Emergence and Frustration of Magnetism with Variable-Range Interactions in a Quantum Simulator
Rajibul Islam, Crystal Senko, Wesley C. Campbell, S. É. Korenblit, J. Smith, A. Lee, E.E. Edwards, C.‐C. Joseph Wang, James K. Freericks, Christopher R. Monroe
Frustration, or the competition between interacting components of a network, is often responsible for the emergent complexity of many-body systems. For instance, frustrated magnetism is a hallmark of poorly understood systems such as quantum spin liquids, spin glasses, and spin ices, whose ground states can be massively degenerate and carry high degrees of quantum entanglement. Here, we engineer frustrated antiferromagnetic interactions between spins stored in a crystal of up to 16 trapped (171)Yb(+) atoms. We control the amount of frustration by continuously tuning the range of interaction and directly measure spin correlation functions and their coherent dynamics. This prototypical quantum simulation points the way toward a new probe of frustrated quantum magnetism and perhaps the design of new quantum materials.
Frustration, or the competition between interacting components of a network, is often responsible for the emergent complexity of many-body systems. For instance, frustrated magnetism is a hallmark of poorly understood systems such as quantum spin liquids, spin glasses, and spin ices, whose ground states can be massively degenerate and carry high degrees of quantum entanglement. Here, we engineer frustrated antiferromagnetic interactions between spins stored in a crystal of up to 16 trapped (171)Yb(+) atoms. We control the amount of frustration by continuously tuning the range of interaction and directly measure spin correlation functions and their coherent dynamics. This prototypical quantum simulation points the way toward a new probe of frustrated quantum magnetism and perhaps the design of new quantum materials.
Two-dimensional (2D) quantum magnetism is a paradigm in strongly correlated many-body physics. The understanding of 2D quantum magnetism can be expedited by employing a controllable quantum simulator that faithfully maps 2D-spin Hamiltonians. The 2D quantum simulators can exhibit exotic phenomena such as frustrated quantum magnetism and topological order and can be used to show quantum computational advantages. Many experimental platforms are being developed, including Rydberg atoms and superconducting annealers. However, with trapped-ion systems, which showed the most advanced controllability and quantum coherence, quantum magnetism was explored in one-dimensional chains. Here, we report simulations of frustrated quantum magnetism with 2D ion crystals. We create a variety of spin-spin interactions for quantum magnets, including those that exhibit frustration by driving different vibrational modes and adiabatically prepare the corresponding ground states. The experimentally measured ground states are consistent with the theoretical predictions and are highly degenerate for geometrically frustrated spin models in two dimensions. Quantum coherence of the ground states is probed by reversing the time evolution of the B-field to the initial value and then measuring the extent to which the remaining state coincides with the initial state. Our results open the door for quantum simulations with 2D ion crystals.
The quantum simulation of complex many body systems holds promise for understanding the origin of emergent properties of strongly correlated systems, such as high-Tc superconductors and spin liquids. Cold atomic systems provide an almost ideal platform for quantum simulation due to their excellent quantum coherence, initialization and readout properties, and their ability to support several forms of interactions. In this thesis, I present experiments on the quantum simulation of long range Ising models in the presence of transverse magnetic fields with a chain of up to sixteen ultracold 171-Yb+ ions trapped in a linear radio frequency Paul trap. Two hyperfine levels in each of the 171-Yb+ ions serve as the spin-1/2 systems. We detect the spin states of the individual ions by observing state-dependent fluorescence with single site resolution, and can directly measure any possible spin correlation function. The spin-spin interactions are engineered by applying dipole forces from precisely tuned lasers whose beatnotes induce stimulated Raman transitions that couple virtually to collective phonon modes of the ion motion. The Ising couplings are controlled, both in sign and strength with respect to the effective transverse field, and adiabatically manipulated to study various aspects of this spin model, such as the emergence of a quantum phase transition in the ground state and spin frustration due to competing antiferromagnetic interactions. Spin frustration often gives rise to a massive degeneracy in the ground state, which can lead to entanglement in the spin system. We detect and characterize this frustration induced entanglement in a system of three spins, demonstrating the first direct experimental connection between frustration and entanglement. With larger numbers of spins we also vary the range of the antiferromagnetic couplings through appropriate laser tunings and observe that longer range interactions reduce the excitation energy and thereby frustrate the ground state order. This system can potentially be scaled up to study a wide range of fully connected spin networks with a few dozens of spins, where the underlying theory becomes intractable on a classical computer.
Many-body quantum mechanics is the fundamental theory behind many areas of modern science, such as condensed-matter physics, nuclear physics, and quantum chemistry. It is also notoriously hard: the classical picture of particles with well-defined positions and velocities is replaced by an intricate interference pattern between all their possible trajectories, captured by the quantum wave function. The exponentially large information content of wave functions makes direct simulation of large, strongly interacting quantum systems impossible, and necessitates strategies to manage the complexity in an analytically or computationally tractable manner. The bulk of this thesis explores two such strategies in the context of quantum spin liquids. In these materials, competition between incompatible interactions results in robust, massive entanglement, down to zero temperature. Such ground states give rise to a range of exotic behaviour, such as topological order and fractionalised excitations: understanding these is a central challenge in the physics of strongly correlated materials. Several quantum-spin-liquid phases are underpinned by strict local conservation laws, which give rise to lattice gauge theories with exotic quasiparticle excitations, such as emergent photons or magnetic monopoles. We developed a systematic approach, based on a large-S bosonisation formalism, to extract gauge-theoretic descriptions from such constrained Hamiltonians automatically, and thus make them amenable to the powerful techniques of quantum field theory. The same field theories also allow us to simulate quantum-spin-liquid systems semiclassically, that is, to replace spin-1/2 operators with classical ``compass needles,'' removing the computational complexity of quantum entanglement without losing the physical behaviour. We demonstrated this approach on quantum spin ice, a paradigmatic and experimentally relevant model of quantum spin liquids and, by simulating it on unprecedented large system sizes, obtained novel insights about its quasiparticles. The success of neural networks in a range of machine-learning problems makes them a natural candidate for representing highly entangled quantum states, allowing in principle an accurate simulation of large, challenging quantum systems with modest computational resources. However, most current approaches using such neural quantum states suffer from the infamous Monte-Carlo sign problem, making deep neural networks unable to learn ground states in antiferromagnetic and fermionic systems. We studied the possible origins of this sign problem and proposed a neural-network ansatz that is able to overcome the sign problem for unfrustrated antiferromagnets. In addition to this main theme, I have been part of an experiment--theory collaboration on understanding the unique magnetoresistance properties of the classical frustrated magnet Ho2Ir2O7. We discovered a mechanism by which antiferromagnetic domains can be coupled to an external magnetic field via an intercalated spin-ice system: such control is highly desirable for spintronics applications. We have also identified scattering channels through which magnetic monopoles give rise to a significant contribution to the resistivity of Ho2Ir2O7: this allows us to directly measure their density in a simple and flexible experiment. Finally, I report studies on the localisation properties of quasicrystals; namely, the discovery of thermodynamic universality not described by the usual power laws in one-dimensional quasiperiodic models, and of a two-dimensional quasicrystal in which localised and partially extended states coexist without a mobility edge.
Certain classes of quantum many-body systems, including those supporting phenomena like high-Tc superconductivity and spin liquids, are believed to be fundamentally intractable to classical modeling. Quantum simulations, in which synthetic materials are engineered by inducing well-controlled quantum systems like ultracold atoms to obey many-body Hamiltonians of interest, are a promising new approach to study this type of physics. In this work, I present several advances toward this ultimate goal of large-scale, highly controllable quantum simulations of many-body spin physics. We simulate long-range Ising and XY spin models in the presence of transverse and longitudinal magnetic fields using chains of up to 18 ultracold 171Yb+ ions held in a linear Paul trap, where two hyperfine levels in each ion encode spin-1/2 states. The tunable spin-spin interactions and effective magnetic fields are engineered using laser fields, and the individual spin states are directly imaged with state-dependent fluorescence. The results in this thesis address several of the ongoing challenges in the development of synthetic quantum matter platforms. One such challenge is establishing more flexible capabilities in the sorts of Hamiltonians we can model. By observing suppression of the ground state spin ordering, we have demonstrated our ability to continuously tune the interaction range in a power-law interaction pattern, and hence the amount of frustration present in the spin system. We have additionally begun developing tools to study particles of higher spin, which could eventually be used to create and study topological phases of matter. Another challenge is the necessity of identifying problems that the next generation of experiments, with flexible (but not arbitrary) controls and classically intractable (but not infinitely large) system sizes, can feasibly shed new light on. We have made measurements of how the range of interaction affects dynamics of spin correlations propagating through the chain, and the excellent agreement between our observations and numerical simulations indicate that at larger sizes, our experiment can meaningfully contribute to the open question of the fundamental speed limit on the transfer of information through such a spin chain. Finally, for classically intractable system sizes, it will be crucial to have multiple techniques at our disposal for validating our understanding of the exact microscopic model being implemented. We have developed and demonstrated an MRI-like spectroscopic technique for probing the energies of the many-body Hamiltonian, which serves as a new method for validating quantum simulations of the transverse Ising model. Our experiments can potentially be scaled up in the near future to study fully connected lattice spin models with several tens of spins, where classical computation begins to fail, and the results described in this thesis contribute to the effort to build experiments that can break new ground in the study of quantum many-body physics.
When sizable quantum fluctuations and strong frustration mechanisms act in concert to repel the formation of conventional long-range order in quantum magnets, they can make way for massively entangled spin liquid phases which may imbue the material with extraordinary properties. \nThe search for such curious phases of matter has proceeded for several decades, gaining extra momentum some fifteen years ago when Kitaev proposed an analytically solvable model for a quantum spin liquid with anyonic excitations on the basis of realistic microscopic spin exchange terms [Kitaev, Annals of Physics 321, 2 (2006)]. Attempts to identify different models or materials which harbor quantum spin liquid ground states have kept researchers -- experimentalists and theorists alike -- in suspense ever since. However, the simulation of quantum many-body systems poses a serious challenge even to modern numerical techniques, particularly in the case of frustrated quantum magnetism in three spatial dimensions. Such models evade tractability by many established approaches, leaving a methodological void. \n \nIn this thesis, we report on recent progress in cutting-edge implementations of the pseudo-fermion functional renormalization group (pf-FRG), which has originally been proposed by Reuther and Wölfle in the context of two-dimensional frustrated quantum magnetism with highly symmetric spin interactions [Reuther and Wölfle, Phys. Rev. B 81, 144410 (2010)]. Reflecting the growing interest in models with SU(2) symmetry-breaking spin exchange terms that has followed the unearthing of Kitaev's honeycomb model, we present a generalized implementation of the pf-FRG which is suited to numerically simulate arbitrary microscopic models with diagonal or off-diagonal two-spin interactions, even in three-dimensional frustrated quantum magnets. We provide insight into the inner workings of the method which has emerged over the course of the last couple of years, arguing that the pf-FRG formalism simultaneously combines aspects of a large-S expansion as well as a large-N expansion on equal footing, thus being able to resolve the subtle interplay between magnetic ordering tendencies and disruptive quantum fluctuations. \n \nMoreover, on a case by case basis we explore the stability of quantum spin liquids in paradigmatic models of frustrated quantum magnetism and elucidate the joint action of geometric frustration, exchange frustration, and quantum fluctuations to inhibit the formation of magnetic long-range order. Examples include: (i) a Heisenberg spin model on the three-dimensional diamond lattice where geometric frustration arises from antiferromagnetic next-nearest neighbor interactions. The additional competition with nearest neighbor interactions leads to an unusually large ground state degeneracy already on classical level. The quantum-to-classical transition is studied by systematically varying the spin length and the different roles of quantum fluctuations and thermal fluctuations are discussed. The theory is applied to interpret experiments on the spin-liquid candidate NiRh2O4; (ii) a Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the face centered cubic lattice which is augmented by competing bond-directional interactions, evolving around the concurrent manifestation of geometric frustration and exchange frustration. A situation is identified where both mechanisms collude to give rise to an unusually large degree of frustration over a wide parameter regime. We discuss related experimental findings on the highly frustrated iridate compound Ba2CeIrO6; (iii) a Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice with additional Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions. The robustness of the unperturbed kagome antiferromagnet's spin liquid ground state against low-symmetry Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions is investigated. Implications for the spin-liquid candidate herbertsmithite are discussed.
Magnetic frustrations are the fundamental cause of many interesting phenomena in materials that have been intensely studied since the middle of the 20th century. Magnetic systems with competing interactions, ranging from insulating antiferromagnets to arrays of superconducting qubits, exhibit nontrivial quantum e ects that arise from the need to satisfy a jagged free energy landscape. The search for and characterization of quantum spin liquids, nontrivial topological phases, and quantum phase transitions is conducted through investigations of such frustrated models. Within the large umbrella of frustrated magnetism I have studied some speci c models with the purpose of answering the following questions: (1) What are the interesting phases and less-interesting phases, and how do they fall in the phase diagram relative to one another? (2) What properties do the phases have, and how can we characterize what happens when one phase transitions to another? Armed with the answers to these questions, researchers can further explore these interesting phenomena and apply them towards new materials and devices. In this thesis, I rst develop a computational methodology for studying both classical and quantum spin models using various forms of Monte Carlo simulation. I use classical Monte Carlo to study highly-frustrated models of Ising spins both at nite temperatures and in the T = 0 limit, to map the phase diagram and determine the universality class of phase transitions. Using these methods, I show that in a dissipative chain of qubits, bath-induced qubit-qubit interactions lead to collective decoherence above a critical dissipation strength. This causes the qubits to lose all stored information and become fully correlated with one another, an e ect that one would need to mitigate in order to perform quantum computation. In another study, I show that in antiferromagnetic insulators with anisotropic interactions, frustration can cause an intermediate paramagnetic phase with oblong \droplets" of correlated spins. This phenomenon is quite general and the presence of these droplets can help explain experimental signatures that occur at unexpected temperatures in such materials. In addition to the classical simulations, I develop a variational Monte Carlo (VMC) technique to search for ground states in Heisenberg-type models, speci cally for spins S = 1. The case of S = 1 is more complicated than the case for S = 1=2 due to an additional local degree of freedom, which has interesting implications for the possible states that can be realized. Using semiclassical energy minimization as well as VMC, I show that spin S = 1 diamond-lattice antiferromagnets experience higher-order spinspin interactions that destroy previously theorized liquid-like spiral spin orderings. However, the presence of these higher-order interactions can also potentially allow other phases such as quantum spin liquids and topological paramagnets. Such results can provide an avenue for explaining anomalous phenomena like low-temperature paramagnetism in future experimental materials.