Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0911.4856 · Europhysics Letters (EPL)

Entanglement mean-field theory and the Curie-Weiss law

Aditi Sen, Ujjwal Sen

Published Jul 1, 2012• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The mean-field theory, in its different hues, forms a useful tool for investigating single-body properties, like magnetization and susceptibility, of many-body systems. We propose an "entanglement mean-field theory", which transforms a many-body system into a two-body one, while retaining footprints of the many-body parent, using which it is possible to examine its two-body properties, and predict temperature-driven as well as quantum fluctuation-driven critical phenomena, by considering two-body self-consistency equations in contrast to single-body ones in mean-field–like theories. Compared to mean-field theory, the proposed one, with little to no extra complicacy, makes better predictions for the critical points, as well as for the qualitative and quantitative behavior of single- and two-body physical quantities. In particular, the predictions of the proposed theory are in much better conformity with the Curie-Weiss law for magnetization. Also, the proposed theory predicts an order by disorder for a correlation function in the random-field transverse quantum Ising model.

DOI
10.1209/0295-5075/99/20011

Related papers

Simulating Quantum Dynamics with Entanglement Mean Field Theory

Aditi Sen, Ujjwal Sen

Exactly solvable many-body systems are few and far between, and the utility of approximate methods cannot be overestimated. Entanglement mean field theory is an approximate method to handle such systems. While mean field theories reduce the many-body system to an effective single-body one, entanglement mean field theory reduces it to a two-body system. And in contrast to mean field theories where the self-consistency equations are in terms of single-site physical parameters, those in entanglement mean field theory are in terms of both single- and two-site parameters. Hitherto, the theory has been applied to predict properties of the static states, like ground and thermal states, of many-body systems. Here we give a method to employ it to predict properties of time-evolved states. The predictions are then compared with known results of paradigmatic spin Hamiltonians.

arXiv:1105.2382•Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 1, 2011•2 citations

Quantum correlated cluster mean-field theory applied to the transverse Ising model

Fábio M. Zimmer, M. Schmidt, Jonas Maziero

Mean-field theory (MFT) is one of the main available tools for analytical calculations entailed in investigations regarding many-body systems. Recently, there has been a surge of interest in ameliorating this kind of method, mainly with the aim of incorporating geometric and correlation properties of these systems. The correlated cluster MFT (CCMFT) is an improvement that succeeded quite well in doing that for classical spin systems. Nevertheless, even the CCMFT presents some deficiencies when applied to quantum systems. In this article, we address this issue by proposing the quantum CCMFT (QCCMFT), which, in contrast to its former approach, uses general quantum states in its self-consistent mean-field equations. We apply the introduced QCCMFT to the transverse Ising model in honeycomb, square, and simple cubic lattices and obtain fairly good results both for the Curie temperature of thermal phase transition and for the critical field of quantum phase transition. Actually, our results match those obtained via exact solutions, series expansions or Monte Carlo simulations.

arXiv:1604.03486•Physical review. E•Jun 13, 2016•10 citations

Mean field theory and renormalization

David L. Sidebottom

Introduction Our discussion of critical phenomena surrounding a second-order phase transition has thus far focused only on qualitative features. We have now examined three systems, fluids, magnets and random percolation, each of which displays an abruptly sharp transition from a less ordered to a more ordered phase as the respective transition point is encountered. Each shows a similar pattern of developing structure just in advance of the critical point. Fluctuations in the respective order parameter display a self-similar structure that is limited only by a single relevant length scale, the correlation length ξ, which diverges on approach to the transition point. For fluids and magnets, this structure arises from inherent fluctuations that are amplified by either a diverging compressibility or susceptibility, respectively. In this chapter, we explore more quantitative, theoretical approaches taken to understand the features of second-order phase transitions. The simplest of these are the mean field theories , in which the pairwise interaction (needed to produce a phase transition) is introduced in the form of an average field. In this approach, the effects of the growing fluctuations of the order parameter near the critical point are ignored. Although the mean field approach does meet many of the requirements and does predict divergences of certain quantities near the transition, the critical exponents predicted by the theory do not match those seen experimentally. Obtaining correct exponents requires a more advanced approach involving renormalization techniques that exploit the self-similar structure of the fluctuations near the critical point and allow all of the various critical exponents to be inter-related, such that knowledge of any two yields all the others.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 5, 2012•0 citations

Critical phenomena: General considerations. Mean-field theory (MFT)

Jean Zinn‐Justin

Abstract This chapter is devoted to a brief review of general properties of phase transitions in macroscopic physics and, in particular in lattice models. Some of these lattice models actually appear as lattice regularizations of Euclidean (imaginary time) quantum physics theory (QFT). Most of the transitions considered in this work have the following character: spins on the lattice, or macroscopic particles in the continuum, interact through short-range forces, assumed, for simplicity, to decay exponentially. For simple systems, it is possible to find a local observable, called order parameter, whose expectation values depend on the phase in the several phase region, for example, the spin in ferromagnetic systems. In the disordered phase, the connected two-point function decreases exponentially at large distance, at a rate characterized by the correlation length (the inverse of the smallest physical mass in particle physics). In continuous transitions, the correlation length diverges at the critical temperature. Within the mean-field approximation (consistent with Landau's theory of critical phenomena), it can be shown that the singular behaviour of thermodynamic quantities at the critical temperature is universal. These properties can also be reproduced by calculating correlation functions with a perturbed Gaussian measure. It is then shown that the leading corrections to the mean-field approximation, in Ising-like systems, diverge at the critical temperature for dimensions smaller than or equal to $4$.

•Apr 15, 2021•0 citations

Quantum mean-field approximation for lattice quantum models: Truncating quantum correlations and retaining classical ones

Daniele Malpetti, Tommaso Roscilde

The mean-field approximation is at the heart of our understanding of complex systems, despite its fundamental limitation of completely neglecting correlations between the elementary constituents. In a recent work [Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 130401 (2016)], we have shown that in quantum many-body systems at finite temperature, two-point correlations can be formally separated into a thermal part and a quantum part and that quantum correlations are generically found to decay exponentially at finite temperature, with a characteristic, temperature-dependent quantum coherence length. The existence of these two different forms of correlation in quantum many-body systems suggests the possibility of formulating an approximation, which affects quantum correlations only, without preventing the correct description of classical fluctuations at all length scales. Focusing on lattice boson and quantum Ising models, we make use of the path-integral formulation of quantum statistical mechanics to introduce such an approximation, which we dub quantum mean-field (QMF) approach, and which can be readily generalized to a cluster form (cluster QMF or cQMF). The cQMF approximation reduces to cluster mean-field theory at $T=0$, while at any finite temperature it produces a family of systematically improved, semi-classical approximations to the quantum statistical mechanics of the lattice theory at hand. Contrary to standard MF approximations, the correct nature of thermal critical phenomena is captured by any cluster size. In the two exemplary cases of the two-dimensional quantum Ising model and of two-dimensional quantum rotors, we study systematically the convergence of the cQMF approximation towards the exact result, and show that the convergence is typically linear or sublinear in the boundary-to-bulk ratio of the clusters as $T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$, while it becomes faster than linear as $T$ grows. These results pave the way towards the development of semiclassical numerical approaches based on an approximate, yet systematically improved account of quantum correlations.

arXiv:1608.01205•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 6, 2017•4 citations

Quantum criticality in the infinite-range transverse field Ising model

Nicholas J. Curro, Kaeshav Danesh, Rajiv Ranjan Singh

We study quantum criticality in the infinite range transverse-field Ising model. We find subtle differences with respect to the well-known single-site mean-field theory, especially in terms of gap, entanglement and quantum criticality. The calculations are based on numerical diagonalization of Hamiltonians with up to a few thousand spins. This is made possible by the enhanced symmetries of the model, which divide the Hamiltonian into many block-diagonal sectors. The finite temperature phase diagram and the characteristic jump in heat capacity closely resemble the behavior in mean-field theory. However, unlike mean-field theory where excitations are always gapped, the excitation gap in the infinite range model goes to zero from both the paramagnetic side and from the ferromagnetic side on approach to the quantum critical point. Also, contrary to mean-field theory, at the quantum critical point the quantum Fisher information becomes large, implying long-range multipartite entanglement. We find that the main role of temperature is to shift statistical weights from one conserved sector to another. However, low energy excitations in each sector arise only near the quantum critical point implying that low energy quantum fluctuations can arise only in the vicinity of the quantum critical field where they can persist up to temperatures of order the exchange constant.

arXiv:2408.02789•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 7, 2024•2 citations
The mean-field theory, in its different hues, forms a useful tool for investigating single-body properties, like magnetization and susceptibility, of many-body systems. We propose an "entanglement mean-field theory", which transforms a many-body system into a two-body one, while retaining footprints of the many-body parent, using which it is possible to examine its two-body properties, and predict temperature-driven as well as quantum fluctuation-driven critical phenomena, by considering two-body self-consistency equations in contrast to single-body ones in mean-field–like theories. Compared to mean-field theory, the proposed one, with little to no extra complicacy, makes better predictions for the critical points, as well as for the qualitative and quantitative behavior of single- and two-body physical quantities. In particular, the predictions of the proposed theory are in much better conformity with the Curie-Weiss law for magnetization. Also, the proposed theory predicts an order by disorder for a correlation function in the random-field transverse quantum Ising model.
Exactly solvable many-body systems are few and far between, and the utility of approximate methods cannot be overestimated. Entanglement mean field theory is an approximate method to handle such systems. While mean field theories reduce the many-body system to an effective single-body one, entanglement mean field theory reduces it to a two-body system. And in contrast to mean field theories where the self-consistency equations are in terms of single-site physical parameters, those in entanglement mean field theory are in terms of both single- and two-site parameters. Hitherto, the theory has been applied to predict properties of the static states, like ground and thermal states, of many-body systems. Here we give a method to employ it to predict properties of time-evolved states. The predictions are then compared with known results of paradigmatic spin Hamiltonians.
Mean-field theory (MFT) is one of the main available tools for analytical calculations entailed in investigations regarding many-body systems. Recently, there has been a surge of interest in ameliorating this kind of method, mainly with the aim of incorporating geometric and correlation properties of these systems. The correlated cluster MFT (CCMFT) is an improvement that succeeded quite well in doing that for classical spin systems. Nevertheless, even the CCMFT presents some deficiencies when applied to quantum systems. In this article, we address this issue by proposing the quantum CCMFT (QCCMFT), which, in contrast to its former approach, uses general quantum states in its self-consistent mean-field equations. We apply the introduced QCCMFT to the transverse Ising model in honeycomb, square, and simple cubic lattices and obtain fairly good results both for the Curie temperature of thermal phase transition and for the critical field of quantum phase transition. Actually, our results match those obtained via exact solutions, series expansions or Monte Carlo simulations.
Introduction Our discussion of critical phenomena surrounding a second-order phase transition has thus far focused only on qualitative features. We have now examined three systems, fluids, magnets and random percolation, each of which displays an abruptly sharp transition from a less ordered to a more ordered phase as the respective transition point is encountered. Each shows a similar pattern of developing structure just in advance of the critical point. Fluctuations in the respective order parameter display a self-similar structure that is limited only by a single relevant length scale, the correlation length ξ, which diverges on approach to the transition point. For fluids and magnets, this structure arises from inherent fluctuations that are amplified by either a diverging compressibility or susceptibility, respectively. In this chapter, we explore more quantitative, theoretical approaches taken to understand the features of second-order phase transitions. The simplest of these are the mean field theories , in which the pairwise interaction (needed to produce a phase transition) is introduced in the form of an average field. In this approach, the effects of the growing fluctuations of the order parameter near the critical point are ignored. Although the mean field approach does meet many of the requirements and does predict divergences of certain quantities near the transition, the critical exponents predicted by the theory do not match those seen experimentally. Obtaining correct exponents requires a more advanced approach involving renormalization techniques that exploit the self-similar structure of the fluctuations near the critical point and allow all of the various critical exponents to be inter-related, such that knowledge of any two yields all the others.
Abstract This chapter is devoted to a brief review of general properties of phase transitions in macroscopic physics and, in particular in lattice models. Some of these lattice models actually appear as lattice regularizations of Euclidean (imaginary time) quantum physics theory (QFT). Most of the transitions considered in this work have the following character: spins on the lattice, or macroscopic particles in the continuum, interact through short-range forces, assumed, for simplicity, to decay exponentially. For simple systems, it is possible to find a local observable, called order parameter, whose expectation values depend on the phase in the several phase region, for example, the spin in ferromagnetic systems. In the disordered phase, the connected two-point function decreases exponentially at large distance, at a rate characterized by the correlation length (the inverse of the smallest physical mass in particle physics). In continuous transitions, the correlation length diverges at the critical temperature. Within the mean-field approximation (consistent with Landau's theory of critical phenomena), it can be shown that the singular behaviour of thermodynamic quantities at the critical temperature is universal. These properties can also be reproduced by calculating correlation functions with a perturbed Gaussian measure. It is then shown that the leading corrections to the mean-field approximation, in Ising-like systems, diverge at the critical temperature for dimensions smaller than or equal to 444.
The mean-field approximation is at the heart of our understanding of complex systems, despite its fundamental limitation of completely neglecting correlations between the elementary constituents. In a recent work [Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 130401 (2016)], we have shown that in quantum many-body systems at finite temperature, two-point correlations can be formally separated into a thermal part and a quantum part and that quantum correlations are generically found to decay exponentially at finite temperature, with a characteristic, temperature-dependent quantum coherence length. The existence of these two different forms of correlation in quantum many-body systems suggests the possibility of formulating an approximation, which affects quantum correlations only, without preventing the correct description of classical fluctuations at all length scales. Focusing on lattice boson and quantum Ising models, we make use of the path-integral formulation of quantum statistical mechanics to introduce such an approximation, which we dub quantum mean-field (QMF) approach, and which can be readily generalized to a cluster form (cluster QMF or cQMF). The cQMF approximation reduces to cluster mean-field theory at T=0T=0T=0, while at any finite temperature it produces a family of systematically improved, semi-classical approximations to the quantum statistical mechanics of the lattice theory at hand. Contrary to standard MF approximations, the correct nature of thermal critical phenomena is captured by any cluster size. In the two exemplary cases of the two-dimensional quantum Ising model and of two-dimensional quantum rotors, we study systematically the convergence of the cQMF approximation towards the exact result, and show that the convergence is typically linear or sublinear in the boundary-to-bulk ratio of the clusters as $T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$, while it becomes faster than linear as TTT grows. These results pave the way towards the development of semiclassical numerical approaches based on an approximate, yet systematically improved account of quantum correlations.
We study quantum criticality in the infinite range transverse-field Ising model. We find subtle differences with respect to the well-known single-site mean-field theory, especially in terms of gap, entanglement and quantum criticality. The calculations are based on numerical diagonalization of Hamiltonians with up to a few thousand spins. This is made possible by the enhanced symmetries of the model, which divide the Hamiltonian into many block-diagonal sectors. The finite temperature phase diagram and the characteristic jump in heat capacity closely resemble the behavior in mean-field theory. However, unlike mean-field theory where excitations are always gapped, the excitation gap in the infinite range model goes to zero from both the paramagnetic side and from the ferromagnetic side on approach to the quantum critical point. Also, contrary to mean-field theory, at the quantum critical point the quantum Fisher information becomes large, implying long-range multipartite entanglement. We find that the main role of temperature is to shift statistical weights from one conserved sector to another. However, low energy excitations in each sector arise only near the quantum critical point implying that low energy quantum fluctuations can arise only in the vicinity of the quantum critical field where they can persist up to temperatures of order the exchange constant.