Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1302.1187 · New Journal of Physics

Thermal versus entanglement entropy: a measurement protocol for fermionic atoms with a quantum gas microscope

Hannes Pichler, Lars Bonnes, Andrew J. Daley, Andreas Martin Läuchli, Peter Zoller

Published Jun 6, 2013• 67 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show how to measure the order-two Renyi entropy of many-body states of spinful fermionic atoms in an optical lattice in equilibrium and non-equilibrium situations. The proposed scheme relies on the possibility to produce and couple two copies of the state under investigation, and to measure the occupation number in a site- and spin-resolved manner, e.g. with a quantum gas microscope. Such a protocol opens the possibility to measure entanglement and test a number of theoretical predictions, such as area laws and their corrections. As an illustration we discuss the interplay between thermal and entanglement entropy for a one dimensional Fermi–Hubbard model at finite temperature, and its possible measurement in an experiment using the present scheme.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/15/6/063003

Related papers

Rényi Entropies from Random Quenches in Atomic Hubbard and Spin Models

Andreas Elben, Benoît Vermersch, Marcello Dalmonte +2 more

We present a scheme for measuring Rényi entropies in generic atomic Hubbard and spin models using single copies of a quantum state and for partitions in arbitrary spatial dimensions. Our approach is based on the generation of random unitaries from random quenches, implemented using engineered time-dependent disorder potentials, and standard projective measurements, as realized by quantum gas microscopes. By analyzing the properties of the generated unitaries and the role of statistical errors, with respect to the size of the partition, we show that the protocol can be realized in existing quantum simulators and used to measure, for instance, area law scaling of entanglement in two-dimensional spin models or the entanglement growth in many-body localized systems.

arXiv:1709.05060•Physical Review Letters•Feb 2, 2018•260 citations

Measuring fermionic entanglement: Entropy, negativity, and spin structure

Eyal Cornfeld, Eran Sela, Moshe Goldstein

The recent direct experimental measurement of quantum entanglement paves the way towards a better understanding of many-body quantum systems and their correlations. Nevertheless, the experimental and theoretical advances had so far been predominantly limited to bosonic systems. Here, we study fermionic systems. Using experimental setups where multiple copies of the same state are prepared, arbitrary-order R\'enyi entanglement entropies and entanglement negativities can be extracted by utilizing spatially uniform beam splitters and on-site occupation measurement. As an example, we simulate the use of our protocols to measure the entanglement growth following a local quench. We also illustrate how our paradigm could be used for experimental quantum simulations of fermions on manifolds with nontrivial spin structures.

arXiv:1808.04471•Physical Review A•Jun 10, 2019•69 citations

Microscopy of Correlations at a Non-Equilibrium Phase Transition

Matthew Rispoli

One of the distinguishing achievements of physics has been the ability to describe the Universe based upon underlying microscopic principles. When there are many participating objects being governed by these microscopic principles, the resultant behavior often harbors emergent collective phenomena that may not be obviously related to the microscopic description. Phase transitions, quantum or classical, are a canonical example of such many-body phenomena that are understood in equilibrium through a framework of thermodynamic constraints, statistical ensembles, and a growth of system-wide correlations at the transition. However, a new class of quantum phase transitions has recently emerged for non-equilibrium systems with behavior that is not captured by this traditional framework. In the case of isolated quantum systems, these transitions occur among excited eigenstates and requires knowledge of the structure of these individual eigenstates in the quantum system. Understanding what drives such a phase transition requires a deeper microscopic knowledge of the role of correlations at the transition. \nThe use of ultracold atoms in optical lattices has paved the way for faithfully realizing quantum phase transitions. In particular, the advent of the quantum gas microscope realized an experimental platform that is highly controllable and provides microscopic access to the many-bodied wave functions. All experiments presented in this thesis use such a quantum gas microscope architecture where a quantum degenerate gas of Rb is used to probe the behavior of non-equilibrium quantum systems in one spatial dimension.\nThis thesis briefly discusses some studies of entanglement in equilibrium quantum phase transitions near the ground state of the system. In the first experiment, we directly measure the second-order R\\'enyi entanglement entropy that develops as a Bose-Hubbard system transitions from a Mott insulator to a superfluid. This is followed by a study of entanglement growth at the transition in the transverse Ising model. \nThese studies progress to the investigation of two particular non-equilibrium quantum phases and their transition into one another: quantum thermalization and many-body localization. We investigate the development of entanglement entropy that mimics thermodynamic entropy for an isolated quantum system which locally thermalizes under its own unitary dynamics. We then investigate the only known robust exception to this thermalizing behavior by studying the onset of many-body localization due to disorder. We observe the breakdown of thermalization in this phase and the logarithmically slow growth of entanglement throughout the system, which identifies the localized system to be an interacting one. Lastly, we investigate the role of correlations in the critical dynamics that emerge at high-orders where the system transitions from thermalizing behavior to many-body localization.

•May 17, 2019•0 citations

Quantum-Gas Microscope for Fermionic Atoms

Lawrence W. Cheuk, Matthew A. Nichols, Melih Okan +5 more

We realize a quantum-gas microscope for fermionic ^{40}K atoms trapped in an optical lattice, which allows one to probe strongly correlated fermions at the single-atom level. We combine 3D Raman sideband cooling with high-resolution optics to simultaneously cool and image individual atoms with single-lattice-site resolution at a detection fidelity above 95%. The imaging process leaves the atoms predominantly in the 3D motional ground state of their respective lattice sites, inviting the implementation of a Maxwell's demon to assemble low-entropy many-body states. Single-site-resolved imaging of fermions enables the direct observation of magnetic order, time-resolved measurements of the spread of particle correlations, and the detection of many-fermion entanglement.

arXiv:1503.02648•Physical Review Letters•May 13, 2015•405 citations

Spin and density resolved microscopy of Hubbard chains

Martin Boll

This thesis reports on the microscopic investigation of antiferromagnetic order in Hubbard chains, realized with ultracold repulsively interacting fermions in an optical lattice. Extending a quantum gas microscope on spin resolution opened the possibility to Access the full charge and spin statistics of a strongly correlated fermionic many body system. Using this technique, we measured antiferromagnetic correlations over distances up to three lattice sites. Starting with a repulsive degenerate two component mixture of 6Li atoms trapped in a single plane of a vertical lattice, we loaded the Atoms into one-dimensional tubes of a transverse optical superlattice. By adiabatically ramping up the lattice potential along the tubes, we isentropically entered the strongly correlated regime of the one-dimensional Fermi-Hubbard Hamiltonian. We spatially separated the two spin states into opposite sites of local double wells orthogonal to the direction of the lattice before single atom and site sensitive imaging. In this way we extracted the spin information of every single lattice site and were able to evaluate spin-spin correlations. The two component degenerate gases were produced with sub-Poissonian atom number fluctuations by magnetically driven evaporative cooling in vicinity of a Feshbach resonance, used to set the scattering length. The dependence of antiferromagnetic correlations on the driving superexchange coupling was experimentally investigated by varying the interparticle scattering length before loading the atoms into the optical lattice. Taking advantage of the underlying trapping potential of the optical lattice, which shaped the filling and the entropy of the gases, the influence of density excitations and different entropies on spin correlations was observed. By post-selecting the Hubbard chains based on their average filling and local atom number fluctuations, spin correlations corresponding to 58% of the zero temperature predictions in the Heisenberg regime were measured. By comparing the obtained antiferromagnetic correlations to Quantum-Monte-Carlo predictions for our System the lowest measured entropy per particle could be stated as s = 0.51(4)kB, clearly below the critical value of s = ln(2)kB, which is required to form longer ranged correlations. Below this critical entropy, in contrast to local density fluctuations, these spin correlations strongly depend on the entropy of the system. In the future, such a spin thermometer can be used to benchmark novel cooling techniques, which are required to enter the temperature regime of d-wave superconducting states. The access to the full particle and spin statistics will enable us to read out multi-point correlation functions, which characterize such exotic states of matter.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Measuring Entanglement Growth in Quench Dynamics of Bosons in an Optical Lattice

Andrew J. Daley, Hannes Pichler, Johannes Schachenmayer +1 more

We discuss a scheme to measure the many-body entanglement growth during quench dynamics with bosonic atoms in optical lattices. By making use of a 1D or 2D setup in which two copies of the same state are prepared, we show how arbitrary order Rényi entropies can be extracted by using tunnel coupling between the copies and measurement of the parity of on-site occupation numbers, as has been performed in recent experiments. We illustrate these ideas for a superfluid-Mott insulator quench in the Bose-Hubbard model, and also for hard-core bosons, and show that the scheme is robust against imperfections in the measurements.

arXiv:1205.1521•Physical Review Letters•Jul 12, 2012•393 citations
We show how to measure the order-two Renyi entropy of many-body states of spinful fermionic atoms in an optical lattice in equilibrium and non-equilibrium situations. The proposed scheme relies on the possibility to produce and couple two copies of the state under investigation, and to measure the occupation number in a site- and spin-resolved manner, e.g. with a quantum gas microscope. Such a protocol opens the possibility to measure entanglement and test a number of theoretical predictions, such as area laws and their corrections. As an illustration we discuss the interplay between thermal and entanglement entropy for a one dimensional Fermi–Hubbard model at finite temperature, and its possible measurement in an experiment using the present scheme.
We present a scheme for measuring Rényi entropies in generic atomic Hubbard and spin models using single copies of a quantum state and for partitions in arbitrary spatial dimensions. Our approach is based on the generation of random unitaries from random quenches, implemented using engineered time-dependent disorder potentials, and standard projective measurements, as realized by quantum gas microscopes. By analyzing the properties of the generated unitaries and the role of statistical errors, with respect to the size of the partition, we show that the protocol can be realized in existing quantum simulators and used to measure, for instance, area law scaling of entanglement in two-dimensional spin models or the entanglement growth in many-body localized systems.
The recent direct experimental measurement of quantum entanglement paves the way towards a better understanding of many-body quantum systems and their correlations. Nevertheless, the experimental and theoretical advances had so far been predominantly limited to bosonic systems. Here, we study fermionic systems. Using experimental setups where multiple copies of the same state are prepared, arbitrary-order R\'enyi entanglement entropies and entanglement negativities can be extracted by utilizing spatially uniform beam splitters and on-site occupation measurement. As an example, we simulate the use of our protocols to measure the entanglement growth following a local quench. We also illustrate how our paradigm could be used for experimental quantum simulations of fermions on manifolds with nontrivial spin structures.
One of the distinguishing achievements of physics has been the ability to describe the Universe based upon underlying microscopic principles. When there are many participating objects being governed by these microscopic principles, the resultant behavior often harbors emergent collective phenomena that may not be obviously related to the microscopic description. Phase transitions, quantum or classical, are a canonical example of such many-body phenomena that are understood in equilibrium through a framework of thermodynamic constraints, statistical ensembles, and a growth of system-wide correlations at the transition. However, a new class of quantum phase transitions has recently emerged for non-equilibrium systems with behavior that is not captured by this traditional framework. In the case of isolated quantum systems, these transitions occur among excited eigenstates and requires knowledge of the structure of these individual eigenstates in the quantum system. Understanding what drives such a phase transition requires a deeper microscopic knowledge of the role of correlations at the transition. \nThe use of ultracold atoms in optical lattices has paved the way for faithfully realizing quantum phase transitions. In particular, the advent of the quantum gas microscope realized an experimental platform that is highly controllable and provides microscopic access to the many-bodied wave functions. All experiments presented in this thesis use such a quantum gas microscope architecture where a quantum degenerate gas of Rb is used to probe the behavior of non-equilibrium quantum systems in one spatial dimension.\nThis thesis briefly discusses some studies of entanglement in equilibrium quantum phase transitions near the ground state of the system. In the first experiment, we directly measure the second-order R\\'enyi entanglement entropy that develops as a Bose-Hubbard system transitions from a Mott insulator to a superfluid. This is followed by a study of entanglement growth at the transition in the transverse Ising model. \nThese studies progress to the investigation of two particular non-equilibrium quantum phases and their transition into one another: quantum thermalization and many-body localization. We investigate the development of entanglement entropy that mimics thermodynamic entropy for an isolated quantum system which locally thermalizes under its own unitary dynamics. We then investigate the only known robust exception to this thermalizing behavior by studying the onset of many-body localization due to disorder. We observe the breakdown of thermalization in this phase and the logarithmically slow growth of entanglement throughout the system, which identifies the localized system to be an interacting one. Lastly, we investigate the role of correlations in the critical dynamics that emerge at high-orders where the system transitions from thermalizing behavior to many-body localization.
We realize a quantum-gas microscope for fermionic ^{40}K atoms trapped in an optical lattice, which allows one to probe strongly correlated fermions at the single-atom level. We combine 3D Raman sideband cooling with high-resolution optics to simultaneously cool and image individual atoms with single-lattice-site resolution at a detection fidelity above 95%. The imaging process leaves the atoms predominantly in the 3D motional ground state of their respective lattice sites, inviting the implementation of a Maxwell's demon to assemble low-entropy many-body states. Single-site-resolved imaging of fermions enables the direct observation of magnetic order, time-resolved measurements of the spread of particle correlations, and the detection of many-fermion entanglement.
This thesis reports on the microscopic investigation of antiferromagnetic order in Hubbard chains, realized with ultracold repulsively interacting fermions in an optical lattice. Extending a quantum gas microscope on spin resolution opened the possibility to Access the full charge and spin statistics of a strongly correlated fermionic many body system. Using this technique, we measured antiferromagnetic correlations over distances up to three lattice sites. Starting with a repulsive degenerate two component mixture of 6Li atoms trapped in a single plane of a vertical lattice, we loaded the Atoms into one-dimensional tubes of a transverse optical superlattice. By adiabatically ramping up the lattice potential along the tubes, we isentropically entered the strongly correlated regime of the one-dimensional Fermi-Hubbard Hamiltonian. We spatially separated the two spin states into opposite sites of local double wells orthogonal to the direction of the lattice before single atom and site sensitive imaging. In this way we extracted the spin information of every single lattice site and were able to evaluate spin-spin correlations. The two component degenerate gases were produced with sub-Poissonian atom number fluctuations by magnetically driven evaporative cooling in vicinity of a Feshbach resonance, used to set the scattering length. The dependence of antiferromagnetic correlations on the driving superexchange coupling was experimentally investigated by varying the interparticle scattering length before loading the atoms into the optical lattice. Taking advantage of the underlying trapping potential of the optical lattice, which shaped the filling and the entropy of the gases, the influence of density excitations and different entropies on spin correlations was observed. By post-selecting the Hubbard chains based on their average filling and local atom number fluctuations, spin correlations corresponding to 58% of the zero temperature predictions in the Heisenberg regime were measured. By comparing the obtained antiferromagnetic correlations to Quantum-Monte-Carlo predictions for our System the lowest measured entropy per particle could be stated as s = 0.51(4)kB, clearly below the critical value of s = ln(2)kB, which is required to form longer ranged correlations. Below this critical entropy, in contrast to local density fluctuations, these spin correlations strongly depend on the entropy of the system. In the future, such a spin thermometer can be used to benchmark novel cooling techniques, which are required to enter the temperature regime of d-wave superconducting states. The access to the full particle and spin statistics will enable us to read out multi-point correlation functions, which characterize such exotic states of matter.
We discuss a scheme to measure the many-body entanglement growth during quench dynamics with bosonic atoms in optical lattices. By making use of a 1D or 2D setup in which two copies of the same state are prepared, we show how arbitrary order Rényi entropies can be extracted by using tunnel coupling between the copies and measurement of the parity of on-site occupation numbers, as has been performed in recent experiments. We illustrate these ideas for a superfluid-Mott insulator quench in the Bose-Hubbard model, and also for hard-core bosons, and show that the scheme is robust against imperfections in the measurements.