Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1105.4063 · Physical Review A

Discriminating quantum-optical beam-splitter channels with number-diagonal signal states: Applications to quantum reading and target detection

Ranjith Nair

Published Sep 8, 2011• 75 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider the problem of distinguishing, with minimum probability of error, two optical beam-splitter channels with unequal complex-valued reflectivities using general quantum probe states entangled over $M$ signal and ${M}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ idler mode pairs of which the signal modes are bounced off the beam splitter while the idler modes are retained losslessly. We obtain a lower bound on the output state fidelity valid for any pure input state. We define number-diagonal signal (NDS) states to be input states whose density operator in the signal modes is diagonal in the multimode number basis. For such input states, we derive series formulas for the optimal error probability, the output state fidelity, and the Chernoff-type upper bounds on the error probability. For the special cases of quantum reading of a classical digital memory and target detection (for which the reflectivities are real valued), we show that for a given input signal photon probability distribution, the fidelity is minimized by the NDS states with that distribution and that for a given average total signal energy ${N}_{s}$, the fidelity is minimized by any multimode Fock state with ${N}_{s}$ total signal photons. For reading of an ideal memory, it is shown that Fock state inputs minimize the Chernoff bound. For target detection under high-loss conditions, a no-go result showing the lack of appreciable quantum advantage over coherent state transmitters is derived. A comparison of the error probability performance for quantum reading of number state and two-mode squeezed vacuum state (or EPR state) transmitters relative to coherent state transmitters is presented for various values of the reflectances. While the nonclassical states in general perform better than the coherent state, the quantitative performance gains differ depending on the values of the reflectances. The experimental outlook for realizing nonclassical gains from number state transmitters with current technology at moderate to high values of the reflectances is argued to be good.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.84.032312

Related papers

Quantum-optical sensing and target detection

Guo Yao Tham

This thesis presents three studies in quantum-enhanced sensing and target detection. The first study explores covert target detection using optical or microwave probes, establishing quantum-mechanical limits on the error probabilities of entanglement-assisted detection methods while maintaining the sender's covertness. It identifies the minimal energy required to preserve covertness and reduce error probabilities, compares two-mode squeezed vacuum probes and coherent states against these limits, and extends the analysis to discriminating thermal loss channels and non-adversarial quantum illumination. The second study focuses on phase-insensitive optical amplifiers, determining the quantum limit on the precision of gain estimation using multimode probes possibly entangled with ancillary systems. It finds that the average photon number and the number of input modes are interchangeable resources for achieving optimal gain sensing precision, contrasting classical probes with quantum probes and highlighting the advantages of the latter, even with single-photon inputs and inefficient photodetection. It also provides a closed-form expression for the energy-constrained Bures distance between two amplifier channels. The third study compares three probe states -- coherent state, two-mode squeezed vacuum (TMSV), and single-photon entangled state (SPES) -- in quantum-enhanced target detection, assessing their performance under signal energy constraints relevant to covert radar sensing. SPES is uniquely positioned as a practical probe due to its non-classical properties after thermal loss and ease of generation. Numerical analysis shows that at low signal energies, the error exponent of TMSV aligns with SPES, indicating comparable detection capabilities and that SPES surpasses the best classical state-the coherent state-in accuracy for certain signal strengths.

arXiv:2410.11372•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Quantum target detection using entangled photons

A. R. Usha Devi, A. K. Rajagopal

We investigate performances of pure continuous variable states in discriminating thermal and identity channels by comparing their $M$-copy error-probability bounds. This offers us a simplified mathematical analysis for quantum target detection with slightly modified features: the object---if it is present---perfectly reflects the signal beam irradiating it, while thermal noise photons are returned to the receiver in its absence. This model facilitates us to obtain analytic results on error-probability bounds, i.e., the quantum Chernoff bound and the lower bound constructed from the Bhattacharya bound on $M$-copy discrimination error probabilities of some important quantum states, like photon number states, $\text{N}$-photon maximally entangled (N00N) states, coherent states and the entangled photons obtained from spontaneous parametric down conversion (SPDC). Comparing the $M$-copy error-bounds, we identify that path-entangled states indeed offer enhanced sensitivity than the photon number state system, when average signal photon number is small compared to the thermal noise level. However, in the high signal-to-noise scenario, N00N states fail to be advantageous than the photon number states. Entangled SPDC photon pairs too outperform conventional coherent state system in the low signal-to-noise case. On the other hand, conventional coherent state system surpasses the performance sensitivity offered by entangled photon pair, when the signal intensity is much above that of thermal noise. We find an analogous performance regime in the lossy target detection (where the target is modeled as a weakly reflecting object) in a high signal-to-noise scenario.

arXiv:0903.3876•Physical Review A•Jun 19, 2009•38 citations

Quantum reading of digital memory with non-Gaussian entangled light

J. Prabhu Tej, A. R. Usha Devi, A. K. Rajagopal

It has been shown recently S. Pirandola [Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 090504 (2011)] that entangled light with Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen correlations retrieves information from digital memory better than any classical light. In identifying this, a model of digital memory with each cell consisting of a reflecting medium with two reflectivities (each memory cell encoding the binary numbers 0 or 1) is employed. The readout of binary memory essentially corresponds to discrimination of two bosonic attenuator channels characterized by different reflectivities. The model requires an entire mathematical paraphernalia of a continuous variable Gaussian setting for its analysis when arbitrary values of reflectivities $0\ensuremath{\le}{r}_{0},{r}_{1}\ensuremath{\le}1$ are considered. Here we restrict ourselves to a basic quantum readout mechanism with two different families of non-Gaussian entangled states of light, in which the binary channels to be discriminated are (i) ideal memory characterized by reflectivity ${r}_{1}=1$ (identity channel) and (ii) a thermal noise channel---where the signal light illuminating the memory location gets completely lost (${r}_{0}=0$) and only a white thermal noise hitting the upper side of the memory reaches the decoder. We compare the quantum reading efficiency of two families of non-Gaussian entangled light [($m,{m}^{\ensuremath{'}}$) family of path-entangled photon states and entangled state obtained by mixing a single photon with coherent light in a 50:50 beam splitter] with any classical source of light in this model. We identify that the classes of non-Gaussian entangled transmitters studied here offer significantly better reading performance than any classical transmitters of light in the regime of low signal intensity. We also demonstrate that the ($m,{m}^{\ensuremath{'}}$) family of entangled light exhibits better reading performance than NOON states.

arXiv:1210.0791•Physical Review A•May 8, 2013•22 citations

Symmetric M -ary phase discrimination using quantum-optical probe states

Ranjith Nair, Brent J. Yen, Saikat Guha +2 more

We present a theoretical study of minimum error probability discrimination, using quantum-optical probe states, of $M$ optical phase shifts situated symmetrically on the unit circle. We assume ideal lossless conditions and full freedom for implementing quantum measurements and for probe-state selection, subject only to a constraint on the average energy, i.e., photon number. In particular, the probe state is allowed to have any number of signal and ancillary modes and to be pure or mixed. Our results are based on a simple criterion that partitions the set of pure probe states into equivalence classes with the same error probability performance. Under an energy constraint, we find the explicit form of the state that minimizes the error probability. This state is an unentangled but nonclassical single-mode state. The error performance of the optimal state is compared with several standard states in quantum optics. We also show that discrimination with zero error is possible only beyond a threshold energy of $(M\ensuremath{-}1)/2$. For the $M=2$ case, we show that the optimum performance is readily demonstrable with current technology. While transmission loss and detector inefficiencies lead to a nonzero erasure probability, the error rate conditional on no erasure is shown to remain the same as the optimal lossless error rate.

arXiv:1206.0673•Physical Review A•Aug 7, 2012•28 citations

Gaussian-state quantum-illumination receivers for target detection

Saikat Guha, Baris I. Erkmen

The signal half of an entangled twin beam, generated using spontaneous parametric downconversion, interrogates a region of space that is suspected of containing a target and has high loss and high (entanglement-breaking) background noise. A joint measurement is performed on the returned light and the idler beam that was retained at the transmitter. An optimal quantum receiver, whose implementation is not yet known, was shown to achieve 6 dB gain in the error-probability exponent relative to that achieved with a single coherent-state (classical) laser transmitter and the optimum receiver. We present two structured optical receivers that achieve up to 3 dB gain in the error exponent over that attained with the classical sensor. These are designs of quantum-optical sensors for target detection, which can be readily implemented in a proof-of-concept experiment, that appreciably outperform the best classical sensor in the low-signal-brightness, high-loss, and high-noise operating regime.

arXiv:0911.0950•Physical Review A•Nov 10, 2009•266 citations

Realizable receivers for discriminating coherent and multicopy quantum states near the quantum limit

Ranjith Nair, Saikat Guha, Si-Hui Tan

We derive the quantum limit on the error probability exponent for discriminating any $M$ multimode coherent states of light and show that it is four times that of an ideal heterodyne receiver for the same signal set. We then propose a receiver that achieves the quantum limit using auxiliary coherent-state fields, beam splitters, and single-photon detectors. The performance of the receiver is compared to standard measurements for various imaging and communication tasks. A related receiver for discriminating arbitrary multicopy pure quantum states is shown to achieve the $M$-ary quantum Chernoff exponent and does so using only local operations and classical communication.

arXiv:1212.2048•Physical Review A•Mar 12, 2014•40 citations
We consider the problem of distinguishing, with minimum probability of error, two optical beam-splitter channels with unequal complex-valued reflectivities using general quantum probe states entangled over MMM signal and M\ensuremath′{M}^{\ensuremath{'}}M\ensuremath′ idler mode pairs of which the signal modes are bounced off the beam splitter while the idler modes are retained losslessly. We obtain a lower bound on the output state fidelity valid for any pure input state. We define number-diagonal signal (NDS) states to be input states whose density operator in the signal modes is diagonal in the multimode number basis. For such input states, we derive series formulas for the optimal error probability, the output state fidelity, and the Chernoff-type upper bounds on the error probability. For the special cases of quantum reading of a classical digital memory and target detection (for which the reflectivities are real valued), we show that for a given input signal photon probability distribution, the fidelity is minimized by the NDS states with that distribution and that for a given average total signal energy Ns{N}_{s}Ns​, the fidelity is minimized by any multimode Fock state with Ns{N}_{s}Ns​ total signal photons. For reading of an ideal memory, it is shown that Fock state inputs minimize the Chernoff bound. For target detection under high-loss conditions, a no-go result showing the lack of appreciable quantum advantage over coherent state transmitters is derived. A comparison of the error probability performance for quantum reading of number state and two-mode squeezed vacuum state (or EPR state) transmitters relative to coherent state transmitters is presented for various values of the reflectances. While the nonclassical states in general perform better than the coherent state, the quantitative performance gains differ depending on the values of the reflectances. The experimental outlook for realizing nonclassical gains from number state transmitters with current technology at moderate to high values of the reflectances is argued to be good.
This thesis presents three studies in quantum-enhanced sensing and target detection. The first study explores covert target detection using optical or microwave probes, establishing quantum-mechanical limits on the error probabilities of entanglement-assisted detection methods while maintaining the sender's covertness. It identifies the minimal energy required to preserve covertness and reduce error probabilities, compares two-mode squeezed vacuum probes and coherent states against these limits, and extends the analysis to discriminating thermal loss channels and non-adversarial quantum illumination. The second study focuses on phase-insensitive optical amplifiers, determining the quantum limit on the precision of gain estimation using multimode probes possibly entangled with ancillary systems. It finds that the average photon number and the number of input modes are interchangeable resources for achieving optimal gain sensing precision, contrasting classical probes with quantum probes and highlighting the advantages of the latter, even with single-photon inputs and inefficient photodetection. It also provides a closed-form expression for the energy-constrained Bures distance between two amplifier channels. The third study compares three probe states -- coherent state, two-mode squeezed vacuum (TMSV), and single-photon entangled state (SPES) -- in quantum-enhanced target detection, assessing their performance under signal energy constraints relevant to covert radar sensing. SPES is uniquely positioned as a practical probe due to its non-classical properties after thermal loss and ease of generation. Numerical analysis shows that at low signal energies, the error exponent of TMSV aligns with SPES, indicating comparable detection capabilities and that SPES surpasses the best classical state-the coherent state-in accuracy for certain signal strengths.
We investigate performances of pure continuous variable states in discriminating thermal and identity channels by comparing their MMM-copy error-probability bounds. This offers us a simplified mathematical analysis for quantum target detection with slightly modified features: the object---if it is present---perfectly reflects the signal beam irradiating it, while thermal noise photons are returned to the receiver in its absence. This model facilitates us to obtain analytic results on error-probability bounds, i.e., the quantum Chernoff bound and the lower bound constructed from the Bhattacharya bound on MMM-copy discrimination error probabilities of some important quantum states, like photon number states, N\text{N}N-photon maximally entangled (N00N) states, coherent states and the entangled photons obtained from spontaneous parametric down conversion (SPDC). Comparing the MMM-copy error-bounds, we identify that path-entangled states indeed offer enhanced sensitivity than the photon number state system, when average signal photon number is small compared to the thermal noise level. However, in the high signal-to-noise scenario, N00N states fail to be advantageous than the photon number states. Entangled SPDC photon pairs too outperform conventional coherent state system in the low signal-to-noise case. On the other hand, conventional coherent state system surpasses the performance sensitivity offered by entangled photon pair, when the signal intensity is much above that of thermal noise. We find an analogous performance regime in the lossy target detection (where the target is modeled as a weakly reflecting object) in a high signal-to-noise scenario.
It has been shown recently S. Pirandola [Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 090504 (2011)] that entangled light with Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen correlations retrieves information from digital memory better than any classical light. In identifying this, a model of digital memory with each cell consisting of a reflecting medium with two reflectivities (each memory cell encoding the binary numbers 0 or 1) is employed. The readout of binary memory essentially corresponds to discrimination of two bosonic attenuator channels characterized by different reflectivities. The model requires an entire mathematical paraphernalia of a continuous variable Gaussian setting for its analysis when arbitrary values of reflectivities $0\ensuremath{\le}{r}_{0},{r}_{1}\ensuremath{\le}1$ are considered. Here we restrict ourselves to a basic quantum readout mechanism with two different families of non-Gaussian entangled states of light, in which the binary channels to be discriminated are (i) ideal memory characterized by reflectivity r1=1{r}_{1}=1r1​=1 (identity channel) and (ii) a thermal noise channel---where the signal light illuminating the memory location gets completely lost (r0=0{r}_{0}=0r0​=0) and only a white thermal noise hitting the upper side of the memory reaches the decoder. We compare the quantum reading efficiency of two families of non-Gaussian entangled light [($m,{m}^{\ensuremath{'}}$) family of path-entangled photon states and entangled state obtained by mixing a single photon with coherent light in a 50:50 beam splitter] with any classical source of light in this model. We identify that the classes of non-Gaussian entangled transmitters studied here offer significantly better reading performance than any classical transmitters of light in the regime of low signal intensity. We also demonstrate that the ($m,{m}^{\ensuremath{'}}$) family of entangled light exhibits better reading performance than NOON states.
We present a theoretical study of minimum error probability discrimination, using quantum-optical probe states, of MMM optical phase shifts situated symmetrically on the unit circle. We assume ideal lossless conditions and full freedom for implementing quantum measurements and for probe-state selection, subject only to a constraint on the average energy, i.e., photon number. In particular, the probe state is allowed to have any number of signal and ancillary modes and to be pure or mixed. Our results are based on a simple criterion that partitions the set of pure probe states into equivalence classes with the same error probability performance. Under an energy constraint, we find the explicit form of the state that minimizes the error probability. This state is an unentangled but nonclassical single-mode state. The error performance of the optimal state is compared with several standard states in quantum optics. We also show that discrimination with zero error is possible only beyond a threshold energy of $(M\ensuremath{-}1)/2$. For the M=2M=2M=2 case, we show that the optimum performance is readily demonstrable with current technology. While transmission loss and detector inefficiencies lead to a nonzero erasure probability, the error rate conditional on no erasure is shown to remain the same as the optimal lossless error rate.
The signal half of an entangled twin beam, generated using spontaneous parametric downconversion, interrogates a region of space that is suspected of containing a target and has high loss and high (entanglement-breaking) background noise. A joint measurement is performed on the returned light and the idler beam that was retained at the transmitter. An optimal quantum receiver, whose implementation is not yet known, was shown to achieve 6 dB gain in the error-probability exponent relative to that achieved with a single coherent-state (classical) laser transmitter and the optimum receiver. We present two structured optical receivers that achieve up to 3 dB gain in the error exponent over that attained with the classical sensor. These are designs of quantum-optical sensors for target detection, which can be readily implemented in a proof-of-concept experiment, that appreciably outperform the best classical sensor in the low-signal-brightness, high-loss, and high-noise operating regime.
We derive the quantum limit on the error probability exponent for discriminating any MMM multimode coherent states of light and show that it is four times that of an ideal heterodyne receiver for the same signal set. We then propose a receiver that achieves the quantum limit using auxiliary coherent-state fields, beam splitters, and single-photon detectors. The performance of the receiver is compared to standard measurements for various imaging and communication tasks. A related receiver for discriminating arbitrary multicopy pure quantum states is shown to achieve the MMM-ary quantum Chernoff exponent and does so using only local operations and classical communication.