Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9810080 · Physical Review Letters

Violation of Bell's Inequality under Strict Einstein Locality Conditions

Gregor Weihs, Thomas D. Jennewein, Christoph Simon, Harald Weinfurter, Anton Zeilinger

Published Dec 7, 1998• 1,675 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We observe strong violation of Bell's inequality in an Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-type experiment with independent observers. Our experiment definitely implements the ideas behind the well-known work by Aspect et al. We for the first time fully enforce the condition of locality, a central assumption in the derivation of Bell's theorem. The necessary spacelike separation of the observations is achieved by sufficient physical distance between the measurement stations, by ultrafast and random setting of the analyzers, and by completely independent data registration.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.81.5039

Related papers

Non-Locality and Quantum Theory: New Experimental Evidence

Luigi Accardi, Massimo Regoli

Starting from the late 60’s many experiments have been performed to verify the violation Bell’s inequality by Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) type correlations. The idea of these experiments being that: (i) Bell’s inequality is a consequence of locality, hence its experimental violation is an indication of non locality; (ii) this violation is a typical quantum phenomenon because any classical system making local choices (either deterministic or random) will produce correlations satisfying this inequality. Both statements (i) and (ii) have been criticized by quantum probability on theoretical grounds (not discussed in the present paper) and the experiment discussed below has been devised to support these theoretical arguments. We emphasize that the goal of our experiment is not to reproduce classically the EPR correlations but to prove that there exist perfectly local classical dynamical systems violating Bell’s inequality. The conclusions of the present experiment are: no contradiction between quantum theory and locality can be deduced from the violation of Bell’s inequality. The Copenhagen interpretation of quantum theory becomes quite reasonable and not metaphyisic if interpreted at the light of the chameleon effect. One can realize quantum entanglement by classical computers. In section (7) we prove that our experiment also provides a classical analogue of the type of logical (i.e. independent of statistics) incompatibilities pointed out by Greenberger, Home and Zeilinger. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Kluwer Academic Publishers eBooks•Feb 24, 2006•14 citations

Non-locality and quantum theory: new experimental evidence

Luigi Accardi, Massimo Regoli

Starting from the late 60's many experiments have been performed to verify the violation Bell's inequality by Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) type correlations. The idea of these experiments being that: (i) Bell's inequality is a consequence of locality, hence its experimental violation is an indication of non locality; (ii) this violation is a typical quantum phenomenon because any classical system making local choices (either deterministic or random) will produce correlations satisfying this inequality. Both statements (i) and (ii) have been criticized by quantum probability on theoretical grounds (not discussed in the present paper) and the experiment discussed below has been devised to support these theoretical arguments. We emphasize that the goal of our experiment is not to reproduce classically the EPR correlations but to prove that there exist perfectly local classical dynamical systems violating Bell's inequality.

arXiv:quant-ph/0007019•Jul 7, 2000•14 citations

The EPR paradox, Bell’s inequality, and the question of locality

Guy Blaylock

Most physicists agree that the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen–Bell paradox exemplifies much of the strange behavior of quantum mechanics, but argument persists about what assumptions underlie the paradox. To clarify what the debate is about, we employ a simple and well-known thought experiment involving two correlated photons to help us focus on the logical assumptions needed to construct the EPR and Bell arguments. The view presented in this paper is that the minimal assumptions behind Bell’s inequality are locality and counterfactual definiteness but not scientific realism, determinism, or hidden variables as are often suggested. We further examine the resulting constraints on physical theory with an illustration from the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics—an interpretation that we argue is deterministic, local, and realist but that nonetheless violates the Bell inequality.

arXiv:0902.3827•American Journal of Physics•Dec 14, 2009•61 citations

BELL NONLOCALITY UNDER STRICT EINSTEIN LOCALITY

Denivaldo Silva, Vidamor Cabannas

This article develops an expanded critical–propositional analysis of Gregor Weihs, Thomas Jennewein, Christoph Simon, Harald Weinfurter, and Anton Zeilinger’s 1998 experiment, “Violation of Bell’s Inequality under Strict Einstein Locality Conditions,” in systematic dialogue with the Theory of Objectivity (TO) formulated by Vidamor Cabannas and Denivaldo Silva. Weihs et al. implemented a Bell-type experiment with polarization-entangled photons, spatially separated measurement stations, rapidly and independently selected analyzer settings, and independent time-tagged registration. The experiment was designed to impose strict spacelike separation between the relevant measurement processes and reported a CHSH value of approximately S = 2.73 ± 0.02, substantially exceeding the Bell-local bound S ≤ 2. The measurement stations were separated by approximately 400 m, whereas the relevant interval between local setting selection and detection was much shorter than the approximately 1.3 µs light-travel time between the stations (Weihs et al. 1998). The purpose of the present study is not to reinterpret the violation of Bell’s inequality as a direct experimental proof of the Theory of Objectivity. Such an inference would exceed what the experiment establishes. Instead, the article distinguishes three epistemic levels: empirical result, theoretical interpretation, and modal-ontological proposition. This distinction is fundamental because the TO presents its Absolute Truths as modal necessities, whereas Bell experiments are contingent empirical investi- gations conducted under explicit mathematical, physical, and statistical assumptions. Within this disciplined framework, the strongest dialogue between Weihs et al. and the TO is found in the Fifth Absolute Truth, according to which the logical existence of an element requires observation or frequency relation with at least two other elements, while “observation” does not mean human consciousness. The Bell experiment is intrinsically relational: the relevant quantity is constructed from joint statistics obtained at physically independent stations, and no human observer is required to produce local physical registration. A second important dialogue arises with the Seventh Absolute Truth and the TO concept of the transcendent element as knowledge or information produced in atomic relations and treated within the theory as equivalent to atomic radiation. The experiment presents a rigorous chain connecting radiation, polarization, interaction, registration, correlation, and recoverable information. Nevertheless, quantum mechanics supports the proposition that radiation can instantiate information-bearing degrees of freedom; this does not by itself demonstrate the stronger ontological identity between radiation and information proposed by the TO. The Fourth and Sixth Absolute Truths also enter the dialogue through physical boundaries, interfaces, experimental differentiation, composition, and antecedent prepa- ration. By contrast, the experiment does not directly test the First Absolute Truth concerning logical-mathematical Nothingness, the Third Absolute Truth concerning Infinity as a non-element, or the complete physical content of the Second Absolute Truth concerning a unique individuating field belonging to every existing element. The article further examines possible relations with the phenomenic elements of the TO, the EIE/EIR Inductive Effects, the Cosmogenic Theorem, the proposed cos- mological Eras, the Law of Logical Minimum, and the Alpha–Omega Test. Throughout the analysis, experimentally grounded relations are distinguished from analogical or heuristic extrapolations. A central conclusion is that Bell nonlocality should not be equated with con- trollable superluminal information transmission, nor should it be treated as automatic demonstration of any unique hidden ontology. Its importance for the TO lies in the empirical inadequacy of the relevant Bell-local class of models and in the consequent importance of relational structure. The paper therefore proposes a future operational program: the TO should derive a quantitative function, correction, threshold, probabil- ity distribution, or observable capable of differing from standard quantum mechanics. Only such a discriminating prediction can transform philosophical compatibility into an independent empirical test. Keywords: Theory of Objectivity; Bell inequality; Bell nonlocality; Einstein locality; quantum entanglement; CHSH inequality; modal ontology; relational ob- servation; information; radiation; Absolute Truths; EIE; EIR; Cosmogenic Theorem; quantum foundations; empirical testability.

•Oct 5, 2026•0 citations

Ghostly action at a distance: A non-technical explanation of the Bell inequality

Mark Alford

We present a non-mathematical explanation of Bell's inequality. Using the inequality, we show how the results of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) experiments violate the principle of strong locality. This indicates, given some reasonable-sounding assumptions, that some sort of faster-than-light influence is present in nature. We discuss the implications, emphasizing the relationship between EPR and the Principle of Relativity, the distinction between causal influences and signals, and the tension between EPR and determinism.

arXiv:1506.02179•American Journal of Physics•May 23, 2016•10 citations

A possible loophole in the theorem of Bell

K. Hess, Walter Philipp

The celebrated inequalities of Bell are based on the assumption that local hidden parameters exist. When combined with conflicting experimental results, these inequalities appear to prove that local hidden parameters cannot exist. This contradiction suggests to many that only instantaneous action at a distance can explain the Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen type of experiments. We show that, in addition to the assumption that hidden parameters exist, Bell tacitly makes a variety of other assumptions that contribute to his being able to obtain the desired contradiction. For instance, Bell assumes that the hidden parameters do not depend on time and are governed by a single probability measure independent of the analyzer settings. We argue that the exclusion of time has neither a physical nor a mathematical basis but is based on Bell's translation of the concept of Einstein locality into the language of probability theory. Our additional set of local hidden variables includes time-like correlated parameters and a generalized probability density. We prove that our extended space of local hidden variables does not permit Bell-type proofs to go forward.

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Nov 27, 2001•81 citations
We observe strong violation of Bell's inequality in an Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-type experiment with independent observers. Our experiment definitely implements the ideas behind the well-known work by Aspect et al. We for the first time fully enforce the condition of locality, a central assumption in the derivation of Bell's theorem. The necessary spacelike separation of the observations is achieved by sufficient physical distance between the measurement stations, by ultrafast and random setting of the analyzers, and by completely independent data registration.
Starting from the late 60’s many experiments have been performed to verify the violation Bell’s inequality by Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) type correlations. The idea of these experiments being that: (i) Bell’s inequality is a consequence of locality, hence its experimental violation is an indication of non locality; (ii) this violation is a typical quantum phenomenon because any classical system making local choices (either deterministic or random) will produce correlations satisfying this inequality. Both statements (i) and (ii) have been criticized by quantum probability on theoretical grounds (not discussed in the present paper) and the experiment discussed below has been devised to support these theoretical arguments. We emphasize that the goal of our experiment is not to reproduce classically the EPR correlations but to prove that there exist perfectly local classical dynamical systems violating Bell’s inequality. The conclusions of the present experiment are: no contradiction between quantum theory and locality can be deduced from the violation of Bell’s inequality. The Copenhagen interpretation of quantum theory becomes quite reasonable and not metaphyisic if interpreted at the light of the chameleon effect. One can realize quantum entanglement by classical computers. In section (7) we prove that our experiment also provides a classical analogue of the type of logical (i.e. independent of statistics) incompatibilities pointed out by Greenberger, Home and Zeilinger. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
Starting from the late 60's many experiments have been performed to verify the violation Bell's inequality by Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) type correlations. The idea of these experiments being that: (i) Bell's inequality is a consequence of locality, hence its experimental violation is an indication of non locality; (ii) this violation is a typical quantum phenomenon because any classical system making local choices (either deterministic or random) will produce correlations satisfying this inequality. Both statements (i) and (ii) have been criticized by quantum probability on theoretical grounds (not discussed in the present paper) and the experiment discussed below has been devised to support these theoretical arguments. We emphasize that the goal of our experiment is not to reproduce classically the EPR correlations but to prove that there exist perfectly local classical dynamical systems violating Bell's inequality.
Most physicists agree that the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen–Bell paradox exemplifies much of the strange behavior of quantum mechanics, but argument persists about what assumptions underlie the paradox. To clarify what the debate is about, we employ a simple and well-known thought experiment involving two correlated photons to help us focus on the logical assumptions needed to construct the EPR and Bell arguments. The view presented in this paper is that the minimal assumptions behind Bell’s inequality are locality and counterfactual definiteness but not scientific realism, determinism, or hidden variables as are often suggested. We further examine the resulting constraints on physical theory with an illustration from the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics—an interpretation that we argue is deterministic, local, and realist but that nonetheless violates the Bell inequality.
This article develops an expanded critical–propositional analysis of Gregor Weihs, Thomas Jennewein, Christoph Simon, Harald Weinfurter, and Anton Zeilinger’s 1998 experiment, “Violation of Bell’s Inequality under Strict Einstein Locality Conditions,” in systematic dialogue with the Theory of Objectivity (TO) formulated by Vidamor Cabannas and Denivaldo Silva. Weihs et al. implemented a Bell-type experiment with polarization-entangled photons, spatially separated measurement stations, rapidly and independently selected analyzer settings, and independent time-tagged registration. The experiment was designed to impose strict spacelike separation between the relevant measurement processes and reported a CHSH value of approximately S = 2.73 ± 0.02, substantially exceeding the Bell-local bound S ≤ 2. The measurement stations were separated by approximately 400 m, whereas the relevant interval between local setting selection and detection was much shorter than the approximately 1.3 µs light-travel time between the stations (Weihs et al. 1998). The purpose of the present study is not to reinterpret the violation of Bell’s inequality as a direct experimental proof of the Theory of Objectivity. Such an inference would exceed what the experiment establishes. Instead, the article distinguishes three epistemic levels: empirical result, theoretical interpretation, and modal-ontological proposition. This distinction is fundamental because the TO presents its Absolute Truths as modal necessities, whereas Bell experiments are contingent empirical investi- gations conducted under explicit mathematical, physical, and statistical assumptions. Within this disciplined framework, the strongest dialogue between Weihs et al. and the TO is found in the Fifth Absolute Truth, according to which the logical existence of an element requires observation or frequency relation with at least two other elements, while “observation” does not mean human consciousness. The Bell experiment is intrinsically relational: the relevant quantity is constructed from joint statistics obtained at physically independent stations, and no human observer is required to produce local physical registration. A second important dialogue arises with the Seventh Absolute Truth and the TO concept of the transcendent element as knowledge or information produced in atomic relations and treated within the theory as equivalent to atomic radiation. The experiment presents a rigorous chain connecting radiation, polarization, interaction, registration, correlation, and recoverable information. Nevertheless, quantum mechanics supports the proposition that radiation can instantiate information-bearing degrees of freedom; this does not by itself demonstrate the stronger ontological identity between radiation and information proposed by the TO. The Fourth and Sixth Absolute Truths also enter the dialogue through physical boundaries, interfaces, experimental differentiation, composition, and antecedent prepa- ration. By contrast, the experiment does not directly test the First Absolute Truth concerning logical-mathematical Nothingness, the Third Absolute Truth concerning Infinity as a non-element, or the complete physical content of the Second Absolute Truth concerning a unique individuating field belonging to every existing element. The article further examines possible relations with the phenomenic elements of the TO, the EIE/EIR Inductive Effects, the Cosmogenic Theorem, the proposed cos- mological Eras, the Law of Logical Minimum, and the Alpha–Omega Test. Throughout the analysis, experimentally grounded relations are distinguished from analogical or heuristic extrapolations. A central conclusion is that Bell nonlocality should not be equated with con- trollable superluminal information transmission, nor should it be treated as automatic demonstration of any unique hidden ontology. Its importance for the TO lies in the empirical inadequacy of the relevant Bell-local class of models and in the consequent importance of relational structure. The paper therefore proposes a future operational program: the TO should derive a quantitative function, correction, threshold, probabil- ity distribution, or observable capable of differing from standard quantum mechanics. Only such a discriminating prediction can transform philosophical compatibility into an independent empirical test. Keywords: Theory of Objectivity; Bell inequality; Bell nonlocality; Einstein locality; quantum entanglement; CHSH inequality; modal ontology; relational ob- servation; information; radiation; Absolute Truths; EIE; EIR; Cosmogenic Theorem; quantum foundations; empirical testability.
We present a non-mathematical explanation of Bell's inequality. Using the inequality, we show how the results of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) experiments violate the principle of strong locality. This indicates, given some reasonable-sounding assumptions, that some sort of faster-than-light influence is present in nature. We discuss the implications, emphasizing the relationship between EPR and the Principle of Relativity, the distinction between causal influences and signals, and the tension between EPR and determinism.
The celebrated inequalities of Bell are based on the assumption that local hidden parameters exist. When combined with conflicting experimental results, these inequalities appear to prove that local hidden parameters cannot exist. This contradiction suggests to many that only instantaneous action at a distance can explain the Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen type of experiments. We show that, in addition to the assumption that hidden parameters exist, Bell tacitly makes a variety of other assumptions that contribute to his being able to obtain the desired contradiction. For instance, Bell assumes that the hidden parameters do not depend on time and are governed by a single probability measure independent of the analyzer settings. We argue that the exclusion of time has neither a physical nor a mathematical basis but is based on Bell's translation of the concept of Einstein locality into the language of probability theory. Our additional set of local hidden variables includes time-like correlated parameters and a generalized probability density. We prove that our extended space of local hidden variables does not permit Bell-type proofs to go forward.