Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0703227 · Physical Review Letters

Regional Versus Global Entanglement in Resonating-Valence-Bond States

Anushya Chandran, Dagomir Kaszlikowski, Aditi Sen, Ujjwal Sen, Vlatko Vedral

Published Oct 25, 2007• 42 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the entanglement properties of resonating-valence-bond states on two and higher dimensional lattices, which play a significant role in our understanding of various many-body systems. We show that these states are genuinely multipartite entangled, while there is only a negligible amount of two-site entanglement. We comment on possible physical implications of our findings.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.99.170502

Related papers

Comment on “Regional Versus Global Entanglement in Resonating-Valence-Bond States”

Fabien Alet, Daniel Braun, Grégoire Misguich

In a recent Letter [Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 170502 (2007); quant-ph/0703227], Chandran and coworkers study the entanglement properties of valence bond (VB) states. Their main result is that VB states do not contain (or only an insignificant amount of) two-site entanglement, whereas they possess multi-body entanglement. Two examples ("RVB gas and liquid") are given to illustrate this claim, which essentially comes from a lower bound derived for spin correlators in VB states. We show in this Comment that (i) for the "RVB liquid" on the square lattice, the calculations and conclusions of Chandran et al. are incorrect. (ii) A simple analytical calculation gives the exact value of the correlator for the "RVB gas", showing that the bound found by Chandran et al. is tight. (iii) The lower bound for spin correlators in VB states is equivalent to a celebrated result of Anderson dating from more than 50 years ago.

arXiv:0812.1932•Physical Review Letters•Dec 10, 2008•4 citations

Kaszlikowskiet al.Reply:

Dagomir Kaszlikowski, Aditi Sen, Ujjwal Sen +1 more

In Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 170502 (2007) (arXiv:quant-ph/0703227), we prove that resonating-valence-bond (RVB) states on arbitrary lattices possess genuine multiparty entanglement, and provide bounds on two-particle entanglement (and correlators). We also conjecture on the entanglement in large and small portions of the whole lattice. The proof, bound, and conjecture are not considered in the Comment in Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 248901 (2008) (arXiv:0812.1932v1 [quant-ph]). Next we take two examples: "RVB gas" and "RVB liquid". RVB liquid for arbitrary lattice size is not considered in the Comment. Two-party entanglement of RVB gas for relatively large lattice size is derived by an independent method in the Comment, and it agrees with our result. Multi-party entanglement of RVB gas is not considered in the Comment. Lastly, we consider an RVB liquid on a 4x4 square lattice and there was an error in the calculation of two-party entanglement in the second decimal place, as noted in the Comment. Note that this calculation was nowhere used in our Letter to derive other results. Moreover, the conclusion of "no two-particle entanglement" is still true for the RVB liquid on a 4x4 square lattice.

arXiv:0901.0100•Physical Review Letters•Dec 10, 2008•2 citations

Entanglement in doped resonating valence bond states

Ravishankar Ramanathan, Dagomir Kaszlikowski, Marcin Wieśniak +1 more

We investigate the entanglement properties of resonating valence bond (RVB) states on a two-dimensional lattice in the presence of dopants that remove electrons from the lattice creating holes. The movement of the holes generated by the Hubbard Hamiltonian in the regime of strong Coulomb repulsion in this setting could be responsible for the phenomenon of high-temperature superconductivity as hypothesized by [Anderson Science 235, 1196 (1987)]. We argue that there is a particular density of dopants (holes) where the entanglement contained in the lattice attains its maximal value for the nearest-neighbor RVB liquid state. This result implies that many-body entanglement may be related to quantum phase transitions that are modeled by RVB theory.

arXiv:0808.3655•Physical Review B•Dec 12, 2008•5 citations

Separability and entanglement of resonating valence-bond states

Gilles Parez, Clément Berthière, William Witczak‐Krempa

We investigate separability and entanglement of Rokhsar-Kivelson (RK) states and resonating valence-bond (RVB) states. These states play a prominent role in condensed matter physics, as they can describe quantum spin liquids and quantum critical states of matter, depending on their underlying lattices. For dimer RK states on arbitrary tileable graphs, we prove the exact separability of the reduced density matrix of k k disconnected subsystems, implying the absence of bipartite and multipartite entanglement between the subsystems. For more general RK states with local constraints, we argue separability in the thermodynamic limit, and show that any local RK state has zero logarithmic negativity, even if the density matrix is not exactly separable. In the case of adjacent subsystems, we find an exact expression for the logarithmic negativity in terms of partition functions of the underlying statistical model. For RVB states, we show separability for disconnected subsystems up to exponentially small terms in the distance d d between the subsystems, and that the logarithmic negativity is exponentially suppressed with d d . We argue that separability does hold in the scaling limit, even for arbitrarily small ratio d/L d / L , where L L is the characteristic size of the subsystems. Our results hold for arbitrary lattices, and encompass a large class of RK and RVB states, which include certain gapped quantum spin liquids and gapless quantum critical systems.

arXiv:2212.11740•SciPost Physics•Aug 21, 2023•8 citations

Entanglement in resonating valence bond states: ladder versus isotropic lattices

Himadri Shekhar Dhar, Aditi Sen

We study the behavior of bipartite, as well as genuine multipartite, entanglement of a resonating valence bond state on a ladder. Although there is negligible bipartite entanglement (BE) present in the rails, as is the case for isotropic lattices in two and higher dimensions, we show that the system possesses significant amounts of BE in the steps of the ladder. However, we find that the genuine multipartite entanglement in the system is substantially low. Therefore, both the properties of bipartite as well as multipartite entanglement in the ladder are contrary to the behavior of entanglement in isotropic lattices, indicating that the geometry of the lattice can play a significant role in quantum information processing tasks. Our results also indicate that numerical and analytical investigations obtained on ladders cannot infer the same on two-dimensional lattices.

arXiv:1003.4401•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Oct 26, 2011•23 citations

Entanglement in many-body quantum systems

Pawan Khatiwada, Imran M. Mirza

Here we briefly revisit entanglement in bipartite quantum systems and mention issues to its extension to multipartite situations. Finally, we indicate the role of entanglement in the description of many-body systems through matrix product states.

Frontiers in Optics•Jan 1, 2020•2 citations
We investigate the entanglement properties of resonating-valence-bond states on two and higher dimensional lattices, which play a significant role in our understanding of various many-body systems. We show that these states are genuinely multipartite entangled, while there is only a negligible amount of two-site entanglement. We comment on possible physical implications of our findings.
In a recent Letter [Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 170502 (2007); quant-ph/0703227], Chandran and coworkers study the entanglement properties of valence bond (VB) states. Their main result is that VB states do not contain (or only an insignificant amount of) two-site entanglement, whereas they possess multi-body entanglement. Two examples ("RVB gas and liquid") are given to illustrate this claim, which essentially comes from a lower bound derived for spin correlators in VB states. We show in this Comment that (i) for the "RVB liquid" on the square lattice, the calculations and conclusions of Chandran et al. are incorrect. (ii) A simple analytical calculation gives the exact value of the correlator for the "RVB gas", showing that the bound found by Chandran et al. is tight. (iii) The lower bound for spin correlators in VB states is equivalent to a celebrated result of Anderson dating from more than 50 years ago.
In Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 170502 (2007) (arXiv:quant-ph/0703227), we prove that resonating-valence-bond (RVB) states on arbitrary lattices possess genuine multiparty entanglement, and provide bounds on two-particle entanglement (and correlators). We also conjecture on the entanglement in large and small portions of the whole lattice. The proof, bound, and conjecture are not considered in the Comment in Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 248901 (2008) (arXiv:0812.1932v1 [quant-ph]). Next we take two examples: "RVB gas" and "RVB liquid". RVB liquid for arbitrary lattice size is not considered in the Comment. Two-party entanglement of RVB gas for relatively large lattice size is derived by an independent method in the Comment, and it agrees with our result. Multi-party entanglement of RVB gas is not considered in the Comment. Lastly, we consider an RVB liquid on a 4x4 square lattice and there was an error in the calculation of two-party entanglement in the second decimal place, as noted in the Comment. Note that this calculation was nowhere used in our Letter to derive other results. Moreover, the conclusion of "no two-particle entanglement" is still true for the RVB liquid on a 4x4 square lattice.
We investigate the entanglement properties of resonating valence bond (RVB) states on a two-dimensional lattice in the presence of dopants that remove electrons from the lattice creating holes. The movement of the holes generated by the Hubbard Hamiltonian in the regime of strong Coulomb repulsion in this setting could be responsible for the phenomenon of high-temperature superconductivity as hypothesized by [Anderson Science 235, 1196 (1987)]. We argue that there is a particular density of dopants (holes) where the entanglement contained in the lattice attains its maximal value for the nearest-neighbor RVB liquid state. This result implies that many-body entanglement may be related to quantum phase transitions that are modeled by RVB theory.
We investigate separability and entanglement of Rokhsar-Kivelson (RK) states and resonating valence-bond (RVB) states. These states play a prominent role in condensed matter physics, as they can describe quantum spin liquids and quantum critical states of matter, depending on their underlying lattices. For dimer RK states on arbitrary tileable graphs, we prove the exact separability of the reduced density matrix of k k disconnected subsystems, implying the absence of bipartite and multipartite entanglement between the subsystems. For more general RK states with local constraints, we argue separability in the thermodynamic limit, and show that any local RK state has zero logarithmic negativity, even if the density matrix is not exactly separable. In the case of adjacent subsystems, we find an exact expression for the logarithmic negativity in terms of partition functions of the underlying statistical model. For RVB states, we show separability for disconnected subsystems up to exponentially small terms in the distance d d between the subsystems, and that the logarithmic negativity is exponentially suppressed with d d . We argue that separability does hold in the scaling limit, even for arbitrarily small ratio d/L d / L , where L L is the characteristic size of the subsystems. Our results hold for arbitrary lattices, and encompass a large class of RK and RVB states, which include certain gapped quantum spin liquids and gapless quantum critical systems.
We study the behavior of bipartite, as well as genuine multipartite, entanglement of a resonating valence bond state on a ladder. Although there is negligible bipartite entanglement (BE) present in the rails, as is the case for isotropic lattices in two and higher dimensions, we show that the system possesses significant amounts of BE in the steps of the ladder. However, we find that the genuine multipartite entanglement in the system is substantially low. Therefore, both the properties of bipartite as well as multipartite entanglement in the ladder are contrary to the behavior of entanglement in isotropic lattices, indicating that the geometry of the lattice can play a significant role in quantum information processing tasks. Our results also indicate that numerical and analytical investigations obtained on ladders cannot infer the same on two-dimensional lattices.