Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0606183 · Classical and Quantum Gravity

On the quantum analogue of Galileo's leaning tower experiment

Md. Manirul Ali, A. S. Majumdar, Dipankar Home, A. K. Pan

Published Oct 11, 2006• 27 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The quantum analogue of Galileo's leaning tower experiment is revisited using wave packets evolving under the gravitational potential. We first calculate the position detection probabilities for particles projected upwards against gravity around the classical turning point and also around the point of initial projection, which exhibit mass dependence at both these points. We then compute the mean arrival time of freely falling particles using the quantum probability current, which also turns out to be mass dependent. The mass dependence of both the position detection probabilities and the mean arrival time vanish in the limit of large mass. Thus, compatibility between the weak equivalence principle and quantum mechanics is recovered in the macroscopic limit of the latter.

DOI
10.1088/0264-9381/23/22/024

Related papers

Strong quantum violation of the gravitational weak equivalence principle by a non-Gaussian wave packet

P Chowdhury, D Home, A S Majumdar +3 more

The weak equivalence principle of gravity is examined at the quantum level in two ways.First, the position detection probabilities of particles described by a non-Gaussian wave packet projected upwards against gravity around the classical turning point and also around the point of initial projection are calculated.These probabilities exhibit mass dependence at both these points, thereby reflecting the quantum violation of the weak equivalence principle.Second, the mean arrival time of freely falling particles is calculated using the quantum probability current, which also turns out to be mass dependent.Such a mass dependence is shown to be enhanced by increasing the non-Gaussianity parameter of the wave packet, thus signifying a stronger violation of the weak equivalence principle through a greater departure from Gaussianity of the initial wave packet.The mass dependence of both the position detection probabilities and the mean arrival time vanishes in the limit of large mass.Thus, compatibility between the weak equivalence principle and quantum mechanics is recovered in the macroscopic limit of the latter.A selection of Bohm trajectories is exhibited to illustrate these features in the free fall case.

arXiv:1107.5159•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Dec 23, 2011•15 citations

Adherence and violation of the equivalence principle from classical to quantum mechanics

Joseph Balsells, Martin Bojowald A

Investigation into the applicability of the equivalence principle in quantum mechanics has taken many forms, with varying conclusions. Here, a dynamical semiclassical description of a wave packet in terms of its center of mass and higher quantum fluctuations is applied to the case of a quantum particle in gravitational free fall. The analysis provides an intuitive account of the origin of mass dependence in quantum-gravitational dynamics through an effective potential that enforces the uncertainty principle. This potential has two implications: (i) The lowest order quantum fluctuations encoding the width and spreading of the wave packet obey an uncertainty relation whose observance is mass dependent. (ii) In an inhomogeneous gravitational field tidal effects couple the center of mass motion to the quantum fluctuations. The combined effect results in a clear demonstration of how some conceptions of the weak equivalence principle, based on mass dependence, are violated. The size of this violation is within sensitivities of current E\"otv\"os and clock-based return time experiments.

arXiv:2310.09218•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Oct 13, 2023•2 citations

Quantum free-fall motion and quantum violation of the weak equivalence principle

Philip Caesar Flores, Eric A. Galapon

The weak equivalence principle (WEP) in the quantum regime has been the subject of many studies with a broad range of approaches to the problem. Here, we tackle the problem anew through the time of arrival (TOA) operator approach. This is done by constructing the TOA operator for a nonrelativistic and structureless particle that is projected upward in a uniform gravitational field with an intended arrival point below the classical turning point. The TOA operator is constructed under the constraint that the inertial and gravitational masses are equivalent and that Galilean invariance is preserved. These constraints are implemented by Weyl quantization of the corresponding classical TOA function for the projectile. The expectation value of the TOA operator is explicitly shown to be equal to the classical time of arrival plus mass-dependent quantum correction terms, implying incompatibility of the WEP with quantum mechanics. The full extent of the violation of the WEP is shown through the mass dependence of TOA distribution for the projectile.

arXiv:1808.02646•Physical Review A•Apr 17, 2019•16 citations

A quantum test of free fall

Ian S. Osborne

Physics![Figure][1] The Leaning Tower of Pisa, Italy PHOTO: © STEFANO POLITI MARKOVINA/ALAMY STOCK PHOTO Galileo Galilei is purported to have dropped objects of different mass from the Leaning Tower of Pisa to demonstrate that they fall at the same rate. In formulating his general theory of relativity, Einstein described this as the universality of free fall—that all objects, irrespective of their mass, will behave identically when subject to the same gravitational field. Taking this into the quantum regime, Duan et al. performed Galileo's drop experiment with rubidium atoms of different quantum mechanical spins. With a sensitive atom-interferometer setup, they showed that the atoms fall at the same rate to within one part in 10 million, upholding Einstein's universality proposition for now. While we await a theory that can unify relativity and the principles of quantum mechanics, such precision-based experimental tests should help place bounds on any proposed theories of quantum gravity. Phys. Rev. Lett. 117 , 023001 (2016). [1]: pending:yes

Science•Jul 28, 2016•0 citations

Quantum Galileo's experiments and mass estimation in a gravitational field

Luigi Seveso, Valerio Peri, Matteo G. A. Paris

We address the problem of estimating the mass of a (quantum) particle interacting with a classical gravitational field. In particular, we analyze in details the ultimate bounds to precision imposed by quantum mechanics and study the effects of gravity in a variety of settings. Our results show that the presence of a gravitational field generally leads to a precision gain, which can be significant in a regime half-way between the quantum and classical domains. We also address quantum enhancement to precision, i.e. the advantages coming from taking into account the quantum nature of the probe particle, and show that non-classicality is indeed a relevant resource for mass estimation. In particular, we suggest schemes for mass-sensing measurements using quantum probes and show that upon employing non-classical states like quantum coherent superpositions one may improve precisions by orders of magnitude. In addition, we discuss the compatibility of the weak equivalence principle (WEP) within the quantum regime using as a guide the notion of Fisher Information. We find that the information on the probe's mass that can be extracted through position measurements is unchanged by turning on a uniform gravitational field. This conclusion is somehow at variance with certain views expressed in the literature that the WEP cannot hold in the quantum regime. In fact, our results show that in an information-theoretic framework, no clash occurs between quantum mechanics and the WEP.

•Mar 31, 2016•1 citation

Quantum Mechanics and the Weak Equivalence Principle

Stella Huérfano, Sarira Sahu, M. Socolovsky

We use the Feynman path integral approach to nonrelativistic quantum mechanics twofold. First, we derive the lagrangian for a spinless particle moving in a uniformly but not necessarily constantly accelerated reference frame; then, applying the strong equivalence principle (SEP) we obtain the Schroedinger equation for a particle in an inertial frame and in the presence of a uniform and constant gravity field. Second, using the associated Feynman propagator, we propagate an initial gaussian wave packet, with the final wave function and probability density depending on the ratio m/hbar, where m is the inertial mass of the particle, thus exhibiting the fact that the weak equivalence principle (WEP) is violated by quantum mechanics. Although due to rapid oscillations the wave function does not exist in the classical limit, the probability density is well defined and mass independent when hbar goes to 0, showing the recovery of the WEP. Finally, at the quantum level, a heavier particle does not necessarily falls faster than a lighter one; this depends on the relations between the initial and final common positions and times of the particles.

arXiv:quant-ph/0606172•Jun 20, 2006•4 citations
The quantum analogue of Galileo's leaning tower experiment is revisited using wave packets evolving under the gravitational potential. We first calculate the position detection probabilities for particles projected upwards against gravity around the classical turning point and also around the point of initial projection, which exhibit mass dependence at both these points. We then compute the mean arrival time of freely falling particles using the quantum probability current, which also turns out to be mass dependent. The mass dependence of both the position detection probabilities and the mean arrival time vanish in the limit of large mass. Thus, compatibility between the weak equivalence principle and quantum mechanics is recovered in the macroscopic limit of the latter.
The weak equivalence principle of gravity is examined at the quantum level in two ways.First, the position detection probabilities of particles described by a non-Gaussian wave packet projected upwards against gravity around the classical turning point and also around the point of initial projection are calculated.These probabilities exhibit mass dependence at both these points, thereby reflecting the quantum violation of the weak equivalence principle.Second, the mean arrival time of freely falling particles is calculated using the quantum probability current, which also turns out to be mass dependent.Such a mass dependence is shown to be enhanced by increasing the non-Gaussianity parameter of the wave packet, thus signifying a stronger violation of the weak equivalence principle through a greater departure from Gaussianity of the initial wave packet.The mass dependence of both the position detection probabilities and the mean arrival time vanishes in the limit of large mass.Thus, compatibility between the weak equivalence principle and quantum mechanics is recovered in the macroscopic limit of the latter.A selection of Bohm trajectories is exhibited to illustrate these features in the free fall case.
Investigation into the applicability of the equivalence principle in quantum mechanics has taken many forms, with varying conclusions. Here, a dynamical semiclassical description of a wave packet in terms of its center of mass and higher quantum fluctuations is applied to the case of a quantum particle in gravitational free fall. The analysis provides an intuitive account of the origin of mass dependence in quantum-gravitational dynamics through an effective potential that enforces the uncertainty principle. This potential has two implications: (i) The lowest order quantum fluctuations encoding the width and spreading of the wave packet obey an uncertainty relation whose observance is mass dependent. (ii) In an inhomogeneous gravitational field tidal effects couple the center of mass motion to the quantum fluctuations. The combined effect results in a clear demonstration of how some conceptions of the weak equivalence principle, based on mass dependence, are violated. The size of this violation is within sensitivities of current E\"otv\"os and clock-based return time experiments.
The weak equivalence principle (WEP) in the quantum regime has been the subject of many studies with a broad range of approaches to the problem. Here, we tackle the problem anew through the time of arrival (TOA) operator approach. This is done by constructing the TOA operator for a nonrelativistic and structureless particle that is projected upward in a uniform gravitational field with an intended arrival point below the classical turning point. The TOA operator is constructed under the constraint that the inertial and gravitational masses are equivalent and that Galilean invariance is preserved. These constraints are implemented by Weyl quantization of the corresponding classical TOA function for the projectile. The expectation value of the TOA operator is explicitly shown to be equal to the classical time of arrival plus mass-dependent quantum correction terms, implying incompatibility of the WEP with quantum mechanics. The full extent of the violation of the WEP is shown through the mass dependence of TOA distribution for the projectile.
Physics![Figure][1] The Leaning Tower of Pisa, Italy PHOTO: © STEFANO POLITI MARKOVINA/ALAMY STOCK PHOTO Galileo Galilei is purported to have dropped objects of different mass from the Leaning Tower of Pisa to demonstrate that they fall at the same rate. In formulating his general theory of relativity, Einstein described this as the universality of free fall—that all objects, irrespective of their mass, will behave identically when subject to the same gravitational field. Taking this into the quantum regime, Duan et al. performed Galileo's drop experiment with rubidium atoms of different quantum mechanical spins. With a sensitive atom-interferometer setup, they showed that the atoms fall at the same rate to within one part in 10 million, upholding Einstein's universality proposition for now. While we await a theory that can unify relativity and the principles of quantum mechanics, such precision-based experimental tests should help place bounds on any proposed theories of quantum gravity. Phys. Rev. Lett. 117 , 023001 (2016). [1]: pending:yes
We address the problem of estimating the mass of a (quantum) particle interacting with a classical gravitational field. In particular, we analyze in details the ultimate bounds to precision imposed by quantum mechanics and study the effects of gravity in a variety of settings. Our results show that the presence of a gravitational field generally leads to a precision gain, which can be significant in a regime half-way between the quantum and classical domains. We also address quantum enhancement to precision, i.e. the advantages coming from taking into account the quantum nature of the probe particle, and show that non-classicality is indeed a relevant resource for mass estimation. In particular, we suggest schemes for mass-sensing measurements using quantum probes and show that upon employing non-classical states like quantum coherent superpositions one may improve precisions by orders of magnitude. In addition, we discuss the compatibility of the weak equivalence principle (WEP) within the quantum regime using as a guide the notion of Fisher Information. We find that the information on the probe's mass that can be extracted through position measurements is unchanged by turning on a uniform gravitational field. This conclusion is somehow at variance with certain views expressed in the literature that the WEP cannot hold in the quantum regime. In fact, our results show that in an information-theoretic framework, no clash occurs between quantum mechanics and the WEP.
We use the Feynman path integral approach to nonrelativistic quantum mechanics twofold. First, we derive the lagrangian for a spinless particle moving in a uniformly but not necessarily constantly accelerated reference frame; then, applying the strong equivalence principle (SEP) we obtain the Schroedinger equation for a particle in an inertial frame and in the presence of a uniform and constant gravity field. Second, using the associated Feynman propagator, we propagate an initial gaussian wave packet, with the final wave function and probability density depending on the ratio m/hbar, where m is the inertial mass of the particle, thus exhibiting the fact that the weak equivalence principle (WEP) is violated by quantum mechanics. Although due to rapid oscillations the wave function does not exist in the classical limit, the probability density is well defined and mass independent when hbar goes to 0, showing the recovery of the WEP. Finally, at the quantum level, a heavier particle does not necessarily falls faster than a lighter one; this depends on the relations between the initial and final common positions and times of the particles.