Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1308.1429 · Physical Review C

Subtraction method and stability condition in extended random-phase approximation theories

V. Tselyaev

Published Nov 4, 2013• 90 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The extended random-phase approximation (RPA) theories are analyzed from the point of view of the problem of the stability of their solutions. Three kinds of such theories are considered: the second RPA and two versions of the quasiparticle-phonon coupling model within the time-blocking approximation: the model including $1p1h\ensuremath{\bigotimes}$phonon configurations and the two-phonon model. It is shown that stability is ensured by making use of the subtraction method proposed previously to solve the double counting problem in these theories. This enables one to generalize the famous Thouless theorem proved in the case of the RPA. These results are illustrated by an example of the schematic model.

DOI
10.1103/physrevc.88.054301

Related papers

エントロピー効果を記述する厳密な有限温度RPA方程式(基研研究会「熱場の量子論とその応用」,研究会報告)

K. Tanabe

Thermal random phase approximation (TRPA) equation is extended to include entropy effect. This realizes a desirable formalism which is exact within the framework of the RPA at finite temperature.The extended form of the TRPA matrix precisely coincides with the stability matrix for the thermal Hartree-Fock-Bogohubov (THFB) solution. Extended forms of the completeness condition of the TRPA solutions and the energy-weighted sum rule are given. An importance of the couplings to pp- and hh-configurations is shown by numerical analysis of the temperature-dependence of the Landau splitting width based on a simple microscopic model.

素粒子論研究•Feb 20, 2000•0 citations

Random-phase approximation and broken symmetry

E. D. D. Davis, W. D. Heiss

The validity of the random-phase approximation (RPA) in broken-symmetry bases is tested in an appropriate many-body system for which exact solutions are available. Initially the regions of stability of the self-consistent quasiparticle bases in this system are established and depicted in a 'phase' diagram. It is found that only stable bases can be used in an RPA calculation. This is particularly true for those RPA modes which are not associated with the onset of instability of the basis; the authors see that these modes do not describe any excited state when the basis is unstable, although from a formal point of view they remain acceptable. The RPA does well in a stable broken-symmetry basis provided one is not too close to a point where a phase transition occurs. This is true for both energies and matrix elements.

Journal of Physics G Nuclear Physics•Sep 1, 1986•27 citations

Extended random-phase approximation in a boson formalism with Pauli principle

Michelangelo Sambataro, F. Catara

The random-phase approximation (RPA) is examined in a boson formalism and special attention is focused on the problem of the violation of the Pauli principle affecting this theory. A mapping technique is discussed and the boson image of a two-body fermion Hamiltonian is constructed. Within the boson space so defined, an extension of RPA is proposed where structure and energy of the ground state, as well as those of the one-phonon states, are analyzed with regard to the role of the spurious components associated with a violation of the Pauli principle. A multistep minimization procedure for the determination of a better ground state is also examined. Numerical tests are performed within the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model.

Physical Review C•Jun 1, 1995•15 citations

Collapse of the random-phase approximation: Examples and counter-examples from the shell model

Calvin W. Johnson, Ionel Stetcu

The Hartree-Fock approximation to the many-fermion problem can break exact symmetries, and in some cases by changing a parameter in the interaction one can drive the Hartree-Fock minimum from a symmetry-breaking state to a symmetry-conserving state (also referred to as a ``phase transition'' in the literature). The order of the transition is important when one applies the random-phase approximation (RPA) to the of the Hartree-Fock wave function: if first order, RPA is stable through the transition, but if second-order, then the RPA amplitudes become large and lead to unphysical results. The latter is known as ``collapse'' of the RPA. While the difference between first- and second-order transitions in the RPA was first pointed out by Thouless, we present for the first time nontrivial examples of both first- and second-order transitions in a uniform model, the interacting shell-model, where we can compare to exact numerical results.

arXiv:0907.2413•Physical Review C•Aug 31, 2009•4 citations

Extension of Self Consistent RPA method to off-site Hubbard Model

Said Harir, Mohamed Bennai, Y. Boughaleb

We are interested in the possibility that a generalization of Self Consistent Random Phase Approximation (SCRPA) to the Extended Hubbard Model can lead us to accurate estimations of the ground state energy, for closed chains in one dimension with periodic boundary conditions: N=2 (two states problem). We have considered an extended Hubbard model including on-site and off-site interactions, we have compared the SCRPA with a Direct Analytical(DA) results for the ground state energy, and have shown that SCRPA solves the two states problem exactly for any value of U (on-site interaction energy), V2 (off-site interaction energy with opposite spins) and (off-site interaction energy with same spins).

PRSM•Mar 17, 2011•0 citations

On the interdependence between ground and one-phonon RPA states

Michelangelo Sambataro, J. Suhonen

Working within a schematic model and in a boson formalism, we provide a descrip tion of the ground and first-excited states of a nuclear system in terms of two independent phonon operators. The description reveals itself quite effective in reproducing the energies of the states. A comparison between these two phonon operators allows us to localize a region where a correct description of these states is compatible with the Random Phase Approximation (RPA) requirement of a single phonon. This region is found to coincide approximately with that spanned by the standard RPA. Outside this region, the two phonons start differing rapidly therefore making the application of the RPA scheme impossible. This allows a better understanding of recently performed higher-order RPA calculations.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Oct 15, 1998•2 citations
The extended random-phase approximation (RPA) theories are analyzed from the point of view of the problem of the stability of their solutions. Three kinds of such theories are considered: the second RPA and two versions of the quasiparticle-phonon coupling model within the time-blocking approximation: the model including 1p1h\ensuremath⨂1p1h\ensuremath{\bigotimes}1p1h\ensuremath⨂phonon configurations and the two-phonon model. It is shown that stability is ensured by making use of the subtraction method proposed previously to solve the double counting problem in these theories. This enables one to generalize the famous Thouless theorem proved in the case of the RPA. These results are illustrated by an example of the schematic model.
Thermal random phase approximation (TRPA) equation is extended to include entropy effect. This realizes a desirable formalism which is exact within the framework of the RPA at finite temperature.The extended form of the TRPA matrix precisely coincides with the stability matrix for the thermal Hartree-Fock-Bogohubov (THFB) solution. Extended forms of the completeness condition of the TRPA solutions and the energy-weighted sum rule are given. An importance of the couplings to pp- and hh-configurations is shown by numerical analysis of the temperature-dependence of the Landau splitting width based on a simple microscopic model.
The validity of the random-phase approximation (RPA) in broken-symmetry bases is tested in an appropriate many-body system for which exact solutions are available. Initially the regions of stability of the self-consistent quasiparticle bases in this system are established and depicted in a 'phase' diagram. It is found that only stable bases can be used in an RPA calculation. This is particularly true for those RPA modes which are not associated with the onset of instability of the basis; the authors see that these modes do not describe any excited state when the basis is unstable, although from a formal point of view they remain acceptable. The RPA does well in a stable broken-symmetry basis provided one is not too close to a point where a phase transition occurs. This is true for both energies and matrix elements.
The random-phase approximation (RPA) is examined in a boson formalism and special attention is focused on the problem of the violation of the Pauli principle affecting this theory. A mapping technique is discussed and the boson image of a two-body fermion Hamiltonian is constructed. Within the boson space so defined, an extension of RPA is proposed where structure and energy of the ground state, as well as those of the one-phonon states, are analyzed with regard to the role of the spurious components associated with a violation of the Pauli principle. A multistep minimization procedure for the determination of a better ground state is also examined. Numerical tests are performed within the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model.
The Hartree-Fock approximation to the many-fermion problem can break exact symmetries, and in some cases by changing a parameter in the interaction one can drive the Hartree-Fock minimum from a symmetry-breaking state to a symmetry-conserving state (also referred to as a ``phase transition'' in the literature). The order of the transition is important when one applies the random-phase approximation (RPA) to the of the Hartree-Fock wave function: if first order, RPA is stable through the transition, but if second-order, then the RPA amplitudes become large and lead to unphysical results. The latter is known as ``collapse'' of the RPA. While the difference between first- and second-order transitions in the RPA was first pointed out by Thouless, we present for the first time nontrivial examples of both first- and second-order transitions in a uniform model, the interacting shell-model, where we can compare to exact numerical results.
We are interested in the possibility that a generalization of Self Consistent Random Phase Approximation (SCRPA) to the Extended Hubbard Model can lead us to accurate estimations of the ground state energy, for closed chains in one dimension with periodic boundary conditions: N=2 (two states problem). We have considered an extended Hubbard model including on-site and off-site interactions, we have compared the SCRPA with a Direct Analytical(DA) results for the ground state energy, and have shown that SCRPA solves the two states problem exactly for any value of U (on-site interaction energy), V2 (off-site interaction energy with opposite spins) and (off-site interaction energy with same spins).
Working within a schematic model and in a boson formalism, we provide a descrip tion of the ground and first-excited states of a nuclear system in terms of two independent phonon operators. The description reveals itself quite effective in reproducing the energies of the states. A comparison between these two phonon operators allows us to localize a region where a correct description of these states is compatible with the Random Phase Approximation (RPA) requirement of a single phonon. This region is found to coincide approximately with that spanned by the standard RPA. Outside this region, the two phonons start differing rapidly therefore making the application of the RPA scheme impossible. This allows a better understanding of recently performed higher-order RPA calculations.