Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:hep-th/9405042 · Physical Review A

How interference effects in mixtures determine the rules of quantum mechanics

Daniel I. Fivel

Published Sep 1, 1994• 33 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is shown that the elementary indistinguishability properties of partially polarized mixtures are consistent only with the conventional Hilbert space model of quantum mechanics and a few exotic alternatives. This applies even in low dimensions where quantum logic and Gleason's theorem give either weak or no constraints. The experimental methods for eliminating the exotic cases (which include quaternionic and octonionic variants of quantum mechanics) are described.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.50.2108

Related papers

A Gleason-type theorem for qubits based on mixtures of projective measurements

Victoria J Wright, Stefan Weigert

Abstract We derive Born’s rule and the density-operator formalism for quantum systems with Hilbert spaces of dimension two or larger. Our extension of Gleason’s theorem only relies upon the consistent assignment of probabilities to the outcomes of projective measurements and their classical mixtures. This assumption is significantly weaker than those required for existing Gleason-type theorems valid in dimension two.

arXiv:1808.08091•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Dec 18, 2018•32 citations

Self-Similar Recursion Closes the Gleason Gap: Uniqueness of the Born Rule in Dimension Two

Graeme Fawcett

Gleason's theorem (1957) establishes that the Born rule is the unique probability measure on Hilbert spaces of dimension d ≥ 3. The restriction to d ≥ 3 is essential: in dimension 2, non-Born frame functions satisfy all of Gleason's constraints. This paper resolves the dimension-2 gap. On a self-similar binary tree — where every node is a two-way split mapping directly to the qubit case — we prove that cos²(πr/2) is the unique correlation function satisfying boundary conditions, monotonicity, positive-semidefinite composition consistency, and continuity. The ingredient closing the gap is self-similar recursion: the same function must satisfy the composition rule at every depth simultaneously, generating an infinite tower of constraints that eliminates all non-Born solutions. The proof uses no quantum mechanical assumptions, no Hilbert space structure, and no representation theory. An h-substitution reveals the composition rule to be the cosine addition identity, reducing the problem to Cauchy's functional equation with fixed endpoints. A universality corollary shows the result is independent of branching factor p for all primes p ≥ 2, establishing the Born rule as a topological consequence of self-similar hierarchical structure. Numerical verification via constraint propagation on finite-depth trees is included.

•Mar 14, 2026•0 citations

Indistinguishability and the external correlation of mixtures

Kirkpatrick, K. A.

Experimental evidence, the heuristics of indistinguishability, and its logical inconsistency with quantum formalism all argue against the existence of a quantum mixture uncorrelated with the exterior, that is, argue for the postulate "The state of a system uncorrelated with its exterior is pure." This is shown to be equivalent with "The state of a system describable in terms of indistinguishable pure states is pure," and with "The state of the universe is pure"; further, it yields a quantitative expression of the traditional relation of welcher Weg information to partial coherence. It is concluded that all mixtures are "improper," the trace-reduction of a composite system's pure state.

arXiv:quant-ph/0308160•Aug 28, 2003•1 citation

Born's Rule from Record-Formation Constraints: A Thermodynamic-Information Axiomatics

Moses Rahnama

We show the Born rule P = |ψ|² is the unique probability rule consistent with thermodynamic constraints on record formation, conditional on the regime where Landauer-type bounds apply. The derivation proceeds from five operational postulates: normalization, phase information loss in record formation, interference consistency, tensor product factorization, and continuity. The key physical insight is that creating a classical measurement record requires that phase information is not retained in the record accessible to observers, a not-reversible operation with entropy flow to the bath and Landauer cost k_B T ln 2 per bit. The squared modulus emerges as the unique probability rule that (i) eliminates phase to produce positive probabilities, (ii) preserves interference effects before measurement, and (iii) satisfies standard probability axioms. This thermodynamically motivated derivation complements Gleason's theorem: where Gleason proves the rule is mathematically necessary (dimension ≥ 3), we show it is the unique rule realizable through record formation under these constraints (all dimensions including d=2). The framework provides a concrete answer to "why squared?": the irreversible formation of a classical record, on a Hilbert space whose norm is preserved by unitary evolution, admits no other consistent probability rule.

•Mar 5, 2026•1 citation

Quantum Mechanics (Revisited)

The paper proposes a new approach in the foundations of Quantum Mechanics.It does not make any assumption about the physical world, but looks at the consequences of the formalism used in models.Whenever a system is represented by variables which meet precise, but common, mathematical properties, one can prove theorems which are very close to the axioms of Quantum Mechanics (Hilbert spaces, observables, eigen values,...).It is then possible to explore the conditions of the validity of these axioms and to give a firm ground to the usual computations.Moreover this approach sheds a new ligth on the issues of determism, and interacting systems.In the third edition of this paper developments have been added about the statistical procedures used to detect anomalies in Physical Laws.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 1, 2010•1 citation

Quantum Mechanics (Revisited)

Jean Claude Dutailly

The paper proposes a new approach in the foundations of Quantum Mechanics.It does not make any assumption about the physical world, but looks at the consequences of the formalism used in models.Whenever a system is represented by variables which meet precise, but common, mathematical properties, one can prove theorems which are very close to the axioms of Quantum Mechanics (Hilbert spaces, observables, eigen values,...).It is then possible to explore the conditions of the validity of these axioms and to give a firm ground to the usual computations.Moreover this approach sheds a new ligth on the issues of determism, and interacting systems.In the third edition of this paper developments have been added about the statistical procedures used to detect anomalies in Physical Laws.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 17, 2015•0 citations
It is shown that the elementary indistinguishability properties of partially polarized mixtures are consistent only with the conventional Hilbert space model of quantum mechanics and a few exotic alternatives. This applies even in low dimensions where quantum logic and Gleason's theorem give either weak or no constraints. The experimental methods for eliminating the exotic cases (which include quaternionic and octonionic variants of quantum mechanics) are described.
Gleason's theorem (1957) establishes that the Born rule is the unique probability measure on Hilbert spaces of dimension d ≥ 3. The restriction to d ≥ 3 is essential: in dimension 2, non-Born frame functions satisfy all of Gleason's constraints. This paper resolves the dimension-2 gap. On a self-similar binary tree — where every node is a two-way split mapping directly to the qubit case — we prove that cos²(πr/2) is the unique correlation function satisfying boundary conditions, monotonicity, positive-semidefinite composition consistency, and continuity. The ingredient closing the gap is self-similar recursion: the same function must satisfy the composition rule at every depth simultaneously, generating an infinite tower of constraints that eliminates all non-Born solutions. The proof uses no quantum mechanical assumptions, no Hilbert space structure, and no representation theory. An h-substitution reveals the composition rule to be the cosine addition identity, reducing the problem to Cauchy's functional equation with fixed endpoints. A universality corollary shows the result is independent of branching factor p for all primes p ≥ 2, establishing the Born rule as a topological consequence of self-similar hierarchical structure. Numerical verification via constraint propagation on finite-depth trees is included.
Experimental evidence, the heuristics of indistinguishability, and its logical inconsistency with quantum formalism all argue against the existence of a quantum mixture uncorrelated with the exterior, that is, argue for the postulate "The state of a system uncorrelated with its exterior is pure." This is shown to be equivalent with "The state of a system describable in terms of indistinguishable pure states is pure," and with "The state of the universe is pure"; further, it yields a quantitative expression of the traditional relation of welcher Weg information to partial coherence. It is concluded that all mixtures are "improper," the trace-reduction of a composite system's pure state.
We show the Born rule P = |ψ|² is the unique probability rule consistent with thermodynamic constraints on record formation, conditional on the regime where Landauer-type bounds apply. The derivation proceeds from five operational postulates: normalization, phase information loss in record formation, interference consistency, tensor product factorization, and continuity. The key physical insight is that creating a classical measurement record requires that phase information is not retained in the record accessible to observers, a not-reversible operation with entropy flow to the bath and Landauer cost k_B T ln 2 per bit. The squared modulus emerges as the unique probability rule that (i) eliminates phase to produce positive probabilities, (ii) preserves interference effects before measurement, and (iii) satisfies standard probability axioms. This thermodynamically motivated derivation complements Gleason's theorem: where Gleason proves the rule is mathematically necessary (dimension ≥ 3), we show it is the unique rule realizable through record formation under these constraints (all dimensions including d=2). The framework provides a concrete answer to "why squared?": the irreversible formation of a classical record, on a Hilbert space whose norm is preserved by unitary evolution, admits no other consistent probability rule.
The paper proposes a new approach in the foundations of Quantum Mechanics.It does not make any assumption about the physical world, but looks at the consequences of the formalism used in models.Whenever a system is represented by variables which meet precise, but common, mathematical properties, one can prove theorems which are very close to the axioms of Quantum Mechanics (Hilbert spaces, observables, eigen values,...).It is then possible to explore the conditions of the validity of these axioms and to give a firm ground to the usual computations.Moreover this approach sheds a new ligth on the issues of determism, and interacting systems.In the third edition of this paper developments have been added about the statistical procedures used to detect anomalies in Physical Laws.
The paper proposes a new approach in the foundations of Quantum Mechanics.It does not make any assumption about the physical world, but looks at the consequences of the formalism used in models.Whenever a system is represented by variables which meet precise, but common, mathematical properties, one can prove theorems which are very close to the axioms of Quantum Mechanics (Hilbert spaces, observables, eigen values,...).It is then possible to explore the conditions of the validity of these axioms and to give a firm ground to the usual computations.Moreover this approach sheds a new ligth on the issues of determism, and interacting systems.In the third edition of this paper developments have been added about the statistical procedures used to detect anomalies in Physical Laws.