Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1312.5286 · Physical Review Letters

Comment on “General Non-Markovian Dynamics of Open Quantum Systems”

Dara P. S. McCutcheon, Juan Pablo Paz, Augusto J. Roncaglia

Published Oct 13, 2015• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The existence of a "non-Markovian dissipationless" regime, characterized by long lived oscillations, was recently reported for a class of quantum open systems (Zhang et al, PRL, 109, 170402, (2012)). It is claimed this could happen in the strong coupling regime, a surprising result which has attracted some attention. We show that this regime exists if and only if the total Hamiltonian is unbounded from below, casting serious doubts on the usefulness of this result.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.115.168901

Related papers

Reply to the Comment on "General Non-Markovian Dynamics of Open Quantum System"

Wei-Min Zhang, Ping‐Yuan Lo, Heng-Na Xiong +2 more

This is the reply to the 2nd version of the comment, [arXiv.1312.5286v2], by McCutcheon {\it et al.} on our paper [PRL 109, 170402 (2012)]. Our letter presents three examples. For the steady-state solution of the first example, i.e., the dissipationless part of Eq.(12) in the PRL, the 2nd version of the Comment claimed that "this [dissipationless] regime exists if and only if the total Hamiltonian is unbounded from below, casting serious doubts on the usefulness of this result." In this reply, we show again that the 2nd version of the Comment is also incorrect.

arXiv:1401.2012•Jan 9, 2014•0 citations

General Non-Markovian Dynamics of Open Quantum Systems

Wei-Min Zhang, Ping‐Yuan Lo, Heng-Na Xiong +2 more

We present a general theory of non-Markovian dynamics for open systems of noninteracting fermions (bosons) linearly coupled to thermal environments of noninteracting fermions (bosons). We explore the non-Markovian dynamics by connecting the exact master equations with the nonequilibirum Green's functions. Environmental backactions are fully taken into account. The non-Markovian dynamics consists of nonexponential decays and dissipationless oscillations. Nonexponential decays are induced by the discontinuity in the imaginary part of the self-energy corrections. Dissipationless oscillations arise from band gaps or the finite band structure of spectral densities. The exact analytic solutions for various non-Markovian thermal environments show that non-Markovian dynamics can be largely understood from the environmental-modified spectra of open systems.

arXiv:1206.4490•Physical Review Letters•Oct 26, 2012•349 citations

Non-Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems without rotating wave approximation

Ming-Jia Tang, Yukai Wu, Ming Lyu +4 more

We study the non-Markovian dynamics of a damped oscillator coupled with a reservoir. We present exact formulas for the oscillator's evolution directly from the BCH formula by series expansion with neither Markovian nor rotating wave approximation (RWA). Based on these, we show the existence of the non-Markovian feature of the system's evolution for the damped oscillator. By numerical simulation we find that the non-Markovian feature exists within a wide range of the coupling strength, even when the coupling strength is very small. To this problem, prior art results have assumed RWA and the existence of non-Markovian feature was found when the system-reservoir coupling is strong enough. However, as we show, given such a strong coupling, the original Hamiltonian without RWA is actually not physical. Therefore, our exact study here has thoroughly concluded the issue of non-Markovian feature.

arXiv:1407.5359•Jul 21, 2014•0 citations

On non-Markovianity in Open Quantum Systems

Kenny Li

Markovian approximation is a widely-employed idea in the descriptions of the dynamics of open quantum systems. Although it is usually claimed to be a concept inspired by classical Markovianity, the physical meaning of this concept, however, is vague. In this thesis, I compare the descriptions of classical stochastic processes and open quantum systems, and show that those inherent differences lead to the non-trivial problem of characterizing quantum non-Markovianity. With various examples, I argue that the current most often used definitions of quantumMarkovianity in the literature do not fully capture the memoryless property of OQSs. To address this issue, I take a different approach by studying a host of Markov-related concepts in the quantum regime. Some of these concepts have long been used in quantum theory, while others are first proposed in this thesis. I define all these concepts under a unified framework, which allows one to rigorously build hierarchy relations among them. In this sense, quantum non-Markovianity is highly context-dependent. The results in this thesis, summarized as a hierarchy figure, are expected to bring clarity to the nature of quantumnon-Markovianity.

•Aug 1, 2017•0 citations

The strong-coupling master equation of quantum open systems

Christen H. Fleming

In this paper we demonstrate how to generate the strong-coupling master equations for open quantum systems of continuous variables. These are the dissipative master equations of quantum Brownian particles for which the environmental noise is stronger than other system forces. Our strong-coupling master equations are very different from other so-called "strong-coupling" master equations (e.g. the quantum Smoluchowski equation) which are perturbing off a limit in which the system energy is taken to be perturbative and thus the dynamics is principally Markovian. Such approximations also require the system mass to be asymptotically large (even as compared to the ratio of noise and induced system frequencies) and thus they do not fully categorize the regime of what one might consider to be strong coupling. Our master equations are highly non-Markovian and radically different for different system potentials, admitting no apparent generic form. This result is quite exciting as it brings forth a new regime for theoretical exploration: the regime of strong noise and dissipation yet non-Markovian, such as strong coupling to a low-temperature environment with large 1/f fluctuations.

arXiv:1012.1392•Dec 7, 2010•0 citations

Capturing non-Markovian dynamics on near-term quantum computers

Kade Head-Marsden, Stefan Krastanov, David A. Mazziotti +1 more

With the rapid progress in quantum hardware, there has been an increased interest in new quantum algorithms to describe complex many-body systems searching for the still-elusive goal of "useful quantum advantage." Surprisingly, quantum algorithms for the treatment of open quantum systems (OQSs) have remained underexplored, in part due to the inherent challenges of mapping non-unitary evolution into the framework of unitary gates. Evolving an open system unitarily necessitates dilation into a new effective system to incorporate critical environmental degrees of freedom. In this context, we present and validate a new quantum algorithm to treat non-Markovian dynamics in OQSs built on the ensemble of Lindblad's trajectories approach, invoking the Sz.-Nagy dilation theorem. Here we demonstrate our algorithm on the Jaynes-Cummings model in the strong-coupling and detuned regimes, relevant in quantum optics and driven quantum system studies. This algorithm, a key step towards generalized modeling of non-Markovian dynamics on a noisy-quantum device, captures a broad class of dynamics and opens up a new direction in OQS problems.

•Feb 25, 2021•60 citations
The existence of a "non-Markovian dissipationless" regime, characterized by long lived oscillations, was recently reported for a class of quantum open systems (Zhang et al, PRL, 109, 170402, (2012)). It is claimed this could happen in the strong coupling regime, a surprising result which has attracted some attention. We show that this regime exists if and only if the total Hamiltonian is unbounded from below, casting serious doubts on the usefulness of this result.
This is the reply to the 2nd version of the comment, [arXiv.1312.5286v2], by McCutcheon {\it et al.} on our paper [PRL 109, 170402 (2012)]. Our letter presents three examples. For the steady-state solution of the first example, i.e., the dissipationless part of Eq.(12) in the PRL, the 2nd version of the Comment claimed that "this [dissipationless] regime exists if and only if the total Hamiltonian is unbounded from below, casting serious doubts on the usefulness of this result." In this reply, we show again that the 2nd version of the Comment is also incorrect.
We present a general theory of non-Markovian dynamics for open systems of noninteracting fermions (bosons) linearly coupled to thermal environments of noninteracting fermions (bosons). We explore the non-Markovian dynamics by connecting the exact master equations with the nonequilibirum Green's functions. Environmental backactions are fully taken into account. The non-Markovian dynamics consists of nonexponential decays and dissipationless oscillations. Nonexponential decays are induced by the discontinuity in the imaginary part of the self-energy corrections. Dissipationless oscillations arise from band gaps or the finite band structure of spectral densities. The exact analytic solutions for various non-Markovian thermal environments show that non-Markovian dynamics can be largely understood from the environmental-modified spectra of open systems.
We study the non-Markovian dynamics of a damped oscillator coupled with a reservoir. We present exact formulas for the oscillator's evolution directly from the BCH formula by series expansion with neither Markovian nor rotating wave approximation (RWA). Based on these, we show the existence of the non-Markovian feature of the system's evolution for the damped oscillator. By numerical simulation we find that the non-Markovian feature exists within a wide range of the coupling strength, even when the coupling strength is very small. To this problem, prior art results have assumed RWA and the existence of non-Markovian feature was found when the system-reservoir coupling is strong enough. However, as we show, given such a strong coupling, the original Hamiltonian without RWA is actually not physical. Therefore, our exact study here has thoroughly concluded the issue of non-Markovian feature.
Markovian approximation is a widely-employed idea in the descriptions of the dynamics of open quantum systems. Although it is usually claimed to be a concept inspired by classical Markovianity, the physical meaning of this concept, however, is vague. In this thesis, I compare the descriptions of classical stochastic processes and open quantum systems, and show that those inherent differences lead to the non-trivial problem of characterizing quantum non-Markovianity. With various examples, I argue that the current most often used definitions of quantumMarkovianity in the literature do not fully capture the memoryless property of OQSs. To address this issue, I take a different approach by studying a host of Markov-related concepts in the quantum regime. Some of these concepts have long been used in quantum theory, while others are first proposed in this thesis. I define all these concepts under a unified framework, which allows one to rigorously build hierarchy relations among them. In this sense, quantum non-Markovianity is highly context-dependent. The results in this thesis, summarized as a hierarchy figure, are expected to bring clarity to the nature of quantumnon-Markovianity.
In this paper we demonstrate how to generate the strong-coupling master equations for open quantum systems of continuous variables. These are the dissipative master equations of quantum Brownian particles for which the environmental noise is stronger than other system forces. Our strong-coupling master equations are very different from other so-called "strong-coupling" master equations (e.g. the quantum Smoluchowski equation) which are perturbing off a limit in which the system energy is taken to be perturbative and thus the dynamics is principally Markovian. Such approximations also require the system mass to be asymptotically large (even as compared to the ratio of noise and induced system frequencies) and thus they do not fully categorize the regime of what one might consider to be strong coupling. Our master equations are highly non-Markovian and radically different for different system potentials, admitting no apparent generic form. This result is quite exciting as it brings forth a new regime for theoretical exploration: the regime of strong noise and dissipation yet non-Markovian, such as strong coupling to a low-temperature environment with large 1/f fluctuations.
With the rapid progress in quantum hardware, there has been an increased interest in new quantum algorithms to describe complex many-body systems searching for the still-elusive goal of "useful quantum advantage." Surprisingly, quantum algorithms for the treatment of open quantum systems (OQSs) have remained underexplored, in part due to the inherent challenges of mapping non-unitary evolution into the framework of unitary gates. Evolving an open system unitarily necessitates dilation into a new effective system to incorporate critical environmental degrees of freedom. In this context, we present and validate a new quantum algorithm to treat non-Markovian dynamics in OQSs built on the ensemble of Lindblad's trajectories approach, invoking the Sz.-Nagy dilation theorem. Here we demonstrate our algorithm on the Jaynes-Cummings model in the strong-coupling and detuned regimes, relevant in quantum optics and driven quantum system studies. This algorithm, a key step towards generalized modeling of non-Markovian dynamics on a noisy-quantum device, captures a broad class of dynamics and opens up a new direction in OQS problems.