Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1209.6285 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

The effect of six-point one-particle reducible local interactions in the dual fermion approach

A. A. Katanin

Published Jan 3, 2013• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We formulate the dual fermion approach for strongly correlated electronic systems in terms of the lattice and dual effective interactions, obtained by using the covariation splitting formula. This allows us to consider the effect of six-point one-particle reducible interactions, which are usually neglected by the dual fermion approach. We show that the consideration of one-particle reducible six-point (as well as higher order) vertices is crucially important for the diagrammatic consistency of this approach. In particular, the relation between the dual and lattice self-energy, derived in the dual fermion approach, implicitly accounts for the effect of the diagrams, containing six-point and higher order local one-particle reducible vertices, and should be applied with caution, if these vertices are neglected. Apart from that, the treatment of the self-energy feedback is also modified by six-point and higher order vertices; these vertices are also important to account for some non-local corrections to the lattice self-energy, which have the same order in the local four-point vertices as the diagrams usually considered in the approach. These observations highlight an importance of six-point and higher order vertices in the dual fermion approach, and call for the development of new schemes of treatment of non-local fluctuations, which are based on one-particle irreducible quantities.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/46/4/045002

Related papers

Using the (extended) dynamical mean field theory as a starting point for the two-particle irreducible functional renormalization-group approach for strongly-correlated systems

A. A. Katanin

We suggest a new approach for treatment of local and non-local interactions in correlated electronic systems, which is based on the combination of the (extended) dynamical mean-field theory ((E)DMFT) and the two-particle irreducible functional renormaliztion-group (2PI-fRG) method. The considering approach uses self-energy and the two-particle irreducible vertices, obtained from (E)DMFT, as an input of 2PI-fRG approach. Using 2PI vertices may improve the applicability of various truncations and fulfilling conservation laws in comparison with one-particle irreducible approaches. In case of purely local interaction in a certain truncation of the DMFT+2PI-fRG equations, the obtained equation for the self-energy has a similar, although not identical, structure to that in the ladder dynamic vertex approximation (D$\Gamma $A). For the non-local interactions, in a simplest truncation we reproduce the results for the two-particle vertices/susceptibilities in the ladder approximation of the dual boson approach, but obtain different equation for the self-energy with a correct treatment of the one-particel reducible vertices of higher orders. The proposed scheme is rather general and can be applied to study various phenomena in strongly-correlated electronic systems, e.g. as a tool describing ab initio screening of the Coulomb interaction in strongly correlated systems.

•Apr 6, 2016•0 citations

Nonlocal collective electronic fluctuations: From model systems to realistic materials

Viktor Harkov

The main focus of the present thesis lies on the development and application of numerical approaches based on quantum lattice models to describe collective excitations in strongly correlated materials. To this end, an efficient and balanced dual triply irreducible local expansion (D-TRILEX) approach that captures the major effects of spatial correlations in strongly correlated fermionic systems is presented, which is based on partial bosonization of the collective electronic fluctuations. Thereby, a specific choice of the bare interaction in the corresponding channel of instability allows a simultaneous description of collective excitations in different channels without facing the Fierz ambiguity problem which usually arises in methods based on partial bosonization. Compared to more elaborate methods, D-TRILEX does not require the computation of the numerically expensive four-point vertex. Furthermore, taking into account only the leading longitudinal contribution of the bosonic modes to the self-energy reduces the complexity of the diagrammatic structure drastically making the method applicable to more complex realistic multi-orbital systems. As the main result of this thesis, the D-TRILEX approach is introduced and its limit of applicability is studied by applying it to the two-dimensional single-band Hubbard model. Performing a comprehensive diagrammatic analysis by comparing D-TRILEX with methods, which consider different sets of diagrams and different approximations for the four-point vertex, we find that contributions that are not considered by the partially bosonized approximation of the four-point vertex have only a minor effect on electronic degrees of freedom and the longitudinal bosonic modes taking into account in D-TRILEX self-energy are the leading ones in a broad range of control parameters. After investigating the applicability of the D-TRILEX approach we apply the method to study collective electronic effects in the hole-doped InSe monolayers using a realistic electronic-structure model. Thereby, we find that due to the weakly screened long-range Coulomb interaction the system shows a charge density waves phase for the broad range of considered parameters, however, inside this regime we have found a coexisting ferromagnetic phase. D-TRILEX can be considered as an approximation of the more elaborate dual boson (DB) theory, which accounts for local correlations within the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) and nonlocal correlations perturbatively. As a further result of this thesis, we investigate the weak coupling regime of the two-dimensional single-band Hubbard model within the ladder DB approximation and compare our results to the numerically exact diagrammatic quantum Monte Carlo (DiagMC) method. We find that the DB method qualitatively captures all the different regimes. Even quantitatively DB shows a good agreement with the exact results for single- and two-particle quantities at high and moderate temperatures. However, the ladder approximation slightly underestimates the strong antiferromagnetic fluctuations that appear in the system at low temperatures. As the final result of this thesis, we perform a parametrization of the local four-point vertex in terms of the (three-point) Hedin vertex and screened interactions in the framework of single-boson exchange (SBE) decomposition. Similar to the D-TRILEX approach the computational costs are reduced by neglecting the interaction-irreducible part of the four-point vertex. The approximated vertex is used to calculate the DMFT susceptibility for different interaction strengths at different temperatures. We find that the approximation shows a good agreement in the limits of weak and strong couplings. Thereby, our study highlights the importance of the Hedin vertex for local vertex corrections.

•May 4, 2023•0 citations

Hidden physics in the dual-fermion approach: A special case of a nonlocal expansion scheme

Gang Li

In this work, we present a nonlocal expansion scheme to study correlated electron systems aiming at a better description of its spatial fluctuations at all length scales. Taking the nonlocal coupling as a perturbation to the local degrees of freedom, we show that the nonlocality in the self-energy function can be efficiently constructed from the coupling between local fluctuations. It can provide one unified framework to incorporate nonlocality to both ordered and disordered correlated many-body fermion systems. In this application, we prove that the dual-fermion approach can be understood as a special case of this nonlocal expansion scheme. The scheme presented in this work is constructed without introducing any dual variable, in which the interacting nature and the correlated behaviors of the lattice fermions have a clear physics correspondence. Thus, in this special case, the equivalence of the dual-fermion approach to the nonlocal expansion scheme beautifully reveals the physics origin of the dual variables. We show that the noninteracting dual-fermion Green's function corresponds exactly to a nonlocal coupling of the lattice fermion renormalized by the local single-particle charge fluctuations, and the dual-fermion self-energy behaves as the one-particle fully irreducible components of the lattice Green's function. Not only limited to this specific example, the nonlocal expansion scheme presented in this work can also be applied to other problems depending on the choice of the local degrees of freedom.

arXiv:1410.6861•Physical Review B•Apr 28, 2015•35 citations

Impact of partially bosonized collective fluctuations on electronic degrees of freedom

Viktor Harkov, Matteo Vandelli, S. Brener +2 more

In this work we present a comprehensive analysis of collective electronic fluctuations and their effect on single-particle properties of the Hubbard model. Our approach is based on a standard dual fermion and boson scheme with the interaction truncated at the two-particle level. Within this framework we compare various approximations that differ in the set of diagrams (ladder vs exact diagrammatic Monte Carlo), and/or in the form of the four-point interaction vertex (exact vs partially bosonized). This allows to evaluate the effect of all components of the four-point vertex function on the electronic self-energy. In particular, we observe that contributions that are not accounted for by the partially bosonized approximation for the vertex have only a minor effect on electronic degrees of freedom in a broad range of model parameters. In addition, we find that in the regime, where the ladder dual fermion approximation provides an accurate solution of the problem, the leading contribution to the self-energy is given by the longitudinal bosonic modes. This can be explained by the fact that contributions of transverse particle-hole and particle-particle modes partially cancel each other. Our results justify the applicability of the recently introduced dual triply irreducible local expansion (D-TRILEX) method that represents one of the simplest consistent diagrammatic extensions of the dynamical mean-field theory. We find that the self-consistent D-TRILEX approach is reasonably accurate also in challenging regimes of the Hubbard model, even where the dynamical mean-field theory does not provide the optimal local reference point (impurity problem) for the diagrammatic expansion.

arXiv:2102.05425•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 14, 2021•51 citations

One-particle irreducible functional approach: A route to diagrammatic extensions of the dynamical mean-field theory

G. Rohringer, A. Toschi, Hartmut Hafermann +3 more

We present an approach which is based on the one-particle irreducible (1PI) generating functional formalism and includes electronic correlations on all length scales beyond the local correlations of dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). This formalism allows us to unify aspects of the dynamical vertex approximation (D$\ensuremath{\Gamma}$A) and the dual fermion (DF) scheme, yielding a consistent formulation of nonlocal correlations at the one- and two-particle level beyond DMFT within the functional integral formalism. In particular, the considered approach includes one-particle reducible contributions from the three- and more-particle vertices in the dual fermion approach, as well as some diagrams not included in the ladder version of D$\ensuremath{\Gamma}$A. To demonstrate the applicability and physical content of the 1PI approach, we compare the diagrammatics of 1PI, DF, and D$\ensuremath{\Gamma}$A, as well as the numerical results of these approaches for the half-filled Hubbard model in two dimensions.

arXiv:1301.7546•Physical Review B•Sep 9, 2013•92 citations

Extended dynamical mean field theory combined with the two-particle irreducible functional renormalization-group approach as a tool to study strongly correlated systems

A. A. Katanin

We propose an approach describing correlated electronic systems within the two-particle irreducible functional renormalization-group (2PI-fRG) approach, which uses initial self-energy and the two-particle irreducible vertices, obtained from (extended) dynamical mean-field theory [E(DMFT)]. Using the 2PI-fRG approach allows us to treat both local and nonlocal interactions. In the case of purely local interaction the corresponding equations have similar (although not identical) structure to the earlier developed DMFT+fRG $({\mathrm{DMF}}^{2}\mathrm{RG})$ approach. In a simplest truncation, neglecting scale dependence of the two-particle irreducible vertices, we reproduce the results for the two-particle vertices/susceptibilities in the ladder approximation of the dual-boson (DB) or the dynamic vertex approximation approach; in more sophisticated truncations the method allows us to consider nonlocal corrections to the self-energy as well as the interplay of charge and spin correlations. The proposed scheme is tested on the two-dimensional standard and extended $U\text{\ensuremath{-}}V$ half-filled Hubbard models. For the standard Hubbard model we obtain nonlocal self-energy, which is in agreement with numerical studies; for the extended Hubbard model we find the boundary of charge instability, which agrees well with the results of the DB approach. We also ascertain that the effect of spin correlations on electron interaction in the charge channel, not considered previously in the DB approach, only slightly reduces critical next-nearest-neighbor interaction of charge instability of the extended Hubbard model at the considered finite low temperature, yielding better agreement with dynamic cluster approximation. The considered method is rather general and can be applied to study various phenomena in strongly correlated electronic systems.

arXiv:1604.01702•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 8, 2019•32 citations
We formulate the dual fermion approach for strongly correlated electronic systems in terms of the lattice and dual effective interactions, obtained by using the covariation splitting formula. This allows us to consider the effect of six-point one-particle reducible interactions, which are usually neglected by the dual fermion approach. We show that the consideration of one-particle reducible six-point (as well as higher order) vertices is crucially important for the diagrammatic consistency of this approach. In particular, the relation between the dual and lattice self-energy, derived in the dual fermion approach, implicitly accounts for the effect of the diagrams, containing six-point and higher order local one-particle reducible vertices, and should be applied with caution, if these vertices are neglected. Apart from that, the treatment of the self-energy feedback is also modified by six-point and higher order vertices; these vertices are also important to account for some non-local corrections to the lattice self-energy, which have the same order in the local four-point vertices as the diagrams usually considered in the approach. These observations highlight an importance of six-point and higher order vertices in the dual fermion approach, and call for the development of new schemes of treatment of non-local fluctuations, which are based on one-particle irreducible quantities.
We suggest a new approach for treatment of local and non-local interactions in correlated electronic systems, which is based on the combination of the (extended) dynamical mean-field theory ((E)DMFT) and the two-particle irreducible functional renormaliztion-group (2PI-fRG) method. The considering approach uses self-energy and the two-particle irreducible vertices, obtained from (E)DMFT, as an input of 2PI-fRG approach. Using 2PI vertices may improve the applicability of various truncations and fulfilling conservation laws in comparison with one-particle irreducible approaches. In case of purely local interaction in a certain truncation of the DMFT+2PI-fRG equations, the obtained equation for the self-energy has a similar, although not identical, structure to that in the ladder dynamic vertex approximation (D$\Gamma $A). For the non-local interactions, in a simplest truncation we reproduce the results for the two-particle vertices/susceptibilities in the ladder approximation of the dual boson approach, but obtain different equation for the self-energy with a correct treatment of the one-particel reducible vertices of higher orders. The proposed scheme is rather general and can be applied to study various phenomena in strongly-correlated electronic systems, e.g. as a tool describing ab initio screening of the Coulomb interaction in strongly correlated systems.
The main focus of the present thesis lies on the development and application of numerical approaches based on quantum lattice models to describe collective excitations in strongly correlated materials. To this end, an efficient and balanced dual triply irreducible local expansion (D-TRILEX) approach that captures the major effects of spatial correlations in strongly correlated fermionic systems is presented, which is based on partial bosonization of the collective electronic fluctuations. Thereby, a specific choice of the bare interaction in the corresponding channel of instability allows a simultaneous description of collective excitations in different channels without facing the Fierz ambiguity problem which usually arises in methods based on partial bosonization. Compared to more elaborate methods, D-TRILEX does not require the computation of the numerically expensive four-point vertex. Furthermore, taking into account only the leading longitudinal contribution of the bosonic modes to the self-energy reduces the complexity of the diagrammatic structure drastically making the method applicable to more complex realistic multi-orbital systems. As the main result of this thesis, the D-TRILEX approach is introduced and its limit of applicability is studied by applying it to the two-dimensional single-band Hubbard model. Performing a comprehensive diagrammatic analysis by comparing D-TRILEX with methods, which consider different sets of diagrams and different approximations for the four-point vertex, we find that contributions that are not considered by the partially bosonized approximation of the four-point vertex have only a minor effect on electronic degrees of freedom and the longitudinal bosonic modes taking into account in D-TRILEX self-energy are the leading ones in a broad range of control parameters. After investigating the applicability of the D-TRILEX approach we apply the method to study collective electronic effects in the hole-doped InSe monolayers using a realistic electronic-structure model. Thereby, we find that due to the weakly screened long-range Coulomb interaction the system shows a charge density waves phase for the broad range of considered parameters, however, inside this regime we have found a coexisting ferromagnetic phase. D-TRILEX can be considered as an approximation of the more elaborate dual boson (DB) theory, which accounts for local correlations within the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) and nonlocal correlations perturbatively. As a further result of this thesis, we investigate the weak coupling regime of the two-dimensional single-band Hubbard model within the ladder DB approximation and compare our results to the numerically exact diagrammatic quantum Monte Carlo (DiagMC) method. We find that the DB method qualitatively captures all the different regimes. Even quantitatively DB shows a good agreement with the exact results for single- and two-particle quantities at high and moderate temperatures. However, the ladder approximation slightly underestimates the strong antiferromagnetic fluctuations that appear in the system at low temperatures. As the final result of this thesis, we perform a parametrization of the local four-point vertex in terms of the (three-point) Hedin vertex and screened interactions in the framework of single-boson exchange (SBE) decomposition. Similar to the D-TRILEX approach the computational costs are reduced by neglecting the interaction-irreducible part of the four-point vertex. The approximated vertex is used to calculate the DMFT susceptibility for different interaction strengths at different temperatures. We find that the approximation shows a good agreement in the limits of weak and strong couplings. Thereby, our study highlights the importance of the Hedin vertex for local vertex corrections.
In this work, we present a nonlocal expansion scheme to study correlated electron systems aiming at a better description of its spatial fluctuations at all length scales. Taking the nonlocal coupling as a perturbation to the local degrees of freedom, we show that the nonlocality in the self-energy function can be efficiently constructed from the coupling between local fluctuations. It can provide one unified framework to incorporate nonlocality to both ordered and disordered correlated many-body fermion systems. In this application, we prove that the dual-fermion approach can be understood as a special case of this nonlocal expansion scheme. The scheme presented in this work is constructed without introducing any dual variable, in which the interacting nature and the correlated behaviors of the lattice fermions have a clear physics correspondence. Thus, in this special case, the equivalence of the dual-fermion approach to the nonlocal expansion scheme beautifully reveals the physics origin of the dual variables. We show that the noninteracting dual-fermion Green's function corresponds exactly to a nonlocal coupling of the lattice fermion renormalized by the local single-particle charge fluctuations, and the dual-fermion self-energy behaves as the one-particle fully irreducible components of the lattice Green's function. Not only limited to this specific example, the nonlocal expansion scheme presented in this work can also be applied to other problems depending on the choice of the local degrees of freedom.
In this work we present a comprehensive analysis of collective electronic fluctuations and their effect on single-particle properties of the Hubbard model. Our approach is based on a standard dual fermion and boson scheme with the interaction truncated at the two-particle level. Within this framework we compare various approximations that differ in the set of diagrams (ladder vs exact diagrammatic Monte Carlo), and/or in the form of the four-point interaction vertex (exact vs partially bosonized). This allows to evaluate the effect of all components of the four-point vertex function on the electronic self-energy. In particular, we observe that contributions that are not accounted for by the partially bosonized approximation for the vertex have only a minor effect on electronic degrees of freedom in a broad range of model parameters. In addition, we find that in the regime, where the ladder dual fermion approximation provides an accurate solution of the problem, the leading contribution to the self-energy is given by the longitudinal bosonic modes. This can be explained by the fact that contributions of transverse particle-hole and particle-particle modes partially cancel each other. Our results justify the applicability of the recently introduced dual triply irreducible local expansion (D-TRILEX) method that represents one of the simplest consistent diagrammatic extensions of the dynamical mean-field theory. We find that the self-consistent D-TRILEX approach is reasonably accurate also in challenging regimes of the Hubbard model, even where the dynamical mean-field theory does not provide the optimal local reference point (impurity problem) for the diagrammatic expansion.
We present an approach which is based on the one-particle irreducible (1PI) generating functional formalism and includes electronic correlations on all length scales beyond the local correlations of dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). This formalism allows us to unify aspects of the dynamical vertex approximation (D$\ensuremath{\Gamma}$A) and the dual fermion (DF) scheme, yielding a consistent formulation of nonlocal correlations at the one- and two-particle level beyond DMFT within the functional integral formalism. In particular, the considered approach includes one-particle reducible contributions from the three- and more-particle vertices in the dual fermion approach, as well as some diagrams not included in the ladder version of D$\ensuremath{\Gamma}$A. To demonstrate the applicability and physical content of the 1PI approach, we compare the diagrammatics of 1PI, DF, and D$\ensuremath{\Gamma}$A, as well as the numerical results of these approaches for the half-filled Hubbard model in two dimensions.
We propose an approach describing correlated electronic systems within the two-particle irreducible functional renormalization-group (2PI-fRG) approach, which uses initial self-energy and the two-particle irreducible vertices, obtained from (extended) dynamical mean-field theory [E(DMFT)]. Using the 2PI-fRG approach allows us to treat both local and nonlocal interactions. In the case of purely local interaction the corresponding equations have similar (although not identical) structure to the earlier developed DMFT+fRG (DMF2RG)({\mathrm{DMF}}^{2}\mathrm{RG})(DMF2RG) approach. In a simplest truncation, neglecting scale dependence of the two-particle irreducible vertices, we reproduce the results for the two-particle vertices/susceptibilities in the ladder approximation of the dual-boson (DB) or the dynamic vertex approximation approach; in more sophisticated truncations the method allows us to consider nonlocal corrections to the self-energy as well as the interplay of charge and spin correlations. The proposed scheme is tested on the two-dimensional standard and extended $U\text{\ensuremath{-}}V$ half-filled Hubbard models. For the standard Hubbard model we obtain nonlocal self-energy, which is in agreement with numerical studies; for the extended Hubbard model we find the boundary of charge instability, which agrees well with the results of the DB approach. We also ascertain that the effect of spin correlations on electron interaction in the charge channel, not considered previously in the DB approach, only slightly reduces critical next-nearest-neighbor interaction of charge instability of the extended Hubbard model at the considered finite low temperature, yielding better agreement with dynamic cluster approximation. The considered method is rather general and can be applied to study various phenomena in strongly correlated electronic systems.