Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:gr-qc/9412047 · Journal of Mathematical Physics

Group quantization of parametrized systems. I. Time levels

P. Hájíček

Published Sep 1, 1995• 37 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A method of quantizing parametrized systems is developed that is based on a kind of ‘‘gauge invariant’’ quantities—the so-called perennials (a perennial must also be an ‘‘integral of motion’’). The problem of time in its particular form (frozen time formalism, global problem of time, multiple choice problem) is met, as well as a related difficulty characteristic for this type of theory: the paucity of perennials. The present paper is an attempt to find some remedy in the ideas on ‘‘forms of relativistic dynamics’’ by Dirac. Some aspects of Dirac’s theory are generalized to all finite-dimensional first-class parametrized systems. The generalization is based on replacing the Poincaré group and the algebra of its generators as used by Dirac by a canonical group of symmetries and by an algebra of elementary perennials. A number of insights are gained; the following are the main results. First, conditions are revealed under which the time evolution of the ordinary quantum mechanics, or a generalization of it, can be constructed. The construction uses a kind of gauge and time choice and it is described in detail. Second, the theory is structured so that the quantum mechanics resulting from different choices of gauge and time are compatible. Third, a practical way is presented of how a broad class of problems can be solved without the knowledge of explicit form of perennials.

DOI
10.1063/1.530911

Related papers

Effective approach to the problem of time: General features and examples

Martin Bojowald A, Philipp A. Höhn, Artur Tsobanjan

The effective approach to quantum dynamics allows a reformulation of the Dirac quantization procedure for constrained systems in terms of an infinite-dimensional constrained system of classical type. For semiclassical approximations, the quantum constrained system can be truncated to finite size and solved by the reduced phase space or gauge-fixing methods. In particular, the classical feasibility of local internal times is directly generalized to quantum systems, overcoming the main difficulties associated with the general problem of time in the semiclassical realm. The key features of local internal times and the procedure of patching global solutions using overlapping intervals of local internal times are described and illustrated by two quantum mechanical examples. Relational evolution in a given choice of internal time is most conveniently described and interpreted in a corresponding choice of gauge at the effective level and changing the internal clock is, therefore, essentially achieved by a gauge transformation. This article complements the conceptual discussion in [M. Bojowald, P. A. H\"ohn, and A. Tsobanjan, Classical Quantum Gravity 28, 035006 (2011).].

arXiv:1011.3040•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jun 21, 2011•125 citations

From classical to quantum mechanics: “How to translate physical ideas into mathematical language”

Hervé Bergeron

Following previous works by E. Prugovečki [Physica A 91A, 202 (1978) and Stochastic Quantum Mechanics and Quantum Space–time (Reidel, Dordrecht, 1986)] on common features of classical and quantum mechanics, we develop a unified mathematical framework for classical and quantum mechanics (based on L2-spaces over classical phase space), in order to investigate to what extent quantum mechanics can be obtained as a simple modification of classical mechanics (on both logical and analytical levels). To obtain this unified framework, we split quantum theory in two parts: (i) general quantum axiomatics (a system is described by a state in a Hilbert space, observables are self-adjoints operators, and so on) and (ii) quantum mechanics proper that specifies the Hilbert space as L2(Rn); the Heisenberg rule [pi,qj]=−iℏδij with p=−iℏ∇, the free Hamiltonian H=−ℏ2Δ/2m and so on. We show that general quantum axiomatics (up to a supplementary “axiom of classicity”) can be used as a nonstandard mathematical ground to formulate physical ideas and equations of ordinary classical statistical mechanics. So, the question of a “true quantization” with “ℏ” must be seen as an independent physical problem not directly related with quantum formalism. At this stage, we show that this nonstandard formulation of classical mechanics exhibits a new kind of operation that has no classical counterpart: this operation is related to the “quantization process,” and we show why quantization physically depends on group theory (the Galilei group). This analytical procedure of quantization replaces the “correspondence principle” (or canonical quantization) and allows us to map classical mechanics into quantum mechanics, giving all operators of quantum dynamics and the Schrödinger equation. The great advantage of this point of view is that quantization is based on concrete physical arguments and not derived from some “pure algebraic rule” (we exhibit also some limit of the correspondence principle). Moreover spins for particles are naturally generated, including an approximation of their interaction with magnetic fields. We also recover by this approach the semi-classical formalism developed by E. Prugovečki [Stochastic Quantum Mechanics and Quantum Space–time (Reidel, Dordrecht, 1986)].

arXiv:quant-ph/0102084•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Sep 1, 2001•12 citations

Dirac Formalism and Symmetry Problems in Quantum Mechanics. II. Symmetry Problems

Jean-Pierre Antoine

The quantum-mechanical formalism developed in a previous article and based on the use of a rigged Hilbert space Φ⊂H⊂Φ′ is here enlarged by taking into account the symmetry properties of the system. First, the compatibility of a particular symmetry with this structure is obtained by requiring Φ to be invariant under the corresponding representation U of the symmetry group in H. The symmetry is then realized by the restriction of U to Φ and its contragradient representation Ǔ in Φ′. This double manifestation of the symmetry is related to the so-called active and passive points of view commonly used for interpreting symmetry operations. Next, a general procedure is given for constructing a suitable space Φ out of the labeled observables of the system and the representation U describing its symmetry properties. This general method is then applied to the case where U is a semidirect product G=T[squared times]Δ, with T Abelian. Finally, the examples of the Euclidean, the Galilei, and the Poincaré groups are briefly studied.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 1969•51 citations

Alternative Hamiltonians and Wigner quantization

Pawe B asiak, A. Horzela, Edward Kapu cik

The Wigner problem, i.e. the investigation of general quantum mechanical commutation relations consistent with the Heisenberg evolution equations of a given shape, is studied. We follow a recently proposed generalization of this idea within which the classical analogy is postulated only for the shape of the time evolution equations and not for a Hamiltonian itself. This links our investigation to the problem of alternative Hamiltonians of classical mechanics and to canonically inequivalent phase-space descriptions of physical systems governed by the same Newton equations of motion. Warned that the time evolution and the other symmetry generators may be given ambiguously even in the formalism of classical mechanics, we do not a priori assume the shape of their quantum analogues. Instead we only require that the set of basic algebraic relations, which quantum mechanical observables are to obey, has a Lie algebra structure. Such a requirement appears to be sufficient to find solutions for simple oscillator-like dynamics. New algebras of quantum mechanical observables are not constructed as a linear envelope of the Heisenberg algebra, and their representations reflect physical results unexpected in the framework of the canonical approach. We illustrate our approach in detail for the example of the one-dimensional harmonic oscillator using the representation of the generalized coherent states.

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Jun 1, 2003•10 citations

QUANTUM MECHANICS IN NONINERTIAL FRAMES WITH A MULTITEMPORAL QUANTIZATION SCHEME I: RELATIVISTIC PARTICLES

David Alba, Luca Lusanna

After a review of the few attempts to define quantum mechanics in noninertial frames, we introduce a family of relativistic nonrigid noninertial frames (equal-time parallel hyper-planes with differentially rotating 3-coordinates) as a gauge fixing of the description of N positive energy particles in the framework of parametrized Minkowski theories. Then we define a multitemporal quantization scheme in which the particles are quantized, but not the gauge variables describing the noninertial frames: they are considered as c-number generalized times. We study the coupled Schrödinger-like equations produced by the first class constraints and we show that there is a physical scalar product independent both from time and generalized times and a unitary evolution. Since a path in the space of the generalized times defines a nonrigid noninertial frame, we can find the associated self-adjoint effective Hamiltonian [Formula: see text] for the noninertial evolution: it differs from the inertial energy operator for the presence of inertial potentials and turns out to be frame-dependent like the energy density in general relativity. After a separation of the relativistic center of mass from the relative variables by means of a recently developed relativistic kinematics, inside [Formula: see text] we can identify the self-adjoint relative energy operator (the invariant mass) [Formula: see text] corresponding to the inertial energy and producing the same levels for the spectra of atoms as in inertial frames. Instead the (in general time-dependent) effective Hamiltonian is responsible for the interferometric effects signaling the noninertiality of the frame. It cannot be interpreted as an energy (there is no relativity principle and no kinematic group in noninertial frames) and generically, like in the case of time-dependent c-number external electromagnetic fields, it has no associated eigenvalue equation defining a noninertial spectrum. This formulation should help to find relativistic Bel inequalities and to define a quantization scheme for canonical gravity after having found a ultraviolet regularization of the Tomonaga–Schwinger formalism in special relativity as required by the Torre–Varadarajan no-go theorem.

arXiv:hep-th/0502194•International Journal of Modern Physics A•Jun 2, 2006•44 citations

Relativistic Particle Theories Without Canonical Quantization

Nisticò, Giuseppe

The diffculties of relativistic particle theories formulated my means of canonical quantization, such as Klein-Gordon and Dirac theories, ultimately led theoretical physicists to turn on quantum field theory to model elementary particle physics. The aim of the present work is to pursue a method alternative to canonical quantization that avoids these dfficulties. In order to guarantee this result, the present approach is constrained to be developed deductively from physical principles. The physical principles assumed for a free particle consist of the symmetry properties of the particle with respect to the Poincaré group and of the transformation properties of the position observable, expressed by means of a suitably conceived notion of quantum transformation. In so doing, the effectiveness of group theoretical methods is exploited. Our work has pointed out the necessity of new classes of irreducible representations of the Poincaré group the theory can be based on. For spin 0 particle, four inequivalent theories are completely determined, that differ from Klein-Gordon theory for the physical interpretation but also for the mathematical structures. In particular, two of these theories requires irreducible representations in the new classes. The present lack of the explicit transformation properties of position with respect to boosts forbids the complete determination of non zero spin particle theories. A particular form of these transformation properties was in past adopted by Jordan and Mukunda. We check its consistency within the present approach; it is found that for spin 1/2 particles there is only one consistent theory; it is unitarily related to Dirac theory, but, once again, it requires the new classes of irreducible representations.

arXiv:1811.01546•Nov 5, 2018•2 citations
A method of quantizing parametrized systems is developed that is based on a kind of ‘‘gauge invariant’’ quantities—the so-called perennials (a perennial must also be an ‘‘integral of motion’’). The problem of time in its particular form (frozen time formalism, global problem of time, multiple choice problem) is met, as well as a related difficulty characteristic for this type of theory: the paucity of perennials. The present paper is an attempt to find some remedy in the ideas on ‘‘forms of relativistic dynamics’’ by Dirac. Some aspects of Dirac’s theory are generalized to all finite-dimensional first-class parametrized systems. The generalization is based on replacing the Poincaré group and the algebra of its generators as used by Dirac by a canonical group of symmetries and by an algebra of elementary perennials. A number of insights are gained; the following are the main results. First, conditions are revealed under which the time evolution of the ordinary quantum mechanics, or a generalization of it, can be constructed. The construction uses a kind of gauge and time choice and it is described in detail. Second, the theory is structured so that the quantum mechanics resulting from different choices of gauge and time are compatible. Third, a practical way is presented of how a broad class of problems can be solved without the knowledge of explicit form of perennials.
The effective approach to quantum dynamics allows a reformulation of the Dirac quantization procedure for constrained systems in terms of an infinite-dimensional constrained system of classical type. For semiclassical approximations, the quantum constrained system can be truncated to finite size and solved by the reduced phase space or gauge-fixing methods. In particular, the classical feasibility of local internal times is directly generalized to quantum systems, overcoming the main difficulties associated with the general problem of time in the semiclassical realm. The key features of local internal times and the procedure of patching global solutions using overlapping intervals of local internal times are described and illustrated by two quantum mechanical examples. Relational evolution in a given choice of internal time is most conveniently described and interpreted in a corresponding choice of gauge at the effective level and changing the internal clock is, therefore, essentially achieved by a gauge transformation. This article complements the conceptual discussion in [M. Bojowald, P. A. H\"ohn, and A. Tsobanjan, Classical Quantum Gravity 28, 035006 (2011).].
Following previous works by E. Prugovečki [Physica A 91A, 202 (1978) and Stochastic Quantum Mechanics and Quantum Space–time (Reidel, Dordrecht, 1986)] on common features of classical and quantum mechanics, we develop a unified mathematical framework for classical and quantum mechanics (based on L2-spaces over classical phase space), in order to investigate to what extent quantum mechanics can be obtained as a simple modification of classical mechanics (on both logical and analytical levels). To obtain this unified framework, we split quantum theory in two parts: (i) general quantum axiomatics (a system is described by a state in a Hilbert space, observables are self-adjoints operators, and so on) and (ii) quantum mechanics proper that specifies the Hilbert space as L2(Rn); the Heisenberg rule [pi,qj]=−iℏδij with p=−iℏ∇, the free Hamiltonian H=−ℏ2Δ/2m and so on. We show that general quantum axiomatics (up to a supplementary “axiom of classicity”) can be used as a nonstandard mathematical ground to formulate physical ideas and equations of ordinary classical statistical mechanics. So, the question of a “true quantization” with “ℏ” must be seen as an independent physical problem not directly related with quantum formalism. At this stage, we show that this nonstandard formulation of classical mechanics exhibits a new kind of operation that has no classical counterpart: this operation is related to the “quantization process,” and we show why quantization physically depends on group theory (the Galilei group). This analytical procedure of quantization replaces the “correspondence principle” (or canonical quantization) and allows us to map classical mechanics into quantum mechanics, giving all operators of quantum dynamics and the Schrödinger equation. The great advantage of this point of view is that quantization is based on concrete physical arguments and not derived from some “pure algebraic rule” (we exhibit also some limit of the correspondence principle). Moreover spins for particles are naturally generated, including an approximation of their interaction with magnetic fields. We also recover by this approach the semi-classical formalism developed by E. Prugovečki [Stochastic Quantum Mechanics and Quantum Space–time (Reidel, Dordrecht, 1986)].
The quantum-mechanical formalism developed in a previous article and based on the use of a rigged Hilbert space Φ⊂H⊂Φ′ is here enlarged by taking into account the symmetry properties of the system. First, the compatibility of a particular symmetry with this structure is obtained by requiring Φ to be invariant under the corresponding representation U of the symmetry group in H. The symmetry is then realized by the restriction of U to Φ and its contragradient representation Ǔ in Φ′. This double manifestation of the symmetry is related to the so-called active and passive points of view commonly used for interpreting symmetry operations. Next, a general procedure is given for constructing a suitable space Φ out of the labeled observables of the system and the representation U describing its symmetry properties. This general method is then applied to the case where U is a semidirect product G=T[squared times]Δ, with T Abelian. Finally, the examples of the Euclidean, the Galilei, and the Poincaré groups are briefly studied.
The Wigner problem, i.e. the investigation of general quantum mechanical commutation relations consistent with the Heisenberg evolution equations of a given shape, is studied. We follow a recently proposed generalization of this idea within which the classical analogy is postulated only for the shape of the time evolution equations and not for a Hamiltonian itself. This links our investigation to the problem of alternative Hamiltonians of classical mechanics and to canonically inequivalent phase-space descriptions of physical systems governed by the same Newton equations of motion. Warned that the time evolution and the other symmetry generators may be given ambiguously even in the formalism of classical mechanics, we do not a priori assume the shape of their quantum analogues. Instead we only require that the set of basic algebraic relations, which quantum mechanical observables are to obey, has a Lie algebra structure. Such a requirement appears to be sufficient to find solutions for simple oscillator-like dynamics. New algebras of quantum mechanical observables are not constructed as a linear envelope of the Heisenberg algebra, and their representations reflect physical results unexpected in the framework of the canonical approach. We illustrate our approach in detail for the example of the one-dimensional harmonic oscillator using the representation of the generalized coherent states.
After a review of the few attempts to define quantum mechanics in noninertial frames, we introduce a family of relativistic nonrigid noninertial frames (equal-time parallel hyper-planes with differentially rotating 3-coordinates) as a gauge fixing of the description of N positive energy particles in the framework of parametrized Minkowski theories. Then we define a multitemporal quantization scheme in which the particles are quantized, but not the gauge variables describing the noninertial frames: they are considered as c-number generalized times. We study the coupled Schrödinger-like equations produced by the first class constraints and we show that there is a physical scalar product independent both from time and generalized times and a unitary evolution. Since a path in the space of the generalized times defines a nonrigid noninertial frame, we can find the associated self-adjoint effective Hamiltonian [Formula: see text] for the noninertial evolution: it differs from the inertial energy operator for the presence of inertial potentials and turns out to be frame-dependent like the energy density in general relativity. After a separation of the relativistic center of mass from the relative variables by means of a recently developed relativistic kinematics, inside [Formula: see text] we can identify the self-adjoint relative energy operator (the invariant mass) [Formula: see text] corresponding to the inertial energy and producing the same levels for the spectra of atoms as in inertial frames. Instead the (in general time-dependent) effective Hamiltonian is responsible for the interferometric effects signaling the noninertiality of the frame. It cannot be interpreted as an energy (there is no relativity principle and no kinematic group in noninertial frames) and generically, like in the case of time-dependent c-number external electromagnetic fields, it has no associated eigenvalue equation defining a noninertial spectrum. This formulation should help to find relativistic Bel inequalities and to define a quantization scheme for canonical gravity after having found a ultraviolet regularization of the Tomonaga–Schwinger formalism in special relativity as required by the Torre–Varadarajan no-go theorem.
The diffculties of relativistic particle theories formulated my means of canonical quantization, such as Klein-Gordon and Dirac theories, ultimately led theoretical physicists to turn on quantum field theory to model elementary particle physics. The aim of the present work is to pursue a method alternative to canonical quantization that avoids these dfficulties. In order to guarantee this result, the present approach is constrained to be developed deductively from physical principles. The physical principles assumed for a free particle consist of the symmetry properties of the particle with respect to the Poincaré group and of the transformation properties of the position observable, expressed by means of a suitably conceived notion of quantum transformation. In so doing, the effectiveness of group theoretical methods is exploited. Our work has pointed out the necessity of new classes of irreducible representations of the Poincaré group the theory can be based on. For spin 0 particle, four inequivalent theories are completely determined, that differ from Klein-Gordon theory for the physical interpretation but also for the mathematical structures. In particular, two of these theories requires irreducible representations in the new classes. The present lack of the explicit transformation properties of position with respect to boosts forbids the complete determination of non zero spin particle theories. A particular form of these transformation properties was in past adopted by Jordan and Mukunda. We check its consistency within the present approach; it is found that for spin 1/2 particles there is only one consistent theory; it is unitarily related to Dirac theory, but, once again, it requires the new classes of irreducible representations.