Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1311.6563

Higher-order semantics for quantum programming languages with classical control

Philip Atzemoglou

Published Nov 26, 2013• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This thesis studies the categorical formalisation of quantum computing, through the prism of type theory, in a three-tier process. The first stage of our investigation involves the creation of the dagger lambda calculus, a lambda calculus for dagger compact categories. Our second contribution lifts the expressive power of the dagger lambda calculus, to that of a quantum programming language, by adding classical control in the form of complementary classical structures and dualisers. Finally, our third contribution demonstrates how our lambda calculus can be applied to various well known problems in quantum computation.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1311.6563

Related papers

Higher-order semantics for quantum programming languages with classical control

George Philip Atzemoglou

This thesis studies the categorical formalisation of quantum computing, through the prism of type theory, in a three-tier process. The first stage of our investigation involves the creation of the dagger lambda calculus, a lambda calculus for dagger compact categories. Our second contribution lifts the expressive power of the dagger lambda calculus, to that of a quantum programming language, by adding classical control in the form of complementary classical structures and dualisers. Finally, our third contribution demonstrates how our lambda calculus can be applied to various well known problems in quantum computation: Quantum Key Distribution, the quantum Fourier transform, and the teleportation protocol./

•Jan 1, 2012•1 citation

Combiner le contrôle classique et quantique : une perspective logique, syntaxique et sémantique

Kinnari Vijay Dave

The focus of this thesis is on laying the theoretical foundation for designing an all-encompassing programming language for quantum computing. The idea inspiring all the contributions of this thesis was to mirror the development of programming languages and logic done for classical computing for its quantum counterpart. Following the groundwork of the Curry-Howard-Lambek correspondence, we try to delve into the three cornerstones of this correspondence - programming languages, logic and category theory with a focus on combining two paradigms of control flow in programs - quantum and classical into one framework. We have tried to achieve more. We have also touched upon the two complementary view of quantum mechanics- Heisenberg and Schrödinger, and adopted one view to define a physically intuitive semantics for the languages we discuss. There are two main contributions that this thesis makes to the existing literature on quantum programming languages. We first introduce a quantum lambda calculus which combines quantum and classical control, whose design is guided by the mathematical structure of its physically intuitive denotational semantics. The operational semantics for this language, is based on an adaptation of quantum configurations which we introduce, and is tied to the denotational model through an adequacy result. The language also provides a prototype of quantum inductive types through the type qnat- a type for quantum natural numbers. The denotational model for this calculus is based on von Neumann algebras- which are at the heart of the mathematical formulation of the Heisenberg view of quantum mechanics. The second contribution is a proof language for the IMALL fragment of Linear logic which builds on some key observations from the calculus introduced above. This language is one of the first such works to be able to support programs which combine constructs such as the quantum switch with measurement. In this aspect, this work is a strict improvement on the previous calculus, since it supports a more fine grained version of quantum control, thus enabling expression of algorithms such as the well-known quantum switch. The syntax is also linear algebraic in nature, supporting linear combinations of terms. A key consequence of this, along with the semantics of the B modality that it introduces is that measurement is no longer a ground construct of the language. In fact, it can now be written as just another program in the language. Finally, the denotational semantics for this work is based on C*-algebras - a generalization of von Neumann algebras. The denotational model is shown to be adequate for the operational semantics, whose linearity turns out to be a natural consequence of this. Finally, we conclude this thesis with limitations of these works and possible directions for future work.

•Dec 17, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Game Semantics

Marc de Visme

In this thesis, we study quantum programming languages, and focus on the quantum lambda-calculus, a paradigmatic language defined by Selinger and Valiron, which mixes a rich classical control flow (higher order functions, etc.) and quantum data (qubit creation, measure, and unitary operations). In this thesis, we search for a denotational semantics of this language, in other words, we extract the meaning and behaviour of programs by interpreting them in an adequately chosen mathematical universe. In order to model the quantum lambda-calculus, one must adapt the traditional denotational models to the mathematics of quantum computation (Hilbert spaces, density matrices, etc.). We have three main contributions:Firstly, we extend game semantics to the quantum case. Game semantics is a dynamic approach to denotational semantics, which focuses on the sequence of interactions between a program and its environment. We obtain the first denotational model of the full quantum lambda-calculus which is both compositional and interactive, meaning that it represents the dynamic of the execution. Our model generalise the recently developed model for the probabilistic case.Secondly, we formally link our model to the only pre-existing denotational model of the full lambda-calculus, the quantum relational model of Pagani, Selinger and Valiron.Lastly, we prove that our game model is fully abstract, the gold standard of denotational semantics, which ensures a total correspondence between the programming language and the model. We deduce that the quantum relational model was also fully abstract, which was an open problem.This thesis is constituted of three parts. The first part details some preliminaries on category theory, used for defining a formal framework including both the quantum game model and the quantum relational model, some preliminaries on the mathematics of quantum computation, and then some preliminaries on quantum programming and its models. The second part starts with some preliminaries on game semantics and defines our quantum game model in the simplified case of the linear quantum lambda-calculus. The third part builds on the second part to define the full quantum game model, prove its full abstraction, and deduce that the quantum relational model is fully abstract too.

•Sep 28, 2020•0 citations

Quantum Lambda Calculus

Peter Selinger, Benoît Valiron

We discuss the design of a typed lambda calculus for quantum computation. After a brief discussion of the role of higher-order functions in quantum information theory, we define the quantum lambda calculus and its operational semantics. Safety invariants, such as the no-cloning property, are enforced by a static type system that is based on intuitionistic linear logic. We also describe a type inference algorithm and a categorical semantics. 4.1 Introduction The lambda calculus, developed in the 1930s by Church and Curry, is a formalism for expressing higher-order functions. In a nutshell, a higher-order function is a function that inputs or outputs a “black box,” which is itself a (possibly higher-order) function. Higher-order functions are a computationally powerful tool. Indeed, the pure untyped lambda calculus has the same computational power as Turing machines (Turing 1937). At the same time, higher-order functions are a useful abstraction for programmers. They form the basis of functional programming languages such as LISP (McCarthy 1960), Scheme (Sussman and Steele 1975), ML (Milner 1978), and Haskell (Hudak et al. 2007). In this chapter, we discuss how to combine higher-order functions with quantum computation. We believe that this is an interesting question for a number of reasons. First, the combination of higher-order functions with quantum phenomena raises the prospect of entangled functions . Certain well-known quantum phenomena can be naturally described in terms of entangled functions, and we give some examples of this in Section 4.2.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 30, 2009•67 citations

The dagger lambda calculus

Philip Atzemoglou

We present a novel lambda calculus that casts the categorical approach to the study of quantum protocols into the rich and well established tradition of type theory. Our construction extends the linear typed lambda calculus with a linear negation of "trivialised" De Morgan duality. Reduction is realised through explicit substitution, based on a symmetric notion of binding of global scope, with rules acting on the entire typing judgement instead of on a specific subterm. Proofs of subject reduction, confluence, strong normalisation and consistency are provided, and the language is shown to be an internal language for dagger compact categories.

arXiv:1406.1633•Electronic Proceedings in Theoretical Computer Science•Dec 28, 2014•1 citation

Semantics of Higher-Order Quantum Computation via Geometry of Interaction

Ichiro Hasuo A, Naohiko Hoshino

While much of the current study on quantum computation employs low-level formalisms such as quantum circuits, several high-level languages/calculi have been recently proposed aiming at structured quantum programming. The current work contributes to the semantical study of such languages, by providing interaction-based semantics of a functional quantum programming language, the latter is based on linear lambda calculus and is equipped with features like the! modality and recursion. The proposed denotational model is the first one that supports the full features of a quantum functional programming language, we also prove adequacy of our semantics. The construction of our model is by a series of existing techniques taken from the semantics of classical computation as well as from process theory. The most notable among them is Girard's Geometry of Interaction (GoI), categorically formulated by Abramsky, Haghverdi and Scott. The mathematical genericity of these techniques - largely dueto their categorical formulation - is exploited for our move from classical to quantum.

ACM/IEEE Symposium on Logic in Computer Science (LICS)•Jun 1, 2011•41 citations
This thesis studies the categorical formalisation of quantum computing, through the prism of type theory, in a three-tier process. The first stage of our investigation involves the creation of the dagger lambda calculus, a lambda calculus for dagger compact categories. Our second contribution lifts the expressive power of the dagger lambda calculus, to that of a quantum programming language, by adding classical control in the form of complementary classical structures and dualisers. Finally, our third contribution demonstrates how our lambda calculus can be applied to various well known problems in quantum computation.
This thesis studies the categorical formalisation of quantum computing, through the prism of type theory, in a three-tier process. The first stage of our investigation involves the creation of the dagger lambda calculus, a lambda calculus for dagger compact categories. Our second contribution lifts the expressive power of the dagger lambda calculus, to that of a quantum programming language, by adding classical control in the form of complementary classical structures and dualisers. Finally, our third contribution demonstrates how our lambda calculus can be applied to various well known problems in quantum computation: Quantum Key Distribution, the quantum Fourier transform, and the teleportation protocol./
The focus of this thesis is on laying the theoretical foundation for designing an all-encompassing programming language for quantum computing. The idea inspiring all the contributions of this thesis was to mirror the development of programming languages and logic done for classical computing for its quantum counterpart. Following the groundwork of the Curry-Howard-Lambek correspondence, we try to delve into the three cornerstones of this correspondence - programming languages, logic and category theory with a focus on combining two paradigms of control flow in programs - quantum and classical into one framework. We have tried to achieve more. We have also touched upon the two complementary view of quantum mechanics- Heisenberg and Schrödinger, and adopted one view to define a physically intuitive semantics for the languages we discuss. There are two main contributions that this thesis makes to the existing literature on quantum programming languages. We first introduce a quantum lambda calculus which combines quantum and classical control, whose design is guided by the mathematical structure of its physically intuitive denotational semantics. The operational semantics for this language, is based on an adaptation of quantum configurations which we introduce, and is tied to the denotational model through an adequacy result. The language also provides a prototype of quantum inductive types through the type qnat- a type for quantum natural numbers. The denotational model for this calculus is based on von Neumann algebras- which are at the heart of the mathematical formulation of the Heisenberg view of quantum mechanics. The second contribution is a proof language for the IMALL fragment of Linear logic which builds on some key observations from the calculus introduced above. This language is one of the first such works to be able to support programs which combine constructs such as the quantum switch with measurement. In this aspect, this work is a strict improvement on the previous calculus, since it supports a more fine grained version of quantum control, thus enabling expression of algorithms such as the well-known quantum switch. The syntax is also linear algebraic in nature, supporting linear combinations of terms. A key consequence of this, along with the semantics of the B modality that it introduces is that measurement is no longer a ground construct of the language. In fact, it can now be written as just another program in the language. Finally, the denotational semantics for this work is based on C*-algebras - a generalization of von Neumann algebras. The denotational model is shown to be adequate for the operational semantics, whose linearity turns out to be a natural consequence of this. Finally, we conclude this thesis with limitations of these works and possible directions for future work.
In this thesis, we study quantum programming languages, and focus on the quantum lambda-calculus, a paradigmatic language defined by Selinger and Valiron, which mixes a rich classical control flow (higher order functions, etc.) and quantum data (qubit creation, measure, and unitary operations). In this thesis, we search for a denotational semantics of this language, in other words, we extract the meaning and behaviour of programs by interpreting them in an adequately chosen mathematical universe. In order to model the quantum lambda-calculus, one must adapt the traditional denotational models to the mathematics of quantum computation (Hilbert spaces, density matrices, etc.). We have three main contributions:Firstly, we extend game semantics to the quantum case. Game semantics is a dynamic approach to denotational semantics, which focuses on the sequence of interactions between a program and its environment. We obtain the first denotational model of the full quantum lambda-calculus which is both compositional and interactive, meaning that it represents the dynamic of the execution. Our model generalise the recently developed model for the probabilistic case.Secondly, we formally link our model to the only pre-existing denotational model of the full lambda-calculus, the quantum relational model of Pagani, Selinger and Valiron.Lastly, we prove that our game model is fully abstract, the gold standard of denotational semantics, which ensures a total correspondence between the programming language and the model. We deduce that the quantum relational model was also fully abstract, which was an open problem.This thesis is constituted of three parts. The first part details some preliminaries on category theory, used for defining a formal framework including both the quantum game model and the quantum relational model, some preliminaries on the mathematics of quantum computation, and then some preliminaries on quantum programming and its models. The second part starts with some preliminaries on game semantics and defines our quantum game model in the simplified case of the linear quantum lambda-calculus. The third part builds on the second part to define the full quantum game model, prove its full abstraction, and deduce that the quantum relational model is fully abstract too.
We discuss the design of a typed lambda calculus for quantum computation. After a brief discussion of the role of higher-order functions in quantum information theory, we define the quantum lambda calculus and its operational semantics. Safety invariants, such as the no-cloning property, are enforced by a static type system that is based on intuitionistic linear logic. We also describe a type inference algorithm and a categorical semantics. 4.1 Introduction The lambda calculus, developed in the 1930s by Church and Curry, is a formalism for expressing higher-order functions. In a nutshell, a higher-order function is a function that inputs or outputs a “black box,” which is itself a (possibly higher-order) function. Higher-order functions are a computationally powerful tool. Indeed, the pure untyped lambda calculus has the same computational power as Turing machines (Turing 1937). At the same time, higher-order functions are a useful abstraction for programmers. They form the basis of functional programming languages such as LISP (McCarthy 1960), Scheme (Sussman and Steele 1975), ML (Milner 1978), and Haskell (Hudak et al. 2007). In this chapter, we discuss how to combine higher-order functions with quantum computation. We believe that this is an interesting question for a number of reasons. First, the combination of higher-order functions with quantum phenomena raises the prospect of entangled functions . Certain well-known quantum phenomena can be naturally described in terms of entangled functions, and we give some examples of this in Section 4.2.
We present a novel lambda calculus that casts the categorical approach to the study of quantum protocols into the rich and well established tradition of type theory. Our construction extends the linear typed lambda calculus with a linear negation of "trivialised" De Morgan duality. Reduction is realised through explicit substitution, based on a symmetric notion of binding of global scope, with rules acting on the entire typing judgement instead of on a specific subterm. Proofs of subject reduction, confluence, strong normalisation and consistency are provided, and the language is shown to be an internal language for dagger compact categories.
While much of the current study on quantum computation employs low-level formalisms such as quantum circuits, several high-level languages/calculi have been recently proposed aiming at structured quantum programming. The current work contributes to the semantical study of such languages, by providing interaction-based semantics of a functional quantum programming language, the latter is based on linear lambda calculus and is equipped with features like the! modality and recursion. The proposed denotational model is the first one that supports the full features of a quantum functional programming language, we also prove adequacy of our semantics. The construction of our model is by a series of existing techniques taken from the semantics of classical computation as well as from process theory. The most notable among them is Girard's Geometry of Interaction (GoI), categorically formulated by Abramsky, Haghverdi and Scott. The mathematical genericity of these techniques - largely dueto their categorical formulation - is exploited for our move from classical to quantum.