcher, Matthew S. Foster

In the absence of spin-orbit coupling, the conventional dogma of Anderson localization asserts that all states localize in two dimensions, with a glaring exception: the quantum Hall plateau transition (QHPT).In that case, the localization length diverges and interference-induced quantum-critical spatial fluctuations appear at all length scales.Normally, QHPT states occur only at isolated energies; accessing them therefore requires fine-tuning of the electron density or magnetic field.In this paper we show that QHPT states can be realized throughout an energy continuum, i.e., as an "energy stack" of critical states wherein each state in the stack exhibits QHPT phenomenology.The stacking occurs without fine-tuning at the surface of a class AIII topological phase, where it is protected by U(1) and (anomalous) chiral or time-reversal symmetries.Spectrum-wide criticality is diagnosed by comparing numerics to universal results for the longitudinal Landauer conductance and wave function multifractality at the QHPT.Results are obtained from an effective 2D surface field theory and from a bulk 3D lattice model.We demonstrate that the stacking of quantum-critical QHPT states is a robust phenomenon that occurs for AIII topological phases with both odd and even winding numbers.The latter conclusion may have important implications for the still poorly understood logarithmic conformal field theory believed to describe the QHPT.

arXiv:1912.06748•Physical Review X•May 1, 2020•23 citations

Field Theories of Interacting and Disordered Dirac Fermions in Graphene

Christian Fräßdorf

After its first isolation by Geim and Novoselov in 2004, graphene has grown quickly into an independent subfield of contemporary condensed matter physics, counting thousands of publications. This material has attracted so much attention not only because it is truly two-dimensional -- a feature long thought to be impossible to be realized in nature -- but also because it is the prime representative of a new class of condensed matter systems, the Dirac materials, whose electronic spectrum disperses linearly around isolated points in the Brillouin zone. An outstanding consequence of this linear energy-momentum dispersion is the collapse of the Fermi surface to isolated points at charge neutrality, accompanied by a vanishing single-particle density of states. While this feature of the noninteracting model is what separates graphene from most other, more conventional condensed matter systems, giving rise to many of its astounding physical properties, it leads to severe computational complications when extending the model to contain two-body interactions and/or disorder. In this thesis we consider both extensions separately. After rigorously deriving the low-energy quantum field theory from a tight-binding model and establishing the one-particle irreducible (1PI) vertex functions as the fundamental building blocks of correlation functions, we construct a nonperturbative formalism for the calculation of these vertex functions using the well-established functional renormalization group (fRG). By combining the fRG with the Keldysh formalism, accounting for possible external electromagnetic fields and nontrivial initial correlations, this framework is capable of handling thermal equilibrium and true nonequilibrium alike. To circumvent some of the technical problems of the standard fRG formalism when treating fermionic systems at finite density, we also explore a variant of the fRG, where the chemical potential is interpreted as a flow parameter. We obtain hierarchical sets of flow equations, which describe the change of the 1PI vertex functions upon varying an artificial cutoff scale or the chemical potential, respectively. These nonperturbative formalisms have been used to calculate the renormalization of the Fermi velocity and the static dielectric function at finite temperature and density in the strong coupling regime as an explicit demonstration of their capabilities. Since the Keldysh fRG is an exact formulation of quantum field theory, in particular when external magnetic fields are present, it should be possible to describe the fractional quantum Hall effect in this framework. However, the typical truncation schemes that are currently available to approximately solve the fRG flow equation fail to account for the nontrivial correlation effects necessary to access the fractional quantum Hall regime. To circumvent this problem we consider a modified field theory, where these correlations are implemented ``by hand'' via a Chern-Simons gauge field, coupling to the fermions in addition to the Coulomb interaction term. This modified field theory is analyzed in a stationary phase approximation including Gaussian fluctuations. The electromagnetic response tensor is calculated in the random phase approximation, yielding the Hall conductivities. In the second part of this thesis we consider disordered Dirac fermions in the absence of two-particle interactions. After sketching how the most general disorder potential for Dirac fermions arises from a tight-binding model, we first consider an explicit physical scenario, a disordered graphene pn junction in the presence of a quantizing magnetic field perpendicular to the graphene sheet. We derive an effective one-dimensional theory for the chiral states that propagate along the junction interface and calculate the full conductance distribution in the crossover between the clean and the strong-disorder limit, via an exact solution of a Fokker-Planck equation. Lastly, we develop a nonperturbative approach to calculate the disorder induced self-energy that is based on exact Schwinger-Dyson equations and Ward identities, not only for graphene, but also for other paradigmatic semimetals with a nodal point dispersion.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Exact Multifractality for Disordered N -Flavor Dirac Fermions in Two Dimensions

Jean-Sébastien Caux

We present a nonperturbative calculation of all multifractal scaling exponents at strong disorder for critical wave functions of Dirac fermions interacting with a non-Abelian random vector potential in two dimensions. The results, valid for an arbitrary number of fermionic flavors, are obtained by deriving from conformal field theory an effective Gaussian model for the wave function amplitudes and mapping it to the thermodynamics of a single particle in a random potential. Our spectrum confirms that the wave functions remain delocalized in the presence of strong disorder.

arXiv:cond-mat/9804133•Physical Review Letters•Nov 9, 1998•37 citations
We numerically investigate critically delocalized wave functions in models of two-dimensional Dirac fermions, subject to vector potential disorder. These describe the surface states of three-dimensional topological superconductors, and can also be realized through long-range correlated bond randomness in artificial materials like molecular graphene. A frozen'' regime can occur for strong disorder in these systems, wherein a single wave function presents a few localized peaks separated by macroscopic distances. Despite this rarefied spatial structure, we find robust correlations between eigenstates at different energies, at both weak and strong disorder. The associated level statistics are always approximately Wigner-Dyson. The system shows generalized Chalker (quantum critical) scaling, even when individual states are quasilocalized in space. We confirm analytical predictions for the density of states and multifractal spectra. For a single Dirac valley, we establish that finite energy states show universal multifractal spectra consistent with the integer quantum Hall plateau transition. A single Dirac fermion at finite energy can therefore behave as a Quantum Hall critical metal.'' For the case of two valleys and non-Abelian disorder, we verify predictions of conformal field theory. Our results for the non-Abelian case imply that both delocalization and conformal invariance are topologically protected for multivalley topological superconductor surface states.
We present numerical evidence that most two-dimensional surface states of a bulk topological superconductor (TSC) sit at an integer quantum Hall plateau transition. We study TSC surface states in class CI with quenched disorder. Low-energy (finite-energy) surface states were expected to be critically delocalized (Anderson localized). We confirm the low-energy picture, but find instead that finite-energy states are also delocalized, with universal statistics that are independent of the TSC winding number, and consistent with the spin quantum Hall plateau transition (percolation).
We present numerical evidence that most two-dimensional surface states of a bulk topological superconductor (TSC) sit at an integer quantum Hall plateau transition. We study TSC surface states in class CI with quenched disorder. Low-energy (finite-energy) surface states were expected to be critically delocalized (Anderson localized). We confirm the low-energy picture, but find instead that finite-energy states are also delocalized, with universal statistics that are independent of the TSC winding number, and consistent with the spin quantum Hall plateau transition (percolation).
We study the Majorana surface states of higher-spin topological superconductors (TSCs) that could be realized in ultracold atomic systems or doped semimetals with spin-orbit coupling. As a paradigmatic example, we consider a model with ppp-wave pairing of spin-3/2 fermions that generalizes $^{3}\mathrm{He}\ensuremath{-}B$. This model has coexisting linear and cubic dispersing Majorana surface bands. We show that these are unstable to interactions, which can generate a spontaneous surface thermal quantum Hall effect (TQHE). By contrast, nonmagnetic quenched disorder induces a surface conformal field theory (CFT) that is stable against weak interactions: topological protection is enhanced by disorder. Gapless surface states of higher-spin TSCs could therefore be robustly realized in solid-state systems, where disorder is inevitable. The surface CFT is characterized by universal signatures that depend only on the bulk topological winding number, and they include power-law scaling of the density of states, a universal multifractal spectrum of local density of states fluctuations, and a quantized ratio of the longitudinal thermal conductivity ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{xx}$ divided by temperature TTT. By contrast, ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}_{xx}/T$ for the clean surface without TQHE order would diverge as $T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$. Since disorder stabilizes the conducting Majorana surface fluid and quantizes thermal transport, our results suggest a close analogy between bulk TSCs and the integer quantum Hall effect.
In the absence of spin-orbit coupling, the conventional dogma of Anderson localization asserts that all states localize in two dimensions, with a glaring exception: the quantum Hall plateau transition (QHPT).In that case, the localization length diverges and interference-induced quantum-critical spatial fluctuations appear at all length scales.Normally, QHPT states occur only at isolated energies; accessing them therefore requires fine-tuning of the electron density or magnetic field.In this paper we show that QHPT states can be realized throughout an energy continuum, i.e., as an "energy stack" of critical states wherein each state in the stack exhibits QHPT phenomenology.The stacking occurs without fine-tuning at the surface of a class AIII topological phase, where it is protected by U(1) and (anomalous) chiral or time-reversal symmetries.Spectrum-wide criticality is diagnosed by comparing numerics to universal results for the longitudinal Landauer conductance and wave function multifractality at the QHPT.Results are obtained from an effective 2D surface field theory and from a bulk 3D lattice model.We demonstrate that the stacking of quantum-critical QHPT states is a robust phenomenon that occurs for AIII topological phases with both odd and even winding numbers.The latter conclusion may have important implications for the still poorly understood logarithmic conformal field theory believed to describe the QHPT.
After its first isolation by Geim and Novoselov in 2004, graphene has grown quickly into an independent subfield of contemporary condensed matter physics, counting thousands of publications. This material has attracted so much attention not only because it is truly two-dimensional -- a feature long thought to be impossible to be realized in nature -- but also because it is the prime representative of a new class of condensed matter systems, the Dirac materials, whose electronic spectrum disperses linearly around isolated points in the Brillouin zone. An outstanding consequence of this linear energy-momentum dispersion is the collapse of the Fermi surface to isolated points at charge neutrality, accompanied by a vanishing single-particle density of states. While this feature of the noninteracting model is what separates graphene from most other, more conventional condensed matter systems, giving rise to many of its astounding physical properties, it leads to severe computational complications when extending the model to contain two-body interactions and/or disorder. In this thesis we consider both extensions separately. After rigorously deriving the low-energy quantum field theory from a tight-binding model and establishing the one-particle irreducible (1PI) vertex functions as the fundamental building blocks of correlation functions, we construct a nonperturbative formalism for the calculation of these vertex functions using the well-established functional renormalization group (fRG). By combining the fRG with the Keldysh formalism, accounting for possible external electromagnetic fields and nontrivial initial correlations, this framework is capable of handling thermal equilibrium and true nonequilibrium alike. To circumvent some of the technical problems of the standard fRG formalism when treating fermionic systems at finite density, we also explore a variant of the fRG, where the chemical potential is interpreted as a flow parameter. We obtain hierarchical sets of flow equations, which describe the change of the 1PI vertex functions upon varying an artificial cutoff scale or the chemical potential, respectively. These nonperturbative formalisms have been used to calculate the renormalization of the Fermi velocity and the static dielectric function at finite temperature and density in the strong coupling regime as an explicit demonstration of their capabilities. Since the Keldysh fRG is an exact formulation of quantum field theory, in particular when external magnetic fields are present, it should be possible to describe the fractional quantum Hall effect in this framework. However, the typical truncation schemes that are currently available to approximately solve the fRG flow equation fail to account for the nontrivial correlation effects necessary to access the fractional quantum Hall regime. To circumvent this problem we consider a modified field theory, where these correlations are implemented ``by hand'' via a Chern-Simons gauge field, coupling to the fermions in addition to the Coulomb interaction term. This modified field theory is analyzed in a stationary phase approximation including Gaussian fluctuations. The electromagnetic response tensor is calculated in the random phase approximation, yielding the Hall conductivities. In the second part of this thesis we consider disordered Dirac fermions in the absence of two-particle interactions. After sketching how the most general disorder potential for Dirac fermions arises from a tight-binding model, we first consider an explicit physical scenario, a disordered graphene pn junction in the presence of a quantizing magnetic field perpendicular to the graphene sheet. We derive an effective one-dimensional theory for the chiral states that propagate along the junction interface and calculate the full conductance distribution in the crossover between the clean and the strong-disorder limit, via an exact solution of a Fokker-Planck equation. Lastly, we develop a nonperturbative approach to calculate the disorder induced self-energy that is based on exact Schwinger-Dyson equations and Ward identities, not only for graphene, but also for other paradigmatic semimetals with a nodal point dispersion.
We present a nonperturbative calculation of all multifractal scaling exponents at strong disorder for critical wave functions of Dirac fermions interacting with a non-Abelian random vector potential in two dimensions. The results, valid for an arbitrary number of fermionic flavors, are obtained by deriving from conformal field theory an effective Gaussian model for the wave function amplitudes and mapping it to the thermodynamics of a single particle in a random potential. Our spectrum confirms that the wave functions remain delocalized in the presence of strong disorder.