Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1211.1574

Delayed choice without choice

M. Dugić

Published Nov 7, 2012• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A critical note on some of the existing proposals for performing the "delayed choice" experiment is placed. By abandoning the original idea and intention, some modern theoretical proposals and experimental evidence are simply incorrectly understood/interpreted. In effect, the Complementarity principle remains practically intact.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1211.1574

Related papers

Is the Interpretation of Delayed-Choice Experiments Misleading?

Roussel, P., I. Stefan

The interpretation of an experimental realization of Wheeler's delayed-choice gedanken experiment is discussed and called into question.

arXiv:0706.2596•Jun 18, 2007•5 citations

A delayed choice quantum eraser experiment that involves no delayed choice, no quantum eraser, and no complementarity

Jeffrey H. Boyd

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Nov 18, 2011•0 citations

A logical interpretation of a delayed-choice, quantum eraser experiment

Sellers, William

This paper shows how one can construe the experimental results in a way that does not involve effects that precede their causes.

arXiv:quant-ph/0303036•Mar 7, 2003•0 citations

On delayed choice and quantum erasure in two-slit experiment for testing complementarity

Guang-Liang Li

The principle of complementarity is one of the cornerstones of quantum theory. The aim of this study was to advance our understanding of complementarity by analyzing the role of delayed choice and quantum erasers in two-slit experiments, and by proposing experiments for verifying the analysis. The analysis is based on models consisting of measurable spaces and probability measures involved in the experiments. The main findings are as follows: (a) The complementarity principle manifests itself in such a way that wave and particle behaviors cannot be simultaneously observed almost surely with respect to any single, fixed measure. (b) Described by different measures, complementary properties can coexist in the same experimental setup. (c) Which-way information will not preclude or erase interference fringes. (d) Delayed choice and quantum erasers are irrelevant to testing complementarity. (e) It is possible for us to know through which slit each quantum object passed almost surely with respect to the measure corresponding to the slit while the interference pattern is intact. Based on the experiments analyzed, realizable experiments are proposed for verifying the above results.

Journal of Physics Communications•Sep 13, 2021•3 citations

Complementarity as corollary

R. M. Angelo, A. D. Ribeiro

Recently, Bohr's complementarity principle was assessed in setups involving delayed choices. These works argued in favor of a reformulation of the aforementioned principle so as to account for situations in which a quantum system would simultaneously behave as wave and particle. Here we defend a framework that, supported by well-known experimental results and consistent with the decoherence paradigm, allows us to interpret complementarity in terms of correlations between the system and an {\em informer}. Our proposal offers formal definition and operational interpretation for the dual behavior in terms of both nonlocal resources and the couple work-information. Most importantly, our results provide a generalized information-based trade-off for the wave-particle duality and a causal interpretation for delayed-choice experiments.

•Apr 8, 2013•2 citations

Intention as the Cause of Collapse: A Theoretical and Multidisciplinary Framework within Quantum Thought

Javed, Mohammad

This paper presents a theoretical and multidisciplinary exploration of wave function collapse, proposing human intention (niyyat) as a foundational causal factor underlying the transition from quantum possibility to observable reality. While conventional interpretations of quantum mechanics attribute collapse to measurement, observation, or environmental decoherence, this work advances an alternative conceptual framework in which intention precedes and governs collapse. Drawing upon quantum mechanics, philosophy of mind, cognitive theory, and interpretive parallels from consciousness studies, the paper introduces Javed’s Quantum Thought, which asserts that reality collapses at the point of intention rather than at observation alone. The observer effect, Quantum Bayesianism (QBism), delayed-choice experiments, and philosophical notions of non-linear causality are examined to support the plausibility of an intention-centered collapse model. The framework reframes superposition as a state maintained in the absence of directed intention, while collapse is understood as the outcome of focused cognitive and existential commitment toward a specific result. In this view, measurement becomes a secondary manifestation of intention rather than its origin. The paper further explores the implications of this model for free will, determinism, multiverse interpretations, and the relationship between consciousness and physical reality. This work does not claim experimental verification, but instead offers a conceptual and philosophical contribution intended to stimulate interdisciplinary dialogue across quantum foundations, philosophy of science, and consciousness research. By positioning intention as a central operator between infinite potential and finite outcome, the paper proposes a coherent interpretive lens for reconsidering the nature of quantum collapse and perceived reality.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations
A critical note on some of the existing proposals for performing the "delayed choice" experiment is placed. By abandoning the original idea and intention, some modern theoretical proposals and experimental evidence are simply incorrectly understood/interpreted. In effect, the Complementarity principle remains practically intact.
The principle of complementarity is one of the cornerstones of quantum theory. The aim of this study was to advance our understanding of complementarity by analyzing the role of delayed choice and quantum erasers in two-slit experiments, and by proposing experiments for verifying the analysis. The analysis is based on models consisting of measurable spaces and probability measures involved in the experiments. The main findings are as follows: (a) The complementarity principle manifests itself in such a way that wave and particle behaviors cannot be simultaneously observed almost surely with respect to any single, fixed measure. (b) Described by different measures, complementary properties can coexist in the same experimental setup. (c) Which-way information will not preclude or erase interference fringes. (d) Delayed choice and quantum erasers are irrelevant to testing complementarity. (e) It is possible for us to know through which slit each quantum object passed almost surely with respect to the measure corresponding to the slit while the interference pattern is intact. Based on the experiments analyzed, realizable experiments are proposed for verifying the above results.
Recently, Bohr's complementarity principle was assessed in setups involving delayed choices. These works argued in favor of a reformulation of the aforementioned principle so as to account for situations in which a quantum system would simultaneously behave as wave and particle. Here we defend a framework that, supported by well-known experimental results and consistent with the decoherence paradigm, allows us to interpret complementarity in terms of correlations between the system and an {\em informer}. Our proposal offers formal definition and operational interpretation for the dual behavior in terms of both nonlocal resources and the couple work-information. Most importantly, our results provide a generalized information-based trade-off for the wave-particle duality and a causal interpretation for delayed-choice experiments.
This paper presents a theoretical and multidisciplinary exploration of wave function collapse, proposing human intention (niyyat) as a foundational causal factor underlying the transition from quantum possibility to observable reality. While conventional interpretations of quantum mechanics attribute collapse to measurement, observation, or environmental decoherence, this work advances an alternative conceptual framework in which intention precedes and governs collapse. Drawing upon quantum mechanics, philosophy of mind, cognitive theory, and interpretive parallels from consciousness studies, the paper introduces Javed’s Quantum Thought, which asserts that reality collapses at the point of intention rather than at observation alone. The observer effect, Quantum Bayesianism (QBism), delayed-choice experiments, and philosophical notions of non-linear causality are examined to support the plausibility of an intention-centered collapse model. The framework reframes superposition as a state maintained in the absence of directed intention, while collapse is understood as the outcome of focused cognitive and existential commitment toward a specific result. In this view, measurement becomes a secondary manifestation of intention rather than its origin. The paper further explores the implications of this model for free will, determinism, multiverse interpretations, and the relationship between consciousness and physical reality. This work does not claim experimental verification, but instead offers a conceptual and philosophical contribution intended to stimulate interdisciplinary dialogue across quantum foundations, philosophy of science, and consciousness research. By positioning intention as a central operator between infinite potential and finite outcome, the paper proposes a coherent interpretive lens for reconsidering the nature of quantum collapse and perceived reality.