Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:physics/9610024 · Journal of Modern Optics

Accuracy of sampling quantum phase space in a photon counting experiment

Konrad Banaszek, Krzysztof Wódkiewicz

Published Nov 1, 1997• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the accuracy of determining the phase space quasi-distribution of a single quantized light mode by a photon counting experiment. We derive an exact analytical formula for the error of the experimental outcome. This result provides an estimate of the experimental parameters, such as the number of events, required to determine the quasi-distribution with assumed precision. Our analysis also shows that it is, in general, not possible to compensate for the imperfection of the photodetector in the numerical processing of the experimental data. The discussion is illustrated with Monte Carlo simulations of the photon counting experiment for the coherent state, the one photon Fock state, and the Schrödinger cat state.

DOI
10.1080/09500349708231893

Related papers

Statistical uncertainty in quantum-optical photodetection measurements

Konrad Banaszek

We present a complete statistical analysis of quantum-optical measurement schemes based on photodetection. Statistical distributions of quantum observables determined from a finite number of experimental runs are analytically characterized with the help of the generating function, which is derived using the exact statistical description of raw experimental outcomes. We use the developed formalism to point out that the statistical uncertainty results in substantial limitations on the information determined about the quantum state; although a family of observables characterizing the quantum state can be safely evaluated from experimental data, its further use to obtain the expectation value of some operators generates exploding statistical errors. These issues are discussed using the example of phase-insensitive measurements of a single light mode. We study reconstruction of the photon number distribution from photon counting and from random-phase homodyne detection. We show that utilization of the reconstructed distribution to evaluate a simple well behaved observable, namely the parity operator, encounters difficulties owing to accumulation of statistical errors. As the parity operator yields the Wigner function at the phase space origin, this example also demonstrates that transformation between various experimentally determined representations of the quantum state is quite a delicate matter.

arXiv:quant-ph/9801059•Journal of Modern Optics•Mar 1, 1999•7 citations

Statistical uncertainty in quantum-optical photodetection measurements

Konrad Banaszek

We present a complete statistical analysis of quantum-optical measurement schemes based on photodetection. Statistical distributions of quantum observables determined from a finite number of experimental runs are analytically characterized with the help of the generating function, which is derived using the exact statistical description of raw experimental outcomes. We use the developed formalism to point out that the statistical uncertainty results in substantial limitations on the information determined about the quantum state; although a family of observables characterizing the quantum state can be safely evaluated from experimental data, its further use to obtain the expectation value of some operators generates exploding statistical errors. These issues are discussed using the example of phase-insensitive measurements of a single light mode. We study reconstruction of the photon number distribution from photon counting and from random-phase homodyne detection. We show that utilization of the reconstructed distribution to evaluate a simple well behaved observable, namely the parity operator, encounters difficulties owing to accumulation of statistical errors. As the parity operator yields the Wigner function at the phase space origin, this example also demonstrates that transformation between various experimentally determined representations of the quantum state is quite a delicate matter.

Journal of Modern Optics•Mar 20, 1999•1 citation

Statistical Uncertainty in Quantum Optical Photodetection Measurements

Konrad Banaszek

We present a complete statistical analysis of quantum optical measurement schemes based on photodetection. Statistical distributions of quantum observables determined from a finite number of experimental runs are characterized with the help of the generating function, which we derive using the exact statistical description of raw experimental outcomes. We use the developed formalism to point out that the statistical uncertainty results in substantial limitations of the determined information on the quantum state: though a family of observables characterizing the quantum state can be safely evaluated from experimental data, its further use to obtain the expectation value of some operators generates exploding statistical errors. These issues are discussed using the example of phase--insensitive measurements of a single light mode. We study reconstruction of the photon number distribution from photon counting and random phase homodyne detection. We show that utilization of the reconstruct...

•Jan 1, 1998•4 citations

Classical Simulation of Quantum Systems?

J. D. Franson

We provide general sufficient conditions for the efficient classical simulation of quantum-optics experiments that involve inputting states to a quantum process and making measurements at the output.The first condition is based on the negativity of phase-space quasiprobability distributions (PQDs) of the output state of the process and the output measurements; the second one is based on the negativity of PQDs of the input states, the output measurements, and the transition function associated with the process.We show that these conditions provide useful practical tools for investigating the effects of imperfections in implementations of boson sampling.In particular, we apply our formalism to boson-sampling experiments that use single-photon or spontaneous-parametric-down-conversion sources and on-off photodetectors.Considering simple models for loss and noise, we show that above some threshold for the probability of random counts in the photodetectors, these boson-sampling experiments are classically simulatable.We identify mode mismatching as the major source of error contributing to random counts and suggest that this is the chief challenge for implementations of boson sampling of interesting size.

Physics•Jun 20, 2016•2 citations

Estimation of photon counting statistics with imperfect detectors

Xiaochuan Han, Dongwei Zhuang, Yuxuan Li +2 more

The study on photon counting statistics is of fundamental importance in quantum optics. We theoretically analyzed the imperfect detection of an arbitrary quantum state. We derived photon counting formulae for six typical quantum states (i.e., Fock, coherent, squeeze-vacuum, thermal, odd and even coherent states) with finite quantum efficiencies and dark counts based on multiple on/off detector arrays. We applied the formulae to the simulation of multiphoton number detections and obtained both the simulated and ideal photon number distributions of each state. A comparison between the results by using the fidelity and relative entropy was carried out to evaluate the detection scheme and help select detectors for different quantum states.

Chinese Physics B•Jul 1, 2018•2 citations

Sufficient Conditions for Efficient Classical Simulation of Quantum Optics

Saleh Rahimi-Keshari, Timothy C. Ralph, Carlton M. Caves

We provide general sufficient conditions for the efficient classical simulation of quantum-optics experiments that involve inputting states to a quantum process and making measurements at the output. The first condition is based on the negativity of phase-space quasiprobability distributions (PQDs) of the output state of the process and the output measurements; the second one is based on the negativity of PQDs of the input states, the output measurements, and the transition function associated with the process. We show that these conditions provide useful practical tools for investigating the effects of imperfections in implementations of boson sampling. In particular, we apply our formalism to boson-sampling experiments that use single-photon or spontaneous-parametric-down-conversion sources and on-off photodetectors. Considering simple models for loss and noise, we show that above some threshold for the probability of random counts in the photodetectors, these boson-sampling experiments are classically simulatable. We identify mode mismatching as the major source of error contributing to random counts and suggest that this is the chief challenge for implementations of boson sampling of interesting size.

arXiv:1511.06526•Physical Review X•Jun 20, 2016•152 citations
We study the accuracy of determining the phase space quasi-distribution of a single quantized light mode by a photon counting experiment. We derive an exact analytical formula for the error of the experimental outcome. This result provides an estimate of the experimental parameters, such as the number of events, required to determine the quasi-distribution with assumed precision. Our analysis also shows that it is, in general, not possible to compensate for the imperfection of the photodetector in the numerical processing of the experimental data. The discussion is illustrated with Monte Carlo simulations of the photon counting experiment for the coherent state, the one photon Fock state, and the Schrödinger cat state.
We present a complete statistical analysis of quantum-optical measurement schemes based on photodetection. Statistical distributions of quantum observables determined from a finite number of experimental runs are analytically characterized with the help of the generating function, which is derived using the exact statistical description of raw experimental outcomes. We use the developed formalism to point out that the statistical uncertainty results in substantial limitations on the information determined about the quantum state; although a family of observables characterizing the quantum state can be safely evaluated from experimental data, its further use to obtain the expectation value of some operators generates exploding statistical errors. These issues are discussed using the example of phase-insensitive measurements of a single light mode. We study reconstruction of the photon number distribution from photon counting and from random-phase homodyne detection. We show that utilization of the reconstructed distribution to evaluate a simple well behaved observable, namely the parity operator, encounters difficulties owing to accumulation of statistical errors. As the parity operator yields the Wigner function at the phase space origin, this example also demonstrates that transformation between various experimentally determined representations of the quantum state is quite a delicate matter.
We present a complete statistical analysis of quantum-optical measurement schemes based on photodetection. Statistical distributions of quantum observables determined from a finite number of experimental runs are analytically characterized with the help of the generating function, which is derived using the exact statistical description of raw experimental outcomes. We use the developed formalism to point out that the statistical uncertainty results in substantial limitations on the information determined about the quantum state; although a family of observables characterizing the quantum state can be safely evaluated from experimental data, its further use to obtain the expectation value of some operators generates exploding statistical errors. These issues are discussed using the example of phase-insensitive measurements of a single light mode. We study reconstruction of the photon number distribution from photon counting and from random-phase homodyne detection. We show that utilization of the reconstructed distribution to evaluate a simple well behaved observable, namely the parity operator, encounters difficulties owing to accumulation of statistical errors. As the parity operator yields the Wigner function at the phase space origin, this example also demonstrates that transformation between various experimentally determined representations of the quantum state is quite a delicate matter.
We present a complete statistical analysis of quantum optical measurement schemes based on photodetection. Statistical distributions of quantum observables determined from a finite number of experimental runs are characterized with the help of the generating function, which we derive using the exact statistical description of raw experimental outcomes. We use the developed formalism to point out that the statistical uncertainty results in substantial limitations of the determined information on the quantum state: though a family of observables characterizing the quantum state can be safely evaluated from experimental data, its further use to obtain the expectation value of some operators generates exploding statistical errors. These issues are discussed using the example of phase--insensitive measurements of a single light mode. We study reconstruction of the photon number distribution from photon counting and random phase homodyne detection. We show that utilization of the reconstruct...
We provide general sufficient conditions for the efficient classical simulation of quantum-optics experiments that involve inputting states to a quantum process and making measurements at the output.The first condition is based on the negativity of phase-space quasiprobability distributions (PQDs) of the output state of the process and the output measurements; the second one is based on the negativity of PQDs of the input states, the output measurements, and the transition function associated with the process.We show that these conditions provide useful practical tools for investigating the effects of imperfections in implementations of boson sampling.In particular, we apply our formalism to boson-sampling experiments that use single-photon or spontaneous-parametric-down-conversion sources and on-off photodetectors.Considering simple models for loss and noise, we show that above some threshold for the probability of random counts in the photodetectors, these boson-sampling experiments are classically simulatable.We identify mode mismatching as the major source of error contributing to random counts and suggest that this is the chief challenge for implementations of boson sampling of interesting size.
The study on photon counting statistics is of fundamental importance in quantum optics. We theoretically analyzed the imperfect detection of an arbitrary quantum state. We derived photon counting formulae for six typical quantum states (i.e., Fock, coherent, squeeze-vacuum, thermal, odd and even coherent states) with finite quantum efficiencies and dark counts based on multiple on/off detector arrays. We applied the formulae to the simulation of multiphoton number detections and obtained both the simulated and ideal photon number distributions of each state. A comparison between the results by using the fidelity and relative entropy was carried out to evaluate the detection scheme and help select detectors for different quantum states.
We provide general sufficient conditions for the efficient classical simulation of quantum-optics experiments that involve inputting states to a quantum process and making measurements at the output. The first condition is based on the negativity of phase-space quasiprobability distributions (PQDs) of the output state of the process and the output measurements; the second one is based on the negativity of PQDs of the input states, the output measurements, and the transition function associated with the process. We show that these conditions provide useful practical tools for investigating the effects of imperfections in implementations of boson sampling. In particular, we apply our formalism to boson-sampling experiments that use single-photon or spontaneous-parametric-down-conversion sources and on-off photodetectors. Considering simple models for loss and noise, we show that above some threshold for the probability of random counts in the photodetectors, these boson-sampling experiments are classically simulatable. We identify mode mismatching as the major source of error contributing to random counts and suggest that this is the chief challenge for implementations of boson sampling of interesting size.