Peer review Bell's Theorem - The Naive View of an Experimentalist Alain Aspect
Livolsi Edoardo
This work presents a critical peer review of Alain Aspect's Bell's Theorem: The Naive View of an Experimentalist from the perspective of foundational theoretical physics. While recognizing the manuscript as a landmark historical and experimental contribution to quantum optics, the review examines its underlying logical architecture rather than its experimental methodology. It is argued that the central ingredients of the analysis—including the entangled state, hidden variables, probability measure, locality condition, subsystem separability, and wavefunction collapse—are introduced as axiomatic assumptions rather than derived from a more fundamental physical principle. Consequently, the observed violation of Bell inequalities establishes the incompatibility of quantum mechanics with a restricted class of local hidden-variable theories, but does not uniquely determine the ontological structure of physical reality. The review distinguishes experimental validation from foundational derivation and emphasizes that alternative theoretical architectures based on globally coherent fields or emergent non-separable dynamics remain logically outside the scope of Bell's theorem. The manuscript is therefore assessed as an outstanding experimental milestone whose foundational conclusions remain structurally incomplete.
•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations