Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0410526 · Europhysics Letters (EPL)

Measurable consequences of the local breakdown of the concept of temperature

Michael J. Hartmann, G. Mahler

Published Apr 28, 2005• 30 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Local temperature defined by a local canonical state of the respective subsystem, does not always exist in quantum many-body systems. Here, we give some examples of how this breakdown of the temperature concept on small length scales might be observed in experiments: Measurements of magnetic properties of an anti-ferromagnetic spin-1 chain. We show that those magnetic properties are in fact strictly local. As a consequence, their measurement reveals whether the local (reduced) state can be thermal. If it is, a temperature may be associated to the measurement results, while this would lead to inconsistencies otherwise.

DOI
10.1209/epl/i2004-10518-5

Related papers

Local versus global thermal states: Correlations and the existence of local temperatures

Michael J. Hartmann, Günter Mahler A, Ortwin G. Hess

We consider a quantum system consisting of a regular chain of elementary subsystems with nearest neighbor interactions and assume that the total system is in a canonical state with temperature T . We analyze under what condition the state factors into a product of canonical density matrices with respect to groups of n subsystems each, and when these groups have the same temperature T. While in classical mechanics the validity of this procedure only depends on the size of the groups n, in quantum mechanics the minimum group size n(min) also depends on the temperature T! As examples, we apply our analysis to a harmonic chain and different types of Ising spin chains. We discuss various features that show up due to the characteristics of the models considered. For the harmonic chain, which successfully describes thermal properties of insulating solids, our approach gives a quantitative estimate of the minimal length scale on which temperature can exist: This length scale is found to be constant for temperatures above the Debye temperature and proportional to T-3 below.

arXiv:quant-ph/0404164•Physical Review E•Dec 30, 2004•41 citations

On the microscopic limit for the existence of local temperature

Michael J. Hartmann

Recent progress in the synthesis and processing of nano-structured materials and systems calls for an improved understanding of thermal properties on small length scales. In this context, the question whether thermodynamics and, in particular, the concept of temperature can apply on the nanoscale is of central interest. Here we consider a quantum system consisting of a regular chain of elementary subsystems with nearest neighbour interactions and assume that the total system is in a canonical state with temperature T. We analyse, under what condition the state factors into a product of canonical density matrices with respect to groups of n subsystems each, and when these groups have the same temperature T. In quantum systems the minimal group size depends on the temperature, contrary to the classical case. As examples, we apply our analysis to a harmonic chain and different types of Ising spin chains. For the harmonic chain, which successfully describes thermal properties of insulating solids, our approach gives a first quantitative estimate of the minimal length scale on which temperature can exist: This length scale is found to be constant for temperatures above the Debye temperature and proportional to 1/T^3 below. We finally apply the harmonic chain model to various materials of relevance for technical applications and discuss the results. These show that, indeed, high temperatures can exist quite locally, while low temperatures exist on larger scales only. The technique of the approach is based on a quantum central limit theorem, which should prove usefull in different settings, too.

•Jan 1, 2005•0 citations

Fundamentals of Nano-Thermodynamics

Michael J. Hartmann, G. Mahler, Ortwin G. Hess

Recent progress in the synthesis and processing of nano-structured materials and systems calls for an improved understanding of thermal properties on small length scales. In this context, the question whether thermodynamics and, in particular, the concept of temperature can apply on the nanoscale is of central interest. Here we consider a quantum system consisting of a regular chain of elementary subsystems with nearest neighbour interactions and assume that the total system is in a canonical state with temperature $T$. We analyse, under what condition the state factors into a product of canonical density matrices with respect to groups of $n$ subsystems each, and when these groups have the same temperature $T$. In quantum systems the minimal group size $n_{\textrm{min}}$ depends on the temperature $T$, contrary to the classical case. As examples, we apply our analysis to a harmonic chain and different types of Ising spin chains. For the harmonic chain, which successfully describes thermal properties of insulating solids, our approach gives a first quantitative estimate of the minimal length scale on which temperature can exist: This length scale is found to be constant for temperatures above the Debye temperature and proportional to $T^{-3}$ below. We finally apply the harmonic chain model to various materials of relevance for technical applications and discuss the results. These show that, indeed, high temperatures can exist quite locally, while low temperatures exist on larger scales only. This has striking consequences: In quasi 1-dimensional systems, like Carbon-Nanotubes, room temperatures (300 Kelvin) exist on length scales of 1 $μ$m, while very low temperatures (10 Kelvin) can only exist on scales larger than 1 mm.

arXiv:cond-mat/0408133•Aug 6, 2004•8 citations

On Which Length Scales Can Temperature Exist in Quantum Systems?

Michael J. Hartmann, Günter Mahler A, Ortwin G. Hess

We consider a regular chain of elementary quantum systems with nearest neighbor interactions and assume that the total system is in a canonical state with temperature $T$. We analyze under what condition the state factors into a product of canonical density matrices with respect to groups of $n$ subsystems each, and when these groups have the same temperature $T$. While in classical mechanics the validity of this procedure only depends on the size of the groups $n$, in quantum mechanics the minimum group size $n_{\text{min}}$ also depends on the temperature $T $! As examples, we apply our analysis to different types of Heisenberg spin chains.

arXiv:cond-mat/0502045•Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Jan 1, 2005•2 citations

Universal locality of quantum thermal susceptibility

Giacomo De Palma, Antonella De Pasquale, Vittorio Giovannetti

The ultimate precision of any measurement of the temperature of a quantum system is the inverse of the local quantum thermal susceptibility [A. De Pasquale et al., Nat. Commun. 7, 12782 (2016)] of the subsystem with which the thermometer interacts. If this subsystem can be described with the canonical ensemble, such quantity reduces to the variance of the local Hamiltonian, which is proportional to the heat capacity of the subsystem. However, the canonical ensemble might not apply in the presence of interactions between the subsystem and the rest of the system. In this work, we address this problem in the framework of locally interacting quantum systems. We prove that the local quantum thermal susceptibility of any subsystem is close to the variance of its local Hamiltonian, provided the volume-to-surface ratio of the subsystem is much larger than the correlation length. This result greatly simplifies the determination of the ultimate precision of any local estimate of the temperature and rigorously determines the regime where interactions can affect this precision.

arXiv:1611.05738•Physical Review A•May 15, 2017•27 citations

Scaling behavior of interactions in a modular quantum system and the existence of local temperature

M Hartmann, J Gemmer, G Mahler +1 more

We consider a quantum system of fixed size consisting of a regular chain of n -level subsystems, where n is finite. Forming groups of N subsystems each, we show that the strength of interaction between the groups scales with N −1/2 . As a consequence, if the total system is in a thermal state with inverse temperature β, a sufficient condition for subgroups of size N to be approximately in a thermal state with the same temperature is √ N ≫ β Ē , where Ē is the width of the occupied level spectrum of the total system. These scaling properties indicate on what scale local temperatures may be meaningfully defined as intensive variables. This question is particularly relevant for non-equilibrium scenarios such as heat conduction, etc.

arXiv:quant-ph/0312158•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Feb 17, 2004•15 citations
Local temperature defined by a local canonical state of the respective subsystem, does not always exist in quantum many-body systems. Here, we give some examples of how this breakdown of the temperature concept on small length scales might be observed in experiments: Measurements of magnetic properties of an anti-ferromagnetic spin-1 chain. We show that those magnetic properties are in fact strictly local. As a consequence, their measurement reveals whether the local (reduced) state can be thermal. If it is, a temperature may be associated to the measurement results, while this would lead to inconsistencies otherwise.
We consider a quantum system consisting of a regular chain of elementary subsystems with nearest neighbor interactions and assume that the total system is in a canonical state with temperature T . We analyze under what condition the state factors into a product of canonical density matrices with respect to groups of n subsystems each, and when these groups have the same temperature T. While in classical mechanics the validity of this procedure only depends on the size of the groups n, in quantum mechanics the minimum group size n(min) also depends on the temperature T! As examples, we apply our analysis to a harmonic chain and different types of Ising spin chains. We discuss various features that show up due to the characteristics of the models considered. For the harmonic chain, which successfully describes thermal properties of insulating solids, our approach gives a quantitative estimate of the minimal length scale on which temperature can exist: This length scale is found to be constant for temperatures above the Debye temperature and proportional to T-3 below.
Recent progress in the synthesis and processing of nano-structured materials and systems calls for an improved understanding of thermal properties on small length scales. In this context, the question whether thermodynamics and, in particular, the concept of temperature can apply on the nanoscale is of central interest. Here we consider a quantum system consisting of a regular chain of elementary subsystems with nearest neighbour interactions and assume that the total system is in a canonical state with temperature T. We analyse, under what condition the state factors into a product of canonical density matrices with respect to groups of n subsystems each, and when these groups have the same temperature T. In quantum systems the minimal group size depends on the temperature, contrary to the classical case. As examples, we apply our analysis to a harmonic chain and different types of Ising spin chains. For the harmonic chain, which successfully describes thermal properties of insulating solids, our approach gives a first quantitative estimate of the minimal length scale on which temperature can exist: This length scale is found to be constant for temperatures above the Debye temperature and proportional to 1/T^3 below. We finally apply the harmonic chain model to various materials of relevance for technical applications and discuss the results. These show that, indeed, high temperatures can exist quite locally, while low temperatures exist on larger scales only. The technique of the approach is based on a quantum central limit theorem, which should prove usefull in different settings, too.
Recent progress in the synthesis and processing of nano-structured materials and systems calls for an improved understanding of thermal properties on small length scales. In this context, the question whether thermodynamics and, in particular, the concept of temperature can apply on the nanoscale is of central interest. Here we consider a quantum system consisting of a regular chain of elementary subsystems with nearest neighbour interactions and assume that the total system is in a canonical state with temperature TTT. We analyse, under what condition the state factors into a product of canonical density matrices with respect to groups of nnn subsystems each, and when these groups have the same temperature TTT. In quantum systems the minimal group size nminn_{\textrm{min}}nmin​ depends on the temperature TTT, contrary to the classical case. As examples, we apply our analysis to a harmonic chain and different types of Ising spin chains. For the harmonic chain, which successfully describes thermal properties of insulating solids, our approach gives a first quantitative estimate of the minimal length scale on which temperature can exist: This length scale is found to be constant for temperatures above the Debye temperature and proportional to T−3T^{-3}T−3 below. We finally apply the harmonic chain model to various materials of relevance for technical applications and discuss the results. These show that, indeed, high temperatures can exist quite locally, while low temperatures exist on larger scales only. This has striking consequences: In quasi 1-dimensional systems, like Carbon-Nanotubes, room temperatures (300 Kelvin) exist on length scales of 1 μμμm, while very low temperatures (10 Kelvin) can only exist on scales larger than 1 mm.
We consider a regular chain of elementary quantum systems with nearest neighbor interactions and assume that the total system is in a canonical state with temperature TTT. We analyze under what condition the state factors into a product of canonical density matrices with respect to groups of nnn subsystems each, and when these groups have the same temperature TTT. While in classical mechanics the validity of this procedure only depends on the size of the groups nnn, in quantum mechanics the minimum group size nminn_{\text{min}}nmin​ also depends on the temperature $T $! As examples, we apply our analysis to different types of Heisenberg spin chains.
The ultimate precision of any measurement of the temperature of a quantum system is the inverse of the local quantum thermal susceptibility [A. De Pasquale et al., Nat. Commun. 7, 12782 (2016)] of the subsystem with which the thermometer interacts. If this subsystem can be described with the canonical ensemble, such quantity reduces to the variance of the local Hamiltonian, which is proportional to the heat capacity of the subsystem. However, the canonical ensemble might not apply in the presence of interactions between the subsystem and the rest of the system. In this work, we address this problem in the framework of locally interacting quantum systems. We prove that the local quantum thermal susceptibility of any subsystem is close to the variance of its local Hamiltonian, provided the volume-to-surface ratio of the subsystem is much larger than the correlation length. This result greatly simplifies the determination of the ultimate precision of any local estimate of the temperature and rigorously determines the regime where interactions can affect this precision.
We consider a quantum system of fixed size consisting of a regular chain of n -level subsystems, where n is finite. Forming groups of N subsystems each, we show that the strength of interaction between the groups scales with N −1/2 . As a consequence, if the total system is in a thermal state with inverse temperature β, a sufficient condition for subgroups of size N to be approximately in a thermal state with the same temperature is √ N ≫ β Ē , where Ē is the width of the occupied level spectrum of the total system. These scaling properties indicate on what scale local temperatures may be meaningfully defined as intensive variables. This question is particularly relevant for non-equilibrium scenarios such as heat conduction, etc.