arXiv:gr-qc/9406054 · Physical Review A

Preferred basis in a measurement process

Anu Venugopalan

Published Sep 1, 1994• 24 citations

Abstract

The effect of decoherence is analyzed for a free particle interacting with an environment via dissipative coupling. The interaction between the particle and the environment occurs by a coupling of the position operator of the particle with the environmental degrees of freedom. By examining the exact solution of the density-matrix equation, one finds that the density matrix becomes completely diagonal in momentum with time, while the position space density matrix remains nonlocal. This establishes the momentum basis as the emergent ``preferred basis'' selected by the environment, which is contrary to the general expectation that position should emerge as the preferred basis, since the coupling with the environment is via the position coordinate.

DOI: 10.1103/physreva.50.2742

Related papers

Is the Preferred Basis selected by the environment?

Tian Wang, David Hobill

We show that in a quantum measurement, the preferred basis is determined by the interaction between the apparatus and the quantum system, instead of by the environment. This interaction entangles three degrees of freedom, one system degree of freedom we are interested in and preserved by the interaction, one system degree of freedom that carries the change due to the interaction, and the apparatus degree of freedom which is always ignored. Considering all three degrees of freedom the composite state only has one decomposition, and this guarantees that the apparatus would end up in the expected preferred basis of our daily experiences. We also point out some problems with the environment-induced super-selection (Einselection) solution to the preferred basis problem, and clarifies a common misunderstanding of environmental decoherence and the preferred basis problem.

arXiv:1412.2852Dec 9, 20141 citation

Phase-Space Measurements, Decoherence, and Classicality

Dorje C. Brody, Eva-Maria Graefe, Rishindra Melanathuru

The emergence of classical behavior in quantum theory is often ascribed to the interaction of a quantum system with its environment, which can be interpreted as environmental monitoring of the system. As a result, off-diagonal elements of the density matrix of the system are damped in the basis of a preferred observable, often taken to be the position, leading to the phenomenon of decoherence. This effect can be modeled dynamically in terms of a Lindblad equation driven by the position operator. Here the question of decoherence resulting from a monitoring of position and momentum, i.e., a phase-space measurement, by the environment is addressed. There is no standard quantum observable corresponding to the detection of phase-space points, which is forbidden by Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. This issue is addressed by use of a coherent-state-based positive operator-valued measure for modeling phase-space monitoring by the environment. In this scheme, decoherence in phase space implies the diagonalization of the density matrix in both position and momentum representations. This is shown to be linked to a Lindblad equation where position and momentum appear as two independent Lindblad operators.

arXiv:2406.19628Physical Review LettersMar 26, 202510 citations

Analysis of the Stern-Gerlach Measurement

Anu Venugopalan, Deepak Kumar, Ghosh, R.

A dynamical model for the collapse of the wave function in a quantum measurement process is proposed by considering the interaction of a quantum system (spin-1/2) with a macroscopic quantum apparatus interacting with an environment in a dissipative manner. The dissipative interaction leads to decoherence in the superposition states of the apparatus, making its behaviour classical in the sense that the density matrix becomes diagonal with time. Since the apparatus is also interacting with the system, the probabilities of the diagonal density matrix are determined by the state vector of the system. We consider a Stern-Gerlach type model, where a spin- 1/2 particle is in an inhomogeneous magnetic field, the whole set up being in contact with a large environment. Here we find that the density matrix of the combined system and apparatus becomes diagonal and the momentum of the particle becomes correlated with a spin operator, selected by the choice of the system-apparatus interaction. This allows for a measurement of spin via a momentum measurement on the particle with associated probabilities in accordance with quantum principles.

arXiv:quant-ph/9501022Jan 27, 19953 citations

Quantum theory of a free particle interacting with a linearly dissipative environment

Vincent Hakim, Vinay Ambegaokar

The quantum-mechanical motion of a free particle coupled to a linearly dissipative environment is analyzed in the Hamiltonian formalism. The total Hamiltonian is diagonalized and its eigenstates displayed. These results are used to discuss the role of initial conditions on the subsequent motion. A widely used initial condition---heat bath uncoupled from particle---is compared with another one in which the initial off-diagonal coherence of the reduced density matrix is comparable to that in the state of thermal equilibrium of the coupled system. Different transient behaviors, on time scales longer than the inverse cutoff frequency of the bath are found. The mean-square momentum of the particle in the steady state is found to depend on this highest bath frequency. An analysis of the correlated states of particle and heat reservoir shows that the latter behaves in some sense like a position-measuring apparatus.

Physical Review AJul 1, 1985307 citations

No Quantum Process Can Explain the Existence of the Preferred Basis: Decoherence Is Not Universal

Hitoshi Inamori

Environment induced decoherence, and other quantum processes, have been proposed in the literature to explain the apparent spontaneous selection—out of the many mathematically eligible bases—of a privileged measurement basis that corresponds to what we actually observe. This paper describes such processes, and demonstrates that—contrary to common belief—no such process can actually lead to a preferred basis in general. The key observation is that environment induced decoherence implicitly assumes a prior independence of the observed system, the observer and the environment. However, such independence cannot be guaranteed, and we show that environment induced decoherence does not succeed in establishing a preferred measurement basis in general. We conclude that the existence of the preferred basis must be postulated in quantum mechanics, and that changing the basis for a measurement is, and must be, described as an actual physical process.

arXiv:1609.07984Journal of Quantum Information ScienceJan 1, 20162 citations

Time-dependent pointer states, determination of the preferred basis of measurement, and decoherence of quantum systems

Hoofar Daneshvar

We present a general analytic method for evaluating the generally time-dependent pointer states of a subsystem, which are defined by their capability not to entangle with the states of another subsystem. We explore the conditions under which the pointer states of the system become independent of time; so that a preferred basis of measurement can be realized. We relate the mathematical conditions for having time-independent pointer states to some classes of possible symmetries in the Hamiltonian of the total composite system. Indeed, our theory would serve as a generalization of the existing theory for determination of the preferred basis of measurement. By exploiting this new theory we can obtain those regimes of the parameter space for a given total Hamiltonian defining our system-environment model for which a preferred basis of measurement can be realized. Moreover, we can predict the corresponding preferred basis of measurement for each regime. We can also obtain the time-dependent pointer states of the system and the environment in most of the other regimes where the pointer states of the system are time-dependent and a preferred basis of measurement cannot be realized at all. This ability to obtain time-dependent pointer states is specifically important in decoherence studies; as these pointer states, although they evolve with time and cannot represent the preferred basis of measurement, they correspond to those initial conditions for the state of the system and the environment for which we can have longer decoherence times. In the next step, we consider a spin-boson Hamiltonian which is generalized such that the Hamiltonians for the system and the interaction with the environment do not commute with each other. Considering a single-mode quantized field in exact resonance with the tunneling matrix element of the system, we calculate the time-dependent pointer states of the system and the environment for the case that the environment initially is prepared in the coherent state. We also obtain a closed form for the offdiagonal element of the reduced density matrix of the system and study the decoherence of the central system in our model. We will show that for the case that the system initially is prepared in one of its pointer states, the offdiagonal element of the reduced density matrix of the system will be a sinusoidal function with a slow decaying envelop which is characterized by a decay time proportional to n-bar.

Jan 1, 20110 citations