Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0703045 · Physical Review A

Comment on “Nonlinear band structure in Bose-Einstein condensates: Nonlinear Schrödinger equation with a Kronig-Penney potential”

Ippei Danshita, Shunji Tsuchiya

Published Jul 16, 2007• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In their recent paper [Phys. Rev. A 71, 033622 (2005)], Seaman et al. studied Bloch states of the condensate wave function in a Kronig-Penney potential and calculated the band structure. They argued that the effective mass is always positive when a swallowtail energy loop is present in the band structure. In this Comment, we reexamine their argument by actually calculating the effective mass. It is found that there exists a region where the effective mass is negative even when a swallowtail is present. Based on this fact, we discuss the interpretation of swallowtails in terms of superfluidity.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.76.017601

Related papers

Nonlinear band structure in Bose-Einstein condensates: Nonlinear Schrödinger equation with a Kronig-Penney potential

B. T. Seaman, Lincoln D. Carr, Murray Holland

All Bloch states of the mean field of a Bose-Einstein condensate in the presence of a one-dimensional lattice are presented in closed analytic form. The band structure is investigated by analyzing the stationary states of the nonlinear Schr\"odinger, or Gross-Pitaevskii, equation for both repulsive and attractive condensates. The appearance of swallowtails in the bands is examined and interpreted in terms of the condensates superfluid properties. The nonlinear stability properties of the Bloch states are described and the stable regions of the bands and swallowtails are mapped out. We find that the Kronig-Penney potential has the same properties as a sinusoidal potential. Bose-Einstein condensates are trapped in sinusoidal optical lattices. The Kronig-Penney potential has the advantage of being analytically tractable, unlike the sinusoidal potential, and, therefore, serves as a good model for understanding experimental phenomena.

arXiv:cond-mat/0410347•Physical Review A•Mar 21, 2005•67 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Nonlinear band structure in Bose-Einstein condensates: Nonlinear Schrödinger equation with a Kronig-Penney potential’ ”

B. T. Seaman, Lincoln D. Carr, Murray Holland

In response to Danshita and Tsuchiya's comment on our work on nonlinear band theory, we show that the size of the region of the swallowtail with a negative effective mass is inversely proportional to the interaction strength, i.e., for large interaction strengths, the region becomes negligibly small. We explain why the appearance of swallowtails is not related to superfluidity, but instead to a more universal nonlinear feature valid for both signs of the underlying atomic interactions: period doubling.

Physical Review A•Jul 16, 2007•1 citation

Nonlinear Band Structure in Bose Einstein Condensates: The Nonlinear Schr\

B. T. Seaman, Lincoln D. Carr, Murray Holland

All Bloch states of the mean field of a Bose-Einstein condensate in the presence of a one dimensional lattice of impurities are presented in closed analytic form. The band structure is investigated by analyzing the stationary states of the nonlinear Schr\odinger, or Gross-Pitaevskii, equation for both repulsive and attractive condensates. The appearance of swallowtails in the bands is examined and interpreted in terms of the condensates superfluid properties. The nonlinear stability properties of the Bloch states are described and the stable regions of the bands and swallowtails are mapped out. We find that the Kronig-Penney potential has the same properties as a sinusoidal potential; Bose-Einstein condensates are trapped in sinusoidal optical lattices. The Kronig-Penney potential has the advantage of being analytically tractable, unlike the sinusoidal potential, and, therefore, serves as a good model for experimental phenomena.

•Oct 13, 2004•0 citations

Period doubling, two-color lattices, and the growth of swallowtails in Bose-Einstein condensates

B. T. Seaman, Lincoln D. Carr, Murray Holland

The band structure of a Bose-Einstein condensate is studied for lattice traps of sinusoidal, Jacobi elliptic, and Kronig-Penney form, all in the context of the nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation. It is demonstrated that the physical properties of the system are independent of the type of lattice. The Kronig-Penney potential, which admits a full exact solution in closed analytical form, is then used to understand the swallowtails, or loops, that form in the band structure. The appearance of swallowtails is explained by adiabatically tuning a second lattice with half the period. Such a two-color lattice, which can be easily realized in experiments, has intriguing physical properties. For instance, swallowtails appear even for weak nonlinearity, which is the experimental regime. We determine the stability properties of this system and relate them to current experiments.

arXiv:cond-mat/0504217•Physical Review A•Sep 6, 2005•41 citations

Stability of Bose-Einstein condensates in a Kronig-Penney potential

Ippei Danshita, Shunji Tsuchiya

We study the stability of Bose-Einstein condensates with superfluid currents in a one-dimensional periodic potential. By using the Kronig-Penney model, the condensate and Bogoliubov bands are analytically calculated and the stability of condensates in a periodic potential is discussed. The Landau and dynamical instabilities occur in a Kronig-Penney potential when the quasimomentum of the condensate exceeds certain critical values as in a sinusoidal potential. It is found that the onsets of the Landau and dynamical instabilities coincide with the point where the perfect transmission of low energy excitations through each potential barrier is forbidden. The Landau instability is caused by the excitations with small $q$ and the dynamical instability is caused by the excitations with $q=\ensuremath{\pi}∕a$ at their onsets, where $q$ is the quasimomentum of excitation and $a$ is the lattice constant. A swallow-tail energy loop appears at the edge of the first condensate band when the mean-field energy is sufficiently larger than the strength of the periodic potential. We find that the upper portion of the swallow-tail is always dynamically unstable, but the second Bogoliubov band has a phonon spectrum reflecting the positive effective mass.

arXiv:cond-mat/0610582•Physical Review A•Mar 22, 2007•38 citations

Loop structure of the lowest Bloch band for a Bose-Einstein condensate

Dmitri Diakonov, Lars Melwyn Jensen, C. J. Pethick +1 more

We investigate analytically and numerically Bloch waves for a Bose-Einstein condensate in a sinusoidal external potential. At low densities the dependence of the energy on the quasimomentum is similar to that for a single particle, but at densities greater than a critical one the lowest band becomes triple valued near the boundary of the first Brillouin zone and develops the structure characteristic of the swallowtail catastrophe. We comment on the experimental consequences of this behavior.

arXiv:cond-mat/0111303•Physical Review A•Jul 16, 2002•118 citations
In their recent paper [Phys. Rev. A 71, 033622 (2005)], Seaman et al. studied Bloch states of the condensate wave function in a Kronig-Penney potential and calculated the band structure. They argued that the effective mass is always positive when a swallowtail energy loop is present in the band structure. In this Comment, we reexamine their argument by actually calculating the effective mass. It is found that there exists a region where the effective mass is negative even when a swallowtail is present. Based on this fact, we discuss the interpretation of swallowtails in terms of superfluidity.
All Bloch states of the mean field of a Bose-Einstein condensate in the presence of a one-dimensional lattice are presented in closed analytic form. The band structure is investigated by analyzing the stationary states of the nonlinear Schr\"odinger, or Gross-Pitaevskii, equation for both repulsive and attractive condensates. The appearance of swallowtails in the bands is examined and interpreted in terms of the condensates superfluid properties. The nonlinear stability properties of the Bloch states are described and the stable regions of the bands and swallowtails are mapped out. We find that the Kronig-Penney potential has the same properties as a sinusoidal potential. Bose-Einstein condensates are trapped in sinusoidal optical lattices. The Kronig-Penney potential has the advantage of being analytically tractable, unlike the sinusoidal potential, and, therefore, serves as a good model for understanding experimental phenomena.
In response to Danshita and Tsuchiya's comment on our work on nonlinear band theory, we show that the size of the region of the swallowtail with a negative effective mass is inversely proportional to the interaction strength, i.e., for large interaction strengths, the region becomes negligibly small. We explain why the appearance of swallowtails is not related to superfluidity, but instead to a more universal nonlinear feature valid for both signs of the underlying atomic interactions: period doubling.
All Bloch states of the mean field of a Bose-Einstein condensate in the presence of a one dimensional lattice of impurities are presented in closed analytic form. The band structure is investigated by analyzing the stationary states of the nonlinear Schr\odinger, or Gross-Pitaevskii, equation for both repulsive and attractive condensates. The appearance of swallowtails in the bands is examined and interpreted in terms of the condensates superfluid properties. The nonlinear stability properties of the Bloch states are described and the stable regions of the bands and swallowtails are mapped out. We find that the Kronig-Penney potential has the same properties as a sinusoidal potential; Bose-Einstein condensates are trapped in sinusoidal optical lattices. The Kronig-Penney potential has the advantage of being analytically tractable, unlike the sinusoidal potential, and, therefore, serves as a good model for experimental phenomena.
The band structure of a Bose-Einstein condensate is studied for lattice traps of sinusoidal, Jacobi elliptic, and Kronig-Penney form, all in the context of the nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation. It is demonstrated that the physical properties of the system are independent of the type of lattice. The Kronig-Penney potential, which admits a full exact solution in closed analytical form, is then used to understand the swallowtails, or loops, that form in the band structure. The appearance of swallowtails is explained by adiabatically tuning a second lattice with half the period. Such a two-color lattice, which can be easily realized in experiments, has intriguing physical properties. For instance, swallowtails appear even for weak nonlinearity, which is the experimental regime. We determine the stability properties of this system and relate them to current experiments.
We study the stability of Bose-Einstein condensates with superfluid currents in a one-dimensional periodic potential. By using the Kronig-Penney model, the condensate and Bogoliubov bands are analytically calculated and the stability of condensates in a periodic potential is discussed. The Landau and dynamical instabilities occur in a Kronig-Penney potential when the quasimomentum of the condensate exceeds certain critical values as in a sinusoidal potential. It is found that the onsets of the Landau and dynamical instabilities coincide with the point where the perfect transmission of low energy excitations through each potential barrier is forbidden. The Landau instability is caused by the excitations with small qqq and the dynamical instability is caused by the excitations with $q=\ensuremath{\pi}∕a$ at their onsets, where qqq is the quasimomentum of excitation and aaa is the lattice constant. A swallow-tail energy loop appears at the edge of the first condensate band when the mean-field energy is sufficiently larger than the strength of the periodic potential. We find that the upper portion of the swallow-tail is always dynamically unstable, but the second Bogoliubov band has a phonon spectrum reflecting the positive effective mass.