arXiv:1304.5824

Advantages of the probability amplitude over the probability density in quantum mechanics

Y. Kurihara, Nhi My Uyen Quach

Published Apr 22, 2013• 1 citation

Abstract

We discuss reasons why a probability amplitude, which becomes a probability density after squaring, is considered as one of the most basic ingredients of quantum mechanics. First, the Heisenberg/Schrodinger equation, an equation of motion in quantum mechanics, describes a time evolution of the probability amplitude rather than of a probability density. There may be reasons why dynamics of a physical system are described by amplitude. In order to investigate one role of the probability amplitude in quantum mechanics, specialized codeword-transfer experiments are designed using classical information theory. Within this context, quantum mechanics based on probability amplitude provides the following: i) a minimum error of the codeword transfer; ii) this error is independent of coding parameters; and iii) nontrivial and nonlocal correlation can be realized. These are considered essential advantages of the probability amplitude over the probability density.

DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.1304.5824

Related papers

Advantages of Probability Amplitude Over Probability Density in Quantum Mechanics

Y. Kurihara, Nhi My Uyen Quach

We discuss reasons why a probability amplitude, which becomes a probability density after squaring, is considered as one of the most basic ingredients of quantum mechanics. First, the Heisenberg/Schrödinger equation, an equation of motion in quantum mechanics, describes a time evolution of the probability amplitude rather than of a probability density. There may be reasons why dynamics of a physical system are described by amplitude. In order to investigate one role of the probability amplitude in quantum mechanics, specialized codeword-transfer experiments are designed using classical information theory. Within this context, quantum mechanics based on probability amplitude provides the following: i) a minimum error of the codeword transfer; ii) this error is independent of coding parameters; and iii) nontrivial and nonlocal correlation can be realized. These are considered essential advantages of the probability amplitude over the probability density.

Applied Physics ResearchMar 17, 20152 citations

Three Essential Reasons Why Nature Chose Quantum Mechanics

Y. Kurihara

We discuss the reason why quantum mechanics is chosen as the most basic law of nature. Probability amplitude, which becomes a probability density after square it, is considered as one of the most essential ingredient of quantum mechanics. Code transfer experiments based on the probability amplitude is proved to be i) error of code transfer is minimum, ii) that error is independent of coding parameters and iii) non-trivial and non-local correlation is possible.

arXiv:1206.2432Jun 12, 20120 citations

On stochastic theories of quantum mechanics

James G. Gilson

Introduction. There exists a very comprehensive theory concerning the time development of probabilistic systems. This is the Theory of Stochastic processes (1). Quantum mechanics as described by the Schrödinger equation rests very heavily on probabilistic interpretation, and yet, after forty years of remarkably rapid advances and successes, it is not clear how it is related to stochastic theory. The formal similarity of certain aspects of, and equations used in these two theories are well known. The diffusion equation corresponds to the Schrödinger equation, a correspondence only marred by a square root of minus unity appearing with the time derivative in the latter equation. The Kolmogoroff–Chapman relation for probabilities in Brownian motion has an analogue (2) in quantum mechanics, not for probabilities though, but for the complex probability amplitudes. The uncertainty relation also has a stochastic analogue (3). Some of these analogous characteristics are actually symptomatic of the gulf which separates these two theories. There are solutions to the diffusion equation which have a very clear physical probabilistic meaning. This is not the case with the corresponding and formally similar solutions to the Schrödinger equation and is partly due to the √ − 1 mentioned earlier. The probabilistic interpretation of the solutions to the diffusion equation is direct and immediate. On the other hand, the probabilistic interpretation of the solutions, ψ of the Schrödinger equation involve the introduction of the probability density, p = ψ*ψ. One great difference between these two theories lies in their each having distinct principles of linear superposition. In Stochastic Theory probabilities are superposed and in quantum mechanics amplitudes or wave functions are superposed.

Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical SocietyOct 1, 196836 citations

Consistency, amplitudes, and probabilities in quantum theory

Ariel Caticha

Quantum theory is formulated as the only consistent way to manipulate probability amplitudes. The crucial ingredient is a very natural consistency constraint: if there are two different ways to compute the amplitude for a given process, the two answers must agree. This constraint is expressed in the form of functional equations the solution of which leads to the usual sum and product rules for amplitudes. An immediate consequence is that the Schr\"odinger equation must be linear; i.e., nonlinear variants of quantum mechanics are inconsistent. The physical interpretation of the theory is given in terms of a single natural rule. This rule, which does not itself involve any probabilities, is used to obtain a proof of Born's statistical postulate: we show that the probability of a certain outcome in an experiment is given by the square of the modulus of the corresponding amplitude. Thus, consistency leads to indeterminism.

arXiv:quant-ph/9804012Physical Review AMar 1, 199861 citations

Path Integral Formalism Intuitive Approach

Lukong Cornelius Fai

One of the important classic experiments that led to the fundamental difference between quantum and classical mechanics is the double slit experiment, which is interesting with respect to the path integral formalism since it leads to a conceptual motivation for introducing it. From Quantum Mechanics, the probability amplitude can also be determined from the Schrodinger equation as it describes the wave properties of the particles. From Quantum Mechanics, the probability amplitude (square of the probability function or wave function) can also be determined from the Schrodinger equation as it describes the wave properties of the particles. Here, the role of the trajectory of a point-like particle, formally is revived in a way compatible with the indetermination principle and is indeed the path integral approach to quantum mechanics.

CRC Press eBooksFeb 19, 20210 citations

Structure of Probabilistic Information and Quantum Laws

Summhammer, J

In quantum experiments the acquisition and representation of basic experimental information is governed by the multinomial probability distribution. There exist unique random variables, whose standard deviation becomes asymptotically invariant of physical conditions. Representing all information by means of such random variables gives the quantum mechanical probability amplitude and a real alternative. For predictions, the linear evolution law (Schrodinger or Dirac equation) turns out to be the only way to extend the invariance property of the standard deviation to the predicted quantities. This indicates that quantum theory originates in the structure of gaining pure, probabilistic information, without any mechanical underpinning.

Feb 20, 20011 citation