Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/9501066 · Physical review. B, Condensed matter

Instability of the disordered critical points of Dirac fermions

Claudio Chamon, Christopher Mudry, Xiao-Gang Wen

Published Mar 15, 1996• 38 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recently, in an attempt to study disordered criticality in quantum Hall systems and $d$-wave superconductivity, it was found that two-dimensional random Dirac-fermion systems contain a line of critical points that is connected to the pure system. We use bosonization and current algebra to study properties of the critical line and calculate the exact scaling dimensions of all local operators. We find that the critical line contains an infinite number of relevant operators with negative scaling dimensions.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.53.r7638

Related papers

Effects of weak disorders on quantum Hall critical points

Jinwu Ye

We study the consequences of the random mass, random scalar potential, and random vector potential on the line of fixed points between integer and/or fractional quantum Hall states and an insulator. This line of fixed points was first identified in a clean Dirac fermion system with both Chern-Simon coupling and Coulomb interaction [Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 5409 (1998)]. By performing a renormalization-group analysis in $1/N$ $(N$ is the number of species of Dirac fermions) and the variances of three disorders ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{M},{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{V},{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{A},$ we find that ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{M}$ is irrelevant along this line, and both ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{A}$ and ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{V}$ are marginal. With the presence of all three disorders, the pure fixed line is unstable. Setting Chern-Simon interaction to zero, we find one nontrivial line of fixed points in the $({\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{A},w)$ plane with dynamic exponent $z=1$ and continuously changing \ensuremath{\nu}; it is stable against small $({\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{M},{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{V})$ in a small range of the line $1<w<1.31,$ therefore it may be relevant to integer quantum Hall transition. Setting ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{M}=0,$ we find a fixed plane with $z=1,$ the part of this plane with $\ensuremath{\nu}>1$ is stable against small ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{M},$ therefore it may be relevant to fractional quantum Hall transition. Although we do not find a generic fixed point with all the couplings nonvanishing, we prove that the theory is renormalizable to the order ${(1/N)}^{2},(1/N)\ensuremath{\Delta},{\ensuremath{\Delta}}^{2},$ and we explore the interesting processes which describe the interferences between the Chern-Simon interaction, the Coulomb interaction, and the three kinds of disorders.

arXiv:cond-mat/9902093•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Sep 15, 1999•34 citations

Renormalization group analysis of Dirac fermions with a random mass

Zhiming Pan, Tong Wang, Tomi Ohtsuki +1 more

Two-dimensional (2D) disordered superconductor (SC) in class D exhibits a disorder-induced quantum multicritical phenomenon among diffusive thermal metal (DTM), topological superconductor (TS), and conventional localized (AI) phases. To characterize the quantum tricritical point where these three phases meet, we carry out a two-loop renormalization group (RG) analysis for 2D Dirac fermion with random mass in terms of the $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$-expansion in the spatial dimension $d=2\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\epsilon}$. In two dimensions $(\ensuremath{\epsilon}=0)$, the random mass is marginally irrelevant around a clean-limit fixed point of the gapless Dirac fermion, while there exists an IR unstable fixed point at finite disorder strength that corresponds to the tricritical point. The critical exponent, dynamical exponent, and scaling dimension of the (uniform) mass term are evaluated around the tricritical point by the two-loop RG analysis. Using a mapping between an effective theory for the 2D random-mass Dirac fermion and the $(1+1)$-dimensional Gross-Neveu model, we further deduce the four-loop evaluation of the critical exponent, and the scaling dimension of the uniform mass around the tricritical point. Both the two-loop and four-loop results suggest that criticalities of a AI-DTM transition line as well as TS-DTM transition line are controlled by other saddle-point fixed point(s) at finite uniform mass.

arXiv:2108.08526•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 18, 2021•6 citations

Critical points of 2d disordered Dirac fermions: the Quantum Hall Transitions revisited

André LeClair

We propose a resolution of the renormalization group flow for the disordered Dirac fermion theories describing the quantum Hall transition (QHT) and spin Quantum Hall transition (SQHT), which previously revealed no perturbative fixed points at 1-loop and higher. The approach involves carrying out the flow in 2 stages, the first stage utilizing a new form of super spin-charge separation to flow to gl(1|1)_N and osp(2|2)_{-2N} supercurrent algebra theories, where N is the number of copies. This leads to the unconventional feature that at the critical point the exponents depend on the original number of copies N. In the second stage, additional forms of disorder are incorporated as dimension zero logarithmic operators, and the resulting actions have explicit forms in terms of two scalar fields and a symplectic fermion. Under some assumptions, the multi-fractal exponents are computed with the result q(1-q)/4 and q(1-q)/8 for the QHT and SQHT respectively, and are within a few percent of numerical estimates.

arXiv:0710.3778•Oct 22, 2007•0 citations

Disorder Induced Phase Transition for Random 2D Dirac Fermions

Victor Gurarie

We present evidence that two dimensional Dirac fermions in the presence of random Abelian gauge potential exhibit a phase transition when the disorder strength exceeds a certain critical value. We argue that this phase transition has novel properties unique to disordered systems. It resembles in many ways the transition from dilute to dense polymers phase in two dimension. In particular, we argue that the central charge of the disordered Dirac fermions, being $c=0$ before the transition, changes to $c=-2$. We discuss possible implications to quantum Hall transitions, in view of recently proposed model for quantum Hall transitions with $c=-2$.

arXiv:cond-mat/9907502•Jul 30, 1999•0 citations

Renormalization Group for disordered Dirac Fermions

André LeClair

We use the recently proposed all orders beta functions to study localization problems in two dimensions.A classification of random Dirac hamiltonians is presented.Beta functions for the Chalker-Coddington network model are presented and it is described how the renormalization group flows are toward a true singularity.The main subject of this talk is localization-delocalization transitions in two dimensions.This is a subject with many challenging and unsolved problems, the most important being finding a theoretical description of the critical properties of the quantum Hall transition.The Chalker-Coddington network model is perhaps the simplest model believed to be in the universality class of the quantum Hall transition [1].It can be formulated as a theory of random Dirac fermions, and it is believed that the disorder averaged effective theory should possess an infra-red fixed point conformal field theory capable of predicting the critical exponents governing the transition, e.g. the delocalization length exponent[2, 3].I will describe an attempt at finding the expected fixed point based on a proposed all orders beta function [5,6].The all-orders beta functions for the network models are based on general formulas found in [4].These beta-functions generally describe current-current interactions in two dimensions.Though they remain conjectural, several strong checks of the formula were performed for the simplest su(2) case in [7].As I will describe, for reasons that are not understood at the time, but appear to be specific to the application of the general theory to disordered systems, the renormalizaton group flows toward a true singularity, and thus we did not find the expected fixed point.The plan of the talk is as follows.I will first describe a classification of Random Dirac Fermions in 2d.In the next section I explain how supersymmetric Effective Actions are obtained upon disorder averaging.These generally involve current-current interactions and in the next section I describe the renormalization group (RG) for general interactions of this kind.Using arguments independent of the detailed beta functions, I then propose a connection between the possible fixed points and the Virasoro Master equation.In the last sections these methods are applied to the network models for the quantum Hall transtions.Unfortuanately, as I will describe, the all orders beta functions that appear to be correct for su(2) predict flows toward true singularities in the disordered problems.

Workshop on Integrable Theories, Solitons and Duality•Dec 1, 2002•0 citations

Quantum criticality of semi-Dirac fermions in 2+1 dimensions

Mikolaj D. Uryszek, Elliot Christou, Akbar Jaefari +2 more

Two-dimensional semi-Dirac fermions are quasiparticles that disperse linearly in one direction and quadratically in the other. We investigate instabilities of semi-Dirac fermions toward charge and spin density wave and superconducting orders, driven by short-range interactions. We analyze the critical behavior of the Yukawa theories for the different order parameters using Wilson momentum shell renormalization group. We generalize to a large number ${N}_{f}$ of fermion flavors to achieve analytic control in $2+1$ dimensions and calculate critical exponents at one-loop order, systematically including $1/{N}_{f}$ corrections. The latter depend on the specific form of the bosonic infrared propagator in $2+1$ dimensions, which needs to be included to regularize divergencies. The $1/{N}_{f}$ corrections are surprisingly small, suggesting that the expansion is well controlled in the physical dimension. The order parameter correlations inherit the electronic anisotropy of the semi-Dirac fermions, leading to correlation lengths that diverge along the spatial directions with distinct exponents, even at the mean-field level. We conjecture that the proximity to the critical point may stabilize novel modulated order phases.

arXiv:1907.11810•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 1, 2019•30 citations
Recently, in an attempt to study disordered criticality in quantum Hall systems and ddd-wave superconductivity, it was found that two-dimensional random Dirac-fermion systems contain a line of critical points that is connected to the pure system. We use bosonization and current algebra to study properties of the critical line and calculate the exact scaling dimensions of all local operators. We find that the critical line contains an infinite number of relevant operators with negative scaling dimensions.
We study the consequences of the random mass, random scalar potential, and random vector potential on the line of fixed points between integer and/or fractional quantum Hall states and an insulator. This line of fixed points was first identified in a clean Dirac fermion system with both Chern-Simon coupling and Coulomb interaction [Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 5409 (1998)]. By performing a renormalization-group analysis in 1/N1/N1/N (N(N(N is the number of species of Dirac fermions) and the variances of three disorders ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{M},{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{V},{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{A},$ we find that ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{M}$ is irrelevant along this line, and both ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{A}$ and ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{V}$ are marginal. With the presence of all three disorders, the pure fixed line is unstable. Setting Chern-Simon interaction to zero, we find one nontrivial line of fixed points in the $({\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{A},w)$ plane with dynamic exponent z=1z=1z=1 and continuously changing \ensuremath{\nu}; it is stable against small $({\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{M},{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{V})$ in a small range of the line 1<w<1.31,1<w<1.31,1<w<1.31, therefore it may be relevant to integer quantum Hall transition. Setting ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{M}=0,$ we find a fixed plane with z=1,z=1,z=1, the part of this plane with $\ensuremath{\nu}>1$ is stable against small ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{M},$ therefore it may be relevant to fractional quantum Hall transition. Although we do not find a generic fixed point with all the couplings nonvanishing, we prove that the theory is renormalizable to the order ${(1/N)}^{2},(1/N)\ensuremath{\Delta},{\ensuremath{\Delta}}^{2},$ and we explore the interesting processes which describe the interferences between the Chern-Simon interaction, the Coulomb interaction, and the three kinds of disorders.
Two-dimensional (2D) disordered superconductor (SC) in class D exhibits a disorder-induced quantum multicritical phenomenon among diffusive thermal metal (DTM), topological superconductor (TS), and conventional localized (AI) phases. To characterize the quantum tricritical point where these three phases meet, we carry out a two-loop renormalization group (RG) analysis for 2D Dirac fermion with random mass in terms of the $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$-expansion in the spatial dimension $d=2\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\epsilon}$. In two dimensions $(\ensuremath{\epsilon}=0)$, the random mass is marginally irrelevant around a clean-limit fixed point of the gapless Dirac fermion, while there exists an IR unstable fixed point at finite disorder strength that corresponds to the tricritical point. The critical exponent, dynamical exponent, and scaling dimension of the (uniform) mass term are evaluated around the tricritical point by the two-loop RG analysis. Using a mapping between an effective theory for the 2D random-mass Dirac fermion and the (1+1)(1+1)(1+1)-dimensional Gross-Neveu model, we further deduce the four-loop evaluation of the critical exponent, and the scaling dimension of the uniform mass around the tricritical point. Both the two-loop and four-loop results suggest that criticalities of a AI-DTM transition line as well as TS-DTM transition line are controlled by other saddle-point fixed point(s) at finite uniform mass.
We propose a resolution of the renormalization group flow for the disordered Dirac fermion theories describing the quantum Hall transition (QHT) and spin Quantum Hall transition (SQHT), which previously revealed no perturbative fixed points at 1-loop and higher. The approach involves carrying out the flow in 2 stages, the first stage utilizing a new form of super spin-charge separation to flow to gl(1|1)_N and osp(2|2)_{-2N} supercurrent algebra theories, where N is the number of copies. This leads to the unconventional feature that at the critical point the exponents depend on the original number of copies N. In the second stage, additional forms of disorder are incorporated as dimension zero logarithmic operators, and the resulting actions have explicit forms in terms of two scalar fields and a symplectic fermion. Under some assumptions, the multi-fractal exponents are computed with the result q(1-q)/4 and q(1-q)/8 for the QHT and SQHT respectively, and are within a few percent of numerical estimates.
We present evidence that two dimensional Dirac fermions in the presence of random Abelian gauge potential exhibit a phase transition when the disorder strength exceeds a certain critical value. We argue that this phase transition has novel properties unique to disordered systems. It resembles in many ways the transition from dilute to dense polymers phase in two dimension. In particular, we argue that the central charge of the disordered Dirac fermions, being c=0c=0c=0 before the transition, changes to c=−2c=-2c=−2. We discuss possible implications to quantum Hall transitions, in view of recently proposed model for quantum Hall transitions with c=−2c=-2c=−2.
We use the recently proposed all orders beta functions to study localization problems in two dimensions.A classification of random Dirac hamiltonians is presented.Beta functions for the Chalker-Coddington network model are presented and it is described how the renormalization group flows are toward a true singularity.The main subject of this talk is localization-delocalization transitions in two dimensions.This is a subject with many challenging and unsolved problems, the most important being finding a theoretical description of the critical properties of the quantum Hall transition.The Chalker-Coddington network model is perhaps the simplest model believed to be in the universality class of the quantum Hall transition [1].It can be formulated as a theory of random Dirac fermions, and it is believed that the disorder averaged effective theory should possess an infra-red fixed point conformal field theory capable of predicting the critical exponents governing the transition, e.g. the delocalization length exponent[2, 3].I will describe an attempt at finding the expected fixed point based on a proposed all orders beta function [5,6].The all-orders beta functions for the network models are based on general formulas found in [4].These beta-functions generally describe current-current interactions in two dimensions.Though they remain conjectural, several strong checks of the formula were performed for the simplest su(2) case in [7].As I will describe, for reasons that are not understood at the time, but appear to be specific to the application of the general theory to disordered systems, the renormalizaton group flows toward a true singularity, and thus we did not find the expected fixed point.The plan of the talk is as follows.I will first describe a classification of Random Dirac Fermions in 2d.In the next section I explain how supersymmetric Effective Actions are obtained upon disorder averaging.These generally involve current-current interactions and in the next section I describe the renormalization group (RG) for general interactions of this kind.Using arguments independent of the detailed beta functions, I then propose a connection between the possible fixed points and the Virasoro Master equation.In the last sections these methods are applied to the network models for the quantum Hall transtions.Unfortuanately, as I will describe, the all orders beta functions that appear to be correct for su(2) predict flows toward true singularities in the disordered problems.
Two-dimensional semi-Dirac fermions are quasiparticles that disperse linearly in one direction and quadratically in the other. We investigate instabilities of semi-Dirac fermions toward charge and spin density wave and superconducting orders, driven by short-range interactions. We analyze the critical behavior of the Yukawa theories for the different order parameters using Wilson momentum shell renormalization group. We generalize to a large number Nf{N}_{f}Nf​ of fermion flavors to achieve analytic control in 2+12+12+1 dimensions and calculate critical exponents at one-loop order, systematically including 1/Nf1/{N}_{f}1/Nf​ corrections. The latter depend on the specific form of the bosonic infrared propagator in 2+12+12+1 dimensions, which needs to be included to regularize divergencies. The 1/Nf1/{N}_{f}1/Nf​ corrections are surprisingly small, suggesting that the expansion is well controlled in the physical dimension. The order parameter correlations inherit the electronic anisotropy of the semi-Dirac fermions, leading to correlation lengths that diverge along the spatial directions with distinct exponents, even at the mean-field level. We conjecture that the proximity to the critical point may stabilize novel modulated order phases.