Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0602147 · Progress in physics

A possible general approach regarding the conformability of angular observables with mathematical rules of quantum mechanics

Spiridon Dumitru

Published Feb 17, 2006• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The conformability of angular observales (angular momentum and azimuthal angle) with the mathematical rules of quantum mechanics is a question which still rouses debates. It is valued negatively within the existing approaches which are restricted by two amendable presumptions. If the respective presumptions are removed one can obtain a general approach in which the mentioned question is valued positively.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0602147

Related papers

Some remarks on the commutation relations for angle-angular momentum variables in quantum mechanics

Colm T. Whelan

A commutation relation for the observables corresponding to the azimuthal angle about the z axis and the z component of the orbital angular momentum in wave mechanics is presented which will be valid on the entire Hilbert space of states.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jun 1, 1980•1 citation

Is there an Azimuthal Angle Observable?

H. S. Perlman, GORDON J. TROUP

The concept of an azimuthal-angle operator canonically conjugate to the z component of angular-momentum operator is known to present certain difficulties in quantum mechanics. These difficulties are resolved rigorously for the first time, and their implications are discussed.

American Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 1969•3 citations

Note on Azimuthal Angle and Angular Momentum in Quantum Mechanics

K. Kraus

American Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1970•8 citations

Quantum formulation of angle and orbital angular momentum

Jörg B. Götte, Stephen Mark Barnett

The quantum mechanical description of the azimuthal rotation angle and the orbital angular momentum around the polar axis differs greatly from the description of position and momentum. This has led to a controversy over the existence of a self-adjoint angle operator in the literature. It is possible to circumvent the problems of defining a self-adjoint operator for a periodic variable by using trigonometric functions of operators as a basis for the quantum mechanical description. This approach, however, does not allow us to study the properties of the angle operator itself. By using a state space of an arbitrarily large yet finite number of dimensions, it is possible to introduce angle and orbital angular momentum as a conjugate pair of variables both represented by Hermitian matrices. After physical and measurable quantities have been calculated in this state space the number of dimensions is allowed to tend to infinity in a limiting procedure. The first part of this chapter reviews the difficulties associated with the quantum mechanical formulation of angle and orbital angular momentum and presents a way to overcome these problems using a finite-dimensional state space. In the second part this formulation is generalised to include the phenomenon of non-integer orbital angular momentum. This part is based on a chapter of the PhD thesis of Götte [1], where further details may be found. Introduction The correct description of a periodic variable such as a rotation angle or the optical phase has been a long standing problem in quantum mechanics. At the root of the problem is the question of whether the variable itself is restricted in a 2 π radian range or whether it evolves continuously without bound.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 8, 2012•2 citations

Coordinate and momentum representations in quantum mechanics

Derek F. Lawden

On the basis of physical principles having a very general nature, A. Landé [1] has demonstrated that the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics can be derived without having recourse to the introduction of special assumptions of an ad hoc type (such as commutation rules governing canonical observables) which are not immediately suggested by our knowledge of the physical world, but which have simply originated as rules which mathematical physicists have discovered by past experience to yield conclusions in conformity with experiment.

Journal of the Australian Mathematical Society•May 1, 1968•2 citations

Spherical angle operators for quantum-mechanical angular momentum

Gerard Nienhuis, S. J. van Enk

We discuss the operators for the spherical angles of a quantum-mechanical angular momentum vector. Since these operators are restricted to the 2 j + 1 dimensional state space, both the polar angle and the azimuthal angle have discrete eigenstates. These two operators do not commute, and thus they have a different eigenvector basis. Their commutation rule reflects the commutation rule for the Cartesian components of angular momentum. The relation with coherent spin states is analyzed.

Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 1993•7 citations
The conformability of angular observales (angular momentum and azimuthal angle) with the mathematical rules of quantum mechanics is a question which still rouses debates. It is valued negatively within the existing approaches which are restricted by two amendable presumptions. If the respective presumptions are removed one can obtain a general approach in which the mentioned question is valued positively.
The quantum mechanical description of the azimuthal rotation angle and the orbital angular momentum around the polar axis differs greatly from the description of position and momentum. This has led to a controversy over the existence of a self-adjoint angle operator in the literature. It is possible to circumvent the problems of defining a self-adjoint operator for a periodic variable by using trigonometric functions of operators as a basis for the quantum mechanical description. This approach, however, does not allow us to study the properties of the angle operator itself. By using a state space of an arbitrarily large yet finite number of dimensions, it is possible to introduce angle and orbital angular momentum as a conjugate pair of variables both represented by Hermitian matrices. After physical and measurable quantities have been calculated in this state space the number of dimensions is allowed to tend to infinity in a limiting procedure. The first part of this chapter reviews the difficulties associated with the quantum mechanical formulation of angle and orbital angular momentum and presents a way to overcome these problems using a finite-dimensional state space. In the second part this formulation is generalised to include the phenomenon of non-integer orbital angular momentum. This part is based on a chapter of the PhD thesis of Götte [1], where further details may be found. Introduction The correct description of a periodic variable such as a rotation angle or the optical phase has been a long standing problem in quantum mechanics. At the root of the problem is the question of whether the variable itself is restricted in a 2 π radian range or whether it evolves continuously without bound.
On the basis of physical principles having a very general nature, A. Landé [1] has demonstrated that the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics can be derived without having recourse to the introduction of special assumptions of an ad hoc type (such as commutation rules governing canonical observables) which are not immediately suggested by our knowledge of the physical world, but which have simply originated as rules which mathematical physicists have discovered by past experience to yield conclusions in conformity with experiment.