Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0511217 · Physical Review Letters

Entangling and Disentangling Power of Unitary Transformations Are Not Equal

Noah Linden, John A. Smolin, Andreas Winter

Published Jul 14, 2009• 41 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider two capacity quantities associated with bipartite unitary gates: the entangling and the disentangling power. Here, we prove that these capacities are different in general by constructing an explicit example of a qubit-qutrit unitary whose entangling power is maximal (2 ebits), but whose disentangling power is strictly less. A corollary is that there can be no unique ordering for unitary gates in terms of their ability to perform nonlocal tasks. Finally, we show that in large dimensions, almost all bipartite unitaries have entangling and disentangling capacities close to maximal.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.103.030501

Related papers

Entangling and assisted entangling power of bipartite unitary operations

Lin Chen, Li Zhi Yu

Nonlocal unitary operations can create quantum entanglement between distributed particles, and the quantification of created entanglement is a hard problem. It corresponds to the concepts of entangling and assisted entangling power when the input states are, respectively, product and arbitrary pure states. We analytically derive them for Schmidt-rank-two bipartite unitary and some complex bipartite permutation unitaries. In particular, the entangling power of permutation unitary of Schmidt rank three can take only one of two values: ${log}_{2}9\ensuremath{-}16/9$ or ${log}_{2}3$ ebits. The entangling power, assisted entangling power, and disentangling power of $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{d}_{B}$ permutation unitaries of Schmidt rank four are all 2 ebits. These quantities are also derived for generalized Clifford operators. We further show that any bipartite permutation unitary of Schmidt rank greater than two has entangling power greater than 1.223 ebits. We construct the generalized controlled-not (cnot) gates whose assisted entangling power reaches the maximum. We quantitatively compare the entangling power and assisted entangling power for general bipartite unitaries and their connection to the disentangling power by proposing a probabilistic protocol for implementing bipartite unitaries.

arXiv:1604.05788•Physical Review A•Aug 8, 2016•16 citations

Disparity between multipartite entangling and disentangling powers of unitaries: Even vs Odd

Samanta, Mrinmoy, Mondal, Sudipta, Aditi Sen De

We compare the multipartite entangling and disentangling powers of unitary operators by assessing their ability to generate or eliminate genuine multipartite entanglement. Our findings reveal that while diagonal unitary operators can exhibit equal entangling and disentangling powers, certain non-diagonal unitaries demonstrate an imbalance when acting on fully separable states, thereby extending the known disparity from bipartite systems to those with any number of parties. Counterintuitively, we construct classes of unitaries and their adjoints that display unequal entanglement generation capacities, behaving differently when applied to systems with an even number of qubits compared to those with an odd number. Further, we illustrate that this asymmetry can be simulated using physically realizable Hamiltonians: systems with an even number of qubits employ nearest-neighbor Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya (DM) interactions, while those with an odd number utilize a combination of Heisenberg and DM interactions. Additionally, we present a circuit composed of random noncommuting unitaries, constructed from alternating layers of two-qubit Haar-random gates, to illustrate the discrepancy in the entangling and disentangling capabilities of unitaries.

arXiv:2505.18539•May 24, 2025•0 citations

Multipartite entangling power by von Neumann entropy

Xinyu Qiu, Zhiwei Song, Lin Chen

Quantifying the entanglement generation of a multipartite unitary operation is a key problem in quantum information processing. We introduce the definition of multipartite entangling, assisted entangling, and disentangling power, which is a natural generalization of the bipartite ones. We show that they are assumed at a specified quantum state. We analytically derive the entangling power of Schmidt-rank-two multiqubit unitary operations by the minimal convex sum of modulo-one complex numbers. Besides we show the necessary and sufficient condition that the assisted entangling power of Schmidt-rank-two unitary operations reaches the maximum. We investigate the widely used multiqubit gates, for example, the entangling power of CCZS gate, the entangling and assisted entangling power of the $n$-qubit Toffoli gate. The entangling power of the three-qubit Fredkin gate is two ebits, and that of the four-qubit Fredkin gate is in two to ${log}_{2}5$ ebits. Further we investigate the entangling power during the noisy implementation of operations.

arXiv:2410.15253•Physical Review A•Feb 7, 2025•1 citation

Entangling power of symmetric two-qubit quantum gates and three-level operations

Diego Morachis Galindo, Jesús A. Maytorena

The capacity of a quantum gate to produce entangled states on a bipartite system is quantified in terms of the entangling power. This quantity is defined as the average of the linear entropy of entanglement of the states produced after applying a quantum gate over the whole set of separable states. Here we focus on symmetric two-qubit quantum gates, acting on the symmetric two-qubit space, and calculate the entangling power in terms of the appropriate local invariant. A geometric description of the local equivalence classes of gates is given in terms of the $\text{su}(3)$ Lie algebra root vectors. These vectors define a primitive cell with hexagonal symmetry on a plane, and through the Weyl group the minimum area on the plane containing the whole set of locally equivalent quantum gates is identified. We give conditions to determine when a given quantum gate produces maximally entangled states from separable ones (perfect entanglers). We find that these gates correspond to one-fourth of the whole set of locally distinct quantum gates. The formalism developed here is applicable to general three-level systems. Via the Majorana representation, qutrit transformations can be regarded as having entangling power and hence classified as perfect and nonperfect entanglers and be grouped into local-equivalence classes of the associated symmetric two-qubit space. The results are illustrated by an anisotropic Heisenberg model, the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model, and two coupled quantized oscillators with cross-Kerr interaction, which we use to obtain three-level gates relevant in qutrit quantum computation.

arXiv:2107.12653•Physical Review A•Jan 3, 2022•11 citations

Entangling power of two-qubit unitary operations

Yi Shen, Lin Chen

Abstract The entangling power of a bipartite unitary operation shows the maximum created entanglement with the product input states. For an arbitrary two-qubit unitary operation, it is sufficient to consider its normalized operation U with parameters and c 3 . We show how to compute the entangling power of U when . In particular we construct the analytical expressions of entangling power of such U for two examples. We also formulate the entangling power of bipartite unitary operations of Schmidt rank two for any dimensions.

arXiv:1804.01222•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Aug 3, 2018•8 citations

Quantum convolutional channels and multiparameter families of 2-unitary matrices

Rafał Bistroń, Jakub Czartowski, Karol Życzkowski

Many alternative approaches to construct quantum channels with large entangling capacity were proposed in the past decade, resulting in multiple isolated gates. In this work, we put forward a novel one, inspired by convolution, which provides greater freedom of nonlocal parameters. Although quantum counterparts of convolution have been shown not to exist for pure states, several attempts with various degrees of rigorousness have been proposed for mixed states. In this work, we follow the approach based on coherifications of multi-stochastic operations and demonstrate a surprising connection to gates with high entangling power. In particular, we identify conditions necessary for the convolutional channels constructed using our method to possess maximal entangling power. Furthermore, we establish new, continuous classes of bipartite 2-unitary matrices of dimension d 2 for d = 7 and d = 9 , with 2 and 4 free nonlocal parameters beyond simple phasing of matrix elements, corresponding to perfect tensors of rank 4 or 4-partite absolutely maximally entangled states.

arXiv:2312.17719•Quantum•Apr 16, 2026•2 citations
We consider two capacity quantities associated with bipartite unitary gates: the entangling and the disentangling power. Here, we prove that these capacities are different in general by constructing an explicit example of a qubit-qutrit unitary whose entangling power is maximal (2 ebits), but whose disentangling power is strictly less. A corollary is that there can be no unique ordering for unitary gates in terms of their ability to perform nonlocal tasks. Finally, we show that in large dimensions, almost all bipartite unitaries have entangling and disentangling capacities close to maximal.
Nonlocal unitary operations can create quantum entanglement between distributed particles, and the quantification of created entanglement is a hard problem. It corresponds to the concepts of entangling and assisted entangling power when the input states are, respectively, product and arbitrary pure states. We analytically derive them for Schmidt-rank-two bipartite unitary and some complex bipartite permutation unitaries. In particular, the entangling power of permutation unitary of Schmidt rank three can take only one of two values: ${log}_{2}9\ensuremath{-}16/9$ or log23{log}_{2}3log2​3 ebits. The entangling power, assisted entangling power, and disentangling power of $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{d}_{B}$ permutation unitaries of Schmidt rank four are all 2 ebits. These quantities are also derived for generalized Clifford operators. We further show that any bipartite permutation unitary of Schmidt rank greater than two has entangling power greater than 1.223 ebits. We construct the generalized controlled-not (cnot) gates whose assisted entangling power reaches the maximum. We quantitatively compare the entangling power and assisted entangling power for general bipartite unitaries and their connection to the disentangling power by proposing a probabilistic protocol for implementing bipartite unitaries.
We compare the multipartite entangling and disentangling powers of unitary operators by assessing their ability to generate or eliminate genuine multipartite entanglement. Our findings reveal that while diagonal unitary operators can exhibit equal entangling and disentangling powers, certain non-diagonal unitaries demonstrate an imbalance when acting on fully separable states, thereby extending the known disparity from bipartite systems to those with any number of parties. Counterintuitively, we construct classes of unitaries and their adjoints that display unequal entanglement generation capacities, behaving differently when applied to systems with an even number of qubits compared to those with an odd number. Further, we illustrate that this asymmetry can be simulated using physically realizable Hamiltonians: systems with an even number of qubits employ nearest-neighbor Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya (DM) interactions, while those with an odd number utilize a combination of Heisenberg and DM interactions. Additionally, we present a circuit composed of random noncommuting unitaries, constructed from alternating layers of two-qubit Haar-random gates, to illustrate the discrepancy in the entangling and disentangling capabilities of unitaries.
Quantifying the entanglement generation of a multipartite unitary operation is a key problem in quantum information processing. We introduce the definition of multipartite entangling, assisted entangling, and disentangling power, which is a natural generalization of the bipartite ones. We show that they are assumed at a specified quantum state. We analytically derive the entangling power of Schmidt-rank-two multiqubit unitary operations by the minimal convex sum of modulo-one complex numbers. Besides we show the necessary and sufficient condition that the assisted entangling power of Schmidt-rank-two unitary operations reaches the maximum. We investigate the widely used multiqubit gates, for example, the entangling power of CCZS gate, the entangling and assisted entangling power of the nnn-qubit Toffoli gate. The entangling power of the three-qubit Fredkin gate is two ebits, and that of the four-qubit Fredkin gate is in two to log25{log}_{2}5log2​5 ebits. Further we investigate the entangling power during the noisy implementation of operations.
The capacity of a quantum gate to produce entangled states on a bipartite system is quantified in terms of the entangling power. This quantity is defined as the average of the linear entropy of entanglement of the states produced after applying a quantum gate over the whole set of separable states. Here we focus on symmetric two-qubit quantum gates, acting on the symmetric two-qubit space, and calculate the entangling power in terms of the appropriate local invariant. A geometric description of the local equivalence classes of gates is given in terms of the su(3)\text{su}(3)su(3) Lie algebra root vectors. These vectors define a primitive cell with hexagonal symmetry on a plane, and through the Weyl group the minimum area on the plane containing the whole set of locally equivalent quantum gates is identified. We give conditions to determine when a given quantum gate produces maximally entangled states from separable ones (perfect entanglers). We find that these gates correspond to one-fourth of the whole set of locally distinct quantum gates. The formalism developed here is applicable to general three-level systems. Via the Majorana representation, qutrit transformations can be regarded as having entangling power and hence classified as perfect and nonperfect entanglers and be grouped into local-equivalence classes of the associated symmetric two-qubit space. The results are illustrated by an anisotropic Heisenberg model, the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model, and two coupled quantized oscillators with cross-Kerr interaction, which we use to obtain three-level gates relevant in qutrit quantum computation.
Abstract The entangling power of a bipartite unitary operation shows the maximum created entanglement with the product input states. For an arbitrary two-qubit unitary operation, it is sufficient to consider its normalized operation U with parameters and c 3 . We show how to compute the entangling power of U when . In particular we construct the analytical expressions of entangling power of such U for two examples. We also formulate the entangling power of bipartite unitary operations of Schmidt rank two for any dimensions.
Many alternative approaches to construct quantum channels with large entangling capacity were proposed in the past decade, resulting in multiple isolated gates. In this work, we put forward a novel one, inspired by convolution, which provides greater freedom of nonlocal parameters. Although quantum counterparts of convolution have been shown not to exist for pure states, several attempts with various degrees of rigorousness have been proposed for mixed states. In this work, we follow the approach based on coherifications of multi-stochastic operations and demonstrate a surprising connection to gates with high entangling power. In particular, we identify conditions necessary for the convolutional channels constructed using our method to possess maximal entangling power. Furthermore, we establish new, continuous classes of bipartite 2-unitary matrices of dimension d 2 for d = 7 and d = 9 , with 2 and 4 free nonlocal parameters beyond simple phasing of matrix elements, corresponding to perfect tensors of rank 4 or 4-partite absolutely maximally entangled states.