Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0506121

Comment on quant-ph/0506105: The modified Grover algorithm cannot speedup unsorted database search

Long, Gui Lu

Published Jun 15, 2005• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a recent paper (quant-ph/0506105), A S Gupta, M. Gupta and A. Pathak proposed a modified Grover algorithm that would exponentially accelerate the unsorted database search problem if the number of marked items is known. If this were true, it would represent a major fundamental breakthrough in computer science, mathematics, quantum information and other related branches of sciences. However the algorithm is not valid. We will explain it in this brief comment.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0506121

Related papers

Comments on quant-ph/0506137: Fast quantum search algorithms by qubit comparisons exploiting global phase interference

Luis Antônio Brasil Kowada, Celina M.H. de Figueiredo, Renato Portugal +1 more

Recently, Andreas de Vries proposed a quantum algorithm that would find an element in an unsorted database exponentially faster than Grover's algorithm. We show that de Vries' algorithm does not work as intended and does not give any clue about the position of the searched element.

arXiv:quant-ph/0507125•Jul 13, 2005•0 citations

The Quadratic Leap: How Grover's Algorithm is Redefining Core Problems in Computer Science and Engineering

Palaganti Venkata Nagendra Sai Sandeep

Grover's algorithm stands as a cornerstone of quantum computing, offering a theoretical quadratic speedup for unstructured search problems. This allows for finding a target item in an unsorted database of N entries in approximately the square root of N steps, a significant improvement over classical algorithms which require a number of operations on the order of N in the worst case. This speedup becomes particularly compelling for very large datasets, where classical exhaustive search becomes computationally intractable. The algorithm achieves this by leveraging fundamental quantum mechanical principles, primarily superposition and interference. It operates by preparing qubits in a uniform superposition of all possible states, then iteratively applying a quantum oracle to mark the desired state by flipping its phase, followed by a diffusion operator that amplifies the probability of the marked state. Despite its theoretical promise, real-world implementation faces substantial challenges stemming from Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware, which is characterized by high error rates and short coherence times. Consequently, achieving a true, scalable quantum advantage remains a future endeavor, contingent on significant hardware advancements. Nevertheless, Grover's algorithm holds significant potential across diverse fields, including enhancing brute-force attacks on cryptographic systems, accelerating solutions for optimization problems, and speeding up search processes in machine learning and unstructured database queries.

•Aug 2, 2025•2 citations

A summary on two new algorithms for Grover's unsorted database search problem

Shang Bin

In this summary we discuss two new algorithms for Grover's unsorted database search problem that claimed to have reached exponential speedup over Grover's original algorithm. One is in the quantum setting with "power queries" that allow for exponential reduction in the number of queries over Grover's original algorithm with "bit queries". The other is to use "dubit queries" on a duality computer - a new computing model uses a quantum system's wave-particle duality, which is able to achieve even greater computing power and better capability than existent quantum computers we have been discussing. We discuss the shortages and difficulties of both schemes as well.

arXiv:quant-ph/0603210•Mar 23, 2006•2 citations

Quantum search by local adiabatic evolution

Jérémie Roland, Nicolas J. Cerf

The adiabatic theorem has been recently used to design quantum algorithms of a new kind, where the quantum computer evolves slowly enough so that it remains near its instantaneous ground state, which tends to the solution. We apply this time-dependent Hamiltonian approach to Grover's problem, i.e., searching a marked item in an unstructured database. We find that by adjusting the evolution rate of the Hamiltonian so as to keep the evolution adiabatic on each infinitesimal time interval, the total running time is of order $\sqrt{N},$ where N is the number of items in the database. We thus recover the advantage of Grover's standard algorithm as compared to a classical search, scaling as N. This is in contrast with the constant-rate adiabatic approach of Farhi et al. (e-print quant-ph/0001106), where the requirement of adiabaticity is expressed only globally, resulting in a time of order N.

arXiv:quant-ph/0107015•Physical Review A•Mar 26, 2002•629 citations

A Review of Grover's Search Algorithm: Applications and Modifications

Ela Demirci, Emre Atlıer Olca

This study investigates the applications and adaptations of the Grover's search algorithm, an algorithm that uses quantum technologies to provide quadratic speedup while searching unsorted data. Through extensive literature review, the applications of Grover's algorithm such as database search, machine learning, cryptography, and optimization is explored in order to further understand areas open to alteration in the algorithm. Visuals are provided with the aim of enhancing the comprehension of Grover's algorithm. This study underscores how various components of Grover's search-like the oracle, diffusion operator, and iteration count-can be modified to solve complex problems more efficiently than classical search algorithms. A table generalizing aspects of modification and each of their benefits is given as an output. The growing importance of quantum technologies and the United Nations' selection of 2025 as the International Year of Quantum Science and Technology makes this research timely.

International Artificial Intelligence and Data Processing Symposium (IDAP)•Sep 6, 2025•3 citations

Improved quantum multi-object search algorithm

Wei-Yun Ma

Grover’s quantum mechanical search algorithm solves the unsorted database search with quadratic speed-up over the classical algorithms.But Grover’s algorithm will be inefficient when the number of matching is close to 2n/2.This paper presents a quantum algorithm which can get a target item with certainty by a single query when the number of the target items is more than a quarter.

Computer Engineering and Applications Journal•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations
In a recent paper (quant-ph/0506105), A S Gupta, M. Gupta and A. Pathak proposed a modified Grover algorithm that would exponentially accelerate the unsorted database search problem if the number of marked items is known. If this were true, it would represent a major fundamental breakthrough in computer science, mathematics, quantum information and other related branches of sciences. However the algorithm is not valid. We will explain it in this brief comment.
Grover's algorithm stands as a cornerstone of quantum computing, offering a theoretical quadratic speedup for unstructured search problems. This allows for finding a target item in an unsorted database of N entries in approximately the square root of N steps, a significant improvement over classical algorithms which require a number of operations on the order of N in the worst case. This speedup becomes particularly compelling for very large datasets, where classical exhaustive search becomes computationally intractable. The algorithm achieves this by leveraging fundamental quantum mechanical principles, primarily superposition and interference. It operates by preparing qubits in a uniform superposition of all possible states, then iteratively applying a quantum oracle to mark the desired state by flipping its phase, followed by a diffusion operator that amplifies the probability of the marked state. Despite its theoretical promise, real-world implementation faces substantial challenges stemming from Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware, which is characterized by high error rates and short coherence times. Consequently, achieving a true, scalable quantum advantage remains a future endeavor, contingent on significant hardware advancements. Nevertheless, Grover's algorithm holds significant potential across diverse fields, including enhancing brute-force attacks on cryptographic systems, accelerating solutions for optimization problems, and speeding up search processes in machine learning and unstructured database queries.
In this summary we discuss two new algorithms for Grover's unsorted database search problem that claimed to have reached exponential speedup over Grover's original algorithm. One is in the quantum setting with "power queries" that allow for exponential reduction in the number of queries over Grover's original algorithm with "bit queries". The other is to use "dubit queries" on a duality computer - a new computing model uses a quantum system's wave-particle duality, which is able to achieve even greater computing power and better capability than existent quantum computers we have been discussing. We discuss the shortages and difficulties of both schemes as well.
The adiabatic theorem has been recently used to design quantum algorithms of a new kind, where the quantum computer evolves slowly enough so that it remains near its instantaneous ground state, which tends to the solution. We apply this time-dependent Hamiltonian approach to Grover's problem, i.e., searching a marked item in an unstructured database. We find that by adjusting the evolution rate of the Hamiltonian so as to keep the evolution adiabatic on each infinitesimal time interval, the total running time is of order N,\sqrt{N},N​, where N is the number of items in the database. We thus recover the advantage of Grover's standard algorithm as compared to a classical search, scaling as N. This is in contrast with the constant-rate adiabatic approach of Farhi et al. (e-print quant-ph/0001106), where the requirement of adiabaticity is expressed only globally, resulting in a time of order N.
This study investigates the applications and adaptations of the Grover's search algorithm, an algorithm that uses quantum technologies to provide quadratic speedup while searching unsorted data. Through extensive literature review, the applications of Grover's algorithm such as database search, machine learning, cryptography, and optimization is explored in order to further understand areas open to alteration in the algorithm. Visuals are provided with the aim of enhancing the comprehension of Grover's algorithm. This study underscores how various components of Grover's search-like the oracle, diffusion operator, and iteration count-can be modified to solve complex problems more efficiently than classical search algorithms. A table generalizing aspects of modification and each of their benefits is given as an output. The growing importance of quantum technologies and the United Nations' selection of 2025 as the International Year of Quantum Science and Technology makes this research timely.