Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1309.5517 · Physical Review A

Fundamental limitations in spin-ensemble quantum memories for cavity fields

Brian Julsgaard, Klaus Mølmer

Published Dec 20, 2013• 21 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Inhomogeneously broadened spin ensembles play an important role in present-day implementation of hybrid quantum processing architectures. When coupled to a cavity, such an ensemble may serve as a multimode quantum memory for the cavity field, and by employing spin-refocusing techniques the quantum-memory time can be extended to the coherence time of individual spins in the ensemble. In this paper, we investigate such a memory protocol capable of storing an unknown cavity-field state, and we examine separately the various constituents of the protocol: the storage and readout part, the memory hold time with the spin ensemble and cavity field decoupled, and the parts employing spin-refocusing techniques. Using both analytical and numerical methods, we derive how the obtainable memory performance scales with various physical parameters.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.88.062324

Related papers

Quantum Memory for Microwave Photons in an Inhomogeneously Broadened Spin Ensemble

Brian Julsgaard, Cécile Grèzes, Patrice Bertet +1 more

We propose a multimode quantum memory protocol able to store the quantum state of the field in a microwave resonator into an ensemble of electronic spins. The stored information is protected against inhomogeneous broadening of the spin ensemble by spin-echo techniques resulting in memory times orders of magnitude longer than previously achieved. By calculating the evolution of the first and second moments of the spin-cavity system variables for current experimental parameters, we show that a memory based on nitrogen vacancy center spins in diamond can store a qubit encoded on the |0> and |1> Fock states of the field with 80% fidelity and outperform classical memory strategies for storage times ≤69 μs.

arXiv:1301.1500•Physical Review Letters•Jun 18, 2013•159 citations

Solid-state cavity quantum electrodynamics with spin ensembles

Hanfeng Wang

Quantum sensors have the potential to operate at fundamental physical performance limits. Among various quantum sensing platforms, solid-state spin emitters stand out due to advantageous characteristics such as room-temperature spin polarization and readout, atomic-scale spatial resolution, and extended coherence times. Despite these strengths, traditional optical detection methods exhibit low readout fidelity in solid-state ensembles, severely limiting their achievable sensitivity. This thesis addresses this limitation by coupling a solid-state emitter ensemble to a microwave cavity, forming a cavity quantum electrodynamics system. Our approach eliminates the need for photon collection required by conventional optical readout methods, and the resulting strongly coupled system allows efficient cavity-based probing of the solid-state spin ensemble. By exploiting the hybrid quantum system with cavity quantum electrodynamics, we achieve record-high sensitivity for solid-state quantum sensors, representing a substantial advancement toward achieving fundamental sensing limits.

•May 1, 2025•0 citations

Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics with Spin Ensembles: From the Semiclassical to the Quantum Regime

Matthias Zens

Spin ensembles inside a cavity act as light-matter interfaces that play an eminentrole in the development of future quantum devices. An apparent asset of ensemble-based systems is the collective enhancement of the coupling strength, facilitating astrong interaction between the light and matter components. Particularly promisingin this regard, due to their convenient handling and integrability, are solid statespin ensembles such as nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond, phosphorous donors in silicon, or rare earth doped crystals. Such ensemble-based setups, however, are almost inevitably inhomogeneously broadened as the different spins of the ensemble typically have different local environments leading to a spectral distribution in their transition frequencies. This so-called inhomogeneous broadening is a major source for decoherence in solid state systems and a major challenge to be addressed for future technical applications.In this thesis, we aim to provide the theoretical framework necessary to describeand understand various effects of inhomogeneously broadened spin ensembles coupled to a single-mode cavity—a system that has been realized in numerous different quantum optical setups and in very different parameter regimes.For macroscopic spin ensembles, i.e., ensembles consisting of a vast number ofspins, quantum fluctuations of the individual spins can typically be neglected, allowing a semiclassical description based on Maxwell-Bloch equations. Here, we study two prominent effects in the strongly nonlinear regime namely optical bistability, resembling a first-order phase transition, and critical slowing down. In particular, we show that the onset of bistability not only depends on the width of the spectral spin distribution but also strongly depends on its exact shape. Furthermore, we analyze the transient times of the cavity amplitude which show a power-law divergence when an external parameter is changed in the vicinity of the phase transition.This critical slowdown is demonstrated in collaboration with the group ofJörg Schmiedmayer at the Atominstitut of TU Wien. In the experiment, negativelycharged nitrogen vacancy centers in diamond are strongly coupled to a superconducting microwave resonator showing transient times of up to 11 hours.In mesoscopic spin ensembles with moderate numbers of constituents, quantumfluctuations gain importance, and semiclassical methods fail. We study thiscrossover between the semiclassical and the quantum regime using a cumulant expansion approach to study the semiclassical-to-quantum boundary for inhomogeneously broadened spin ensembles inside a cavity. In addition, we develop a time-adaptivevariational renormalization group method to calculate the full quantumdynamics of spin ensembles containing up to one hundred spins. With the aid ofthis method, we examine mesoscopic spin ensembles whose spin distributions form a comb-shaped structure. These so-called atomic frequency combs have promising properties for the storage of quantum information. On the one hand, we show that arbitrary multi-photon states are absorbed by the comb-shaped spin ensembleand re-emitted into the cavity at periodic time intervals. On the other hand, wedemonstrate that by means of such a spin ensemble a coherent input pulse can beconverted into periodic pulses of non-classical light.Finally, we address spin echoes, which are a fundamental part in nuclear magneticresonance as well as in electron spin resonance. Specifically, we transfer the Hahnecho to the strong coupling regime, where we find a new dynamical phenomenonfeaturing a periodic sequence of self-sustained echoes after a conventional Hahn echo pulse. In collaboration with the group of Hans Hübl at the Technical UniversityMunich, a first demonstration of this intriguing multiecho signature is presented inan electron spin resonance experiment with phosphorus donors in silicon.

•Nov 1, 2021•0 citations

Multi-mode storage and retrieval of microwave fields in a spin ensemble

Cécile Grèzes, Brian Julsgaard, Yuimaru Kubo +13 more

A quantum memory at microwave frequencies, able to store the state of multiple superconducting qubits for long times, is a key element for quantum information processing. Electronic and nuclear spins are natural candidates for the storage medium as their coherence time can be well above one second. Benefiting from these long coherence times requires to apply the refocusing techniques used in magnetic resonance, a major challenge in the context of hybrid quantum circuits. Here we report the first implementation of such a scheme, using ensembles of nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centres in diamond coupled to a superconducting resonator, in a setup compatible with superconducting qubit technology. We implement the active reset of the NV spins into their ground state by optical pumping and their refocusing by Hahn echo sequences. This enables the storage of multiple microwave pulses at the picoWatt level and their retrieval after up to $35 μ$s, a three orders of magnitude improvement compared to previous experiments.

arXiv:1401.7939•Jan 30, 2014•21 citations

Cumulant expansion approach to nonlinear dynamics of inhomogeneous ensembles in cavity QED

Matthias Zens

In the last couple of years much effort has been dedicated to the development and the investigation of hybrid quantum devices, which combine the advantages of very dissimilar quantum systems for the realization of efficient quantum computation and communication technologies. Particularly interesting in this regard are solid-state quantum memories based on ensembles of spins (e.g. nitrogen vacancy defects in diamond or rare-earth doped crystals) coupled to superconducting microwave cavities. Here the spin-ensemble acts as a robust memory where the collective coupling to the cavity mode allows for the coherent transfer of quantum information. The major downside of ensembles inside solid-state systems is their natural tendency to exhibit inhomogeneous broadening of the transition frequencies, which makes experiments as well as their theoretical description very challenging. On the theoretical side it is primarily the computational complexity due to the exponential growth of the associated Hilbert space with the system size that inevitably calls for approximation schemes. To date, the theoretical description of large spin-cavity systems is mainly limited to weak driving fields, where the number of spin-excitations in the ensemble is negligible, corresponding to a Holstein-Primakoff approximation, or to mean-field approaches, where correlations within the system are neglected. In this thesis we aim to develop a model that accurately accounts for the dynamics of large inhomogeneously broadened spin ensembles, coupled to a single cavity mode, even in the case of strong driving fields. In particular we employ the generalized cumulant expansion method to account for correlations within the system, which allows us to go beyond the Holstein-Primakoff and mean-field approximations. As a first step, we demonstrate the applicability of the cumulant expansion technique to the well-studied Jaynes-Cummings model and investigate its main limitations. We then move on to the Tavis-Cummings model with multiple spins inside the cavity and generalize our approach to ensembles containing a very large number of spins (ca. 10 12). Our model aims not only to provide a proper description of ensemble-based quantum memories, but also to serve as a novel tool for the investigation of interesting new physics arising from cooperative effects in inhomogeneous ensembles.

•Sep 1, 2016•1 citation

Multimode memories with longitudinally broadened ensembles

J. Nunn, Karl Surmacz, F. C. Waldermann +6 more

Quantum storage of multiple optical modes affords improved performance for quantum repeaters. We present new analytic and numerical results unifying the scaling of the multimode storage capacity for various memory protocols in artificially broadened ensembles.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics•May 4, 2008•0 citations
Inhomogeneously broadened spin ensembles play an important role in present-day implementation of hybrid quantum processing architectures. When coupled to a cavity, such an ensemble may serve as a multimode quantum memory for the cavity field, and by employing spin-refocusing techniques the quantum-memory time can be extended to the coherence time of individual spins in the ensemble. In this paper, we investigate such a memory protocol capable of storing an unknown cavity-field state, and we examine separately the various constituents of the protocol: the storage and readout part, the memory hold time with the spin ensemble and cavity field decoupled, and the parts employing spin-refocusing techniques. Using both analytical and numerical methods, we derive how the obtainable memory performance scales with various physical parameters.
We propose a multimode quantum memory protocol able to store the quantum state of the field in a microwave resonator into an ensemble of electronic spins. The stored information is protected against inhomogeneous broadening of the spin ensemble by spin-echo techniques resulting in memory times orders of magnitude longer than previously achieved. By calculating the evolution of the first and second moments of the spin-cavity system variables for current experimental parameters, we show that a memory based on nitrogen vacancy center spins in diamond can store a qubit encoded on the |0> and |1> Fock states of the field with 80% fidelity and outperform classical memory strategies for storage times ≤69 μs.
Quantum sensors have the potential to operate at fundamental physical performance limits. Among various quantum sensing platforms, solid-state spin emitters stand out due to advantageous characteristics such as room-temperature spin polarization and readout, atomic-scale spatial resolution, and extended coherence times. Despite these strengths, traditional optical detection methods exhibit low readout fidelity in solid-state ensembles, severely limiting their achievable sensitivity. This thesis addresses this limitation by coupling a solid-state emitter ensemble to a microwave cavity, forming a cavity quantum electrodynamics system. Our approach eliminates the need for photon collection required by conventional optical readout methods, and the resulting strongly coupled system allows efficient cavity-based probing of the solid-state spin ensemble. By exploiting the hybrid quantum system with cavity quantum electrodynamics, we achieve record-high sensitivity for solid-state quantum sensors, representing a substantial advancement toward achieving fundamental sensing limits.
Spin ensembles inside a cavity act as light-matter interfaces that play an eminentrole in the development of future quantum devices. An apparent asset of ensemble-based systems is the collective enhancement of the coupling strength, facilitating astrong interaction between the light and matter components. Particularly promisingin this regard, due to their convenient handling and integrability, are solid statespin ensembles such as nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond, phosphorous donors in silicon, or rare earth doped crystals. Such ensemble-based setups, however, are almost inevitably inhomogeneously broadened as the different spins of the ensemble typically have different local environments leading to a spectral distribution in their transition frequencies. This so-called inhomogeneous broadening is a major source for decoherence in solid state systems and a major challenge to be addressed for future technical applications.In this thesis, we aim to provide the theoretical framework necessary to describeand understand various effects of inhomogeneously broadened spin ensembles coupled to a single-mode cavity—a system that has been realized in numerous different quantum optical setups and in very different parameter regimes.For macroscopic spin ensembles, i.e., ensembles consisting of a vast number ofspins, quantum fluctuations of the individual spins can typically be neglected, allowing a semiclassical description based on Maxwell-Bloch equations. Here, we study two prominent effects in the strongly nonlinear regime namely optical bistability, resembling a first-order phase transition, and critical slowing down. In particular, we show that the onset of bistability not only depends on the width of the spectral spin distribution but also strongly depends on its exact shape. Furthermore, we analyze the transient times of the cavity amplitude which show a power-law divergence when an external parameter is changed in the vicinity of the phase transition.This critical slowdown is demonstrated in collaboration with the group ofJörg Schmiedmayer at the Atominstitut of TU Wien. In the experiment, negativelycharged nitrogen vacancy centers in diamond are strongly coupled to a superconducting microwave resonator showing transient times of up to 11 hours.In mesoscopic spin ensembles with moderate numbers of constituents, quantumfluctuations gain importance, and semiclassical methods fail. We study thiscrossover between the semiclassical and the quantum regime using a cumulant expansion approach to study the semiclassical-to-quantum boundary for inhomogeneously broadened spin ensembles inside a cavity. In addition, we develop a time-adaptivevariational renormalization group method to calculate the full quantumdynamics of spin ensembles containing up to one hundred spins. With the aid ofthis method, we examine mesoscopic spin ensembles whose spin distributions form a comb-shaped structure. These so-called atomic frequency combs have promising properties for the storage of quantum information. On the one hand, we show that arbitrary multi-photon states are absorbed by the comb-shaped spin ensembleand re-emitted into the cavity at periodic time intervals. On the other hand, wedemonstrate that by means of such a spin ensemble a coherent input pulse can beconverted into periodic pulses of non-classical light.Finally, we address spin echoes, which are a fundamental part in nuclear magneticresonance as well as in electron spin resonance. Specifically, we transfer the Hahnecho to the strong coupling regime, where we find a new dynamical phenomenonfeaturing a periodic sequence of self-sustained echoes after a conventional Hahn echo pulse. In collaboration with the group of Hans Hübl at the Technical UniversityMunich, a first demonstration of this intriguing multiecho signature is presented inan electron spin resonance experiment with phosphorus donors in silicon.
A quantum memory at microwave frequencies, able to store the state of multiple superconducting qubits for long times, is a key element for quantum information processing. Electronic and nuclear spins are natural candidates for the storage medium as their coherence time can be well above one second. Benefiting from these long coherence times requires to apply the refocusing techniques used in magnetic resonance, a major challenge in the context of hybrid quantum circuits. Here we report the first implementation of such a scheme, using ensembles of nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centres in diamond coupled to a superconducting resonator, in a setup compatible with superconducting qubit technology. We implement the active reset of the NV spins into their ground state by optical pumping and their refocusing by Hahn echo sequences. This enables the storage of multiple microwave pulses at the picoWatt level and their retrieval after up to 35μ35 μ35μs, a three orders of magnitude improvement compared to previous experiments.
In the last couple of years much effort has been dedicated to the development and the investigation of hybrid quantum devices, which combine the advantages of very dissimilar quantum systems for the realization of efficient quantum computation and communication technologies. Particularly interesting in this regard are solid-state quantum memories based on ensembles of spins (e.g. nitrogen vacancy defects in diamond or rare-earth doped crystals) coupled to superconducting microwave cavities. Here the spin-ensemble acts as a robust memory where the collective coupling to the cavity mode allows for the coherent transfer of quantum information. The major downside of ensembles inside solid-state systems is their natural tendency to exhibit inhomogeneous broadening of the transition frequencies, which makes experiments as well as their theoretical description very challenging. On the theoretical side it is primarily the computational complexity due to the exponential growth of the associated Hilbert space with the system size that inevitably calls for approximation schemes. To date, the theoretical description of large spin-cavity systems is mainly limited to weak driving fields, where the number of spin-excitations in the ensemble is negligible, corresponding to a Holstein-Primakoff approximation, or to mean-field approaches, where correlations within the system are neglected. In this thesis we aim to develop a model that accurately accounts for the dynamics of large inhomogeneously broadened spin ensembles, coupled to a single cavity mode, even in the case of strong driving fields. In particular we employ the generalized cumulant expansion method to account for correlations within the system, which allows us to go beyond the Holstein-Primakoff and mean-field approximations. As a first step, we demonstrate the applicability of the cumulant expansion technique to the well-studied Jaynes-Cummings model and investigate its main limitations. We then move on to the Tavis-Cummings model with multiple spins inside the cavity and generalize our approach to ensembles containing a very large number of spins (ca. 10 12). Our model aims not only to provide a proper description of ensemble-based quantum memories, but also to serve as a novel tool for the investigation of interesting new physics arising from cooperative effects in inhomogeneous ensembles.