Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:gr-qc/9405058 · Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields

Unitarity restoration in the presence of closed timelike curves

Arlen Anderson

Published May 15, 1995• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A proposal is made for a mathematically unambiguous treatment of evolution in the presence of closed timelike curves. In contrast to other proposals for handling the naively nonunitary evolution that is often present in such situations, this proposal is causal, linear in the initial density matrix, and preserves probability. It provides a physically reasonable interpretation of invertible nonunitary evolution by redefining the final Hilbert space so that the evolution is unitary or equivalently by removing the nonunitary part of the evolution operator using a polar decomposition.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.51.5707

Related papers

Quantum no-go theorems in causality respecting systems in the presence of closed timelike curves: Tweaking the Deutsch condition

Asutosh Kumar, Indranil Chakrabarty, Arun Kumar Pati +2 more

Quantum no-go theorems in causality respecting systems in the presence of closed timelike curves: Tweaking the Deutsch condition, Kumar, Asutosh, Chakrabarty, Indranil, Pati, Arun Kumar, Sen(De), Aditi, Sen, Ujjwal

arXiv:1511.08560•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Jun 6, 2018•3 citations

Unitarity in Quantum Mechanics: A Critical Audit from First Principles

Justin Richer

This work presents a rigorous, first-principles audit of unitarity in quantum mechanics, treating unitarity not as a foundational axiom but as a hypothesis whose validity depends on explicit physical and mathematical assumptions. The analysis is conducted entirely within the operational framework of open quantum systems, using completely positive trace-preserving (CPTP) maps to describe the dynamics of reduced subsystems. By systematically isolating and auditing every prerequisite required for unitary evolution—including perfect isolation, Hilbert-space factorization, linearity, the Born rule, and time parameterization—the manuscript demonstrates that unitarity is neither fundamental nor universal, but instead an emergent, scale-dependent consistency condition. The paper distinguishes clearly between mathematical bookkeeping identities and physically meaningful conservation laws, showing that probability conservation does not require unitarity, and that reversibility and energy conservation are not guaranteed by unitary evolution alone. Explicit, mathematically consistent non-unitary evolution models are constructed, including Lindblad dynamics, non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, stochastic Schrödinger equations, non-Markovian evolution, and quantum Darwinism. The work further identifies the precise regimes in which unitary dynamics emerges as an effective approximation—such as weak coupling, short timescales, or limited observational resolution—and delineates the conditions under which it fails. Empirical evidence from atomic spectroscopy, quantum information processing, decoherence experiments, and measurement theory is used to anchor the analysis without assuming fundamental unitarity. The central conclusion is unambiguous: no physically accessible open or effective subsystem undergoes strictly unitary evolution. Unitarity is shown to be an emergent, conditional, and scale-dependent property rather than a fundamental law of nature. This manuscript is intended as a foundational clarification of the status of unitarity in quantum theory and is suitable for researchers in quantum foundations, open quantum systems, quantum information, and quantum gravity. FUSION OS INNOVATIONS

•Jan 16, 2026•0 citations

Can We Believe in a Purely Unitary Quantum Dynamics?

Fedor Herbut

It is pointed out that the question of a purely unitary quantum dynamics amounts to the question if von Neumann entropy of a dynamically closed quantum system is preserved in evolution.

arXiv:quant-ph/0507218•Jul 22, 2005•2 citations

Path integrals, density matrices, and information flow with closed timelike curves

H. David Politzer

Two formulations of quantum mechanics, inequivalent in the presence of closed timelike curves, are studied in the context of a soluable system. It illustrates how quantum field nonlinearities lead to a breakdown of unitarity, causality, and superposition using a path integral. Deutsch's density matrix approach is causal but typically destroys coherence. For each of these formulations I demonstrate that there are yet further alternatives in prescribing the handling of information flow (inequivalent to previous analyses) that have implications for any system in which unitarity or coherence is not preserved.

arXiv:gr-qc/9310027•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Apr 15, 1994•54 citations

Unitarity and causality in generalized quantum mechanics for nonchronal spacetimes

James B. Hartle

Spacetime must be foliable by spacelike surfaces for the quantum mechanics of matter fields to be formulated in terms of a unitarily evolving state vector defined on spacelike surfaces. When a spacetime possesses nonchronal regions which cannot be foliated by spacelike surfaces, as in the case of spacetimes with closed timelike curves, a more general formulation of quantum mechanics is required. In such generalizations the transition matrix between alternatives on two spacelike surfaces lying in regions of spacetime where foliating families can be defined may be nonunitary if a nonchronal region lies between them. This paper describes a sum-over-histories generalized quantum mechanics whose probabilities consistently obey the rules of probability theory even in the presence of such nonunitarity. The usual notion of state on a spacelike surface is lost in this generalization. Anomalies such as nonconservation of energy or "Everett phones" that are exhibited by some generalizations of quantum mechanics are not found in this one. However, the generalization is acausal in the sense that the existence of nonchronal regions of spacetime in the future can affect the probabilities of alternatives today and signaling outside the light cone is possible. The detectability of nonunitary evolution and violations of causality in measurement situations are briefly considered.

arXiv:gr-qc/9309012•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jun 15, 1994•69 citations

UNITARY EVOLUTION AS A UNIQUENESS CRITERION

Jerónimo Cortez, Guillermo Antonio Mena Marugán, Javier Olmedo +1 more

We briefly review the use of unitary evolution as a uniqueness criterion in the selection of quantum representations, in the context of scalar fields in non-stationary situations.

arXiv:1311.0443•The Ninth Marcel Grossmann Meeting•Jan 29, 2015•0 citations
A proposal is made for a mathematically unambiguous treatment of evolution in the presence of closed timelike curves. In contrast to other proposals for handling the naively nonunitary evolution that is often present in such situations, this proposal is causal, linear in the initial density matrix, and preserves probability. It provides a physically reasonable interpretation of invertible nonunitary evolution by redefining the final Hilbert space so that the evolution is unitary or equivalently by removing the nonunitary part of the evolution operator using a polar decomposition.
This work presents a rigorous, first-principles audit of unitarity in quantum mechanics, treating unitarity not as a foundational axiom but as a hypothesis whose validity depends on explicit physical and mathematical assumptions. The analysis is conducted entirely within the operational framework of open quantum systems, using completely positive trace-preserving (CPTP) maps to describe the dynamics of reduced subsystems. By systematically isolating and auditing every prerequisite required for unitary evolution—including perfect isolation, Hilbert-space factorization, linearity, the Born rule, and time parameterization—the manuscript demonstrates that unitarity is neither fundamental nor universal, but instead an emergent, scale-dependent consistency condition. The paper distinguishes clearly between mathematical bookkeeping identities and physically meaningful conservation laws, showing that probability conservation does not require unitarity, and that reversibility and energy conservation are not guaranteed by unitary evolution alone. Explicit, mathematically consistent non-unitary evolution models are constructed, including Lindblad dynamics, non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, stochastic Schrödinger equations, non-Markovian evolution, and quantum Darwinism. The work further identifies the precise regimes in which unitary dynamics emerges as an effective approximation—such as weak coupling, short timescales, or limited observational resolution—and delineates the conditions under which it fails. Empirical evidence from atomic spectroscopy, quantum information processing, decoherence experiments, and measurement theory is used to anchor the analysis without assuming fundamental unitarity. The central conclusion is unambiguous: no physically accessible open or effective subsystem undergoes strictly unitary evolution. Unitarity is shown to be an emergent, conditional, and scale-dependent property rather than a fundamental law of nature. This manuscript is intended as a foundational clarification of the status of unitarity in quantum theory and is suitable for researchers in quantum foundations, open quantum systems, quantum information, and quantum gravity. FUSION OS INNOVATIONS
Two formulations of quantum mechanics, inequivalent in the presence of closed timelike curves, are studied in the context of a soluable system. It illustrates how quantum field nonlinearities lead to a breakdown of unitarity, causality, and superposition using a path integral. Deutsch's density matrix approach is causal but typically destroys coherence. For each of these formulations I demonstrate that there are yet further alternatives in prescribing the handling of information flow (inequivalent to previous analyses) that have implications for any system in which unitarity or coherence is not preserved.
Spacetime must be foliable by spacelike surfaces for the quantum mechanics of matter fields to be formulated in terms of a unitarily evolving state vector defined on spacelike surfaces. When a spacetime possesses nonchronal regions which cannot be foliated by spacelike surfaces, as in the case of spacetimes with closed timelike curves, a more general formulation of quantum mechanics is required. In such generalizations the transition matrix between alternatives on two spacelike surfaces lying in regions of spacetime where foliating families can be defined may be nonunitary if a nonchronal region lies between them. This paper describes a sum-over-histories generalized quantum mechanics whose probabilities consistently obey the rules of probability theory even in the presence of such nonunitarity. The usual notion of state on a spacelike surface is lost in this generalization. Anomalies such as nonconservation of energy or "Everett phones" that are exhibited by some generalizations of quantum mechanics are not found in this one. However, the generalization is acausal in the sense that the existence of nonchronal regions of spacetime in the future can affect the probabilities of alternatives today and signaling outside the light cone is possible. The detectability of nonunitary evolution and violations of causality in measurement situations are briefly considered.