As quantum computing technology improves and quantum computers with a small but non-trivial number of N > 100 qubits appear feasible in the near future the question of possible applications of small quantum computers gains importance. One frequently mentioned application is Feynman's original proposal of simulating quantum systems, and in particular the electronic structure of molecules and materials. In this paper, we analyze the computational requirements for one of the standard algorithms to perform quantum chemistry on a quantum computer. We focus on the quantum resources required to find the ground state of a molecule twice as large as what current classical computers can solve exactly. We find that while such a problem requires about a ten-fold increase in the number of qubits over current technology, the required increase in the number of gates that can be coherently executed is many orders of magnitude larger. This suggests that for quantum computation to become useful for quantum chemistry problems, drastic algorithmic improvements will be needed.
As quantum computing technology improves and quantum computers with a small but non-trivial number of N > 100 qubits appear feasible in the near future the question of possible applications of small quantum computers gains importance. One frequently mentioned application is Feynman's original proposal of simulating quantum systems, and in particular the electronic structure of molecules and materials. In this paper, we analyze the computational requirements for one of the standard algorithms to perform quantum chemistry on a quantum computer. We focus on the quantum resources required to find the ground state of a molecule twice as large as what current classical computers can solve exactly. We find that while such a problem requires about a ten-fold increase in the number of qubits over current technology, the required increase in the number of gates that can be coherently executed is many orders of magnitude larger. This suggests that for quantum computation to become useful for quantum chemistry problems, drastic algorithmic improvements will be needed.
As quantum computing technology improves and quantum computers with a small but non-trivial number of N ≥ 100 qubits appear feasible in the near future the question of possible applications of small quantum computers gains importance. One frequently mentioned application is Feynman’s original proposal of simulating quantum systems, and in particular the electronic structure of molecules and materials. In this paper, we analyze the computational requirements for one of the standard algorithms to perform quantum chemistry on a quantum computer. We focus on the quantum resources required to find the ground state of a molecule twice as large as what current classical computers can solve exactly. We find that while such a problem requires about a ten-fold increase in the number of qubits over current technology, the required increase in the number of gates that can be coherently executed is many orders of magnitude larger. This suggests that for quantum computation to become useful for quantum chemistry problems, drastic algorithmic improvements will be needed.
As we begin to reach the limits of classical computing, quantum computing has emerged as a technology that has captured the imagination of the scientific world. While for many years, the ability to execute quantum algorithms was only a theoretical possibility, recent advances in hardware mean that quantum computing devices now exist that can carry out quantum computation on a limited scale. Thus, it is now a real possibility, and of central importance at this time, to assess the potential impact of quantum computers on real problems of interest. One of the earliest and most compelling applications for quantum computers is Feynman's idea of simulating quantum systems with many degrees of freedom. Such systems are found across chemistry, physics, and materials science. The particular way in which quantum computing extends classical computing means that one cannot expect arbitrary simulations to be sped up by a quantum computer, thus one must carefully identify areas where quantum advantage may be achieved. In this review, we briefly describe central problems in chemistry and materials science, in areas of electronic structure, quantum statistical mechanics, and quantum dynamics that are of potential interest for solution on a quantum computer. We then take a detailed snapshot of current progress in quantum algorithms for ground-state, dynamics, and thermal-state simulation and analyze their strengths and weaknesses for future developments.
Determining properties of molecules and materials is one of the premier applications of quantum computing. A major question in the thesis is: how might we use long- and near-term quantum computers to solve problems of chemical interest? First, we give an overview of the standard model in electronic structure theory. Electronic structure methods have been improved significantly in the last decades; however, it is still a non-trivial task to fit experimental results for complex molecular systems. Second, we introduce quantum computation and quantum algorithms as an alternative device to solve the electronic structure problem. In the remaining part of the thesis, we describe the research projects. The thesis covers two (rather different) research directions: software and hardware projects. For the software part, we contribute with two new algorithms: Phase-Estimation Interval Target Energy Readout (PHILTER) and Recursive Variational Series Estimation (RVSE), where both are designed to be run on a quantum digital computer and extract materials and molecular properties. The PHILTER algorithm is a modification of the Quantum Phase Estimation and is designed to compute excited state energies within a target energy-interval for cases where good approximations for the states in the target energy-interval are either unknown or hard to prepare. For the RVSE algorithm, we pose the question: how might we use imperfect near-term quantum computers to solve problems of practical value? In this work, we introduce a method to compute expectation values of general functions of a Hamiltonian with respect to an input state using low depth quantum circuits suitable for noisy intermediate-scale quantum computers. For the hardware part, we propose a new chemical quantum computer by using molecular electronics as a basis for quantum computing. In this work, we pose the question: can scattering of electrons in molecules produce quantum gates? We construct one-qubit gates using one-electron scattering in molecules, and two-qubit controlled-phase gates using electron-electron scattering along metallic leads. We show initial applications of the framework by illustrating one-qubit gates using the molecular electronic structure of molecular hydrogen as a baseline model.
As quantum hardware continues to improve, more and more application scientists have entered the field of quantum computing. However, even with the rapid improvements in the last few years, quantum devices, especially for quantum chemistry applications, still struggle to perform calculations that classical computers could not calculate. In lieu of being able to perform specific calculations, it is important have a systematic way of estimating the resources necessary to tackle specific problems. Standard arguments about computational complexity provide hope that quantum computers will be useful for problems in quantum chemistry but obscure the true impact of many algorithmic overheads. These overheads will ultimately determine the precise point when quantum computers will perform better than classical computers. We have developed QREChem to provide logical resource estimates for ground state energy estimation in quantum chemistry through a Trotter-based quantum phase estimation approach. QREChem provides resource estimates which include the specific overheads inherent to problems in quantum chemistry by including heuristic estimates of the number of Trotter steps and number of necessary ancilla, allowing for more accurate estimates of the total number of gates. We utilize QREChem to provide logical resource estimates for a variety of small molecules in various basis sets, obtaining estimates in the range of 107–1015 for total number of T gates. We also determine estimates for the FeMoco molecule and compare all estimates to other resource estimation tools. Finally, we compare the total resources, including hardware and error correction overheads, demonstrating the need for fast error correction cycle times.
In quantum chemistry, the "electronic structure problem" refers to the process of numerically solving Schrodinger's equation for a given molecular system. These calculations rank among the most CPU-intensive computations that are performed nowadays, yet they are also crucial to the design of new drugs and materials. The idea behind quantum simulation of quantum chemistry is that a quantum computer could perform such calculations in a manner that is exponentially more efficient than what a classical computer could accomplish. In fact, quantum simulation is quite possibly the application most naturally suited to a quantum computer. In this work we introduce novel algorithms for the simulation of quantum chemistry, algorithms that are exponentially more precise than previous algorithms in the literature. Previous algorithms are based on the Trotter-Suzuki decomposition and scale like the inverse of the desired precision, while our algorithms represent the first practical application of the recently developed truncated Taylor series approach, and they achieve scaling that is logarithmic in the inverse of the precision. We explore algorithms for both second-quantized and first-quantized encodings of the chemistry Hamiltonian, where the second-quantized encoding requires mathcalO(N) qubits for an N spin-orbital system, and the highly compressed first-quantized encoding requires mathcalO(eta) qubits, where eta<<N is the number of electrons in the system. We first introduce a second-quantized algorithm that uses pre-computed molecular integrals, resulting in a gate count that scales like widetildecalO(N8t). Next we introduce algorithms that compute molecular integrals on the fly by carefully discretizing these integrals. Indeed, figuring out how to evaluate the integrals in an efficient manner is one of the main challenges of applying the truncated Taylor series approach to the chemistry problem: the complexity of a general quantum algorithm is traditionally formulated in terms of the number of queries made to an oracle whose assumption we just assume, but in this case, we actually construct the oracle for our specific problem. The evaluation of the oracle itself requires evaluating molecular integrals, which adds additional complexity to an algorithm. We find that the gate count of the second-quantized on-the-fly algorithm scales like widetildecalO(N5t). We also find that the first-quantized on-the-fly algorithm, which uses the configuration interaction (CI) matrix representation of the Hamiltonian, requires at most widetildecalO(eta2N3t) gates. In general, the discovery of exponentially more precise algorithms will allow for the simulation of larger molecular systems than was previously possible under Trotter-based methods. In addition, the results here can be generalized to the simulation of other fermionic systems beyond the electronic structure problem.
With quantum computers on the horizon, it is essential to understand what problems they can be used to solve. One potential application is simulating quantum systems, in particular, systems with many interacting electrons. However, there is a disparity between the computational resources required to study these problems and the capabilities of modern experimental quantum devices. In this thesis, we make progress toward closing this gap by reducing the cost of quantum simulation of quantum chemistry on a number of fronts. In the first half, we develop three improved quantum simulation algorithms by approximating time evolution under the Hamiltonian using a truncated Taylor series rather than the Trotter-Suzuki decomposition. We do this first for the molecular electronic structure Hamiltonian in two representations, obtaining asymptotic improvements in terms of both the number of orbitals and the required precision. We also apply the truncated Taylor series paradigm to quantum simulation in real space, where we consider simulation of general wave functions discretized on a uniform grid. In the second half, by working with Hamiltonians tailored specifically to quantum algorithms, we demonstrate that Trotter steps of the electronic structure Hamiltonian can be simulated in exactly N depth and with only linear connectivity, where N is the number of spin-orbitals. This resolves the problem of non-locality in fermion-to-qubit mappings, and has wide-ranging applications for variational and phase estimation-based quantum simulation of quantum chemistry. We further study this algorithm on an error-corrected quantum computer using the surface code. Benchmarking it alongside other product formula approaches, we show that quantum simulation of scientifically important instances of the electronic structure problem that are classically intractable can be performed with only a few hundred thousand physical qubits and fewer than one billion costly fault-tolerant gates. Finally, we study the effect of using randomized Hamiltonians in iterative phase estimation, and how this allows us to reduce the costs of simulation as well as to exploit knowledge of the ground state in how we design our simulation algorithm.