Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/0111076 · International Journal of Theoretical Physics

The Sasaki Hook Is Not a [Static] Implicative Connective but Induces a Backward [in Time] Dynamic One That Assigns Causes

Bob Coecke, Sonja Smets

Published Aug 1, 2004• 39 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1023/b:ijtp.0000048815.92983.6e

Related papers

Why is the Sasaki Hook not a Static Implication within Quantum Logic

Sonja Smets, Diederik Aerts, Serge Gutwirth

•Jan 1, 2002•0 citations

On Causation and a Counterfactual in Operational Quantum Logic: The Sasaki Hook

Sonja Smets

•Jan 1, 2002•0 citations

On Causation and a Counterfactual in Quantum Logic: The Sasaki Hook

Sonja Smets

We analyze G.M. Hardegree's interpretation of the Sasaki hook as a Stalnaker conditional and explain how he makes use of the basic conceptual machinery of OQL, i.e. the operational quantum logic which originated with the Geneva Approach to the foundations of physics. In particular we focus on measurements which are ideal and of the first kind, since these encode the content of the so-called Sasaki projections within the Geneva Approach. The Sasaki projections play a fundamental role when analyzing the condition under which the properties expressed by Sasaki hooks can be considered as actual. We finish with a note on how the Sasaki hook can be conceived as ``assigning causes for properties to be actual", which links the interpretation of G.M. Hardegree to what has been called ``dynamic OQL".

Logique et analyse/Logique et analyse. Nouvelle série•Apr 1, 2002•14 citations

Nondeterminism can be causal

Michael J. Manthey

International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Oct 1, 1984•4 citations

Why delayed choice experiments do Not imply retrocausality

David Ellerman

Quantum Studies Mathematics and Foundations•Jan 20, 2015•21 citations

Implications of Relativistically Consistent Wave Function Collapse

Allan Goff, Dale Lehmann, Joel Siegel

In the current formalism of quantum mechanics, collapse of the wave function is envisioned as occurring “instantaneously”. Since this is in conflict with the fact that “simultaneity” is not a relativistic invariant, quantum mechanics and relativity are in conflict with each another. This conflict is benign as long as faster-than-light (FTL) phenomena are disallowed. This paper explores this conflict and considers the implications if collapse can be specified to occur in a way that is consistent with relativity. In particular, relativistically consistent wave function collapse forces us to reconsider our preconceptions of causality. We are led to consider two cases; timelike and spacelike. For two events that are causally connected by a timelike interval, the earlier-in-time event is the cause in all reference frames, but the spatial ordering is not preserved. For two events that are causally connected by a spacelike interval, the temporal ordering is not preserved but the spatial ordering is, just the reverse. This is philosophically disturbing since for spacelike causes half the reference frames see the cause as proceeding backwards in time. However, in and of itself this is not logically inconsistent. Backwards-in-Time Causality (BTC) seems at first glance to permit temporal paradox, since two spacelike causal connections can be used to create a closed causal loop in spacetime. While temporal paradox is logically inconsistent, BTC can still be allowed if there is also a censor mechanism that prevents temporal paradox. In relativity, FTL and BTC are two sides of the same coin, so the major implication of relativistically consistent wave function collapse is that quantum systems should be able to support both FTL and BTC phenomena despite Eberhard’s “proof.”

AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference & Exhibit (JPC)•Jul 9, 2006•6 citations
We analyze G.M. Hardegree's interpretation of the Sasaki hook as a Stalnaker conditional and explain how he makes use of the basic conceptual machinery of OQL, i.e. the operational quantum logic which originated with the Geneva Approach to the foundations of physics. In particular we focus on measurements which are ideal and of the first kind, since these encode the content of the so-called Sasaki projections within the Geneva Approach. The Sasaki projections play a fundamental role when analyzing the condition under which the properties expressed by Sasaki hooks can be considered as actual. We finish with a note on how the Sasaki hook can be conceived as ``assigning causes for properties to be actual", which links the interpretation of G.M. Hardegree to what has been called ``dynamic OQL".
In the current formalism of quantum mechanics, collapse of the wave function is envisioned as occurring “instantaneously”. Since this is in conflict with the fact that “simultaneity” is not a relativistic invariant, quantum mechanics and relativity are in conflict with each another. This conflict is benign as long as faster-than-light (FTL) phenomena are disallowed. This paper explores this conflict and considers the implications if collapse can be specified to occur in a way that is consistent with relativity. In particular, relativistically consistent wave function collapse forces us to reconsider our preconceptions of causality. We are led to consider two cases; timelike and spacelike. For two events that are causally connected by a timelike interval, the earlier-in-time event is the cause in all reference frames, but the spatial ordering is not preserved. For two events that are causally connected by a spacelike interval, the temporal ordering is not preserved but the spatial ordering is, just the reverse. This is philosophically disturbing since for spacelike causes half the reference frames see the cause as proceeding backwards in time. However, in and of itself this is not logically inconsistent. Backwards-in-Time Causality (BTC) seems at first glance to permit temporal paradox, since two spacelike causal connections can be used to create a closed causal loop in spacetime. While temporal paradox is logically inconsistent, BTC can still be allowed if there is also a censor mechanism that prevents temporal paradox. In relativity, FTL and BTC are two sides of the same coin, so the major implication of relativistically consistent wave function collapse is that quantum systems should be able to support both FTL and BTC phenomena despite Eberhard’s “proof.”