Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0206023

Tractability of Approximation for Weighted Korobov Spaces on Classical and Quantum Computers

Erich Novak, Ian H. Sloan, H. Woźniakowski

Published Jun 4, 2002• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The paper studies quantum complexity, tractability, and strong tractability for high dimensional multivariate approximation. We study a space of functions important in many applications. A function space is weighted if certain variables are more important than others; the weights show the relative importance of the variables. In an unweighted space all variables are equally important and multivariate approximation is intractable. We want to study when the complexity of multivariate approximation is independent of the number of variables and depends polynomially on 1/E. The main conclusions are: Multivariate approximation on a quantum computer can be solved roughly (1/E)^(1+r) times faster than on a classical computer using randomization. Here, r is a positive parameter that depends on the weights and may be large. This means that the speed-up of quantum over classical computers may be much larger than quadratic. Multivariate approximation on a quantum computer is exponentially faster than on a classical computer with a worst case assurance even if the sum of weights is infinite but a certain power of them is finite. We have designed a quantum algorithm with error at most E that uses about d+log(1/E) qubits. Hence, we have only linear dependence on the dimension d and logarithmic dependence on 1/E. Therefore, for some applications the number of qubits is quite modest.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/0206023

Related papers

Exponential convergence and tractability of multivariate integration for Korobov spaces

Josef Dick, Gerhard Larcher, Friedrich Pillichshammer +1 more

In this paper we study multivariate integration for a weighted Korobov space for which the Fourier coefficients of the functions decay exponentially fast. This implies that the functions of this space are infinitely times differentiable. Weights of the Korobov space monitor the influence of each variable and each group of variables. We show that there are numerical integration rules which achieve an exponential convergence of the worst-case integration error. We also investigate the dependence of the worst-case error on the number of variables s s , and show various tractability results under certain conditions on weights of the Korobov space. Tractability means that the dependence on s s is never exponential, and sometimes the dependence on s s is polynomial or there is no dependence on s s at all.

Mathematics of Computation•Nov 2, 2010•55 citations

A note on approximation in weighted Korobov spaces via multiple rank-1 lattices

Mou Cai, Takashi Goda

This paper studies the multivariate approximation of functions in weighted Korobov spaces using multiple rank-1 lattice rules. It has been shown by Kämmerer and Volkmer (2019) that algorithms based on multiple rank-1 lattices achieve the optimal convergence rate for the $L_{\infty}$ error in Wiener-type spaces, up to logarithmic factors. While this result was translated to weighted Korobov spaces in the recent monograph by Dick, Kritzer, and Pillichshammer (2022), the analysis requires the smoothness parameter $α$ to be greater than $1$ and is restricted to product weights. In this paper, we extend this result for multiple rank-1 lattice-based algorithms to the case where $1/2<α\le 1$ and for general weights, covering a broader range of periodic functions with low smoothness and general relative importance of variables. We also provide a summability condition on the weights to ensure strong polynomial tractability for any $α>1/2$. Furthermore, by incorporating random shifts into multiple rank-1 lattice-based algorithms, we prove that the resulting randomized algorithm achieves a nearly optimal convergence rate in terms of the worst-case root mean squared $L_2$ error, while retaining the same tractability property.

arXiv:2601.20290•Jan 28, 2026•0 citations

Contributions to Information-Based Complexity and to Quantum Computing

Petras, Iasonas

Multivariate continuous problems are widely encountered in physics, chemistry, finance and in computational sciences. Unfortunately, interesting real world multivariate continuous problems can almost never be solved analytically. As a result, they are typically solved numerically and therefore approximately. In this thesis we deal with the approximate solution of multivariate problems. The complexity of such problems in the classical setting has been extensively studied in the literature. On the other hand the quantum computational model presents a promising alternative for dealing with multivariate problems. The idea of using quantum mechanics to simulate quantum physics was initially proposed by Feynman in 1982. Its potential was demonstrated by Shor's integer factorization algorithm, which exponentially improves the cost of the best classical algorithm known. In the first part of this thesis we study the tractability of multivariate problems in the worst and average case settings using the real number model with oracles. We derive necessary and sufficient conditions for weak tractability for linear multivariate tensor product problems in those settings. More specifically, we initially study necessary and sufficient conditions for weak tractability on linear multivariate tensor product problems in the worst case setting under the absolute error criterion. The complexity of such problems depends on the rate of decay of the squares of the singular values of the solution operator for the univariate problem. We show a condition on the singular values that is sufficient for weak tractability. The same condition is known to be necessary for weak tractability. Then, we study linear multivariate tensor product problems in the average case setting under the absolute error criterion. The complexity of such problems depends on the rate of decay of the eigenvalues of the covariance operator of the induced measure of the one dimensional problem. We derive a necessary and sufficient condition on the eigenvalues for such problems to be weakly tractable but not polynomially tractable. In the second part of this thesis we study quantum algorithms for certain eigenvalue problems and the implementation and design of quantum circuits for a modification of the quantum NAND evaluation algorithm on k-ary trees, where k is a constant. First, we study quantum algorithms for the estimation of the ground state energy of the multivariate time-independent Schrodinger equation corresponding to a multiparticle system in a box. The dimension d of the problem depends linearly to the number of particles of the system. We design a quantum algorithm that approximates the lowest eigenvalue with relative error ε for a non-negative potential V, where V as well as its first order partial derivatives are continuous and uniformly bounded by one. The algorithm requires a number of quantum operations that depends polynomially on the inverse of the accuracy and linearly on the number of the particles of the system. We note that the cost of any classical deterministic algorithm grows exponentially in the number of particles. Thus we have an exponential speedup with respect to the dimension of the problem d, when compared to the classical deterministic case. We extend our results to convex non-negative potentials V, where V as well as its first order partial derivatives are continuous and uniformly bounded by constants C and C' respectively. The algorithm solves the eigenvalue problem for a sequence of convex potentials in order to obtain its final result. More specifically, the quantum algorithm estimates the ground state energy with relative error ε a number of quantum operations that depends polynomially on the inverse of the accuracy, the uniform bound C on the potential and the dimension d of the problem. In addition, we present a modification of the algorithm that produces a quantum state which approximates the ground state eigenvector of the discretized Hamiltonian within Δ. This algorithm requires a number of quantum operations that depends pollynomially on the inverse of ε, the inverse of Δ, the uniform bound C on the potential and the dimension d of the problem. Finally, we consider the algorithm by Ambainis et.al. that evaluates balanced binary NAND formulas. We design a quantum circuit that implements a modification of the algorithm for k-ary trees, where k is a constant. Furthermore, we design another quantum circuit that consists exclusively of Clifford and T gates. This circuit approximates the previous one with error ε using the Solovay-Kitaev algorithm.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Complexity of multivariate Feynman-Kac path integration in randomized and quantum settings

Marek Kwas

The Feynman-Kac path integration problem was studied in the worst case setting by Plaskota et al. (J. Comp. Phys. 164 (2000) 335) for the univariate case and by Kwas and Li (J. Comp. 19 (2003) 730) for the multivariate case with d space variables. In this paper we consider the multivariate Feynman-Kac path integration problem in the randomized and quantum settings. For smooth multivariate functions, it was proven in Kwas and Li (2003) that the classical worst case complexity suffers from the curse of dimensionality in d. We show that in both the randomized and quantum settings the curse of dimensionality is vanquished, i.e., the number of function evaluations and/or quantum queries required to compute an e-approximation has a bound independent of d and depending polynomially on 1/e. The exponents of these polynomials are at most 2 in the randomized setting and at most 1 in the quantum setting. Hence we have exponential speedup over the classical worst case setting and quadratic speedup of the quantum setting over the randomized setting. However, both the randomized and quantum algorithms presented here still require extensive precomputing, similar to the algorithms of Plaskota et al. (2000) and Kwas and Li(2003).

arXiv:quant-ph/0410134•Oct 18, 2004•9 citations

The power of standard information for multivariate approximation in the randomized setting

G.W. Wasilkowski, H. Woźniakowski

We study approximating multivariate functions from a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with the error between the function and its approximation measured in a weighted $L_2$-norm. We consider functions with an arbitrarily large number of variables, $d$, and we focus on the randomized setting with algorithms using standard information consisting of function values at randomly chosen points. We prove that standard information in the randomized setting is as powerful as linear information in the worst case setting. Linear information means that algorithms may use arbitrary continuous linear functionals, and by the power of information we mean the speed of convergence of the $n$th minimal errors, i.e., of the minimal errors among all algorithms using $n$ function evaluations. Previously, it was only known that standard information in the randomized setting is no more powerful than the linear information in the worst case setting. We also study (strong) tractability of multivariate approximation in the randomized setting. That is, we study when the minimal number of function evaluations needed to reduce the initial error by a factor $\varepsilon$ is polynomial in $\varepsilon ^{-1}$ (strong tractability), and polynomial in $d$ and $\varepsilon ^{-1}$ (tractability). We prove that these notions in the randomized setting for standard information are equivalent to the same notions in the worst case setting for linear information. This result is useful since for a number of important applications only standard information can be used and verifying (strong) tractability for standard information is in general difficult, whereas (strong) tractability in the worst case setting for linear information is known for many spaces and is relatively easy to check. We illustrate the tractability results for weighted Korobov spaces. In particular, we present necessary and sufficient conditions for strong tractability and tractability. For product weights independent of $d$, we prove that strong tractability is equivalent to tractability. We stress that all proofs are constructive. That is, we provide randomized algorithms that enjoy the maximal speed of convergence. We also exhibit randomized algorithms which achieve strong tractability and tractability error bounds.

Mathematics of Computation•Dec 13, 2006•34 citations

Complexity and tractability of the heat equation

Arthur G. Werschulz

In a previous paper, we developed a general framework for establishing tractability and strong tractability for quasilinear multivariate problems in the worst case setting. One important example of such a problem is the solution of the heat equation ut = ∆u − qu in Id × (0,T), where I is the unit inter- val and T is a maximum time value. This problem is to be solved subject to homogeneous Dirichlet boundary conditions, along with the initial conditions u(·,0) = f over Id. The solution u depends linearly on f, but nonlinearly on q. Here, both f and q are d-variate functions from a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with finite-order weights of order ω. This means that, although d can be arbitrary large, f and q can be decomposed as sums of functions of at most ω variables, with ω independent of d. In this paper, we apply our previous general results to the heat equation. We study both the absolute and normalized error criteria. For either error criterion, we show that the problem is . That is, the number of evaluations of f and q needed to obtain an ε-approximation is polynomial in ε and d, with the degree of the polynomial depending linearly on ω. In addition, we want to know when the problem is strongly tractable, meaning that the dependence is polynomial only in ε, independently of d. We show that if the sum of the weights defining the weighted reproducing kernel Hilbert space is uniformly bounded in d and the integral of the univariate kernel is positive, then the heat equation is strongly tractable

•Jan 1, 2006•1 citation
The paper studies quantum complexity, tractability, and strong tractability for high dimensional multivariate approximation. We study a space of functions important in many applications. A function space is weighted if certain variables are more important than others; the weights show the relative importance of the variables. In an unweighted space all variables are equally important and multivariate approximation is intractable. We want to study when the complexity of multivariate approximation is independent of the number of variables and depends polynomially on 1/E. The main conclusions are: Multivariate approximation on a quantum computer can be solved roughly (1/E)^(1+r) times faster than on a classical computer using randomization. Here, r is a positive parameter that depends on the weights and may be large. This means that the speed-up of quantum over classical computers may be much larger than quadratic. Multivariate approximation on a quantum computer is exponentially faster than on a classical computer with a worst case assurance even if the sum of weights is infinite but a certain power of them is finite. We have designed a quantum algorithm with error at most E that uses about d+log(1/E) qubits. Hence, we have only linear dependence on the dimension d and logarithmic dependence on 1/E. Therefore, for some applications the number of qubits is quite modest.
In this paper we study multivariate integration for a weighted Korobov space for which the Fourier coefficients of the functions decay exponentially fast. This implies that the functions of this space are infinitely times differentiable. Weights of the Korobov space monitor the influence of each variable and each group of variables. We show that there are numerical integration rules which achieve an exponential convergence of the worst-case integration error. We also investigate the dependence of the worst-case error on the number of variables s s , and show various tractability results under certain conditions on weights of the Korobov space. Tractability means that the dependence on s s is never exponential, and sometimes the dependence on s s is polynomial or there is no dependence on s s at all.
This paper studies the multivariate approximation of functions in weighted Korobov spaces using multiple rank-1 lattice rules. It has been shown by Kämmerer and Volkmer (2019) that algorithms based on multiple rank-1 lattices achieve the optimal convergence rate for the L∞L_{\infty}L∞​ error in Wiener-type spaces, up to logarithmic factors. While this result was translated to weighted Korobov spaces in the recent monograph by Dick, Kritzer, and Pillichshammer (2022), the analysis requires the smoothness parameter ααα to be greater than 111 and is restricted to product weights. In this paper, we extend this result for multiple rank-1 lattice-based algorithms to the case where 1/2<α≤11/2<α\le 11/2<α≤1 and for general weights, covering a broader range of periodic functions with low smoothness and general relative importance of variables. We also provide a summability condition on the weights to ensure strong polynomial tractability for any α>1/2α>1/2α>1/2. Furthermore, by incorporating random shifts into multiple rank-1 lattice-based algorithms, we prove that the resulting randomized algorithm achieves a nearly optimal convergence rate in terms of the worst-case root mean squared L2L_2L2​ error, while retaining the same tractability property.
Multivariate continuous problems are widely encountered in physics, chemistry, finance and in computational sciences. Unfortunately, interesting real world multivariate continuous problems can almost never be solved analytically. As a result, they are typically solved numerically and therefore approximately. In this thesis we deal with the approximate solution of multivariate problems. The complexity of such problems in the classical setting has been extensively studied in the literature. On the other hand the quantum computational model presents a promising alternative for dealing with multivariate problems. The idea of using quantum mechanics to simulate quantum physics was initially proposed by Feynman in 1982. Its potential was demonstrated by Shor's integer factorization algorithm, which exponentially improves the cost of the best classical algorithm known. In the first part of this thesis we study the tractability of multivariate problems in the worst and average case settings using the real number model with oracles. We derive necessary and sufficient conditions for weak tractability for linear multivariate tensor product problems in those settings. More specifically, we initially study necessary and sufficient conditions for weak tractability on linear multivariate tensor product problems in the worst case setting under the absolute error criterion. The complexity of such problems depends on the rate of decay of the squares of the singular values of the solution operator for the univariate problem. We show a condition on the singular values that is sufficient for weak tractability. The same condition is known to be necessary for weak tractability. Then, we study linear multivariate tensor product problems in the average case setting under the absolute error criterion. The complexity of such problems depends on the rate of decay of the eigenvalues of the covariance operator of the induced measure of the one dimensional problem. We derive a necessary and sufficient condition on the eigenvalues for such problems to be weakly tractable but not polynomially tractable. In the second part of this thesis we study quantum algorithms for certain eigenvalue problems and the implementation and design of quantum circuits for a modification of the quantum NAND evaluation algorithm on k-ary trees, where k is a constant. First, we study quantum algorithms for the estimation of the ground state energy of the multivariate time-independent Schrodinger equation corresponding to a multiparticle system in a box. The dimension d of the problem depends linearly to the number of particles of the system. We design a quantum algorithm that approximates the lowest eigenvalue with relative error ε for a non-negative potential V, where V as well as its first order partial derivatives are continuous and uniformly bounded by one. The algorithm requires a number of quantum operations that depends polynomially on the inverse of the accuracy and linearly on the number of the particles of the system. We note that the cost of any classical deterministic algorithm grows exponentially in the number of particles. Thus we have an exponential speedup with respect to the dimension of the problem d, when compared to the classical deterministic case. We extend our results to convex non-negative potentials V, where V as well as its first order partial derivatives are continuous and uniformly bounded by constants C and C' respectively. The algorithm solves the eigenvalue problem for a sequence of convex potentials in order to obtain its final result. More specifically, the quantum algorithm estimates the ground state energy with relative error ε a number of quantum operations that depends polynomially on the inverse of the accuracy, the uniform bound C on the potential and the dimension d of the problem. In addition, we present a modification of the algorithm that produces a quantum state which approximates the ground state eigenvector of the discretized Hamiltonian within Δ. This algorithm requires a number of quantum operations that depends pollynomially on the inverse of ε, the inverse of Δ, the uniform bound C on the potential and the dimension d of the problem. Finally, we consider the algorithm by Ambainis et.al. that evaluates balanced binary NAND formulas. We design a quantum circuit that implements a modification of the algorithm for k-ary trees, where k is a constant. Furthermore, we design another quantum circuit that consists exclusively of Clifford and T gates. This circuit approximates the previous one with error ε using the Solovay-Kitaev algorithm.
The Feynman-Kac path integration problem was studied in the worst case setting by Plaskota et al. (J. Comp. Phys. 164 (2000) 335) for the univariate case and by Kwas and Li (J. Comp. 19 (2003) 730) for the multivariate case with d space variables. In this paper we consider the multivariate Feynman-Kac path integration problem in the randomized and quantum settings. For smooth multivariate functions, it was proven in Kwas and Li (2003) that the classical worst case complexity suffers from the curse of dimensionality in d. We show that in both the randomized and quantum settings the curse of dimensionality is vanquished, i.e., the number of function evaluations and/or quantum queries required to compute an e-approximation has a bound independent of d and depending polynomially on 1/e. The exponents of these polynomials are at most 2 in the randomized setting and at most 1 in the quantum setting. Hence we have exponential speedup over the classical worst case setting and quadratic speedup of the quantum setting over the randomized setting. However, both the randomized and quantum algorithms presented here still require extensive precomputing, similar to the algorithms of Plaskota et al. (2000) and Kwas and Li(2003).
We study approximating multivariate functions from a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with the error between the function and its approximation measured in a weighted L2L_2L2​-norm. We consider functions with an arbitrarily large number of variables, ddd, and we focus on the randomized setting with algorithms using standard information consisting of function values at randomly chosen points. We prove that standard information in the randomized setting is as powerful as linear information in the worst case setting. Linear information means that algorithms may use arbitrary continuous linear functionals, and by the power of information we mean the speed of convergence of the nnnth minimal errors, i.e., of the minimal errors among all algorithms using nnn function evaluations. Previously, it was only known that standard information in the randomized setting is no more powerful than the linear information in the worst case setting. We also study (strong) tractability of multivariate approximation in the randomized setting. That is, we study when the minimal number of function evaluations needed to reduce the initial error by a factor ε\varepsilonε is polynomial in ε−1\varepsilon ^{-1}ε−1 (strong tractability), and polynomial in ddd and ε−1\varepsilon ^{-1}ε−1 (tractability). We prove that these notions in the randomized setting for standard information are equivalent to the same notions in the worst case setting for linear information. This result is useful since for a number of important applications only standard information can be used and verifying (strong) tractability for standard information is in general difficult, whereas (strong) tractability in the worst case setting for linear information is known for many spaces and is relatively easy to check. We illustrate the tractability results for weighted Korobov spaces. In particular, we present necessary and sufficient conditions for strong tractability and tractability. For product weights independent of ddd, we prove that strong tractability is equivalent to tractability. We stress that all proofs are constructive. That is, we provide randomized algorithms that enjoy the maximal speed of convergence. We also exhibit randomized algorithms which achieve strong tractability and tractability error bounds.
In a previous paper, we developed a general framework for establishing tractability and strong tractability for quasilinear multivariate problems in the worst case setting. One important example of such a problem is the solution of the heat equation ut = ∆u − qu in Id × (0,T), where I is the unit inter- val and T is a maximum time value. This problem is to be solved subject to homogeneous Dirichlet boundary conditions, along with the initial conditions u(·,0) = f over Id. The solution u depends linearly on f, but nonlinearly on q. Here, both f and q are d-variate functions from a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with finite-order weights of order ω. This means that, although d can be arbitrary large, f and q can be decomposed as sums of functions of at most ω variables, with ω independent of d. In this paper, we apply our previous general results to the heat equation. We study both the absolute and normalized error criteria. For either error criterion, we show that the problem is . That is, the number of evaluations of f and q needed to obtain an ε-approximation is polynomial in ε and d, with the degree of the polynomial depending linearly on ω. In addition, we want to know when the problem is strongly tractable, meaning that the dependence is polynomial only in ε, independently of d. We show that if the sum of the weights defining the weighted reproducing kernel Hilbert space is uniformly bounded in d and the integral of the univariate kernel is positive, then the heat equation is strongly tractable