Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1207.1176 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Unbounded $\mathcal {C}$-symmetries and their nonuniqueness

Carl M. Bender, Sergiusz Kużel

Published Oct 23, 2012• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is shown that if the operator for a -symmetric Hamiltonian with simple eigenvalues is not unique, then it is unbounded. The fact that the operator is unbounded is significant because, while there is a formal equivalence between a -symmetric Hamiltonian and a conventionally Hermitian Hamiltonian in the sense that the two Hamiltonians are isospectral, the Hilbert spaces are inequivalent. This is so because the mapping from one Hilbert space to the other is unbounded. This shows that -symmetric quantum theories are mathematically distinct from conventional Hermitian quantum theories. This article is part of a special issue of Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical devoted to 'Quantum physics with non-Hermitian operators'.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/45/44/444005

Related papers

Can PT-Symmetric Quantum Mechanics be a Viable Alternative Quantum Theory?

Sungwook Lee, Lawrence R. Mead

Update: A time-independent $n\times n$ PT-symmetric (and symmetric) Hamiltonian is diagonalizable since it has all distinct real eigenvalues and the resulting diagonal matrix is a real symmetric matrix. The diagonalization results an isometry so there shouldn't be any issue with unitarity and unfortunately this very elementary mathematical fact somehow did not draw the authors' attention. However, PT-symmetric quantum mechanics is not out of trouble. For time-dependent PT-symmetric (and symmetric) Hamiltonians (even $2\times 2$ ones) the authors observed that there is a violation of unitarity. Moreover, the first named author showed in his recent article arXiv:1312.7738 that PT-symmetric quantum mechanics is indeed a certain kind of Hermitian quantum mechanics and that in order for time-evolution to be unitary with respect to $J$-inner product (one that gives rise to a Hilbert space structure on the space of state functions), the potential energy operator $V(x)$ must be real. This means that those complex PT-symmetric Hamiltonians that have been studied by physicists are unfortunately unphysical. The first named author discussed in a subsequent article arXiv:1401.5149 that while finite-state PT-symmetric quantum mechanics with time-independent Hamiltonians is not physically any different from Hermitian quantum mechanics, PT-symmetric quantum mechanics exhibits a distinctive symmetry from that of Hermitian quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1303.6339•Mar 25, 2013•0 citations

\mathcal{Q}\mathcal{T} -symmetry and weak pseudo-hermiticity

Ali Mostafazadeh

For an invertible (bounded) linear operator acting in a Hilbert space , we consider the consequences of the -symmetry of a non-hermitian Hamiltonian where is the time-reversal operator. If H is symmetric in the sense that , then -symmetry is equivalent to -weak-pseudo-hermiticity. But in general this equivalence does not hold. We show this using some specific examples. Among these is a large class of non- -symmetric Hamiltonians that share the spectral properties of -symmetric Hamiltonians.

arXiv:0710.4879•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 23, 2008•20 citations

Reflectionless potentials and symmetry

Zafar Ahmed, Carl M. Bender, Michael Berry

Large families of Hamiltonians that are non-Hermitian in the conventional sense have been found to have all eigenvalues real, a fact attributed to an unbroken symmetry. The corresponding quantum theories possess an unconventional scalar product. The eigenvalues are determined by differential equations with boundary conditions imposed in wedges in the complex plane. For a special class of such systems, it is possible to impose the -symmetric boundary conditions on the real axis, which lies on the edges of the wedges. The -symmetric spectrum can then be obtained by imposing the more transparent requirement that the potential be reflectionless.

arXiv:quant-ph/0508117•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Sep 14, 2005•74 citations

Introduction to 𝒫𝒯-symmetric quantum theory

Carl M. Bender

In most introductory courses on quantum mechanics one is taught that the Hamiltonian operator must be Hermitian in order that the energy levels be real and that the theory be unitary (probability conserving). To express the Hermiticity of a Hamiltonian, one writes H = H †, where the symbol † denotes the usual Dirac Hermitian conjugation; that is, transpose and complex conjugate. In the past few years it has been recognized that the requirement of Hermiticity, which is often stated as an axiom of quantum mechanics, may be replaced by the less mathematical and more physical requirement of space – time reflection symmetry (𝒫𝒯 symmetry) without losing any of the essential physical features of quantum mechanics. Theories defined by non-Hermitian 𝒫𝒯-symmetric Hamiltonians exhibit strange and unexpected properties at the classical as well as at the quantum level. This paper explains how the requirement of Hermiticity can be evaded and discusses the properties of some non-Hermitian 𝒫𝒯-symmetric quantum theories.

arXiv:quant-ph/0501052•Contemporary Physics•Jul 1, 2005•497 citations

CPT-Frames for Non-Hermitian Hamiltonians

Cao Huai

Based on the P T-symmetric quantum theory,the concepts of P T-frame,P T-symmetric operator and CPT-frame on a Hilbert space K and for an operator on K are proposed.It is proved that the spectrum and point spectrum of a P T-symmetric linear operator are both symmetric with respect to the real axis and the eigenvalues of an unbroken P T-symmetric operator are real.For a linear operator H on Cd,it is proved that H has unbroken P T symmetry if and only if it has d diferent eigenvalues and the corresponding eigenstates are eigenstates of P T.Given a C P T-frame on K,a new positive inner product on K is induced and called C P T-inner product.Te relationship between the CP T-adjoint and the Dirac adjoint of a densely defined linear operator is derived,and it is proved that an operator which has a bounded CP T-frame is CP T-Hermitian if and only if it is T-symmetric,in that case,it is similar to a Hermitian operator.The existence of an operator C consisting of a CP T-frame is discussed.These concepts and results will serve a mathematical discussion about P T-symmetric quantum mechanics.

理论物理通讯：英文版•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Consistency of PT-symmetric quantum mechanics

Dorje C. Brody

Abstract In recent reports, suggestions have been put forward to the effect that parity and time-reversal (PT) symmetry in quantum mechanics is incompatible with causality. It is shown here, in contrast, that PT-symmetric quantum mechanics is fully consistent with standard quantum mechanics. This follows from the surprising fact that the much-discussed metric operator on Hilbert space is not physically observable. In particular, for closed quantum systems in finite dimensions there is no statistical test that one can perform on the outcomes of measurements to determine whether the Hamiltonian is Hermitian in the conventional sense, or PT-symmetric—the two theories are indistinguishable. Nontrivial physical effects arising as a consequence of PT symmetry are expected to be observed, nevertheless, for open quantum systems with balanced gain and loss.

arXiv:1508.02190•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 29, 2016•76 citations
Unbounded C\mathcal {C}C-symmetries and their nonuniqueness
It is shown that if the operator for a -symmetric Hamiltonian with simple eigenvalues is not unique, then it is unbounded. The fact that the operator is unbounded is significant because, while there is a formal equivalence between a -symmetric Hamiltonian and a conventionally Hermitian Hamiltonian in the sense that the two Hamiltonians are isospectral, the Hilbert spaces are inequivalent. This is so because the mapping from one Hilbert space to the other is unbounded. This shows that -symmetric quantum theories are mathematically distinct from conventional Hermitian quantum theories. This article is part of a special issue of Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical devoted to 'Quantum physics with non-Hermitian operators'.
Update: A time-independent n×nn\times nn×n PT-symmetric (and symmetric) Hamiltonian is diagonalizable since it has all distinct real eigenvalues and the resulting diagonal matrix is a real symmetric matrix. The diagonalization results an isometry so there shouldn't be any issue with unitarity and unfortunately this very elementary mathematical fact somehow did not draw the authors' attention. However, PT-symmetric quantum mechanics is not out of trouble. For time-dependent PT-symmetric (and symmetric) Hamiltonians (even 2×22\times 22×2 ones) the authors observed that there is a violation of unitarity. Moreover, the first named author showed in his recent article arXiv:1312.7738 that PT-symmetric quantum mechanics is indeed a certain kind of Hermitian quantum mechanics and that in order for time-evolution to be unitary with respect to JJJ-inner product (one that gives rise to a Hilbert space structure on the space of state functions), the potential energy operator V(x)V(x)V(x) must be real. This means that those complex PT-symmetric Hamiltonians that have been studied by physicists are unfortunately unphysical. The first named author discussed in a subsequent article arXiv:1401.5149 that while finite-state PT-symmetric quantum mechanics with time-independent Hamiltonians is not physically any different from Hermitian quantum mechanics, PT-symmetric quantum mechanics exhibits a distinctive symmetry from that of Hermitian quantum mechanics.
Large families of Hamiltonians that are non-Hermitian in the conventional sense have been found to have all eigenvalues real, a fact attributed to an unbroken symmetry. The corresponding quantum theories possess an unconventional scalar product. The eigenvalues are determined by differential equations with boundary conditions imposed in wedges in the complex plane. For a special class of such systems, it is possible to impose the -symmetric boundary conditions on the real axis, which lies on the edges of the wedges. The -symmetric spectrum can then be obtained by imposing the more transparent requirement that the potential be reflectionless.
In most introductory courses on quantum mechanics one is taught that the Hamiltonian operator must be Hermitian in order that the energy levels be real and that the theory be unitary (probability conserving). To express the Hermiticity of a Hamiltonian, one writes H = H †, where the symbol † denotes the usual Dirac Hermitian conjugation; that is, transpose and complex conjugate. In the past few years it has been recognized that the requirement of Hermiticity, which is often stated as an axiom of quantum mechanics, may be replaced by the less mathematical and more physical requirement of space – time reflection symmetry (𝒫𝒯 symmetry) without losing any of the essential physical features of quantum mechanics. Theories defined by non-Hermitian 𝒫𝒯-symmetric Hamiltonians exhibit strange and unexpected properties at the classical as well as at the quantum level. This paper explains how the requirement of Hermiticity can be evaded and discusses the properties of some non-Hermitian 𝒫𝒯-symmetric quantum theories.
Based on the P T-symmetric quantum theory,the concepts of P T-frame,P T-symmetric operator and CPT-frame on a Hilbert space K and for an operator on K are proposed.It is proved that the spectrum and point spectrum of a P T-symmetric linear operator are both symmetric with respect to the real axis and the eigenvalues of an unbroken P T-symmetric operator are real.For a linear operator H on Cd,it is proved that H has unbroken P T symmetry if and only if it has d diferent eigenvalues and the corresponding eigenstates are eigenstates of P T.Given a C P T-frame on K,a new positive inner product on K is induced and called C P T-inner product.Te relationship between the CP T-adjoint and the Dirac adjoint of a densely defined linear operator is derived,and it is proved that an operator which has a bounded CP T-frame is CP T-Hermitian if and only if it is T-symmetric,in that case,it is similar to a Hermitian operator.The existence of an operator C consisting of a CP T-frame is discussed.These concepts and results will serve a mathematical discussion about P T-symmetric quantum mechanics.
Abstract In recent reports, suggestions have been put forward to the effect that parity and time-reversal (PT) symmetry in quantum mechanics is incompatible with causality. It is shown here, in contrast, that PT-symmetric quantum mechanics is fully consistent with standard quantum mechanics. This follows from the surprising fact that the much-discussed metric operator on Hilbert space is not physically observable. In particular, for closed quantum systems in finite dimensions there is no statistical test that one can perform on the outcomes of measurements to determine whether the Hamiltonian is Hermitian in the conventional sense, or PT-symmetric—the two theories are indistinguishable. Nontrivial physical effects arising as a consequence of PT symmetry are expected to be observed, nevertheless, for open quantum systems with balanced gain and loss.