Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0604137 · Physical Review B

Fermion Cooper pairing with unequal masses: Standard field theory approach

Lianyi He, Meng Jin, Pengfei Zhuang

Published Jul 24, 2006• 25 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Fermion Cooper pairing with unequal masses is investigated in a standard field theory approach. We derived the superfluid density and Meissner mass squared of the U(1) gauge field in a general two-species model and found that the often used proportional relation between the two quantities is broken when the fermion masses are unequal. In the weak-coupling region, the superfluid density is always negative but the Meissner mass squared becomes mostly positive when the mass ratio between the pairing fermions is large enough. We established a proper momentum configuration of the LOFF pairing with unequal masses and showed that the LOFF state is energetically favored due to the negative superfluid density. The single-plane-wave LOFF state is physically equivalent to an anisotropic state with a spontaneously generated superflow. The extension to a finite-range interaction is briefly discussed.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.74.024516

Related papers

Pairing in a two-component ultracold Fermi gas: Phases with broken-space symmetries

Armen Sedrakian, Jordi Mur-Petit, A. Polls +1 more

We explore the phase diagram of a two-component ultracold atomic Fermi gas interacting with zero-range forces in the limit of weak coupling. We focus on the dependence of the pairing gap and the free energy on the variations in the number densities of the two species while the total density of the system is held fixed. As the density asymmetry is increased, the system exhibits a transition from a homogenous Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) phase to phases with spontaneously broken global space symmetries. One such realization is the deformed Fermi surface superfluidity (DFS) which exploits the possibility of deforming the Fermi surfaces of the species into ellipsoidal form at zero total momentum of Cooper pairs. The critical asymmetries at which the transition from DFS to the unpaired state occurs are larger than those for the BCS phase. In this precritical region the DFS phase lowers the pairing energy of the asymmetric BCS state. We compare quantitatively the DFS phase to another realization of superconducting phases with broken translational symmetry: the single-plane-wave Larkin-Ovchinnikov-Fulde-Ferrell phase, which is characterized by a nonvanishing center-of-mass momentum of the Cooper pairs. The possibility of the detection of the DFS phase in the time-of-flight experiments is discussed and quantified for the case of $^{6}\mathrm{Li}$ atoms trapped in two different hyperfine states.

arXiv:cond-mat/0504511•Physical Review A•Jul 22, 2005•101 citations

Resonant pairing between fermions with unequal masses

Shin-Tza Wu, C.-H. Pao, Sungkit Yip

We study via mean-field theory the pairing between fermions of different masses, especially at the unitary limit. At equal populations, the thermodynamic properties are identical with the equal mass case provided an appropriate rescaling is made. At unequal populations, for sufficiently light majority species, the system does not phase separate. For sufficiently heavy majority species, the phase separated normal phase have a density larger than that of the superfluid. For atoms in harmonic traps, the density profiles for unequal mass fermions can be drastically different from their equal-mass counterparts.

arXiv:cond-mat/0604572•Physical Review B•Dec 13, 2006•60 citations

LOFF pairing vs breached pairing in asymmetric fermion superfluids

Lianyi He, Meng Jin, Pengfei Zhuang

A general analysis for the competition between breached pairing (BP) and LOFF pairing mechanisms in asymmetric fermion superfluids is presented in the frame of a four fermion interaction model. Two physical conditions which can induce mismatched Fermi surfaces are considered: (1) fixed chemical potential asymmetry $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\mu}$ and (2) fixed fermion number asymmetry $\ensuremath{\alpha}$. In case (1), the BP state is ruled out because of Sarma instability, and the LOFF state is thermodynamically stable in a narrow window of $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\mu}$. In case (2), while the Sarma instability can be avoided and both the BP and LOFF states can survive provided $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ is less than the corresponding critical value, the BP state suffers magnetic instability and the LOFF state is always thermodynamically stable. While the LOFF window in case (2) is much larger than the one in the conventional case (1), the longitudinal superfluid density of the LOFF state is negative for small $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ and it suffers magnetic instability too.

arXiv:cond-mat/0601147•Physical Review B•Jun 29, 2006•71 citations

Superfluid pairing between fermions with unequal masses

M. A. Baranov, C. Lobo, Gora V. Shlyapnikov

We consider a superfluid state in a two-component gas of fermionic atoms with equal densities and unequal masses in the BCS limit. We develop a perturbation theory along the lines proposed by Gorkov and Melik-Barkhudarov and find that for a large difference in the masses of heavy $(M)$ and light $(m)$ atoms one has to take into account both the second-order and third-order contributions. The result for the critical temperature and order parameter is then quite different from the prediction of the simple BCS approach. Moreover, the small parameter of the theory turns out to be $({p}_{F}\ensuremath{\mid}a\ensuremath{\mid}∕\ensuremath{\hbar})\sqrt{M∕m}⪡1$, where ${p}_{F}$ is the Fermi momentum and $a$ the scattering length. Thus, for a large mass ratio $M∕m$ the conventional perturbation theory requires significantly smaller Fermi momenta (densities) or scattering lengths than in the case of $M\ensuremath{\sim}m$, where the small parameter is ${p}_{F}\ensuremath{\mid}a\ensuremath{\mid}∕\ensuremath{\hbar}⪡1$. We show that three-body scattering resonances appearing at a large mass ratio due to the presence of three-body bound Efimov states do not influence the result, which in this sense becomes universal.

arXiv:0801.1815•Physical Review A•Sep 29, 2008•46 citations

Asymmetric Fermi superfluid with different atomic species in a harmonic trap

C.-H. Pao, Shin-Tza Wu, Sungkit Yip

We study the dilute fermion gas with pairing between two species and unequal concentrations in a harmonic trap using the mean-field theory and the local density approximation. We found that the system can exhibit a superfluid shell structure sandwiched by the normal fermions. This superfluid shell structure occurs if the mass ratio is larger than a certain critical value, which increases from the weak-coupling BCS region to the strong-coupling Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) side. In the strong-coupling BEC regime, the radii of the superfluid phase are less sensitive to the mass ratios and are similar to the case of pairing with equal masses. However, the lighter leftover fermions are easier to mix with the superfluid core than the heavier ones. A partially polarized superfluid can be found if the majority fermions are lighter, whereas phase separation is still found if they are heavier.

arXiv:0708.3167•Physical Review A•Nov 26, 2007•26 citations

Mixtures of ultracold fermions with unequal masses

M. Iskin, C. A. R. Sá de Melo

We analyze the phase diagram of superfluidity for two-species fermion mixtures from the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) to Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) limit as a function of scattering parameter, population imbalance, and mass anisotropy. We identify regions corresponding to normal, or uniform or nonuniform superfluid phases, and discuss topological quantum phase transitions in the BCS, unitarity, and BEC limits. We derive the Ginzburg-Landau equation near the critical temperature, and show that it describes a dilute mixture of paired and unpaired fermions in the BEC limit. We also obtain the zero temperature low frequency and long wavelength collective excitation spectrum, and recover the Bogoliubov relation for weakly interacting dilute bosons in the BEC limit. Lastly, we discuss the effects of harmonic traps and the resulting density profiles in the BEC regime.

arXiv:cond-mat/0703258•Physical Review A•Jul 2, 2007•52 citations
Fermion Cooper pairing with unequal masses is investigated in a standard field theory approach. We derived the superfluid density and Meissner mass squared of the U(1) gauge field in a general two-species model and found that the often used proportional relation between the two quantities is broken when the fermion masses are unequal. In the weak-coupling region, the superfluid density is always negative but the Meissner mass squared becomes mostly positive when the mass ratio between the pairing fermions is large enough. We established a proper momentum configuration of the LOFF pairing with unequal masses and showed that the LOFF state is energetically favored due to the negative superfluid density. The single-plane-wave LOFF state is physically equivalent to an anisotropic state with a spontaneously generated superflow. The extension to a finite-range interaction is briefly discussed.
We explore the phase diagram of a two-component ultracold atomic Fermi gas interacting with zero-range forces in the limit of weak coupling. We focus on the dependence of the pairing gap and the free energy on the variations in the number densities of the two species while the total density of the system is held fixed. As the density asymmetry is increased, the system exhibits a transition from a homogenous Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) phase to phases with spontaneously broken global space symmetries. One such realization is the deformed Fermi surface superfluidity (DFS) which exploits the possibility of deforming the Fermi surfaces of the species into ellipsoidal form at zero total momentum of Cooper pairs. The critical asymmetries at which the transition from DFS to the unpaired state occurs are larger than those for the BCS phase. In this precritical region the DFS phase lowers the pairing energy of the asymmetric BCS state. We compare quantitatively the DFS phase to another realization of superconducting phases with broken translational symmetry: the single-plane-wave Larkin-Ovchinnikov-Fulde-Ferrell phase, which is characterized by a nonvanishing center-of-mass momentum of the Cooper pairs. The possibility of the detection of the DFS phase in the time-of-flight experiments is discussed and quantified for the case of 6Li^{6}\mathrm{Li}6Li atoms trapped in two different hyperfine states.
We study via mean-field theory the pairing between fermions of different masses, especially at the unitary limit. At equal populations, the thermodynamic properties are identical with the equal mass case provided an appropriate rescaling is made. At unequal populations, for sufficiently light majority species, the system does not phase separate. For sufficiently heavy majority species, the phase separated normal phase have a density larger than that of the superfluid. For atoms in harmonic traps, the density profiles for unequal mass fermions can be drastically different from their equal-mass counterparts.
A general analysis for the competition between breached pairing (BP) and LOFF pairing mechanisms in asymmetric fermion superfluids is presented in the frame of a four fermion interaction model. Two physical conditions which can induce mismatched Fermi surfaces are considered: (1) fixed chemical potential asymmetry $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\mu}$ and (2) fixed fermion number asymmetry $\ensuremath{\alpha}$. In case (1), the BP state is ruled out because of Sarma instability, and the LOFF state is thermodynamically stable in a narrow window of $\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\mu}$. In case (2), while the Sarma instability can be avoided and both the BP and LOFF states can survive provided $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ is less than the corresponding critical value, the BP state suffers magnetic instability and the LOFF state is always thermodynamically stable. While the LOFF window in case (2) is much larger than the one in the conventional case (1), the longitudinal superfluid density of the LOFF state is negative for small $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ and it suffers magnetic instability too.
We consider a superfluid state in a two-component gas of fermionic atoms with equal densities and unequal masses in the BCS limit. We develop a perturbation theory along the lines proposed by Gorkov and Melik-Barkhudarov and find that for a large difference in the masses of heavy (M)(M)(M) and light (m)(m)(m) atoms one has to take into account both the second-order and third-order contributions. The result for the critical temperature and order parameter is then quite different from the prediction of the simple BCS approach. Moreover, the small parameter of the theory turns out to be $({p}_{F}\ensuremath{\mid}a\ensuremath{\mid}∕\ensuremath{\hbar})\sqrt{M∕m}⪡1$, where pF{p}_{F}pF​ is the Fermi momentum and aaa the scattering length. Thus, for a large mass ratio M∕mM∕mM∕m the conventional perturbation theory requires significantly smaller Fermi momenta (densities) or scattering lengths than in the case of $M\ensuremath{\sim}m$, where the small parameter is ${p}_{F}\ensuremath{\mid}a\ensuremath{\mid}∕\ensuremath{\hbar}⪡1$. We show that three-body scattering resonances appearing at a large mass ratio due to the presence of three-body bound Efimov states do not influence the result, which in this sense becomes universal.
We study the dilute fermion gas with pairing between two species and unequal concentrations in a harmonic trap using the mean-field theory and the local density approximation. We found that the system can exhibit a superfluid shell structure sandwiched by the normal fermions. This superfluid shell structure occurs if the mass ratio is larger than a certain critical value, which increases from the weak-coupling BCS region to the strong-coupling Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) side. In the strong-coupling BEC regime, the radii of the superfluid phase are less sensitive to the mass ratios and are similar to the case of pairing with equal masses. However, the lighter leftover fermions are easier to mix with the superfluid core than the heavier ones. A partially polarized superfluid can be found if the majority fermions are lighter, whereas phase separation is still found if they are heavier.
We analyze the phase diagram of superfluidity for two-species fermion mixtures from the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) to Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) limit as a function of scattering parameter, population imbalance, and mass anisotropy. We identify regions corresponding to normal, or uniform or nonuniform superfluid phases, and discuss topological quantum phase transitions in the BCS, unitarity, and BEC limits. We derive the Ginzburg-Landau equation near the critical temperature, and show that it describes a dilute mixture of paired and unpaired fermions in the BEC limit. We also obtain the zero temperature low frequency and long wavelength collective excitation spectrum, and recover the Bogoliubov relation for weakly interacting dilute bosons in the BEC limit. Lastly, we discuss the effects of harmonic traps and the resulting density profiles in the BEC regime.