Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0302146

Can quantum imaging be classically simulated?

Milena D’Angelo, Yanhua H. Shih

Published Feb 19, 2003• 16 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum imaging has been demonstrated since 1995 by using entangled photon pairs. The physics community named these experiments "ghost image", "quantum crypto-FAX", "ghost interference", etc. Recently, Bennink et al. simulated the "ghost" imaging experiment by two co-rotating k-vector correlated lasers. Did the classical simulation simulate the quantum aspect of the "ghost" image? We wish to provide an answer. In fact, the simulation is very similar to a historical model of local realism. The goal of this article is to clarify the different physics behind the two types of experiments and address the fundamental issues of quantum theory that EPR was concerned with since 1935.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0302146

Related papers

Resolution of quantum and classical ghost imaging

Milena D’Angelo, Alejandra Valencia, Morton H. Rubin +1 more

The quantum ghost imaging phenomena, experimentally demonstrated a decade ago, exploited the apparent spooky action at a distance of entangled photon pairs and offered a novel approach toward imaging. Can ghost imaging effects be produced by ``classical'' light sources, such as separable systems of photon pairs or thermal light? If so, can these sources achieve the same accuracy achieved by entangled states? In order to answer these questions, we formulate the different physics behind entangled and separable systems in terms of a set of inequalities derived from the historical argument of Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen. We show that the ghost images produced by separable sources are subject to the standard statistical limitations. However, entangled states offer the possibility of overcoming such limitations. Imaging can, therefore, achieve its fundamental limit through the high spatial resolution and nonlocal behavior of entangled systems.

Physical Review A•Jul 14, 2005•103 citations

The Physics of Ghost Imaging

Yanhua H. Shih

One of the most surprising consequences of quantum mechanics is the nonlocal multi-particle interference observable in joint-detection of distant particle-detectors. Ghost imaging is one of such phenomena. Two types of ghost imaging have been experimentally demonstrated since 1995. Type-one ghost imaging uses entangled photon pairs as the light source. The nonlocal point-to-point image-forming correlation is the result of a constructive-destructive superposition among a large number of biphoton amplitudes, a nonclassical entity corresponding to different yet indistinguishable alternative ways of producing a joint-detction event between distant photodetectors. Type-two ghost imaging uses chaotic-thermal light. The type-two image-forming correlation is the result of interferences between paired two-photon amplitudes, corresponding to two different yet indistinguishable alternative ways of triggering a join-detection event by two independent photons. A great deal of confusion about ghost imaging comes from "ghost shadow". Similar to x-ray photography, a ghost shadow can be made in coincidences by "blocking-partial blocking-unblocking" of either co-rotating laser beams or classically correlated "speckles". "Ghost shadow" is indeed a classical phenomenon. The physics of ghost imaging, however, is fundamentally different. This article is aimed at exploring the nonlocal two-photon interference nature of ghost imaging.

arXiv:0805.1166•May 7, 2008•16 citations

Quantum imaging

Milena D’Angelo, Yanhua H. Shih

Since the early days of quantum mechanics, physicists have been puzzled by the counterintuitive consequences of entanglement. Quantum imaging is one of the most intriguing effects exhibiting the typical nonlocal behavior of entangled states and has in fact stimulated an intense debate regarding fundamental issues of quantum theory. Recently, particular attention has been given to the possibility of simulating quantum imaging classically, that is, without entanglement. The study of quantum imaging has also lead to useful practical applications such as high precision nonlocal timing-positioning and quantum lithography, in which measurements may achieve resolution even beyond the classical limits. In this paper, we first introduce the concept of quantum imaging and emphasize its peculiar quantum nature through a set of inequalities derived from the historical argument of Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR). The EPR inequalities are the quantitative formulation of the very different physics governing entangled and separable systems. We show that two-photon imaging may achieve its fundamental limit only through nonlocal measurements realized on entangled photon pairs. Furthermore, we show that quantum imaging may be exploited to overcome the Rayleigh diffraction limit; this is the basic idea behind quantum lithography. Finally, we discuss the possibility of extending the coherent two-photon imaging typical of entangled photon pairs to incoherent coincidence imaging, by employing chaotic light. From an applicative viewpoint, chaotic radiation may represent the ideal candidate for mimicking quantum ghost imaging, provided adequate detection schemes are developed.

Laser Physics Letters•Sep 16, 2005•133 citations

The physics of ghost imaging

Yanhua H. Shih

One of the most surprising consequences of quantum mechanics is the nonlocal behavior of a multi-particle system. Although questions regarding fundamental issues of quantum theory still exist, nonclassical surprises have started to play important roles in practical applications. Ghost imaging is one of these exciting areas. Two types of ghost imaging have been experimentally demonstrated since 1995. Type-one ghost imaging uses entangled photon pairs and type-two ghost imaging uses chaotic light. The unique point-to-point image-forming correlation between the object and image planes in ghost imaging is the result of a constructive-destructive interference which involves the nonlocal superposition of two-photon amplitudes, a nonclassical entity corresponding to different yet indistinguishable alternative ways of triggering a joint-detection event. This talk will explore and analyze the quantum nature of ghost imaging. It is true that classical challenges have never stopped. Quantum? Classical? A hot debate is currently focused on ghost imaging. This talk will defend the quantum mechanical point of view.

International Conference on Quantum Information•Jan 1, 2008•15 citations

Quantum Imaging

Yanhua H. Shih

One of the most surprising consequences of quantum mechanics is the entanglement of two or more distant particles. Although questions regarding fundamental issues of quantum theory still exist, quantum entanglement has started to play important roles in practical engineering applications. Quantum imaging is one of these exciting areas. Quantum imaging has demonstrated two peculiar features: (1) reproducing ghost images in a nonlocal manner, and (2) enhancing the spatial resolution of imaging beyond the diffraction limit. In this article, we start with the review of classical imaging to establish the basic concepts and formalisms of imaging. We then analyze two-photon imaging with particular emphasis on the physics of spatial resolution enhancement and the ghost imaging phenomenon.

•Jul 2, 2007•0 citations

Quantum and Classical Coincidence Imaging

Ryan S. Bennink, Sean J. Bentley, Robert W. Boyd +1 more

Coincidence, or ghost, imaging is a technique that uses two correlated optical fields to form an image of an object. In this work we identify aspects of coincidence imaging which can be performed with classically correlated light sources and aspects which require quantum entanglement. We find that entangled photons allow high-contrast, high-resolution imaging to be performed at any distance from the light source. We demonstrate this fact by forming ghost images in the near and far fields of an entangled photon source, noting that the product of the resolutions of these images is a factor of 3 better than that which is allowed by classical diffraction theory.

Physical Review Letters•Jan 22, 2004•417 citations
Quantum imaging has been demonstrated since 1995 by using entangled photon pairs. The physics community named these experiments "ghost image", "quantum crypto-FAX", "ghost interference", etc. Recently, Bennink et al. simulated the "ghost" imaging experiment by two co-rotating k-vector correlated lasers. Did the classical simulation simulate the quantum aspect of the "ghost" image? We wish to provide an answer. In fact, the simulation is very similar to a historical model of local realism. The goal of this article is to clarify the different physics behind the two types of experiments and address the fundamental issues of quantum theory that EPR was concerned with since 1935.
The quantum ghost imaging phenomena, experimentally demonstrated a decade ago, exploited the apparent spooky action at a distance of entangled photon pairs and offered a novel approach toward imaging. Can ghost imaging effects be produced by ``classical'' light sources, such as separable systems of photon pairs or thermal light? If so, can these sources achieve the same accuracy achieved by entangled states? In order to answer these questions, we formulate the different physics behind entangled and separable systems in terms of a set of inequalities derived from the historical argument of Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen. We show that the ghost images produced by separable sources are subject to the standard statistical limitations. However, entangled states offer the possibility of overcoming such limitations. Imaging can, therefore, achieve its fundamental limit through the high spatial resolution and nonlocal behavior of entangled systems.
One of the most surprising consequences of quantum mechanics is the nonlocal multi-particle interference observable in joint-detection of distant particle-detectors. Ghost imaging is one of such phenomena. Two types of ghost imaging have been experimentally demonstrated since 1995. Type-one ghost imaging uses entangled photon pairs as the light source. The nonlocal point-to-point image-forming correlation is the result of a constructive-destructive superposition among a large number of biphoton amplitudes, a nonclassical entity corresponding to different yet indistinguishable alternative ways of producing a joint-detction event between distant photodetectors. Type-two ghost imaging uses chaotic-thermal light. The type-two image-forming correlation is the result of interferences between paired two-photon amplitudes, corresponding to two different yet indistinguishable alternative ways of triggering a join-detection event by two independent photons. A great deal of confusion about ghost imaging comes from "ghost shadow". Similar to x-ray photography, a ghost shadow can be made in coincidences by "blocking-partial blocking-unblocking" of either co-rotating laser beams or classically correlated "speckles". "Ghost shadow" is indeed a classical phenomenon. The physics of ghost imaging, however, is fundamentally different. This article is aimed at exploring the nonlocal two-photon interference nature of ghost imaging.
Since the early days of quantum mechanics, physicists have been puzzled by the counterintuitive consequences of entanglement. Quantum imaging is one of the most intriguing effects exhibiting the typical nonlocal behavior of entangled states and has in fact stimulated an intense debate regarding fundamental issues of quantum theory. Recently, particular attention has been given to the possibility of simulating quantum imaging classically, that is, without entanglement. The study of quantum imaging has also lead to useful practical applications such as high precision nonlocal timing-positioning and quantum lithography, in which measurements may achieve resolution even beyond the classical limits. In this paper, we first introduce the concept of quantum imaging and emphasize its peculiar quantum nature through a set of inequalities derived from the historical argument of Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR). The EPR inequalities are the quantitative formulation of the very different physics governing entangled and separable systems. We show that two-photon imaging may achieve its fundamental limit only through nonlocal measurements realized on entangled photon pairs. Furthermore, we show that quantum imaging may be exploited to overcome the Rayleigh diffraction limit; this is the basic idea behind quantum lithography. Finally, we discuss the possibility of extending the coherent two-photon imaging typical of entangled photon pairs to incoherent coincidence imaging, by employing chaotic light. From an applicative viewpoint, chaotic radiation may represent the ideal candidate for mimicking quantum ghost imaging, provided adequate detection schemes are developed.
One of the most surprising consequences of quantum mechanics is the nonlocal behavior of a multi-particle system. Although questions regarding fundamental issues of quantum theory still exist, nonclassical surprises have started to play important roles in practical applications. Ghost imaging is one of these exciting areas. Two types of ghost imaging have been experimentally demonstrated since 1995. Type-one ghost imaging uses entangled photon pairs and type-two ghost imaging uses chaotic light. The unique point-to-point image-forming correlation between the object and image planes in ghost imaging is the result of a constructive-destructive interference which involves the nonlocal superposition of two-photon amplitudes, a nonclassical entity corresponding to different yet indistinguishable alternative ways of triggering a joint-detection event. This talk will explore and analyze the quantum nature of ghost imaging. It is true that classical challenges have never stopped. Quantum? Classical? A hot debate is currently focused on ghost imaging. This talk will defend the quantum mechanical point of view.
One of the most surprising consequences of quantum mechanics is the entanglement of two or more distant particles. Although questions regarding fundamental issues of quantum theory still exist, quantum entanglement has started to play important roles in practical engineering applications. Quantum imaging is one of these exciting areas. Quantum imaging has demonstrated two peculiar features: (1) reproducing ghost images in a nonlocal manner, and (2) enhancing the spatial resolution of imaging beyond the diffraction limit. In this article, we start with the review of classical imaging to establish the basic concepts and formalisms of imaging. We then analyze two-photon imaging with particular emphasis on the physics of spatial resolution enhancement and the ghost imaging phenomenon.
Coincidence, or ghost, imaging is a technique that uses two correlated optical fields to form an image of an object. In this work we identify aspects of coincidence imaging which can be performed with classically correlated light sources and aspects which require quantum entanglement. We find that entangled photons allow high-contrast, high-resolution imaging to be performed at any distance from the light source. We demonstrate this fact by forming ghost images in the near and far fields of an entangled photon source, noting that the product of the resolutions of these images is a factor of 3 better than that which is allowed by classical diffraction theory.