Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0811.2430

What particles that never met "know" of one another?

Sofia Wechsler

Published Nov 16, 2008• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

An experiment proposed by Yurke and Stoler, and similar to that realized experimentally by Sciarrino et al., is analyzed. In Sciarrino's realization, identical photons from a degenerated down-conversion pair are used, i.e. the photons met in the past. In the experiment analyzed here the particles are also identical, but from different sources. As long as one can tell from which source came each particle, the joint wave function remains factorizable. However, a configuration is created in which one cannot tell anymore which particle came from which source. As a result, the wave function becomes non-factorizable, symmetrical (for bosons) or antisymmetrical (for fermions). In part of the cases the situation is even more surprising: the particles never meet, s.t. the symmetry (antisymmetry) is produced at-a-distance without the particles having had the possibility to interact in any way.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0811.2430

Related papers

What particles that never met

Sofia Wechsler

An experiment proposed by Yurke and Stoler, and similar to that realized experimentally by Sciarrino et al., is analyzed. In Sciarrino's realization, identical photons from a degenerated down-conversion pair are used, i.e. the photons met in the past. In the experiment analyzed here the particles are also identical, but from different sources. As long as one can tell from which source came each particle, the joint wave function remains factorizable. However, a configuration is created in which one cannot tell anymore which particle came from which source. As a result, the wave function becomes non-factorizable, symmetrical (for bosons) or antisymmetrical (for fermions). In part of the cases the situation is even more surprising: the particles never meet, s.t. the symmetry (antisymmetry) is produced at-a-distance without the particles having had the possibility to interact in any way.

•Nov 16, 2008•0 citations

Identical Particles

S. Rajasekar, R. Velusamy

In quantum mechanics the situation is different because the uncertainty principle does not allow us to know the initial positions and momenta of the particles with desired accuracy. The individual particle is described by a wave packet. Since the wave packet is localized and spreading with time, it is impossible to distinguish two identical particles as their wave functions always overlap at any point in space. Quantum theory describes any object at energies below its excitation threshold with four degrees of freedom. The wave functions of all the states of a given system of identical particles must have the same symmetry; otherwise, the wave function of a state formally a superposition of states of different symmetry would be neither symmetrical nor antisymmetrical. Hence, for a system of identical particles, at high energies and low concentration, probable number of particles per quantum state will be very small. Wave functions of the particles are well separated.

CRC Press eBooks•Sep 29, 2022•0 citations

Symmetrizing the symmetrization postulate

Michael York

Reasonable requirements of (a) physical invariance under particle permutation and (b) physical completeness of state descriptions [1], enable us to deduce a Symmetric Permutation Rule(SPR): that by taking care with our state descriptions, it is always possible to construct state vectors (or wave functions) that are purely symmetric under pure permutation for all particles, regardless of type distinguishability or spin. The conventional exchange antisymmetry for two identical half-integer spin particles is shown to be due to a subtle interdependence in the individual state descriptions arising from an inherent geometrical asymmetry. For three or more such particles, however, antisymmetrization of the state vector for all pairs simultaneously is shown to be impossible and the SPR makes observably different predictions, although the usual pairwise exclusion rules are maintained. The usual caveat of fermion antisymmetrization—that composite integer spin particles (with fermionic constituents) behave only approximately like bosons—is no longer necessary.

arXiv:quant-ph/0006101•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2000•5 citations

Symmetry Properties and the Identity of Similar Particles

Enós E. Witmer, John P. Vinti

It is demonstrated that in a system of $N$ similar particles, the permissible wave functions are either symmetrical or antisymmetrical with respect to interchanges of the particles, if the following principles are assumed to be valid: (1) The interchange of two like particles produces no change in any measurable property of the system. In particular, if $\ensuremath{\psi}$ is to be a permissible wave function, $\ensuremath{\psi}\overline{\ensuremath{\psi}}$ must be unaltered by such an interchange. (2) All the wave functions obtained from a given permissible wave function by permuting the similar particles are also permissible wave functions for the same eigenvalue.

Physical Review•Apr 1, 1935•3 citations

Symmetrizing The Symmetrization Postulate

Michael York

Abstract. Reasonable requirements of (a) physical invariance under particle permutation and (b) physical completeness of state descriptions [1], enable us to deduce a Symmetric Permutation Rule(SPR): that by taking care with our state descriptions, it is always possible to construct state vectors (or wave functions) that are purely symmetric under pure permutation for all particles, regardless of type distinguishability or spin. The conventional exchange antisymmetry for two identical half-integer spin particles is shown to be due to a subtle interdependence in the individual state descriptions arising from an inherent geometrical asymmetry. For three or more such particles, however, antisymmetrization of the state vector for all pairs simultaneously is shown to be impossible and the SPR makes observably different predictions, although the usual pairwise exclusion rules are maintained. The usual caveat of fermion antisymmetrization – that composite integer spin particles (with fermionic consitituents) behave only approximately like bosons – is no longer necessary. I TERMINOLOGY

•Jun 22, 2000•5 citations

Interference Phenomena for Particles Obeying Bose or Fermi Statistics

M. Moshińsky

IT is well known from experiment, as well as from classical theory, that strictly monochromatic light waves originating from different sources do interfere.' An example in which the waves are nearly monochromatic is found in the case of radio waves, and it is known that radio waves from two stations that have the same frequency show an interference effect. We may describe the phenomenon quantum mechanically if we represent the light quanta emitted by both sources by waves in Schroedinger configuration space. So long as we consider the quanta emitted by one source as different from those emitted by the other, the total wave function will be the product of the wave functions corresponding to the quanta emanating from both sources, and there will be no interference effect. In the present paper, we will see how things are changed when we symmetrize or antisymmetrize the wave function, i.e. assume either Bose or Fermi statistics for the particles. In the simple quantum mechanical picture that we will use here, we will assume a definite number of photons coming out from each source, and this implies that the phase relations will be undetermined.2 As a result, even the symmetrized wave functions must be expected to give, at any point in space, the same density of quanta that classical theory determines, when the intensity is averaged over the phase differences between the two sources. This implies that no interference is observed between the waves from the two sources. If we want to look for an interference effect when dealing with a quantum picture in which we have a definite number of photons, we must look for a phenomenon whose classical description should be independent of the phase. We shall make use of the fact that, in classical theory,

•Feb 27, 1950•1 citation
An experiment proposed by Yurke and Stoler, and similar to that realized experimentally by Sciarrino et al., is analyzed. In Sciarrino's realization, identical photons from a degenerated down-conversion pair are used, i.e. the photons met in the past. In the experiment analyzed here the particles are also identical, but from different sources. As long as one can tell from which source came each particle, the joint wave function remains factorizable. However, a configuration is created in which one cannot tell anymore which particle came from which source. As a result, the wave function becomes non-factorizable, symmetrical (for bosons) or antisymmetrical (for fermions). In part of the cases the situation is even more surprising: the particles never meet, s.t. the symmetry (antisymmetry) is produced at-a-distance without the particles having had the possibility to interact in any way.
An experiment proposed by Yurke and Stoler, and similar to that realized experimentally by Sciarrino et al., is analyzed. In Sciarrino's realization, identical photons from a degenerated down-conversion pair are used, i.e. the photons met in the past. In the experiment analyzed here the particles are also identical, but from different sources. As long as one can tell from which source came each particle, the joint wave function remains factorizable. However, a configuration is created in which one cannot tell anymore which particle came from which source. As a result, the wave function becomes non-factorizable, symmetrical (for bosons) or antisymmetrical (for fermions). In part of the cases the situation is even more surprising: the particles never meet, s.t. the symmetry (antisymmetry) is produced at-a-distance without the particles having had the possibility to interact in any way.
In quantum mechanics the situation is different because the uncertainty principle does not allow us to know the initial positions and momenta of the particles with desired accuracy. The individual particle is described by a wave packet. Since the wave packet is localized and spreading with time, it is impossible to distinguish two identical particles as their wave functions always overlap at any point in space. Quantum theory describes any object at energies below its excitation threshold with four degrees of freedom. The wave functions of all the states of a given system of identical particles must have the same symmetry; otherwise, the wave function of a state formally a superposition of states of different symmetry would be neither symmetrical nor antisymmetrical. Hence, for a system of identical particles, at high energies and low concentration, probable number of particles per quantum state will be very small. Wave functions of the particles are well separated.
Reasonable requirements of (a) physical invariance under particle permutation and (b) physical completeness of state descriptions [1], enable us to deduce a Symmetric Permutation Rule(SPR): that by taking care with our state descriptions, it is always possible to construct state vectors (or wave functions) that are purely symmetric under pure permutation for all particles, regardless of type distinguishability or spin. The conventional exchange antisymmetry for two identical half-integer spin particles is shown to be due to a subtle interdependence in the individual state descriptions arising from an inherent geometrical asymmetry. For three or more such particles, however, antisymmetrization of the state vector for all pairs simultaneously is shown to be impossible and the SPR makes observably different predictions, although the usual pairwise exclusion rules are maintained. The usual caveat of fermion antisymmetrization—that composite integer spin particles (with fermionic constituents) behave only approximately like bosons—is no longer necessary.
It is demonstrated that in a system of NNN similar particles, the permissible wave functions are either symmetrical or antisymmetrical with respect to interchanges of the particles, if the following principles are assumed to be valid: (1) The interchange of two like particles produces no change in any measurable property of the system. In particular, if $\ensuremath{\psi}$ is to be a permissible wave function, $\ensuremath{\psi}\overline{\ensuremath{\psi}}$ must be unaltered by such an interchange. (2) All the wave functions obtained from a given permissible wave function by permuting the similar particles are also permissible wave functions for the same eigenvalue.
Abstract. Reasonable requirements of (a) physical invariance under particle permutation and (b) physical completeness of state descriptions [1], enable us to deduce a Symmetric Permutation Rule(SPR): that by taking care with our state descriptions, it is always possible to construct state vectors (or wave functions) that are purely symmetric under pure permutation for all particles, regardless of type distinguishability or spin. The conventional exchange antisymmetry for two identical half-integer spin particles is shown to be due to a subtle interdependence in the individual state descriptions arising from an inherent geometrical asymmetry. For three or more such particles, however, antisymmetrization of the state vector for all pairs simultaneously is shown to be impossible and the SPR makes observably different predictions, although the usual pairwise exclusion rules are maintained. The usual caveat of fermion antisymmetrization – that composite integer spin particles (with fermionic consitituents) behave only approximately like bosons – is no longer necessary. I TERMINOLOGY
IT is well known from experiment, as well as from classical theory, that strictly monochromatic light waves originating from different sources do interfere.' An example in which the waves are nearly monochromatic is found in the case of radio waves, and it is known that radio waves from two stations that have the same frequency show an interference effect. We may describe the phenomenon quantum mechanically if we represent the light quanta emitted by both sources by waves in Schroedinger configuration space. So long as we consider the quanta emitted by one source as different from those emitted by the other, the total wave function will be the product of the wave functions corresponding to the quanta emanating from both sources, and there will be no interference effect. In the present paper, we will see how things are changed when we symmetrize or antisymmetrize the wave function, i.e. assume either Bose or Fermi statistics for the particles. In the simple quantum mechanical picture that we will use here, we will assume a definite number of photons coming out from each source, and this implies that the phase relations will be undetermined.2 As a result, even the symmetrized wave functions must be expected to give, at any point in space, the same density of quanta that classical theory determines, when the intensity is averaged over the phase differences between the two sources. This implies that no interference is observed between the waves from the two sources. If we want to look for an interference effect when dealing with a quantum picture in which we have a definite number of photons, we must look for a phenomenon whose classical description should be independent of the phase. We shall make use of the fact that, in classical theory,