Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:hep-th/0204006 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

Comment on $lquot$Relativistic extension of shape-invariant potentials$rquot$

Antonio S de Castro

Published Jul 12, 2002• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This comment criticizes the recently published approach of Alhaidari for solving relativistic problems. It is shown that his gauge considerations are inaccurate and that the class of exactly solvable relativistic problems is not as large as the author claims.
DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/35/29/404

Related papers

Comment on $lquot$Relativistic extension of shape invariant potentials$rquot$

Arvind Narayan Vaidya, R. de Lima Rodrigues

In this comment, we point out numerous errors in the paper of Alhaidari cited in the title.

arXiv:hep-th/0204022•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jul 12, 2002•7 citations

Reply to 'Comment on "Relativistic shape invariant potentials"'

Abdulaziz D Alhaidari

The points raised in the Comment are addressed and except for one error, which will be corrected, the conclusion is that all of our findings are accurate.

arXiv:hep-ph/0204362•Apr 30, 2002•0 citations

Generation of exactly solvable ring shaped potentials of non relativistic quantum mechanics

Arup Bharali

•Dec 31, 2013•0 citations

Extending the class of solvable potentials. I. The infinite potential well with a sinusoidal bottom

Abdulaziz D Alhaidari, H. Bahlouli

This is the first in a series of papers where we succeed in enlarging the class of exactly solvable potentials in one and three dimensions by obtaining solutions for new relativistic and nonrelativistic problems. This is accomplished by constructing a matrix representation of the wave operator in a complete square integrable basis that makes it tridiagonal. Expanding the wave function in this basis makes the wave equation equivalent to a three-term recursion relation for the expansion coefficients. Consequently, finding solutions of the recursion relation is equivalent to solving the original problem. Doing so results in a larger class of solvable potentials. The usual diagonal representation constraint results in a reduction from the larger class to the conventional class of solvable potentials, giving the well-known energy spectra and the corresponding wave functions. Moreover, some of the new solvable problems show evidence of a Klauder-like phenomenon. In the present work, we give an exact solution for the infinite potential well with a bottom that has a sinusoidal shape.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 2008•28 citations

Comment on `On computing quantum waves exactly from classical action'

Gabor Vattay

A recent article by Lohmiller \& Slotine (Proc.\ R.\ Soc.\ A \textbf{482}: 20250413) claims that the Schrödinger equation can be solved exactly using only classical least action and classical fluid density, asserting that this formulation avoids semiclassical approximations. We show that their mathematical derivation contains a foundational error. By neglecting the spatial derivatives of the probability density amplitude, the authors inadvertently omit the quantum potential -- the term originally identified by Madelung and later emphasised by Bohm. Consequently, their proposed equivalence is not exact but rather constitutes the standard semiclassical approximation. We further demonstrate that each of the paper's illustrative examples either belongs to a class where the quantum potential vanishes identically due to the geometry of the problem, or recovers the correct quantum result by importing quantum eigenfunctions through the initial conditions, thereby concealing the error.

quant-pharXiv:2605.02621•May 5, 2026•2 citations

A comment on relativistic Hamiltonian equations for any spin

David Leo Weaver

Annals of Physics•Dec 1, 1975•0 citations
Comment on lquotlquotlquotRelativistic extension of shape-invariant potentialsrquotrquotrquot
Comment on lquotlquotlquotRelativistic extension of shape invariant potentialsrquotrquotrquot
This is the first in a series of papers where we succeed in enlarging the class of exactly solvable potentials in one and three dimensions by obtaining solutions for new relativistic and nonrelativistic problems. This is accomplished by constructing a matrix representation of the wave operator in a complete square integrable basis that makes it tridiagonal. Expanding the wave function in this basis makes the wave equation equivalent to a three-term recursion relation for the expansion coefficients. Consequently, finding solutions of the recursion relation is equivalent to solving the original problem. Doing so results in a larger class of solvable potentials. The usual diagonal representation constraint results in a reduction from the larger class to the conventional class of solvable potentials, giving the well-known energy spectra and the corresponding wave functions. Moreover, some of the new solvable problems show evidence of a Klauder-like phenomenon. In the present work, we give an exact solution for the infinite potential well with a bottom that has a sinusoidal shape.
A recent article by Lohmiller \& Slotine (Proc.\ R.\ Soc.\ A \textbf{482}: 20250413) claims that the Schrödinger equation can be solved exactly using only classical least action and classical fluid density, asserting that this formulation avoids semiclassical approximations. We show that their mathematical derivation contains a foundational error. By neglecting the spatial derivatives of the probability density amplitude, the authors inadvertently omit the quantum potential -- the term originally identified by Madelung and later emphasised by Bohm. Consequently, their proposed equivalence is not exact but rather constitutes the standard semiclassical approximation. We further demonstrate that each of the paper's illustrative examples either belongs to a class where the quantum potential vanishes identically due to the geometry of the problem, or recovers the correct quantum result by importing quantum eigenfunctions through the initial conditions, thereby concealing the error.