Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/9808150 · Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics

Ergodic properties of a generic nonintegrable quantum many-body system in the thermodynamic limit

Tomaž Prosen

Published Oct 1, 1999• 117 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study a generic but simple nonintegrable quantum many-body system of locally interacting particles, namely, a kicked-parameter (t,V) model of spinless fermions on a one-dimensional lattice (equivalent to a kicked Heisenberg XX-Z chain of 1/2 spins). The statistical properties of the dynamics (quantum ergodicity and quantum mixing) and the nature of quantum transport in the thermodynamic limit are considered as the kick parameters (which control the degree of nonintegrability) are varied. We find and demonstrate ballistic transport and nonergodic, nonmixing dynamics (implying infinite conductivity at all temperatures) in the integrable regime of zero or very small kick parameters, and more generally and importantly, also in the nonintegrable regime of intermediate values of kicked parameters, whereas only for sufficiently large kick parameters do we recover quantum ergodicity and mixing implying normal (diffusive) transport. We propose an order parameter (charge stiffness D) which controls the phase transition from nonmixing and nonergodic dynamics (ordered phase, D>0) to mixing and ergodic dynamics (disordered phase, D=0) in the thermodynamic limit. Furthermore, we find exponential decay of time correlation functions in the regime of mixing dynamics. The results are obtained consistently within three different numerical and analytical approaches: (i) time evolution of a finite system and direct computation of time correlation functions, (ii) full diagonalization of finite systems and statistical analysis of stationary data, and (iii) algebraic construction of quantum invariants of motion of an infinite system, in particular the time-averaged observables.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.60.3949

Related papers

Time Evolution of a Quantum Many-Body System: Transition from Integrability to Ergodicity in the Thermodynamic Limit

Tomaž Prosen

Numerical evidence is given for nonergodic (nonmixing) behavior, exhibiting ideal transport, of a simple nonintegrable many-body quantum system in the thermodynamic limit, namely, the kicked $t$- $V$ model of spinless fermions on a ring. However, for sufficiently large kick parameters $t$ and $V$ we recover quantum ergodicity, and normal transport, which can be described by random matrix theory.

arXiv:cond-mat/9707180•Physical Review Letters•Mar 2, 1998•129 citations

Quantum invariants of motion in a generic many-body system

Tomaž Prosen

A dynamical Lie algebraic method for the construction of quantum invariants of motion in non-integrable many-body systems of infinite size is proposed and applied to a simple but generic toy model, namely an infinite kicked t - V chain of interacting spinless fermions. The transition from an integrable via quasi-integrable ( intermediate ) to a quantum ergodic (quantum mixing) regime in parameter space is investigated. A dynamical phase transition between an ergodic and intermediate (neither ergodic nor completely integrable) regime in thermodynamic limit is proposed. The existence or non-existence of local conservation laws corresponds to the intermediate or ergodic regime, respectively. The computation of time-correlation functions of typical observables by means of local conservation laws is found to be fully consistent with direct calculations on finite systems.

arXiv:cond-mat/9803358•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Sep 18, 1998•41 citations

ERGODIC PROPERTIES OF QUANTUM SPIN CHAINS: KICKED TRANSVERSE ISING MODEL

Tomai Prosen

The problem of calculation of time-correlation functions and relaxation phenomena in interacting quantum many-body systems or quantized fields is put into the framework of ergodic theory and dynamical systems. In this spirit we discuss spectral analysis of the adjoint propagator in a suitable Hilbert space of quantum observables in Heisenberg picture as an alternative approach to characterize many-body dynamics. We illustrate our approach by working out the time-autocorrelation functions at infinite temperature of a large class of observabIes for a spin s = 1/2 Ising chain in a periodically kicking transverse magnetic field, and show that they decay to their asymptotic values as ex: t3/ 2 General understanding of time-correlation functions and relaxation phenomena of interacting quantum many-body systems is a challenging problem with only very partial existing solutions. Situation is much better if one considers the motion of a one-body or few-body systems where the classical ergodic theory (see e.g. [1]) describes a variety of different types of motion, ranging from quasi-periodic integrable motion characterized by a discrete spectrum of the (Liouville) evolution operator, through KAM quasi-integrability, to ergodicity, mixing and chaos characterized by a continuous evolution spectrum. Mixing, which is equivalent of saying that correlation functions of an arbitrary pair of observables (A,B) decay in time, limt-HXJ ((A(t)B) (A)(B)) = 0, is the necessary dynamical property needed to justify the relaxation to equilibrium (micro/grand/canonical) state and the laws of statistical mechanics, such as the fluctuation-dissipation theorem and transport laws. Mixing in quantum many-body system has been investigated by numerical experiment only quite recently [2]. In another numerical experiment [3], a suggestive possibility of dynamical phase transition from non-ergodic/non-mixing to ergodic/mixing dynamics in a non-integrable periodically kicked chain of interacting spinless fermions (kicked t-V model) has been proposed. General absence of mixing in completely integrable quantum many-body systems (such as those solvable by Bethe ansatz), being the consequence of an infinite sequence of conservation 317 J. Bonca et al. (eds.), Open Problems in Strongly Correlated Electron Systems. 317-322. © 2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers. 318 OPEN PROBLEMS IN STRONGLY CORRELATED ELECTRON SYSTEMS laws, is directly responsible for finite temperature anomalous transport properties of such systems [4, 5]. Quantum mixing property is defined (here) relative with respect to a certain (Hilbert) (sub)space 6 of observables and is most conveniently discussed in Heisenberg picture where the equations of motion for quantum observable A(t) are addressed. Our approach may be interpreted also as a kind ofgeneralization ofLee's recurrence-relations methodof constructing continued-fraction representation of time-correlation functions [6]. After a short outline of the main ideas we will illustrate the method by describing a recent calculation [8] of the time-correlation functions for Ising s = 1/2 spin chain periodically kicked with transverse magnetic field. Quantum dynamics in Heisenberg picture is governed by the Heisenberg equation (d/dt)A(t) = i( adH(t))A(t), where (adH)A:= [H, A1 =HA AH. Our aim is to include description of dynamics of periodically time-dependent (e.g. kicked) quantum systems so we will adopt Floquet formalism and integrate equations of motion over one period of time T (for autonomous systems, T may be arbitrary, e.g. infinitesimally small), defining the so called quantum Floquet map or one-step propagatorU := T exp(-i J; dtH(t) )which induces the adjoint Floquet map U ad acting on the (sub)space 6 of observables A(t +T) = U ad A(t), U A:= utAU. We should require the subspace 6 to be invariat under dynamics, namely A E 6 :::} U ad A E 6. Linear space 6 is turned into the Hilbert space by introducing an innner product of two extensive observables in thermodynamic limit (size L -+ 00) as (AlB) = (AtB), (A):= lim .!.. tr A £--+00 L tr 1 (1) (2) which has a meaning of a canonical average at infinite temperature. 1 We note that the adjoint Floquet map U ad is a unitary operator in 6 w.r.t. inner product (1), or equivalently, that ad H is selfadjoint. Thus a pair (U ad , 6) defines a unitary evolution to which we apply standard terminology and results of spectral theory of dynamical systems (see e.g. part III of ref. [1]). To any observable A E 6 we assign spectral measure dI-'A(fJ), where the spectral parameter lies on a unit circle () E 8 1 == [0, 21f), which is directly related to the time-autocorrelation function of A (t) (AtA(mT)) = (AI[U 1 A) = / dI-'A(fJ)e • So, ergodic properties of the unitary evolution are dual to its spectral properties: IThis is the simplest choice which makes sense also for time-dependent systems. For autonomous systems one may work with more general finite-temperature canonical inner product (see e.g. [6]). Ergodic Properties ofQuantum Spin Chains: Kicked Transverse Ising Model 319 • Quantum dynamics is ergodic in 6 iff 1 is (at most) simple (nondegenerate) eigenvalue of Uad (with eigenvector 1 if 1 E 6). Then limT-too ~ JOT dt {(A(t)IB) (All)(IIB)} = O. • Quantum dynamics is mixing in 6 iflimt-too(A(t)IB) = (All)(IIB) for arbitrary A, B E 6. Then U ad has an absolutely continuous spectrum, except possibly for a simple eigenvalue 1. • If 1 is a multiply degenerate eigenvalue of U ad then the corresponding eigenvectors Qn are the conservation laws of 6, U ad Qn = Qn Let Qn be a complete set of orthonormalized (QnIQm) = dnm eigenvectors with eigenvalue 1. The averaged time-autocorrelation function is the spectral weight at point 1 1 jT DA:= lim -T dt(A(t)IA) = L. I(QnIA )1 • T-too 2 -T n (3) For example, if A = J is the particle/spin current D J is proportional to the charge/spin stiffness at infinite temperature and D J > 0 indicates ballistic transport. Even when the set of known conservation laws is incomplete, the above relation gives rigorous lower bound on DA [7, 5]. Next we propose a simple but nontrivial application of the above picture. We consider aHilbert space 6 ofobservables over infinite spin 1/2 chains described by Pauli operators a}, s E {x, y, z}, j E Z, which is spanned by two infinite sequences of selfadjoint observables Un and Vn,nEZ, namely n ~ 1, n =0, n <-1 ,

•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Absence of Diffusion in an Interacting System of Spinless Fermions on a One-Dimensional Disordered Lattice

Yevgeny Bar Lev, Guy Cohen, David R. Reichman

We study the infinite temperature dynamics of a prototypical one-dimensional system expected to exhibit many-body localization. Using numerically exact methods, we establish the dynamical phase diagram of this system based on the statistics of its eigenvalues and its dynamical behavior. We show that the nonergodic phase is reentrant as a function of the interaction strength, illustrating that localization can be reinforced by sufficiently strong interactions even at infinite temperature. Surprisingly, within the accessible time range, the ergodic phase shows subdiffusive behavior, suggesting that the diffusion coefficient vanishes throughout much of the phase diagram in the thermodynamic limit. Our findings strongly suggest that Wigner-Dyson statistics of eigenvalue spacings may appear in a class of ergodic but subdiffusive systems.

arXiv:1407.7535•Physical Review Letters•Mar 11, 2015•332 citations

Ergodic and Discrete Time Crystal Phases in Periodically Kicked Many-Body Quantum Systems: An Analytical Study

Vijay Kumar, Dibyendu Roy

We analytically study the time evolution of the expectation values of observables in periodically kicked many-body quantum systems. Starting from an initial state, we compute both the transient and the long-time properties of the observables. Our derivation explains the criteria and the mechanism that lead to the infinite-temperature statistical average of observables at long times, irrespective of the initial state. When the criteria are violated, the observables oscillate with time. These oscillations are subharmonic and robust to small perturbations, suggesting the emergence of a discrete time crystal phase. We demonstrate these features explicitly in periodically kicked nonintegrable spin chains. For a spin chain with two kicks per cycle, we show that the kicked chain can exhibit an ergodic or a discrete-time crystal phase for the same kicking strengths, depending on the initial state preparation. We complement our time-evolution study of observables with the spectral form factor of these kicked models.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2605.01969•May 5, 2026•0 citations

Signatures of diffusion and ballistic transport in the stiffness, dynamical correlation functions, and statistics of one-dimensional systems

Subroto Mukerjee, B. Sriram Shastry

Integrable and nonintegrable systems have very different transport properties. In this paper, we highlight these differences for specific one-dimensional models of interacting lattice fermions. The technique used is a finite temperature numerical calculation of the adiabatic stiffness (also called the Drude weight or charge stiffness) and isothermal stiffness (also called the ``Meissner'' stiffness) in electrical and energy transport, and the momentum dependent dynamical conductivities $\ensuremath{\sigma}(q,\ensuremath{\omega})$ and $\ensuremath{\kappa}(q,\ensuremath{\omega})$. We apply a flux twist to break the Kramers degeneracy; thus, allowing us to focus on the effect of the dynamical degeneracies in the integrable system. In this situation, we show that the isothermal stiffness goes to zero rapidly with the system size for both types of systems even at high temperatures; while the adiabatic stiffness appears to go to zero in the nonintegrable system and to a finite value in the integrable one. We analyze this difference in terms of the statistics of the current matrix elements and the degeneracies of the systems, and show that in the integrable system, despite the presence of degeneracies, the dominant contribution to the adiabatic stiffness comes from large-current-carrying nondegenerate states. We also show that energy transport at nonzero $\ensuremath{\omega}$ and $q$ occurs within a banded continuum in the integrable system indicative of ballistic transport while the nonintegrable system shows diffusion but with the existence of overdamped excitations at large values of momentum.

arXiv:0705.3791•Physical Review B•Jun 24, 2008•39 citations
We study a generic but simple nonintegrable quantum many-body system of locally interacting particles, namely, a kicked-parameter (t,V) model of spinless fermions on a one-dimensional lattice (equivalent to a kicked Heisenberg XX-Z chain of 1/2 spins). The statistical properties of the dynamics (quantum ergodicity and quantum mixing) and the nature of quantum transport in the thermodynamic limit are considered as the kick parameters (which control the degree of nonintegrability) are varied. We find and demonstrate ballistic transport and nonergodic, nonmixing dynamics (implying infinite conductivity at all temperatures) in the integrable regime of zero or very small kick parameters, and more generally and importantly, also in the nonintegrable regime of intermediate values of kicked parameters, whereas only for sufficiently large kick parameters do we recover quantum ergodicity and mixing implying normal (diffusive) transport. We propose an order parameter (charge stiffness D) which controls the phase transition from nonmixing and nonergodic dynamics (ordered phase, D>0) to mixing and ergodic dynamics (disordered phase, D=0) in the thermodynamic limit. Furthermore, we find exponential decay of time correlation functions in the regime of mixing dynamics. The results are obtained consistently within three different numerical and analytical approaches: (i) time evolution of a finite system and direct computation of time correlation functions, (ii) full diagonalization of finite systems and statistical analysis of stationary data, and (iii) algebraic construction of quantum invariants of motion of an infinite system, in particular the time-averaged observables.
Numerical evidence is given for nonergodic (nonmixing) behavior, exhibiting ideal transport, of a simple nonintegrable many-body quantum system in the thermodynamic limit, namely, the kicked ttt- VVV model of spinless fermions on a ring. However, for sufficiently large kick parameters ttt and VVV we recover quantum ergodicity, and normal transport, which can be described by random matrix theory.
A dynamical Lie algebraic method for the construction of quantum invariants of motion in non-integrable many-body systems of infinite size is proposed and applied to a simple but generic toy model, namely an infinite kicked t - V chain of interacting spinless fermions. The transition from an integrable via quasi-integrable ( intermediate ) to a quantum ergodic (quantum mixing) regime in parameter space is investigated. A dynamical phase transition between an ergodic and intermediate (neither ergodic nor completely integrable) regime in thermodynamic limit is proposed. The existence or non-existence of local conservation laws corresponds to the intermediate or ergodic regime, respectively. The computation of time-correlation functions of typical observables by means of local conservation laws is found to be fully consistent with direct calculations on finite systems.
The problem of calculation of time-correlation functions and relaxation phenomena in interacting quantum many-body systems or quantized fields is put into the framework of ergodic theory and dynamical systems. In this spirit we discuss spectral analysis of the adjoint propagator in a suitable Hilbert space of quantum observables in Heisenberg picture as an alternative approach to characterize many-body dynamics. We illustrate our approach by working out the time-autocorrelation functions at infinite temperature of a large class of observabIes for a spin s = 1/2 Ising chain in a periodically kicking transverse magnetic field, and show that they decay to their asymptotic values as ex: t3/ 2 General understanding of time-correlation functions and relaxation phenomena of interacting quantum many-body systems is a challenging problem with only very partial existing solutions. Situation is much better if one considers the motion of a one-body or few-body systems where the classical ergodic theory (see e.g. [1]) describes a variety of different types of motion, ranging from quasi-periodic integrable motion characterized by a discrete spectrum of the (Liouville) evolution operator, through KAM quasi-integrability, to ergodicity, mixing and chaos characterized by a continuous evolution spectrum. Mixing, which is equivalent of saying that correlation functions of an arbitrary pair of observables (A,B) decay in time, limt-HXJ ((A(t)B) (A)(B)) = 0, is the necessary dynamical property needed to justify the relaxation to equilibrium (micro/grand/canonical) state and the laws of statistical mechanics, such as the fluctuation-dissipation theorem and transport laws. Mixing in quantum many-body system has been investigated by numerical experiment only quite recently [2]. In another numerical experiment [3], a suggestive possibility of dynamical phase transition from non-ergodic/non-mixing to ergodic/mixing dynamics in a non-integrable periodically kicked chain of interacting spinless fermions (kicked t-V model) has been proposed. General absence of mixing in completely integrable quantum many-body systems (such as those solvable by Bethe ansatz), being the consequence of an infinite sequence of conservation 317 J. Bonca et al. (eds.), Open Problems in Strongly Correlated Electron Systems. 317-322. © 2001 Kluwer Academic Publishers. 318 OPEN PROBLEMS IN STRONGLY CORRELATED ELECTRON SYSTEMS laws, is directly responsible for finite temperature anomalous transport properties of such systems [4, 5]. Quantum mixing property is defined (here) relative with respect to a certain (Hilbert) (sub)space 6 of observables and is most conveniently discussed in Heisenberg picture where the equations of motion for quantum observable A(t) are addressed. Our approach may be interpreted also as a kind ofgeneralization ofLee's recurrence-relations methodof constructing continued-fraction representation of time-correlation functions [6]. After a short outline of the main ideas we will illustrate the method by describing a recent calculation [8] of the time-correlation functions for Ising s = 1/2 spin chain periodically kicked with transverse magnetic field. Quantum dynamics in Heisenberg picture is governed by the Heisenberg equation (d/dt)A(t) = i( adH(t))A(t), where (adH)A:= [H, A1 =HA AH. Our aim is to include description of dynamics of periodically time-dependent (e.g. kicked) quantum systems so we will adopt Floquet formalism and integrate equations of motion over one period of time T (for autonomous systems, T may be arbitrary, e.g. infinitesimally small), defining the so called quantum Floquet map or one-step propagatorU := T exp(-i J; dtH(t) )which induces the adjoint Floquet map U ad acting on the (sub)space 6 of observables A(t +T) = U ad A(t), U A:= utAU. We should require the subspace 6 to be invariat under dynamics, namely A E 6 :::} U ad A E 6. Linear space 6 is turned into the Hilbert space by introducing an innner product of two extensive observables in thermodynamic limit (size L -+ 00) as (AlB) = (AtB), (A):= lim .!.. tr A £--+00 L tr 1 (1) (2) which has a meaning of a canonical average at infinite temperature. 1 We note that the adjoint Floquet map U ad is a unitary operator in 6 w.r.t. inner product (1), or equivalently, that ad H is selfadjoint. Thus a pair (U ad , 6) defines a unitary evolution to which we apply standard terminology and results of spectral theory of dynamical systems (see e.g. part III of ref. [1]). To any observable A E 6 we assign spectral measure dI-'A(fJ), where the spectral parameter lies on a unit circle () E 8 1 == [0, 21f), which is directly related to the time-autocorrelation function of A (t) (AtA(mT)) = (AI[U 1 A) = / dI-'A(fJ)e • So, ergodic properties of the unitary evolution are dual to its spectral properties: IThis is the simplest choice which makes sense also for time-dependent systems. For autonomous systems one may work with more general finite-temperature canonical inner product (see e.g. [6]). Ergodic Properties ofQuantum Spin Chains: Kicked Transverse Ising Model 319 • Quantum dynamics is ergodic in 6 iff 1 is (at most) simple (nondegenerate) eigenvalue of Uad (with eigenvector 1 if 1 E 6). Then limT-too ~ JOT dt {(A(t)IB) (All)(IIB)} = O. • Quantum dynamics is mixing in 6 iflimt-too(A(t)IB) = (All)(IIB) for arbitrary A, B E 6. Then U ad has an absolutely continuous spectrum, except possibly for a simple eigenvalue 1. • If 1 is a multiply degenerate eigenvalue of U ad then the corresponding eigenvectors Qn are the conservation laws of 6, U ad Qn = Qn Let Qn be a complete set of orthonormalized (QnIQm) = dnm eigenvectors with eigenvalue 1. The averaged time-autocorrelation function is the spectral weight at point 1 1 jT DA:= lim -T dt(A(t)IA) = L. I(QnIA )1 • T-too 2 -T n (3) For example, if A = J is the particle/spin current D J is proportional to the charge/spin stiffness at infinite temperature and D J > 0 indicates ballistic transport. Even when the set of known conservation laws is incomplete, the above relation gives rigorous lower bound on DA [7, 5]. Next we propose a simple but nontrivial application of the above picture. We consider aHilbert space 6 ofobservables over infinite spin 1/2 chains described by Pauli operators a}, s E {x, y, z}, j E Z, which is spanned by two infinite sequences of selfadjoint observables Un and Vn,nEZ, namely n ~ 1, n =0, n <-1 ,
We study the infinite temperature dynamics of a prototypical one-dimensional system expected to exhibit many-body localization. Using numerically exact methods, we establish the dynamical phase diagram of this system based on the statistics of its eigenvalues and its dynamical behavior. We show that the nonergodic phase is reentrant as a function of the interaction strength, illustrating that localization can be reinforced by sufficiently strong interactions even at infinite temperature. Surprisingly, within the accessible time range, the ergodic phase shows subdiffusive behavior, suggesting that the diffusion coefficient vanishes throughout much of the phase diagram in the thermodynamic limit. Our findings strongly suggest that Wigner-Dyson statistics of eigenvalue spacings may appear in a class of ergodic but subdiffusive systems.
We analytically study the time evolution of the expectation values of observables in periodically kicked many-body quantum systems. Starting from an initial state, we compute both the transient and the long-time properties of the observables. Our derivation explains the criteria and the mechanism that lead to the infinite-temperature statistical average of observables at long times, irrespective of the initial state. When the criteria are violated, the observables oscillate with time. These oscillations are subharmonic and robust to small perturbations, suggesting the emergence of a discrete time crystal phase. We demonstrate these features explicitly in periodically kicked nonintegrable spin chains. For a spin chain with two kicks per cycle, we show that the kicked chain can exhibit an ergodic or a discrete-time crystal phase for the same kicking strengths, depending on the initial state preparation. We complement our time-evolution study of observables with the spectral form factor of these kicked models.
Integrable and nonintegrable systems have very different transport properties. In this paper, we highlight these differences for specific one-dimensional models of interacting lattice fermions. The technique used is a finite temperature numerical calculation of the adiabatic stiffness (also called the Drude weight or charge stiffness) and isothermal stiffness (also called the ``Meissner'' stiffness) in electrical and energy transport, and the momentum dependent dynamical conductivities $\ensuremath{\sigma}(q,\ensuremath{\omega})$ and $\ensuremath{\kappa}(q,\ensuremath{\omega})$. We apply a flux twist to break the Kramers degeneracy; thus, allowing us to focus on the effect of the dynamical degeneracies in the integrable system. In this situation, we show that the isothermal stiffness goes to zero rapidly with the system size for both types of systems even at high temperatures; while the adiabatic stiffness appears to go to zero in the nonintegrable system and to a finite value in the integrable one. We analyze this difference in terms of the statistics of the current matrix elements and the degeneracies of the systems, and show that in the integrable system, despite the presence of degeneracies, the dominant contribution to the adiabatic stiffness comes from large-current-carrying nondegenerate states. We also show that energy transport at nonzero $\ensuremath{\omega}$ and qqq occurs within a banded continuum in the integrable system indicative of ballistic transport while the nonintegrable system shows diffusion but with the existence of overdamped excitations at large values of momentum.