arXiv:cond-mat/0610850 · Physical Review B

Pfaffian pairing and backflow wavefunctions for electronic structure quantum Monte Carlo methods

Michal Bajdich, Luboš Mitáš, Lucas K. Wagner, Kevin E. Schmidt

Published Mar 10, 2008• 116 citations

Abstract

We investigate pfaffian trial wavefunctions with singlet and triplet pair orbitals by quantum Monte Carlo methods. We present mathematical identities and the key algebraic properties necessary for efficient evaluation of pfaffians. Following upon our previous study [Bajdich et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 130201 (2006)], we explore the possibilities of expanding the wavefunction in linear combinations of pfaffians. We observe that molecular systems require much larger expansions than atomic systems and linear combinations of a few pfaffians lead to rather small gains in correlation energy. We also test the wavefunction based on fully antisymmetrized product of independent pair orbitals. Despite its seemingly large variational potential, we do not observe additional gains in correlation energy. We find that pfaffians lead to substantial improvements in fermion nodes when compared to Hartree-Fock wavefunctions and exhibit the minimal number of two nodal domains in agreement with recent results on fermion nodes topology. We analyze the nodal structure differences of Hartree-Fock, pfaffian, and essentially exact large-scale configuration interaction wavefunctions. Finally, we combine the recently proposed form of backflow correlations [Drummond et al., J. Phys. Chem. 124, 22401 (2006); Rios et al., Phys. Rev. E. 74, 066701 (2006)] with both determinantal and pfaffian based wavefunctions.

DOI: 10.1103/physrevb.77.115112

Related papers

Pfaffian Pairing Wave Functions in Electronic-Structure Quantum Monte Carlo Simulations

Michal Bajdich, Luboš Mitáš, G. Drobný +2 more

We investigate the accuracy of trial wave functions for quantum Monte Carlo based on Pfaffian functional form with singlet and triplet pairing. Using a set of first row atoms and molecules we find that these wave functions provide very consistent and systematic behavior in recovering the correlation energies on the level of 95%. In order to get beyond this limit we explore the possibilities of multi-Pfaffian pairing wave functions. We show that a small number of Pfaffians recovers another large fraction of the missing correlation energy comparable to the larger-scale configuration interaction wave functions. We also find that Pfaffians lead to substantial improvements in fermion nodes when compared to Hartree-Fock wave functions.

arXiv:cond-mat/0512327Physical Review LettersApr 5, 2006145 citations

Electronic structure quantum Monte Carlo

Michal Bajdich, Luboš Mitáš

Electronic structure quantum Monte Carlo Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) is an advanced simulation methodology for studies of manybody quantum systems. The QMC approaches combine analytical insights with stochastic computational techniques for efficient solution of several classes of important many-body problems such as the stationary Schrödinger equation. QMC methods of various flavors have been applied to a great variety of systems spanning continuous and lattice quantum models, molecular and condensed systems, BEC-BCS ultracold condensates, nuclei, etc. In this review, we focus on the electronic structure QMC, i.e., methods relevant for systems described by the electron-ion Hamiltonians. Some of the key QMC achievements include direct treatment of electron correlation, accuracy in predicting energy differences and favorable scaling in the system size. Calculations of atoms, molecules, clusters and solids have demonstrated QMC applicability to real systems with hundreds of electrons while providing 90-95% of the correlation energy and energy differences typically within a few percent of experiments. Advances in accuracy beyond these limits are hampered by the so-called fixed-node approximation which is used to circumvent the notorious fermion sign problem. Many-body nodes of fermion states and their properties have therefore become one of the important topics for further progress in predictive power and efficiency of QMC calculations. Some of our recent results on the wave function nodes and related nodal domain topologies will be briefly reviewed. This includes analysis of few-electron systems and descriptions of exact and approximate nodes using transformations and projections of the highly-dimensional nodal hypersurfaces into the 3D space. Studies of fermion nodes offer new insights into topological properties of eigenstates such as explicit demonstrations that generic fermionic ground states exhibit the minimal number of two nodal domains. Recently proposed trial wave functions based on Pfaffians with pairing orbitals are presented and their nodal properties are tested in calculations of first row atoms and molecules. Finally, backflow "dressed" coordinates are introduced as another possibility for capturing correlation effects and for decreasing the fixed-node bias.

arXiv:1008.2369Acta Physica Slovaca Reviews and TutorialsApr 1, 200933 citations

General Correlated Geminal Ansatz for Electronic Structure Calculations: Exploiting Pfaffians in Place of Determinants

Claudio Genovese, Tomonori Shirakawa, Kousuke Nakano +1 more

High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide We propose here a single Pfaffian correlated variational ansatz that dramatically improves the accuracy with respect to the single determinant one, while remaining at a similar computational cost. A much larger correlation energy is indeed determined by the most general two electron pairing function, including both singlet and triplet channels, combined with a many-body Jastrow factor, including all possible spin–spin, spin–density, and density–density terms. The main technical ingredient to exploit this accuracy is the use of the Pfaffian for antisymmetrizing a highly correlated pairing function, thus recovering the Fermi statistics for electrons with an affordable computational cost. Moreover, the application of the diffusion Monte Carlo, within the fixed node approximation, allows us to obtain very accurate binding energies for the first preliminary calculations reported in this study: C 2, N 2, and O 2 and the benzene molecule. This is promising and remarkable, considering that they represent extremely difficult molecules even for computationally demanding multideterminant approaches, and opens therefore the way for realistic and accurate electronic simulations with an algorithm scaling at most as the fourth power of the number of electrons.

arXiv:2002.03347Journal of Chemical Theory and ComputationAug 17, 202021 citations

Pairing in Cold Atoms and other Applications for Quantum Monte Carlo methods

Michal Bajdich, Jindřich Kolorenč, Luboš Mitáš +1 more

We discuss the importance of the fermion nodes for the quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods and find two cases of the exact nodes. We describe the structure of the generalized pairing wave functions in Pfaffian antisymmetric form and demonstrate their equivalency with certain class of configuration interaction wave functions. We present the QMC calculations of a model fermion system at unitary limit. We find the system to have the energy of E=0.425Efree and the condensate fraction of α=0.48. Further we also perform the QMC calculations of the potential energy surface and the electric dipole moment along that surface of the LiSr molecule. We estimate the vibrationally averaged dipole moment to be 〈D〉ν=0=−0.4(2).

Physics ProcediaFeb 1, 20102 citations

Backflow and pairing wave function for quantum Monte Carlo methods

Pablo López Ríos

Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods are a class of stochastic techniques that can be used to compute the properties of electronic systems accurately from first principles. This thesis is mainly concerned with the development of trial wave functions for QMC. An extension of the backflow transformation to inhomogeneous electronic systems is presented and applied to atoms, molecules and extended systems. The backflow transformation I have developed typically retrieves an additional 50% of the remaining correlation energy at the variational Monte Carlo level, and 30% at the diffusion Monte Carlo level; the number of parameters required to achieve a given fraction of the correlation energy does not appear to increase with system size. The expense incurred by the use of backflow transformations is investigated, and it is found to scale favourably with system size. Additionally, I propose a single wave function form for studying the electron-hole system which includes pairing effects and is capable of describing all of the relevant phases of this system. The effectiveness of this general wave function is demonstrated by applying it to a particular transition between two phases of the symmetric electron-hole bilayer, and it is found that using a single wave function form gives a more accurate physical description of the system than using a different wave function to describe each phase. Both of these developments are new, and they provide a powerful set of tools for designing accurate wave functions. Backflow transformations are particularly important for systems with repulsive interactions, while pairing wave functions are important for attractive interactions. It is possible to combine backflow and pairing to further increase the accuracy of the wave function. The wave function technology that I have developed should therefore be useful across a very wide range of problems.

Oct 2, 20064 citations

Variational Monte Carlo

Richard M. Martin, Lucia Reining, David M. Ceperley

Since the form of PN is the same as that occurring in the statistical mechanics of the classical gas (replace f 2 ( r ij ) by exp[- V ( r ij /kT ]), we can use the same integration techniques that are used in the classical problem. W. L. McMillan, 1965 Summary Building on the random walk methods developed in the previous chapter, we show how to compute properties of many-body trial wavefunctions using a random walk. This method, called variational Monte Carlo, is the simplest stochastic quantum many-body technique. Whereas mean-field methods are usually limited to single determinants, variational Monte Carlo can treat any correlated trial function, as long as its values are computable. We discuss how to optimize such trial wavefunctions, how to compute their momentum distribution, how to use non-local pseudopotentials, how to compute excited states, and how to correct for the finite size of the simulation cell. Deterministic quantum methods have difficulties. For example, the Hartree–Fock method assumes the wavefunction is a single Slater determinant, neglecting correlation. If one expands as a sum of determinants, it is very difficult to have the results size-consistent since the number of determinants needed will grow exponentially with the system size. As we have seen, the DMFT method introduced in Ch. 16 assumes locality. In Ch. 6 we discussed general properties of many-body wavefunctions. Using Monte Carlo methods, we can directly incorporate correlation into a wavefunction, without having to make any further approximations other than the form of the correlation factors. In many cases the energy and other properties are very close to the exact results. Some of the usual restrictions on the form of the many-body wavefunction are not an issue in variational Monte Carlo. The most important generalization of the HF wavefunction is to put correlation directly into the wavefunction via the “Jastrow” factor. At next order, one can use the “backflow” wavefunction, in which correlation is also built into the determinant. The variational Monte Carlo method (VMC) was first used by McMillan [44] to calculate the ground-state properties of superfluid 4 He. One of the key problems at that time was whether the observed superfluid properties were a consequence of Bose condensation.

Cambridge University Press eBooksMay 31, 20161 citation