Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0610316 · Physical Review B

Topological order and topological entropy in classical systems

Claudio Castelnovo, Claudio Chamon

Published Nov 8, 2007• 57 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that the concept of topological order, introduced to describe ordered quantum systems which cannot be classified by broken symmetries, also applies to classical systems. We discuss some of the fundamental properties of this type of classical order and propose how to expose it via a generalized topological entropy. Starting from a specific example, we show how to use (quantum) pure state density matrices to construct corresponding (classical) thermally mixed ones that retain precisely half of the original topological entropy, a result that we generalize to a whole class of systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.76.174416

Related papers

Topological order of mixed states in correlated quantum many-body systems

Fabian Grusdt

Topological order has become a new paradigm to distinguish ground states of interacting many-body systems without conventional long-range order. Here, we discuss possible extensions of this concept to density matrices describing statistical ensembles. For a large class of quasithermal states, which can be realized as thermal states of some quasilocal Hamiltonian, we generalize earlier definitions of density-matrix topology to generic many-body systems with strong correlations. We point out that the robustness of topological order, defined as a pattern of long-range entanglement, depends crucially on the perturbations under consideration. While it is intrinsically protected against local perturbations of arbitrary strength in an infinite closed quantum system, purely local perturbations can destroy topological order in open systems coupled to baths if the coupling is sufficiently strong. We discuss our classification scheme using the finite-temperature quantum Hall states and point out that the classical Hall effect can be understood as a finite-temperature topological phase.

arXiv:1609.02432•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 2, 2017•34 citations

Replica topological order in quantum mixed states and quantum error correction

Zhuan Li, Roger S. K. Mong

Topological phases of matter offer a promising platform for quantum computation and quantum error correction. Nevertheless, unlike its counterpart in pure states, descriptions of topological order in mixed states remain relatively underexplored. Our work gives two definitions for replica topological order in mixed states, which involve $n$ copies of density matrices of the mixed state. Our framework categorizes topological orders in mixed states as either quantum, classical, or trivial, depending on the type of information that can be encoded. For the case of the toric code model in the presence of decoherence, we associate for each phase a quantum channel and describes the structure of the code space. We show that in the quantum-topological phase, there exists a postselection-based error correction protocol that recovers the quantum information, while in the classical-topological phase, the quantum information has decohere and cannot be fully recovered. We accomplish this by describing the mixed state as a projected entangled pairs state (PEPS) and identifying the symmetry-protected topological order of its boundary state to the bulk topology. Using this formalism, we enumerate all the possible mixed state phases which result from applying a local decoherence channel to the toric code. In addition to the classical-topological phases that have been previously reported on, we also find mixed states exhibiting chiral topological order. We discuss the extent that our findings can be extrapolated to $n\ensuremath{\rightarrow}1$ limit.

arXiv:2402.09516•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 5, 2025•8 citations

A recipe for topological observables of density matrices

Charles-Edouard Bardyn

Meaningful topological invariants for mixed quantum states are challenging to identify as there is no unique way to define them, and most choices do not directly relate to physical observables. Here, we propose a simple pragmatic approach to construct topological invariants of mixed states while preserving a connection to physical observables, by continuously deforming known topological invariants for pure (ground) states. Our approach relies on expectation values of many-body operators, with no reference to single-particle (e.g., Bloch) wavefunctions. To illustrate it, we examine extensions to mixed states of $U(1)$ geometric (Berry) phases and their corresponding topological invariant (winding or Chern number). We discuss measurement schemes, and provide a detailed construction of invariants for thermal or more general mixed states of quantum systems with (at least) $U(1)$ charge-conservation symmetry, such as quantum Hall insulators.

arXiv:1711.09735•Nov 27, 2017•3 citations

Gapped quantum liquids and topological order, stochastic local transformations and emergence of unitarity

Bei Zeng, Xiao-Gang Wen

In this work, we present some new understanding of topological order, including three main aspects. (1) It was believed that classifying topological orders corresponds to classifying gapped quantum states. We show that such a statement is not precise. We introduce the concept of gapped quantum liquid as a special kind of gapped quantum states that can ``dissolve'' any product states on additional sites. Topologically ordered states actually correspond to gapped quantum liquids with stable ground-state degeneracy. Symmetry-breaking states for on-site symmetry are also gapped quantum liquids, but with unstable ground-state degeneracy. (2) We point out that the universality classes of generalized local unitary (gLU) transformations (without any symmetry) contain both topologically ordered states and symmetry-breaking states. This allows us to use a gLU invariant---topological entanglement entropy---to probe the symmetry-breaking properties hidden in the exact ground state of a finite system, which does not break any symmetry. This method can probe symmetry- breaking orders even without knowing the symmetry and the associated order parameters. (3) The universality classes of topological orders and symmetry-breaking orders can be distinguished by stochastic local (SL) transformations (i.e., local invertible transformations): small SL transformations can convert the symmetry-breaking classes to the trivial class of product states with finite probability of success, while the topological-order classes are stable against any small SL transformations, demonstrating a phenomenon of emergence of unitarity. This allows us to give a definition of long-range entanglement based on SL transformations, under which only topologically ordered states are long-range entangled.

arXiv:1406.5090•Physical Review B•Mar 12, 2015•97 citations

Mixed-State Topological Phase: Quantized Topological Order Parameter and Lieb-Schultz-Mattis Theorem

Linhao Li, Yuan Yao

We investigate the extension of pure-state symmetry protected topological phases to mixed-state regime with a strong U(1) and a weak $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetries in one-dimensional spin systems by the concept of quantum channels. We propose a corresponding topological phase order parameter for short-range entangled mixed states by showing that it is quantized and its distinct values can be realized by concrete spin systems with disorders, sharply signaling phase transitions among them. We also give a model-independent way to generate two distinct phases by various types of translation and reflection transformations. These results on the short-range entangled mixed states further enable us to generalize the conventional Lieb-Schultz-Mattis theorem to mixed states, even without the concept of spectral gaps and lattice Hamiltonians.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2603.24031•Mar 26, 2026•0 citations

Topological and error-correcting properties for symmetry-protected topological order

Bei Zeng, D. L. Zhou

We study the symmetry-protected topological (SPT) orders for bosonic systems from an information-theoretic viewpoint. We show that with a proper choice of the onsite basis, the degenerate ground-state space of SPT orders (on a manifold with boundary) is a quantum error-correcting code with macroscopic classical distance, hence is stable against any local bit-flip errors. We show that this error-correcting property of the SPT orders has a natural connection to that of the symmetry-breaking orders, whose degenerate ground-state space is a classical error-correcting code with a macroscopic distance, providing a new angle for the hidden symmetry-breaking properties in SPT orders. We further propose new types of topological entanglement entropy that probe the SPT orders hidden in their symmetric ground states, which also signal the topological phase transitions protected by symmetry. Combined with the original definition of topological entanglement entropy that probes the “intrinsic topological orders”, and the recent proposed one that probes the symmetry-breaking orders, the set of different types of topological entanglement entropy may hence distinguish topological orders, SPT orders, and symmetry-breaking orders, which may be mixed up in a single system.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Mar 1, 2016•32 citations
We show that the concept of topological order, introduced to describe ordered quantum systems which cannot be classified by broken symmetries, also applies to classical systems. We discuss some of the fundamental properties of this type of classical order and propose how to expose it via a generalized topological entropy. Starting from a specific example, we show how to use (quantum) pure state density matrices to construct corresponding (classical) thermally mixed ones that retain precisely half of the original topological entropy, a result that we generalize to a whole class of systems.
Topological order has become a new paradigm to distinguish ground states of interacting many-body systems without conventional long-range order. Here, we discuss possible extensions of this concept to density matrices describing statistical ensembles. For a large class of quasithermal states, which can be realized as thermal states of some quasilocal Hamiltonian, we generalize earlier definitions of density-matrix topology to generic many-body systems with strong correlations. We point out that the robustness of topological order, defined as a pattern of long-range entanglement, depends crucially on the perturbations under consideration. While it is intrinsically protected against local perturbations of arbitrary strength in an infinite closed quantum system, purely local perturbations can destroy topological order in open systems coupled to baths if the coupling is sufficiently strong. We discuss our classification scheme using the finite-temperature quantum Hall states and point out that the classical Hall effect can be understood as a finite-temperature topological phase.
Topological phases of matter offer a promising platform for quantum computation and quantum error correction. Nevertheless, unlike its counterpart in pure states, descriptions of topological order in mixed states remain relatively underexplored. Our work gives two definitions for replica topological order in mixed states, which involve nnn copies of density matrices of the mixed state. Our framework categorizes topological orders in mixed states as either quantum, classical, or trivial, depending on the type of information that can be encoded. For the case of the toric code model in the presence of decoherence, we associate for each phase a quantum channel and describes the structure of the code space. We show that in the quantum-topological phase, there exists a postselection-based error correction protocol that recovers the quantum information, while in the classical-topological phase, the quantum information has decohere and cannot be fully recovered. We accomplish this by describing the mixed state as a projected entangled pairs state (PEPS) and identifying the symmetry-protected topological order of its boundary state to the bulk topology. Using this formalism, we enumerate all the possible mixed state phases which result from applying a local decoherence channel to the toric code. In addition to the classical-topological phases that have been previously reported on, we also find mixed states exhibiting chiral topological order. We discuss the extent that our findings can be extrapolated to $n\ensuremath{\rightarrow}1$ limit.
Meaningful topological invariants for mixed quantum states are challenging to identify as there is no unique way to define them, and most choices do not directly relate to physical observables. Here, we propose a simple pragmatic approach to construct topological invariants of mixed states while preserving a connection to physical observables, by continuously deforming known topological invariants for pure (ground) states. Our approach relies on expectation values of many-body operators, with no reference to single-particle (e.g., Bloch) wavefunctions. To illustrate it, we examine extensions to mixed states of U(1)U(1)U(1) geometric (Berry) phases and their corresponding topological invariant (winding or Chern number). We discuss measurement schemes, and provide a detailed construction of invariants for thermal or more general mixed states of quantum systems with (at least) U(1)U(1)U(1) charge-conservation symmetry, such as quantum Hall insulators.
In this work, we present some new understanding of topological order, including three main aspects. (1) It was believed that classifying topological orders corresponds to classifying gapped quantum states. We show that such a statement is not precise. We introduce the concept of gapped quantum liquid as a special kind of gapped quantum states that can ``dissolve'' any product states on additional sites. Topologically ordered states actually correspond to gapped quantum liquids with stable ground-state degeneracy. Symmetry-breaking states for on-site symmetry are also gapped quantum liquids, but with unstable ground-state degeneracy. (2) We point out that the universality classes of generalized local unitary (gLU) transformations (without any symmetry) contain both topologically ordered states and symmetry-breaking states. This allows us to use a gLU invariant---topological entanglement entropy---to probe the symmetry-breaking properties hidden in the exact ground state of a finite system, which does not break any symmetry. This method can probe symmetry- breaking orders even without knowing the symmetry and the associated order parameters. (3) The universality classes of topological orders and symmetry-breaking orders can be distinguished by stochastic local (SL) transformations (i.e., local invertible transformations): small SL transformations can convert the symmetry-breaking classes to the trivial class of product states with finite probability of success, while the topological-order classes are stable against any small SL transformations, demonstrating a phenomenon of emergence of unitarity. This allows us to give a definition of long-range entanglement based on SL transformations, under which only topologically ordered states are long-range entangled.
We investigate the extension of pure-state symmetry protected topological phases to mixed-state regime with a strong U(1) and a weak Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ symmetries in one-dimensional spin systems by the concept of quantum channels. We propose a corresponding topological phase order parameter for short-range entangled mixed states by showing that it is quantized and its distinct values can be realized by concrete spin systems with disorders, sharply signaling phase transitions among them. We also give a model-independent way to generate two distinct phases by various types of translation and reflection transformations. These results on the short-range entangled mixed states further enable us to generalize the conventional Lieb-Schultz-Mattis theorem to mixed states, even without the concept of spectral gaps and lattice Hamiltonians.
We study the symmetry-protected topological (SPT) orders for bosonic systems from an information-theoretic viewpoint. We show that with a proper choice of the onsite basis, the degenerate ground-state space of SPT orders (on a manifold with boundary) is a quantum error-correcting code with macroscopic classical distance, hence is stable against any local bit-flip errors. We show that this error-correcting property of the SPT orders has a natural connection to that of the symmetry-breaking orders, whose degenerate ground-state space is a classical error-correcting code with a macroscopic distance, providing a new angle for the hidden symmetry-breaking properties in SPT orders. We further propose new types of topological entanglement entropy that probe the SPT orders hidden in their symmetric ground states, which also signal the topological phase transitions protected by symmetry. Combined with the original definition of topological entanglement entropy that probes the “intrinsic topological orders”, and the recent proposed one that probes the symmetry-breaking orders, the set of different types of topological entanglement entropy may hence distinguish topological orders, SPT orders, and symmetry-breaking orders, which may be mixed up in a single system.