Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1206.5485 · Physical Review Letters

Open Timelike Curves Violate Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle

Jacques Pienaar, Timothy C. Ralph, Casey R. Myers

Published Feb 4, 2013• 33 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Toy models for quantum evolution in the presence of closed timelike curves have gained attention in the recent literature due to the strange effects they predict. The circuits that give rise to these effects appear quite abstract and contrived, as they require nontrivial interactions between the future and past that lead to infinitely recursive equations. We consider the special case in which there is no interaction inside the closed timelike curve, referred to as an open timelike curve (OTC), for which the only local effect is to increase the time elapsed by a clock carried by the system. Remarkably, circuits with access to OTCs are shown to violate Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, allowing perfect state discrimination and perfect cloning of coherent states. The model is extended to wave packets and smoothly recovers standard quantum mechanics in an appropriate physical limit. The analogy with general relativistic time dilation suggests that OTCs provide a novel alternative to existing proposals for the behavior of quantum systems under gravity.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.110.060501

Related papers

Any quantum state can be cloned in the presence of closed timelike curves

Doyeol Ahn, Timothy C. Ralph, Mann, R. B.

The possible existence of closed timelike curves (CTCs) draws attention to fundamental questions about what is physically possible and what is not. An example is the "no cloning theorem" in quantum mechanics, which states that no physical means exists by which an unknown arbitrary quantum state can be reproduced or copied perfectly. Using the Deutsch approach, we show here that this theorem can be circumvented in the presence of closed timelike curves, allowing the cloning of an unknown arbitrary quantum state chosen from a finite alphabet of states. Since the "no cloning theorem" has played a central role in the development of quantum information science, it is clear that the existence of CTCs would radically change the rules for quantum information technology. Nevertheless we show that this type of cloning does not violate no-signalling criteria.

arXiv:1008.0221•Aug 2, 2010•3 citations

Closed time like curves enable perfect state distinguishability

James William Harrington, Mark M. Wilde, Todd A. Brun

The causal self-consistency condition for closed timelike curves can give rise to nonlinear interactions on chronology-respecting qubits. We demonstrate that particular unitary interactions between closed timelike curve qubits and chronology-respecting qubits allow perfect distinguishability of nonorthogonal states, and provide a constructive proof for an arbitrary number of nonorthogonal states. This has a number of highly significant consequences. For example, an adversary with access to closed timelike curves can break the B92, BB84, and SARG04 quantum key distribution protocols, or any prepare-and-measure quantum key distribution scheme. Our result also implies that a party with access to closed timelike curves can violate the Holevo bound by accessing more than log(N) bits of information from an N-dimensional quantum state. In principle, he can transmit an arbitrarily large amount of classical information with a quantum system of fixed size. We discuss the implications of this for quantum cloning.

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Quantum fields on closed timelike curves

Jacques Pienaar, Casey R. Myers, Timothy C. Ralph

Recently, there has been much interest in the evolution of quantum particles on closed timelike curves (CTCs). However, such models typically assume pointlike particles with only two degrees of freedom; a very questionable assumption given the relativistic setting of the problem. We show that it is possible to generalize the Deutsch model of CTCs to fields using the equivalent circuit formalism. We give examples for coherent, squeezed, and single-photon states interacting with the CTC via a beamsplitter. The model is then generalized further to account for the smooth transition to normal quantum mechanics as the CTC becomes much smaller than the size of the modes interacting on it. In this limit, we find that the system behaves like a standard quantum-mechanical feedback loop.

arXiv:1110.3582•Physical Review A•Dec 21, 2011•9 citations

Timelike curves can increase entanglement with LOCC

Subhayan Roy Moulick, Prasanta Kumar Panigrahi

We study the nature of entanglement in presence of Deutschian closed timelike curves (D-CTCs) and open timelike curves (OTCs) and find that existence of such physical systems in nature would allow us to increase entanglement using local operations and classical communication (LOCC). This is otherwise in direct contradiction with the fundamental definition of entanglement. We study this problem from the perspective of Bell state discrimination, and show how D-CTCs and OTCs can unambiguously distinguish between four Bell states with LOCC, that is otherwise known to be impossible.

arXiv:1511.00538•Scientific Reports•Nov 29, 2016•7 citations

Information flow of quantum states interacting with closed timelike curves

Timothy C. Ralph, Casey R. Myers

Recently, the quantum information processing power of closed timelike curves has been discussed. Because the most widely accepted model for quantum closed timelike curve interactions contains ambiguities, different authors have been able to reach radically different conclusions as to the power of such interactions. By tracing the information flow through such systems we are able to derive equivalent circuits with unique solutions, thus allowing an objective decision between the alternatives to be made. We conclude that closed timelike curves, if they exist and are well described by these simple models, would be a powerful resource for quantum information processing.

arXiv:1003.1987•Physical Review A•Dec 29, 2010•37 citations

Quantum Closed Timelike Curves: Deutsch Model and Temporal Evolution

Mikhail Pavlov

Abstract This study examines closed timelike curves (CTCs) in quantum mechanics, focusing on the Deutsch model, one of the most widely studied frameworks for describing quantum systems in the presence of time loops. In this model, a quantum state ∣ψ⟩|\psi\rangle∣ψ⟩ interacts unitarily with its past version, effectively forming a two-qubit system where the chronologically consistent qubit interacts with a qubit ρCTC\rho_{\text{CTC}}ρCTC trapped in a closed timelike curve. The state ρCTC\rho_{\text{CTC}}ρCTC is determined by the Deutsch consistency condition, ensuring self-consistent evolution along the CTC. This approach allows for rigorous modeling of quantum systems under non-classical temporal structures, providing insights into temporal correlations, causality violations, and the potential computational advantages offered by CTC-assisted quantum operations. While alternative CTC models based on postselection have been proposed, the Deutsch model remains a foundational reference for studying quantum evolution in non-linear temporal frameworks. Its analysis informs research in quantum information, retrocausality, and the theoretical limits of computation in exotic spacetime geometries.

•Mar 4, 2026•0 citations
Toy models for quantum evolution in the presence of closed timelike curves have gained attention in the recent literature due to the strange effects they predict. The circuits that give rise to these effects appear quite abstract and contrived, as they require nontrivial interactions between the future and past that lead to infinitely recursive equations. We consider the special case in which there is no interaction inside the closed timelike curve, referred to as an open timelike curve (OTC), for which the only local effect is to increase the time elapsed by a clock carried by the system. Remarkably, circuits with access to OTCs are shown to violate Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, allowing perfect state discrimination and perfect cloning of coherent states. The model is extended to wave packets and smoothly recovers standard quantum mechanics in an appropriate physical limit. The analogy with general relativistic time dilation suggests that OTCs provide a novel alternative to existing proposals for the behavior of quantum systems under gravity.
The possible existence of closed timelike curves (CTCs) draws attention to fundamental questions about what is physically possible and what is not. An example is the "no cloning theorem" in quantum mechanics, which states that no physical means exists by which an unknown arbitrary quantum state can be reproduced or copied perfectly. Using the Deutsch approach, we show here that this theorem can be circumvented in the presence of closed timelike curves, allowing the cloning of an unknown arbitrary quantum state chosen from a finite alphabet of states. Since the "no cloning theorem" has played a central role in the development of quantum information science, it is clear that the existence of CTCs would radically change the rules for quantum information technology. Nevertheless we show that this type of cloning does not violate no-signalling criteria.
The causal self-consistency condition for closed timelike curves can give rise to nonlinear interactions on chronology-respecting qubits. We demonstrate that particular unitary interactions between closed timelike curve qubits and chronology-respecting qubits allow perfect distinguishability of nonorthogonal states, and provide a constructive proof for an arbitrary number of nonorthogonal states. This has a number of highly significant consequences. For example, an adversary with access to closed timelike curves can break the B92, BB84, and SARG04 quantum key distribution protocols, or any prepare-and-measure quantum key distribution scheme. Our result also implies that a party with access to closed timelike curves can violate the Holevo bound by accessing more than log(N) bits of information from an N-dimensional quantum state. In principle, he can transmit an arbitrarily large amount of classical information with a quantum system of fixed size. We discuss the implications of this for quantum cloning.
Recently, there has been much interest in the evolution of quantum particles on closed timelike curves (CTCs). However, such models typically assume pointlike particles with only two degrees of freedom; a very questionable assumption given the relativistic setting of the problem. We show that it is possible to generalize the Deutsch model of CTCs to fields using the equivalent circuit formalism. We give examples for coherent, squeezed, and single-photon states interacting with the CTC via a beamsplitter. The model is then generalized further to account for the smooth transition to normal quantum mechanics as the CTC becomes much smaller than the size of the modes interacting on it. In this limit, we find that the system behaves like a standard quantum-mechanical feedback loop.
We study the nature of entanglement in presence of Deutschian closed timelike curves (D-CTCs) and open timelike curves (OTCs) and find that existence of such physical systems in nature would allow us to increase entanglement using local operations and classical communication (LOCC). This is otherwise in direct contradiction with the fundamental definition of entanglement. We study this problem from the perspective of Bell state discrimination, and show how D-CTCs and OTCs can unambiguously distinguish between four Bell states with LOCC, that is otherwise known to be impossible.
Recently, the quantum information processing power of closed timelike curves has been discussed. Because the most widely accepted model for quantum closed timelike curve interactions contains ambiguities, different authors have been able to reach radically different conclusions as to the power of such interactions. By tracing the information flow through such systems we are able to derive equivalent circuits with unique solutions, thus allowing an objective decision between the alternatives to be made. We conclude that closed timelike curves, if they exist and are well described by these simple models, would be a powerful resource for quantum information processing.
Abstract This study examines closed timelike curves (CTCs) in quantum mechanics, focusing on the Deutsch model, one of the most widely studied frameworks for describing quantum systems in the presence of time loops. In this model, a quantum state ∣ψ⟩|\psi\rangle∣ψ⟩ interacts unitarily with its past version, effectively forming a two-qubit system where the chronologically consistent qubit interacts with a qubit ρCTC\rho_{\text{CTC}}ρCTC trapped in a closed timelike curve. The state ρCTC\rho_{\text{CTC}}ρCTC is determined by the Deutsch consistency condition, ensuring self-consistent evolution along the CTC. This approach allows for rigorous modeling of quantum systems under non-classical temporal structures, providing insights into temporal correlations, causality violations, and the potential computational advantages offered by CTC-assisted quantum operations. While alternative CTC models based on postselection have been proposed, the Deutsch model remains a foundational reference for studying quantum evolution in non-linear temporal frameworks. Its analysis informs research in quantum information, retrocausality, and the theoretical limits of computation in exotic spacetime geometries.