A paradigmatic example of a phase transition taking place in the absence of symmetry-breaking is provided by the Berezinkii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) transition in the two-dimensional XY model. In the framework of canonical ensemble, this phase transition is defined as an infinite-order one. To the contrary, by tackling the transitional behavior of the two dimensional XY model in the microcanonical ensemble, we show that the BKT phase transition is of second order. This provides a new example of statistical ensemble inequivalence that could apply to a broad class of systems undergoing BKT phase transitions.