Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1106.3870

The origin of phase transitions enlightened by an elementary classical spin model

Fabrizio Baroni

Published Jun 20, 2011• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce a classical spin model with long-range interaction undergoing a first-order $\mathbb{Z}_2$-symmetry breaking phase transition (SBPT) which is in our knowledge one of the simplest models showing such a phenomenon. Its aim is to enlighten the generating-mechanism of a SBPT in general, at least for long-range systems, even though it may be give hints useful also for short-range systems. Further, we present a general rule to model the shape of the long-range potential energy of a Hamiltonian system for a $\mathbb{Z}_2$-SBPT to occur. The main feature is a double-well potential which competes with the concavity of the entropy in shaping the free energy, accordingly to Landau mean-field theory of SBPTs. Finally, we revisit the Ising and the spherical model (Berlin-Kak) models in the mean version at the light of the results obtained here. The model introduced here may be suitable even for didactic purposes and for numerical investigation of the dynamic near the transition point.

Related papers

Classical phase transitions in a one-dimensional short-range spin model

Petro Sarkanych, Yurij V. Holovatch, Ralph Kenna B

Abstract Ising’s solution of a classical spin model famously demonstrated the absence of a positive-temperature phase transition in one-dimensional equilibrium systems with short-range interactions. No-go arguments established that the energy cost to insert domain walls in such systems is outweighed by entropy excess so that symmetry cannot be spontaneously broken. An archetypal way around the no-go theorems is to augment interaction energy by increasing the range of interaction. Here we introduce new ways around the no-go theorems by investigating entropy depletion instead. We implement this for the Potts model with invisible states. Because spins in such a state do not interact with their surroundings, they contribute to the entropy but not the interaction energy of the system. Reducing the number of invisible states to a negative value decreases the entropy by an amount sufficient to induce a positive-temperature classical phase transition. This approach is complementary to the long-range interaction mechanism. Alternatively, subjecting positive numbers of invisible states to imaginary or complex fields can trigger such a phase transition. We also discuss potential physical realisability of such systems.

arXiv:1806.02569•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Oct 22, 2018•12 citations

Quantum Phase Transition in the Coupled-Top Model: From Z2 to U(1) Symmetry Breaking

Wen-Jian Mao, Ye F. Tian, Liwei Duan +1 more

We investigate the coupled-top model, which describes two large spins interacting along both x and y directions. By tuning coupling strengths along distinct directions, the system exhibits different symmetries, ranging from a discrete Z2 to a continuous U(1) symmetry. The anisotropic coupled-top model displays a discrete Z2 symmetry, and the symmetry breaking induced by strong coupling drives a quantum phase transition from a disordered paramagnetic phase to an ordered ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic phase. In particular, the isotropic coupled-top model possesses a continuous U(1) symmetry, whose breaking gives rise to the Goldstone mode. The phase boundary can be well captured by the mean-field approach, characterized by the distinct behaviors of the order parameter. Higher-order quantum effects beyond the mean-field contribution can be achieved by mapping the large spins to bosonic operators via the Holstein–Primakoff transformation. For the anisotropic coupled-top model with Z2 symmetry, the energy gap closes, and both quantum fluctuations and entanglement entropy diverge near the critical point, signaling the onset of second-order quantum phase transitions. Strikingly, when U(1) symmetry is broken, the energy gap vanishes beyond the critical point, yielding a novel critical exponent of 1, rather than 1/2 for Z2 symmetry breaking. The rich symmetry structure of the coupled-top model underpins its role as a paradigmatic model for studying quantum phase transitions and exploring associated physical phenomena.

arXiv:2502.09394•Entropy•Apr 27, 2025•0 citations

Theory of Dynamical Phase Transitions in Quantum Systems with Symmetry-Breaking Eigenstates

Ángel L. Corps, Armando Relaño

We present a theory for the two kinds of dynamical quantum phase transitions, termed DPT-I and DPT-II, based on a minimal set of symmetry assumptions. In the special case of collective systems with infinite-range interactions, both are triggered by excited-state quantum phase transitions. For quenches below the critical energy, the existence of an additional conserved charge, identifying the corresponding phase, allows for a nonzero value of the dynamical order parameter characterizing DPTs-I, and precludes the main mechanism giving rise to nonanalyticities in the return probability, trademark of DPTs-II. We propose a statistical ensemble describing the long-time averages of order parameters in DPTs-I, and provide a theoretical proof for the incompatibility of the main mechanism for DPTs-II with the presence of this additional conserved charge. Our results are numerically illustrated in the fully connected transverse-field Ising model, which exhibits both kinds of dynamical phase transitions. Finally, we discuss the applicability of our theory to systems with finite-range interactions, where the phenomenology of excited-state quantum phase transitions is absent. We illustrate our findings by means of numerical calculations with experimentally relevant initial states.

arXiv:2205.03443•Physical Review Letters•Mar 9, 2023•43 citations

Quantum field theory of phase transitions in Fermi systems

R. D. Mattuck, Börje Johansson

The theory of fermion phase transitions is reviewed from a unified field theoretic standpoint, based on the diagrammatic perturbation expansion of a generalized matrix propagator. Transitions from a normal to a condensed phase are characterized by the spontaneous appearance of long-range order and (in the presence of a suitable infinitesimal external field) broken symmetry. This is illustrated by the ferromagnetic, solid, superconducting and spindensity wave ground states. The phenomenon is explained qualitatively as caused by the creation of a long-range internal field, F, due to the interactions between particles. This field establishes long-range order in the system, and is in turn itself established by the long-range order, in a self-consistent fashion. The mechanism here is expressed quantitatively in terms of a self-consistent Dyson equation relating a generalized matrix propagator, G, to a proper self-energy matrix, Σ. The off-diagonal elements of G describe ‘anomalous’ propagation processes which are characteristic for the condensed phase, and they yield directly the long-range order parameters. The Σ-matrix is just the potential of the internal field. The method is illustrated by applying it to the ferromagnetic phase of a system with δ-function interaction between particles. Finally, the technique is used to derive the vertex part equation for the transition point.

Advances In Physics•Jul 1, 1968•63 citations

Continuous symmetry breaking in 1D spin chains and 1+1D field theory

Adam Nahum

We argue that ground states of 1D spin chains can spontaneously break U(1) ``easy-plane'' spin rotation symmetry, via true long-range order of $(S^x, S^y)$, at the phase transition between two quasi-long-range-ordered phases. The critical point can be reached by tuning a single parameter in a Hamiltonian with the same symmetry as the XXZ model, without further fine-tuning. Equivalently, it can arise in systems of bosons with particle-hole symmetry, as a long-range-ordered transition point between two quasi-long-range-ordered superfluids. Our approach is to start with the continuum field theory of the isotropic Heisenberg ferromagnet and consider generic perturbations that respect easy-plane symmetry. We argue for a renormalization-group flow to a critical point where long-range order in $(S^x, S^y)$ is enabled by coexisting critical fluctuations of $S^z$. (We also discuss multicritical points where further parameters are tuned to zero.) These results show that it is much easier to break continuous symmetries in 1D than standard lore would suggest. The failure of standard intuition for 1D chains (based on the quantum--classical correspondence) can be attributed to Berry phases, which prevent the 1+1D system from mapping to a classical 2D spin model. The present theory also gives an example of an ordered state whose Goldstone mode is interacting even in the infra-red, rather than becoming a free field.

arXiv:2506.21540•Jun 26, 2025•10 citations

Landau Theory of Phase Transitions

Francesco Caravelli, Diego A. R. Dalvit

In the previous chapters, we discussed mean-field approaches such as the Curie–Weiss and Bragg–Williams theories, which provide a microscopic justification for macroscopic order parameters and spontaneous symmetry breaking. However, these approaches were based on specific microscopic Hamiltonians. Lev Davidovich Landau introduced a far more general and elegant framework: one that does not depend on microscopic details but on symmetry principles and analyticity of the free energy near the transition.

CRC Press eBooks•Jun 19, 2026•0 citations
We introduce a classical spin model with long-range interaction undergoing a first-order Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​-symmetry breaking phase transition (SBPT) which is in our knowledge one of the simplest models showing such a phenomenon. Its aim is to enlighten the generating-mechanism of a SBPT in general, at least for long-range systems, even though it may be give hints useful also for short-range systems. Further, we present a general rule to model the shape of the long-range potential energy of a Hamiltonian system for a Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​-SBPT to occur. The main feature is a double-well potential which competes with the concavity of the entropy in shaping the free energy, accordingly to Landau mean-field theory of SBPTs. Finally, we revisit the Ising and the spherical model (Berlin-Kak) models in the mean version at the light of the results obtained here. The model introduced here may be suitable even for didactic purposes and for numerical investigation of the dynamic near the transition point.
Abstract Ising’s solution of a classical spin model famously demonstrated the absence of a positive-temperature phase transition in one-dimensional equilibrium systems with short-range interactions. No-go arguments established that the energy cost to insert domain walls in such systems is outweighed by entropy excess so that symmetry cannot be spontaneously broken. An archetypal way around the no-go theorems is to augment interaction energy by increasing the range of interaction. Here we introduce new ways around the no-go theorems by investigating entropy depletion instead. We implement this for the Potts model with invisible states. Because spins in such a state do not interact with their surroundings, they contribute to the entropy but not the interaction energy of the system. Reducing the number of invisible states to a negative value decreases the entropy by an amount sufficient to induce a positive-temperature classical phase transition. This approach is complementary to the long-range interaction mechanism. Alternatively, subjecting positive numbers of invisible states to imaginary or complex fields can trigger such a phase transition. We also discuss potential physical realisability of such systems.
We investigate the coupled-top model, which describes two large spins interacting along both x and y directions. By tuning coupling strengths along distinct directions, the system exhibits different symmetries, ranging from a discrete Z2 to a continuous U(1) symmetry. The anisotropic coupled-top model displays a discrete Z2 symmetry, and the symmetry breaking induced by strong coupling drives a quantum phase transition from a disordered paramagnetic phase to an ordered ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic phase. In particular, the isotropic coupled-top model possesses a continuous U(1) symmetry, whose breaking gives rise to the Goldstone mode. The phase boundary can be well captured by the mean-field approach, characterized by the distinct behaviors of the order parameter. Higher-order quantum effects beyond the mean-field contribution can be achieved by mapping the large spins to bosonic operators via the Holstein–Primakoff transformation. For the anisotropic coupled-top model with Z2 symmetry, the energy gap closes, and both quantum fluctuations and entanglement entropy diverge near the critical point, signaling the onset of second-order quantum phase transitions. Strikingly, when U(1) symmetry is broken, the energy gap vanishes beyond the critical point, yielding a novel critical exponent of 1, rather than 1/2 for Z2 symmetry breaking. The rich symmetry structure of the coupled-top model underpins its role as a paradigmatic model for studying quantum phase transitions and exploring associated physical phenomena.
We present a theory for the two kinds of dynamical quantum phase transitions, termed DPT-I and DPT-II, based on a minimal set of symmetry assumptions. In the special case of collective systems with infinite-range interactions, both are triggered by excited-state quantum phase transitions. For quenches below the critical energy, the existence of an additional conserved charge, identifying the corresponding phase, allows for a nonzero value of the dynamical order parameter characterizing DPTs-I, and precludes the main mechanism giving rise to nonanalyticities in the return probability, trademark of DPTs-II. We propose a statistical ensemble describing the long-time averages of order parameters in DPTs-I, and provide a theoretical proof for the incompatibility of the main mechanism for DPTs-II with the presence of this additional conserved charge. Our results are numerically illustrated in the fully connected transverse-field Ising model, which exhibits both kinds of dynamical phase transitions. Finally, we discuss the applicability of our theory to systems with finite-range interactions, where the phenomenology of excited-state quantum phase transitions is absent. We illustrate our findings by means of numerical calculations with experimentally relevant initial states.
The theory of fermion phase transitions is reviewed from a unified field theoretic standpoint, based on the diagrammatic perturbation expansion of a generalized matrix propagator. Transitions from a normal to a condensed phase are characterized by the spontaneous appearance of long-range order and (in the presence of a suitable infinitesimal external field) broken symmetry. This is illustrated by the ferromagnetic, solid, superconducting and spindensity wave ground states. The phenomenon is explained qualitatively as caused by the creation of a long-range internal field, F, due to the interactions between particles. This field establishes long-range order in the system, and is in turn itself established by the long-range order, in a self-consistent fashion. The mechanism here is expressed quantitatively in terms of a self-consistent Dyson equation relating a generalized matrix propagator, G, to a proper self-energy matrix, Σ. The off-diagonal elements of G describe ‘anomalous’ propagation processes which are characteristic for the condensed phase, and they yield directly the long-range order parameters. The Σ-matrix is just the potential of the internal field. The method is illustrated by applying it to the ferromagnetic phase of a system with δ-function interaction between particles. Finally, the technique is used to derive the vertex part equation for the transition point.
We argue that ground states of 1D spin chains can spontaneously break U(1) ``easy-plane'' spin rotation symmetry, via true long-range order of (Sx,Sy)(S^x, S^y)(Sx,Sy), at the phase transition between two quasi-long-range-ordered phases. The critical point can be reached by tuning a single parameter in a Hamiltonian with the same symmetry as the XXZ model, without further fine-tuning. Equivalently, it can arise in systems of bosons with particle-hole symmetry, as a long-range-ordered transition point between two quasi-long-range-ordered superfluids. Our approach is to start with the continuum field theory of the isotropic Heisenberg ferromagnet and consider generic perturbations that respect easy-plane symmetry. We argue for a renormalization-group flow to a critical point where long-range order in (Sx,Sy)(S^x, S^y)(Sx,Sy) is enabled by coexisting critical fluctuations of SzS^zSz. (We also discuss multicritical points where further parameters are tuned to zero.) These results show that it is much easier to break continuous symmetries in 1D than standard lore would suggest. The failure of standard intuition for 1D chains (based on the quantum--classical correspondence) can be attributed to Berry phases, which prevent the 1+1D system from mapping to a classical 2D spin model. The present theory also gives an example of an ordered state whose Goldstone mode is interacting even in the infra-red, rather than becoming a free field.
In the previous chapters, we discussed mean-field approaches such as the Curie–Weiss and Bragg–Williams theories, which provide a microscopic justification for macroscopic order parameters and spontaneous symmetry breaking. However, these approaches were based on specific microscopic Hamiltonians. Lev Davidovich Landau introduced a far more general and elegant framework: one that does not depend on microscopic details but on symmetry principles and analyticity of the free energy near the transition.