Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0703002

Macroscopic Reality in Quantum Mechanics; Origin and Dissipation

Kentaro Urasaki

Published Mar 1, 2007• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the connection between dissipation and reality in macroscopic quantum systems. We present the following scenario; if we consider the dynamics of a `partial' wave function, the dissipation is represented as a nonlocal term and it causes destructive interference to suppress the quantum fluctuation. Using the variational method, we confirm that this dissipation term is a reasonable extension of the standard (Schrödinger) description for isolated systems, from which we also derive the classical action. Consequently, in macroscopic systems, the states whose time-integrated dissipation takes an extreme value come true. This description, which is consistent with our sense of reality, coexists with the usual linear-time-dependent description.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0703002

Related papers

Photoinduced macroscopic quantum tunneling

Sudip Chakravarty, Steven Allan Kivelson

Recently there has been interest in macroscopic systems which can be described in terms of the quantum dynamics of the same collective variables which describe their classical behavior. In particular, there has been considerable interest in the following questions: (1) Is it possible to observe unambiguous evidence of the quantum-mechanical nature of a macroscopic collective coordinate? (2) In what way is the quantum mechanics of a macroscopic variable different from that of a microscopic variable or, in other words, what is the effect of dissipation on the dynamics of a quantum-mechanical system? Spectroscopic evidence of the quantization of energy levels can be found by measuring the system's response to an applied ac perturbation, exploiting the quantum-mechanical relation between energy and frequency. The specific system studied is a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID). It is shown that a time-varying magnetic field through the superconducting loop in a rf SQUID can cause transitions between different fluxoid states. The role of dissipation is discussed in detail, and it is shown that in the case that dissipation is characterized by linear damping in the classical limit, the photon-absorption process depends critically on the ratio of the resistance of the weak link to the fundamental unit of resistance h/${e}^{2}$. .AE

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jul 1, 1985•46 citations

Dissipative Processes as a Conceptual Basis for Classical and Quantum Behavior

Giulio Bornacin

This work proposes a conceptual and ontological reformulation of classical dynamics, thermodynamics, and quantum mechanics based on a single postulate: dissipation is a fundamental property of all physical processes. Traditional dynamics relies on the idealization of isolated, reversible systems, yet no real physical system satisfies such conditions. By introducing an intrinsic dissipative energy term into the equations of motion, we suggest that dissipation entails an irreversible loss of physical information, from which a classical uncertainty principle naturally follows. Stationary states are reinterpreted as zero‑dissipation configurations, lacking internal temporal evolution, thereby offering an ontological basis for quantization, non‑locality, and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Quantum mechanics can thus be viewed as the mathematical description of these stationary states and of the dissipative transitions connecting them. The framework is conceptually consistent with fluctuation‑dissipation theory, open‑system quantum dynamics, decoherence theory, and relaxation phenomena in NMR spectroscopy. Several experimental proposals are outlined to discriminate this ontological model from both classical mechanics and standard quantum mechanics.

•May 12, 2026•0 citations

Unified dynamics for microscopic and macroscopic systems

G. C. Ghirardi, A. Rimini, T. Weber

An explicit model allowing a unified description of microscopic and macroscopic systems is exhibited. First, a modified quantum dynamics for the description of macroscopic objects is constructed and it is shown that it forbids the occurrence of linear superpositions of states localized in far-away spatial regions and induces an evolution agreeing with classical mechanics. This dynamics also allows a description of the evolution in terms of trajectories. To set up a unified description of all physical phenomena, a modification of the dynamics, with respect to the standard Hamiltonian one, is then postulated also for microscopic systems. It is shown that one can consistently deduce from it the previously considered dynamics for the center of mass of macroscopic systems. Choosing in an appropriate way the parameters of the so-obtained model one can show that both the standard quantum theory for microscopic objects and the classical behavior for macroscopic objects can all be derived in a consistent way. In the case of a macroscopic system one can obtain, by means of appropriate approximations, a description of the evolution in terms of a phase-space density distribution obeying a Fokker-Planck diffusion equation. The model also provides the basis for a conceptually appealing description of quantum measurement.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jul 15, 1986•2,795 citations

From macroscopic irreversibility to microscopic reversibility via a nonlinear schrödinger‐type field equation

Dieter Schuch, Kyu -Myung Chung

Abstract The aim of our work was to find an unambiguous connection between irreversible macroscopic dynamics and reversible microdynamics that makes it possible to manifest irreversibility on a submacroscopic level without the use of coarse graining arguments. On this level the state of a physical system can be described by a field amplitude Ψ and the time evolution of this system is determined by a field equation for Ψ. For conservative systems, this field equation is formally identical with the linear Schrödinger equation, which can be constructed with the help of the classic Hamiltonian function for the corresponding problem. Regarding irreversible phenomena like damping due to a frictional force, for those dissipative systems no classic Hamiltonian function exists. Therefore the corresponding field equation cannot be obtained in the usual way. Nevertheless, also for dissipative systems it is possible to obtain a field equation in an unambiguous way using only Newton's form of classic mechanics. The result of our method is a nonlinear Schrödinger‐type field equation with a logarithmic nonlinearity. We discuss in more detail the properties of our logarithmic nonlinearity that corresponds to a macroscopic frictional force in a unique way. A figurative interpretation in terms of environment and interaction can be given. From a more formal point of view, the compatibility of our nonlinear operator with principles known from the theory of linear operators is investigated. One of the surprising results is the fact that although our nonlinear Hamiltonian HNL is “Hermitean” in the usual sense, in contrast to the linear theory an operator exp(i · HNL) is not unitary. Furthermore, in our theory the time‐derivative of the mean value of an operator is not only essentially determined by (the mean value of) its commutator with the Hamiltonian. There also occurs an additional term that causes irreversibility of the evolution and is connected with the feature of our theory that (in general) time derivative and construction of the mean value are no longer commuting operations. This fact shows some similarity with coarse graining theories, but in our theory the reason can be traced back unambiguously to an irreversible physical phenomenon.

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•May 1, 1986•43 citations

Disentanglement of quantum wave functions: Answer to ‘‘Comment on ‘Unified dynamics for microscopic and macroscopic systems’ ’’

G. C. Ghirardi, A. Rimini, T. Weber

It is shown that the assumption of a stochastic localization process for the quantum wave function is essentially different from the suppression of coherence over macroscopic distances arising from the interaction with the environment and allows for a conceptually complete derivation of the classical behavior of macroscopic bodies.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Nov 15, 1987•98 citations

Dissipative Quantum Systems

Gert‐Ludwig Ingold

Dissipation is a ubiquitous phenomenon in real physical systems. Its nature is made clear by considering the damped harmonic oscillator, a paradigm for dissipative sys-tems in the classical as well as the quantum regime. After starting at a nonequilibrium position, the system will perform damped oscillations and end up in the equilibrium

•Jan 1, 1997•24 citations
We study the connection between dissipation and reality in macroscopic quantum systems. We present the following scenario; if we consider the dynamics of a `partial' wave function, the dissipation is represented as a nonlocal term and it causes destructive interference to suppress the quantum fluctuation. Using the variational method, we confirm that this dissipation term is a reasonable extension of the standard (Schrödinger) description for isolated systems, from which we also derive the classical action. Consequently, in macroscopic systems, the states whose time-integrated dissipation takes an extreme value come true. This description, which is consistent with our sense of reality, coexists with the usual linear-time-dependent description.
Recently there has been interest in macroscopic systems which can be described in terms of the quantum dynamics of the same collective variables which describe their classical behavior. In particular, there has been considerable interest in the following questions: (1) Is it possible to observe unambiguous evidence of the quantum-mechanical nature of a macroscopic collective coordinate? (2) In what way is the quantum mechanics of a macroscopic variable different from that of a microscopic variable or, in other words, what is the effect of dissipation on the dynamics of a quantum-mechanical system? Spectroscopic evidence of the quantization of energy levels can be found by measuring the system's response to an applied ac perturbation, exploiting the quantum-mechanical relation between energy and frequency. The specific system studied is a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID). It is shown that a time-varying magnetic field through the superconducting loop in a rf SQUID can cause transitions between different fluxoid states. The role of dissipation is discussed in detail, and it is shown that in the case that dissipation is characterized by linear damping in the classical limit, the photon-absorption process depends critically on the ratio of the resistance of the weak link to the fundamental unit of resistance h/e2{e}^{2}e2. .AE
This work proposes a conceptual and ontological reformulation of classical dynamics, thermodynamics, and quantum mechanics based on a single postulate: dissipation is a fundamental property of all physical processes. Traditional dynamics relies on the idealization of isolated, reversible systems, yet no real physical system satisfies such conditions. By introducing an intrinsic dissipative energy term into the equations of motion, we suggest that dissipation entails an irreversible loss of physical information, from which a classical uncertainty principle naturally follows. Stationary states are reinterpreted as zero‑dissipation configurations, lacking internal temporal evolution, thereby offering an ontological basis for quantization, non‑locality, and the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Quantum mechanics can thus be viewed as the mathematical description of these stationary states and of the dissipative transitions connecting them. The framework is conceptually consistent with fluctuation‑dissipation theory, open‑system quantum dynamics, decoherence theory, and relaxation phenomena in NMR spectroscopy. Several experimental proposals are outlined to discriminate this ontological model from both classical mechanics and standard quantum mechanics.
An explicit model allowing a unified description of microscopic and macroscopic systems is exhibited. First, a modified quantum dynamics for the description of macroscopic objects is constructed and it is shown that it forbids the occurrence of linear superpositions of states localized in far-away spatial regions and induces an evolution agreeing with classical mechanics. This dynamics also allows a description of the evolution in terms of trajectories. To set up a unified description of all physical phenomena, a modification of the dynamics, with respect to the standard Hamiltonian one, is then postulated also for microscopic systems. It is shown that one can consistently deduce from it the previously considered dynamics for the center of mass of macroscopic systems. Choosing in an appropriate way the parameters of the so-obtained model one can show that both the standard quantum theory for microscopic objects and the classical behavior for macroscopic objects can all be derived in a consistent way. In the case of a macroscopic system one can obtain, by means of appropriate approximations, a description of the evolution in terms of a phase-space density distribution obeying a Fokker-Planck diffusion equation. The model also provides the basis for a conceptually appealing description of quantum measurement.
Abstract The aim of our work was to find an unambiguous connection between irreversible macroscopic dynamics and reversible microdynamics that makes it possible to manifest irreversibility on a submacroscopic level without the use of coarse graining arguments. On this level the state of a physical system can be described by a field amplitude Ψ and the time evolution of this system is determined by a field equation for Ψ. For conservative systems, this field equation is formally identical with the linear Schrödinger equation, which can be constructed with the help of the classic Hamiltonian function for the corresponding problem. Regarding irreversible phenomena like damping due to a frictional force, for those dissipative systems no classic Hamiltonian function exists. Therefore the corresponding field equation cannot be obtained in the usual way. Nevertheless, also for dissipative systems it is possible to obtain a field equation in an unambiguous way using only Newton's form of classic mechanics. The result of our method is a nonlinear Schrödinger‐type field equation with a logarithmic nonlinearity. We discuss in more detail the properties of our logarithmic nonlinearity that corresponds to a macroscopic frictional force in a unique way. A figurative interpretation in terms of environment and interaction can be given. From a more formal point of view, the compatibility of our nonlinear operator with principles known from the theory of linear operators is investigated. One of the surprising results is the fact that although our nonlinear Hamiltonian HNL is “Hermitean” in the usual sense, in contrast to the linear theory an operator exp(i · HNL) is not unitary. Furthermore, in our theory the time‐derivative of the mean value of an operator is not only essentially determined by (the mean value of) its commutator with the Hamiltonian. There also occurs an additional term that causes irreversibility of the evolution and is connected with the feature of our theory that (in general) time derivative and construction of the mean value are no longer commuting operations. This fact shows some similarity with coarse graining theories, but in our theory the reason can be traced back unambiguously to an irreversible physical phenomenon.