Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1308.6343

Can spontaneous symmetry breaking order develop in a topological phase?

Huaiming Guo

Published Aug 29, 2013• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Landau's symmetry breaking theory is the basis of modern condensed matter physics, from which most phases can be understood. The recent discovery of topological insulators simulates the study on the topological phase which is beyond this theory. An interesting question is whether the topological phase and spontaneous symmetry breaking order can coexist. We study this problem based on the topological phase in the Haldane model. Firstly by including a staggered potential, we show that if the system is subjected to the symmetry needed by the charge density wave (CDW) order in advance, the topological phase can coexist with the CDW order, realizing the topological CDW phase. While when the nearest neighor interaction which preserves the symmetry of the origin Hamiltonian is included, the CDW order can not develop from spontaneous symmetry breaking in the topological phase. The results imply that a spontaneous symmetry breaking order may not develop in a topological phase.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1308.6343

Related papers

Symmetry-breaking topological insulators in the Z2 Bose-Hubbard model

Daniel González-Cuadra, Alexandre Dauphin, Przemysław R. Grzybowski +3 more

We study a one-dimensional model of interacting bosons coupled to a dynamical ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ field, the ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ Bose-Hubbard model, and analyze the interplay between spontaneous symmetry breaking and topological symmetry protection. In a previous work, we showed how this model exhibits a spontaneous breaking of the translational symmetry through a bosonic Peierls transition. Here we find how, at half filling, the resulting phase also displays topological features that coexist with the presence of long-range order and yields a topological bond order wave. Using both analytical and numerical methods, we describe the properties of this phase, showing that it cannot be adiabatically connected to a topological phase of noninteracting bosons, and thus constitutes an instance of an interaction-induced symmetry-breaking topological insulator.

arXiv:1811.08392•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 24, 2019•58 citations

Spontaneous symmetry breaking of an interacting Chern insulator on a topological square lattice

Yi-Xiang Wang, Dong‐Xiang Qi

The interplay between topology and correlation lies at the forefront of modern condensed matter physics. In this paper, we study the extended fermion-Hubbard model, including the on-site as well as the nearest-neighbor repulsive interactions, on a topological square lattice that supports the Chern insulator. Within the mean-field method, we find that the spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) charge-density wave or antiferromagnetic insulator dominates the system when the onsite or nearest-neighbor interactions are strong enough. It is interesting that the antiferromagnetic Chern insulator will appear in the phase diagram when there is an explicitly nonvanishing sublattice potential. In addition, we explore how a finite-size ribbon structure affects the phase diagram and point out that the critical interaction for SSB occurs with weaker strength than the bulk system.

arXiv:2001.06758•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 27, 2019•13 citations

Higher-order topological insulator in a modified Haldane-Hubbard model

Tian-Cheng Yi, Hai‐Qing Lin, Rubem Mondaini

We investigate the ground-state phase diagram of a modified spinless Haldane-Hubbard model, with broken threefold rotational symmetry, employing exact diagonalization calculations. The interplay of asymmetry, interactions, and topology gives rise to a rich phase diagram. The noninteracting limit of the Hamiltonian exhibits a higher-order topological insulator characterized by the existence of corner modes, in contrast to known chiral edge metallic states of the standard Haldane model. Our investigation demonstrates that these symmetry-protected states are robust to the presence of finite interactions. Furthermore, in certain regimes of parameters, we show that a topological Mott insulator exists in this model, where a nontrivial topological bulk coexists with an interaction-driven charge-density wave, whose emergence is characterized by a ${Z}_{2}$-symmetry breaking within the $3d\text{-Ising}$ universality class.

arXiv:2212.10835•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 20, 2023•8 citations

Symmetry protected topological phases of matter

Yoshimasa Hidaka, Ken Shiozaki, Kenji Fukushima

One problem of paramount importance in physics over various fields such as elementary particle physics, condensed matter physics, and statistical mechanics has been to make classification of phases of matter, including nontrivial structures of the vacuum. The triumphant history of theory on the phase classification and the phase transition can be traced back to Landau, which is based on the spontaneous breaking of symmetry. It is known, however, that other kinds of phases exist that cannot be characterized by conventional arguments of symmetry breaking, namely, topological phases. Topological phases are gapped phases at zero temperature without symmetry breaking. Examples of the topological phases include a quantum phase in a fractional quantum Hall system, where the ground state exhibits degeneracy, and an anyon, a quasi-particle with nontrivial statistical nature, neither boson nor fermion, emerges as a low-energy excitation. In contemporary physics of the 21st century, it has been revealed that, among various topological states, there exists a nontrivial ground state that does not have ground state degeneracy and yet can be distinguished from a trivial state. This nontrivial ground state, i.e., a topological insulator, has been recognized first in free electron systems [1–3] and later extended to more general quantum many-body systems with interactions including bosonic (spin) systems. Now, such a generalized situation is called a symmetry protected topological (SPT) phase [4–7]. From the point of a modern view of the SPT phase, nontrivial states, such as the Haldane state proposed in antiferromagnetic quantum spin systems in the 1980’s [8] and the ground state in the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki model [9], belong to the SPT phase. A remarkable feature of the SPT phase is that, if the system has a surface, gapless surface states appear and they are stable against disturbances which do not break the symmetry. One way to understand these surface states is the quantum anomaly on the surface. That is, as long as the surface is concerned, the quantum anomaly arises, but the whole system has no quantum anomaly, and the symmetry is preserved due to cancellation from the bulk contribution. This canceling mechanism of the quantum anomaly has been long known as the anomaly inflow in elementary particle physics [10]. In fact, the classification of the SPT phases can be identified as the classification of the quantum anomaly through the bulk-boundary correspondence. This type of the quantum anomaly closely related to the SPT phase can provide us with a useful theoretical device to constrain phases that can or cannot be realized under the ’t Hooft anomaly matching condition [11–13]. It is quite difficult to scrutinize nonperturbatively interacting systems, but the ’t Hooft anomaly matching condition can be applied to those systems, and possible phases can be constrained. Nowadays, our understanding of the SPT phases has been so developed that applications of the anomaly matching condition can cover systems with finite groups and/or extending objects [14–16]. In this way, the concept of the topological phases has been essential by now in a wide range of physics, particularly in elementary particle physics, condensed matter physics, and statistical mechanics, as mentioned in the beginning. This special section is a collection of papers related to the topological aspects of physics including the topological phases. We would like to express our sincere gratitude to all the authors who made excellent contributions.

Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Mar 16, 2022•1 citation

Theoretical studies of some topological systems

Danbo Zhang

Understanding the interplay between symmetries and phases lies at the heart of characterizing states of matter. The conventional Landau's paradigm associates local ordered states with symmetry breaking, but this paradigm fails to include gapped topological phases, which can only be distinguished by the global topological invariant and the present of gapless edge modes at open boundaries. In this thesis, variety of states of matter is enriched from two aspects: a new paradigm of phases that incorporates both symmetry broken phase and topological phase, and exotic topological phases that are realized in different degree of freedoms of the same system. The two aspects are explored by studying corresponding one dimensional fermionic models. Besides gapped phases, exotic quasiparticle interferences of gapless topological systems are also investigated. \n \nThe first chapter serves as a theoretical basis for the next two chapters by giving an introduction to topological phases in one dimension. In particular, a bosonization method is introduced to describe topological degeneracy and edge zero modes, which is favoured by the ability to deal with interactions as well as to uncover the phenomena of spin-charge separation. \n \nIn the second chapter a new paradigm of phases is proposed and investigated that incorporates both symmetry broken phases and symmetry-protected topological phases. Through exact-solvable models bond spin density wave(BSDW) states are proposed as candidates for this new paradigm, which are $\\ZZ_2$ symmetry breaking due to spontaneous dimerization and yet each is topological nontrivial with edge zero modes of fractional fermions. More general lattice models are constructed, and it is shown that BSDW exists in a considerable regime of parameters for a family of lattice models, from both mean-field analysis and bosonization. \n \nIn the third chapter, we give an effective field description for spin-charge separated edge modes consisting of both Majorana modes and fractional fermions, and demonstrate how to harvest both simultaneously in a spinless fermionic ladder with particle-hole symmetry and single-chain fermion parity. Further, the idea of spin-charge separated edge modes is applied to reinterpret the prominent Haldane phase of spin-1 chain in its equivalent spin-$\\frac{1}{2}$ fermionic model. \n \nIn contrast to the above two theoretically oriented topics that aim to add variety to topological phases, the third topic establishes a bridge between abstract concepts for topological systems to remarkable features that can be detected in experiments. The last chapter reveals how topological charges for topological Fermi points, through exhibiting exotic quasiparticle interference in the presence of impurities, could be visualized in STS measurements. \nThe generalized joint density of states(GJDOS) is applied to address effects from the geometry of band dispersion and topological charges separately. Both analytical results and numerical simulation suggest distinct and robust quasiparticle interference features as indicators for topological charges that can be accessed by FT-STS experiments.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Non-onsite symmetry breaking: Topological phase coexistence and criticality

Zhehao Zhang, Yabo Li, Tsung-Cheng Lu

We explore the states of matter arising from the spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) of $\mathbb{Z}_2$ non-onsite symmetries. In one spatial dimension, we construct a frustration-free lattice model exhibiting SSB of a non-onsite symmetry, which features the coexistence of two ground states with distinct symmetry-protected topological (SPT) orders. We analytically prove the two-fold ground-state degeneracy and the existence of a finite energy gap. Fixing the symmetry sector yields a long-range entangled ground state that features long-range correlations among non-invertible charged operators. We also present a constant-depth measurement-feedback protocol to prepare such a state with a constant success probability in the thermodynamic limit, which may be of independent interest. Under a symmetric deformation, the SSB persists up to a critical point, beyond which a gapless phase characterized by a conformal field theory emerges. In two spatial dimensions, the SSB of 1-form non-onsite symmetries leads to a long-range entangled state (SPT soup) - a condensate of 1d SPT along any closed loops. On a torus, there are four such locally indistinguishable states that exhibit algebraic correlations between local operators, which we derived via a mapping to the critical $O(2)$ loop model. This constitutes an intriguing example of `topological quantum criticality'.

arXiv:2411.05004•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 5, 2026•16 citations
Landau's symmetry breaking theory is the basis of modern condensed matter physics, from which most phases can be understood. The recent discovery of topological insulators simulates the study on the topological phase which is beyond this theory. An interesting question is whether the topological phase and spontaneous symmetry breaking order can coexist. We study this problem based on the topological phase in the Haldane model. Firstly by including a staggered potential, we show that if the system is subjected to the symmetry needed by the charge density wave (CDW) order in advance, the topological phase can coexist with the CDW order, realizing the topological CDW phase. While when the nearest neighor interaction which preserves the symmetry of the origin Hamiltonian is included, the CDW order can not develop from spontaneous symmetry breaking in the topological phase. The results imply that a spontaneous symmetry breaking order may not develop in a topological phase.
We study a one-dimensional model of interacting bosons coupled to a dynamical Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ field, the Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ Bose-Hubbard model, and analyze the interplay between spontaneous symmetry breaking and topological symmetry protection. In a previous work, we showed how this model exhibits a spontaneous breaking of the translational symmetry through a bosonic Peierls transition. Here we find how, at half filling, the resulting phase also displays topological features that coexist with the presence of long-range order and yields a topological bond order wave. Using both analytical and numerical methods, we describe the properties of this phase, showing that it cannot be adiabatically connected to a topological phase of noninteracting bosons, and thus constitutes an instance of an interaction-induced symmetry-breaking topological insulator.
The interplay between topology and correlation lies at the forefront of modern condensed matter physics. In this paper, we study the extended fermion-Hubbard model, including the on-site as well as the nearest-neighbor repulsive interactions, on a topological square lattice that supports the Chern insulator. Within the mean-field method, we find that the spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) charge-density wave or antiferromagnetic insulator dominates the system when the onsite or nearest-neighbor interactions are strong enough. It is interesting that the antiferromagnetic Chern insulator will appear in the phase diagram when there is an explicitly nonvanishing sublattice potential. In addition, we explore how a finite-size ribbon structure affects the phase diagram and point out that the critical interaction for SSB occurs with weaker strength than the bulk system.
We investigate the ground-state phase diagram of a modified spinless Haldane-Hubbard model, with broken threefold rotational symmetry, employing exact diagonalization calculations. The interplay of asymmetry, interactions, and topology gives rise to a rich phase diagram. The noninteracting limit of the Hamiltonian exhibits a higher-order topological insulator characterized by the existence of corner modes, in contrast to known chiral edge metallic states of the standard Haldane model. Our investigation demonstrates that these symmetry-protected states are robust to the presence of finite interactions. Furthermore, in certain regimes of parameters, we show that a topological Mott insulator exists in this model, where a nontrivial topological bulk coexists with an interaction-driven charge-density wave, whose emergence is characterized by a Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​-symmetry breaking within the 3d-Ising3d\text{-Ising}3d-Ising universality class.
One problem of paramount importance in physics over various fields such as elementary particle physics, condensed matter physics, and statistical mechanics has been to make classification of phases of matter, including nontrivial structures of the vacuum. The triumphant history of theory on the phase classification and the phase transition can be traced back to Landau, which is based on the spontaneous breaking of symmetry. It is known, however, that other kinds of phases exist that cannot be characterized by conventional arguments of symmetry breaking, namely, topological phases. Topological phases are gapped phases at zero temperature without symmetry breaking. Examples of the topological phases include a quantum phase in a fractional quantum Hall system, where the ground state exhibits degeneracy, and an anyon, a quasi-particle with nontrivial statistical nature, neither boson nor fermion, emerges as a low-energy excitation. In contemporary physics of the 21st century, it has been revealed that, among various topological states, there exists a nontrivial ground state that does not have ground state degeneracy and yet can be distinguished from a trivial state. This nontrivial ground state, i.e., a topological insulator, has been recognized first in free electron systems [1–3] and later extended to more general quantum many-body systems with interactions including bosonic (spin) systems. Now, such a generalized situation is called a symmetry protected topological (SPT) phase [4–7]. From the point of a modern view of the SPT phase, nontrivial states, such as the Haldane state proposed in antiferromagnetic quantum spin systems in the 1980’s [8] and the ground state in the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki model [9], belong to the SPT phase. A remarkable feature of the SPT phase is that, if the system has a surface, gapless surface states appear and they are stable against disturbances which do not break the symmetry. One way to understand these surface states is the quantum anomaly on the surface. That is, as long as the surface is concerned, the quantum anomaly arises, but the whole system has no quantum anomaly, and the symmetry is preserved due to cancellation from the bulk contribution. This canceling mechanism of the quantum anomaly has been long known as the anomaly inflow in elementary particle physics [10]. In fact, the classification of the SPT phases can be identified as the classification of the quantum anomaly through the bulk-boundary correspondence. This type of the quantum anomaly closely related to the SPT phase can provide us with a useful theoretical device to constrain phases that can or cannot be realized under the ’t Hooft anomaly matching condition [11–13]. It is quite difficult to scrutinize nonperturbatively interacting systems, but the ’t Hooft anomaly matching condition can be applied to those systems, and possible phases can be constrained. Nowadays, our understanding of the SPT phases has been so developed that applications of the anomaly matching condition can cover systems with finite groups and/or extending objects [14–16]. In this way, the concept of the topological phases has been essential by now in a wide range of physics, particularly in elementary particle physics, condensed matter physics, and statistical mechanics, as mentioned in the beginning. This special section is a collection of papers related to the topological aspects of physics including the topological phases. We would like to express our sincere gratitude to all the authors who made excellent contributions.
Understanding the interplay between symmetries and phases lies at the heart of characterizing states of matter. The conventional Landau's paradigm associates local ordered states with symmetry breaking, but this paradigm fails to include gapped topological phases, which can only be distinguished by the global topological invariant and the present of gapless edge modes at open boundaries. In this thesis, variety of states of matter is enriched from two aspects: a new paradigm of phases that incorporates both symmetry broken phase and topological phase, and exotic topological phases that are realized in different degree of freedoms of the same system. The two aspects are explored by studying corresponding one dimensional fermionic models. Besides gapped phases, exotic quasiparticle interferences of gapless topological systems are also investigated. \n \nThe first chapter serves as a theoretical basis for the next two chapters by giving an introduction to topological phases in one dimension. In particular, a bosonization method is introduced to describe topological degeneracy and edge zero modes, which is favoured by the ability to deal with interactions as well as to uncover the phenomena of spin-charge separation. \n \nIn the second chapter a new paradigm of phases is proposed and investigated that incorporates both symmetry broken phases and symmetry-protected topological phases. Through exact-solvable models bond spin density wave(BSDW) states are proposed as candidates for this new paradigm, which are ZZ2\\ZZ_2ZZ2​ symmetry breaking due to spontaneous dimerization and yet each is topological nontrivial with edge zero modes of fractional fermions. More general lattice models are constructed, and it is shown that BSDW exists in a considerable regime of parameters for a family of lattice models, from both mean-field analysis and bosonization. \n \nIn the third chapter, we give an effective field description for spin-charge separated edge modes consisting of both Majorana modes and fractional fermions, and demonstrate how to harvest both simultaneously in a spinless fermionic ladder with particle-hole symmetry and single-chain fermion parity. Further, the idea of spin-charge separated edge modes is applied to reinterpret the prominent Haldane phase of spin-1 chain in its equivalent spin-frac12\\frac{1}{2}frac12 fermionic model. \n \nIn contrast to the above two theoretically oriented topics that aim to add variety to topological phases, the third topic establishes a bridge between abstract concepts for topological systems to remarkable features that can be detected in experiments. The last chapter reveals how topological charges for topological Fermi points, through exhibiting exotic quasiparticle interference in the presence of impurities, could be visualized in STS measurements. \nThe generalized joint density of states(GJDOS) is applied to address effects from the geometry of band dispersion and topological charges separately. Both analytical results and numerical simulation suggest distinct and robust quasiparticle interference features as indicators for topological charges that can be accessed by FT-STS experiments.
We explore the states of matter arising from the spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) of Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ non-onsite symmetries. In one spatial dimension, we construct a frustration-free lattice model exhibiting SSB of a non-onsite symmetry, which features the coexistence of two ground states with distinct symmetry-protected topological (SPT) orders. We analytically prove the two-fold ground-state degeneracy and the existence of a finite energy gap. Fixing the symmetry sector yields a long-range entangled ground state that features long-range correlations among non-invertible charged operators. We also present a constant-depth measurement-feedback protocol to prepare such a state with a constant success probability in the thermodynamic limit, which may be of independent interest. Under a symmetric deformation, the SSB persists up to a critical point, beyond which a gapless phase characterized by a conformal field theory emerges. In two spatial dimensions, the SSB of 1-form non-onsite symmetries leads to a long-range entangled state (SPT soup) - a condensate of 1d SPT along any closed loops. On a torus, there are four such locally indistinguishable states that exhibit algebraic correlations between local operators, which we derived via a mapping to the critical O(2)O(2)O(2) loop model. This constitutes an intriguing example of `topological quantum criticality'.