We present the algorithmic details of the dynamical cluster approximation (DCA), with a quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) method used to solve the effective cluster problem. The DCA is a fully causal approach which systematically restores nonlocal correlations to the dynamical mean field approximation (DMFA) while preserving the lattice symmetries. The DCA becomes exact for an infinite cluster size, while reducing to the DMFA for a cluster size of unity. We present a generalization of the Hirsch-Fye QMC algorithm for the solution of the embedded cluster problem. We use the two-dimensional Hubbard model to illustrate the performance of the DCA technique. At half filling, we show that the DCA drives the spurious finite-temperature antiferromagnetic transition found in the DMFA slowly towards zero temperature as the cluster size increases, in conformity with the Mermin-Wagner theorem. Moreover, we find that there is a finite-temperature metal to insulator transition which persists into the weak-coupling regime. This suggests that the magnetism of the model is Heisenberg-like for all nonzero interactions. Away from half filling, we find that the sign problem that arises in QMC simulations is significantly less severe in the context of DCA. Hence, we were able to obtain good statistics for small clusters. For these clusters, the DCA results show evidence of non-Fermi-liquid behavior and superconductivity near half filling.
We present the algorithmic details of the dynamical cluster approximation (DCA), with a quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) method used to solve the effective cluster problem. The DCA is a fully causal approach which systematically restores nonlocal correlations to the dynamical mean field approximation (DMFA) while preserving the lattice symmetries. The DCA becomes exact for an infinite cluster size, while reducing to the DMFA for a cluster size of unity. We present a generalization of the Hirsch-Fye QMC algorithm for the solution of the embedded cluster problem. We use the two-dimensional Hubbard model to illustrate the performance of the DCA technique. At half filling, we show that the DCA drives the spurious finite-temperature antiferromagnetic transition found in the DMFA slowly towards zero temperature as the cluster size increases, in conformity with the Mermin-Wagner theorem. Moreover, we find that there is a finite-temperature metal to insulator transition which persists into the weak-coupling regime. This suggests that the magnetism of the model is Heisenberg-like for all nonzero interactions. Away from half filling, we find that the sign problem that arises in QMC simulations is significantly less severe in the context of DCA. Hence, we were able to obtain good statistics for small clusters. For these clusters, the DCA results show evidence of non-Fermi-liquid behavior and superconductivity near half filling.
We recently introduced the dynamical cluster approximation (DCA), a technique that includes short-ranged dynamical correlations in addition to the local dynamics of the dynamical mean-field approximation while preserving causality. The technique is based on an iterative self-consistency scheme on a finite-size periodic cluster. The dynamical mean-field approximation (exact result) is obtained by taking the cluster to a single site (the thermodynamic limit). Here, we provide details of our method, explicitly show that it is causal, systematic, $\ensuremath{\Phi}$ derivable, and that it becomes conserving as the cluster size increases. We demonstrate the DCA by applying it to a quantum Monte Carlo and exact enumeration study of the two-dimensional Falicov-Kimball model. The resulting spectral functions preserve causality, and the spectra and the charge-density-wave transition temperature converge quickly and systematically to the thermodynamic limit as the cluster size increases.
The dynamical cluster approximation (DCA) is a quantum cluster extension to the single-site dynamical mean-field theory that incorporates spatially nonlocal dynamic correlations systematically and nonperturbatively. The DCA+ algorithm addresses the cluster shape dependence of the DCA and improves the convergence with cluster size by introducing a lattice self-energy with continuous momentum dependence. However, we show that the DCA+ algorithm is plagued by a fundamental problem when its self-consistency equations are formulated using the bare Green's function of the cluster. This problem is most severe in the strongly correlated regime at low doping, where the DCA+ self-energy becomes overly metallic and local, and persists to cluster sizes where the standard DCA has long converged. In view of the failure of the DCA+ algorithm, we propose to complement DCA simulations with a post-interpolation procedure for single-particle and two-particle correlation functions to preserve continuous momentum dependence and the associated benefits in the DCA. We demonstrate the effectiveness of this practical approach with results for the half-filled and hole-doped two-dimensional Hubbard model.
The dynamical cluster approximation (DCA) is a systematic extension beyond the single-site approximation in dynamical mean field theory, to include spatially nonlocal correlations in quantum many-body simulations of strongly correlated systems. We extend the DCA with a continuous lattice self-energy in order to achieve better convergence with cluster size. This method, which we call DCA+, cures the cluster-shape dependence problems of the DCA, without suffering from causality violations of previous attempts to interpolate the cluster self-energy. A practical approach based on standard inference techniques is given to deduce the continuous lattice self-energy from an interpolated cluster self-energy. We study the pseudogap region of a hole-doped two-dimensional Hubbard model and find that, in the DCA+algorithm, the self-energy and pseudogap temperature T∗ converge monotonously with cluster size. Introduction of a continuous lattice self-energy eliminates artificial long-range correlations and thus significantly reduces the sign problem of the quantum Monte Carlo cluster solver in the DCA+algorithm compared to the normal DCA. Simulations with much larger cluster sizes thus become feasible, which, along with the improved convergence in cluster size, raises hope that precise extrapolations to the exact infinite cluster size limit can be reached for other physical quantities as well.
We study the Hubbard model using the cellular dynamical mean-field theory (CDMFT) with quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations. We present the algorithmic details of CDMFT with the Hirsch-Fye QMC method for the solution of the self-consistently embedded quantum cluster problem. We use the one- and two-dimensional half filled Hubbard model to gauge the performance of CDMFT+QMC particularly for small clusters by comparing with the exact results and also with other quantum cluster methods. We calculate single-particle Green's functions and self-energies on small clusters to study their size dependence in one and two dimensions. It is shown that in one dimension, CDMFT with two sites in the cluster is already able to describe with high accuracy the evolution of the density as a function of the chemical potential and the compressibility divergence at the Mott transition, in good agreement with the exact Bethe ansatz result. With increasing U the result on small clusters rapidly approaches that of the infinite size cluster. Large scattering rate and a positive slope in the real part of the self-energy in one dimension suggest that the system is a non-Fermi liquid for all the parameters studied here. In two dimensions, at intermediate to strong coupling, even the smallest cluster $({N}_{c}=2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2)$ accounts for more than 95% of the correlation effect of the infinite-size cluster in the single particle spectrum, suggesting that some of the important problems in strongly correlated electron systems may be studied highly accurately with a reasonable computational effort. Finally, as an application that is sensitive to details of correlations, we show that CDMFT+QMC can describe spin-charge separated Luttinger liquid physics in one dimension. The spinon and holon branches appear only for sufficiently large system sizes.
This thesis will describe efforts to enhance our ability to simulate the 2D Hubbard model. Chapter 2 provides a background on the main computational techniques used throughout the work, including quantum Monte Carlo (QMC), dynamical mean field theory (DMFT), the dynamical cluster approximation (DCA), the continuous time auxiliary field algorithm (CTAUX), and the Maximum Entropy Method (MEM) for numeric analytic continuation. Chapter 3 presents new work on applying Twisted Boundary Conditions to the DCA framework. This method is applied in a effort to access thermodynamic (i.e. large system) information about the Hubbard model without the immense computational expense required to simulate large lattices directly. Chapter 4 describes efforts to study the extended 2D Hubbard model, which re-introduces non-local interactions between electrons that drive the formation of charge ordered phases. The work includes a thorough analysis of the phase diagram of the model away from half-filling, as well as analysis of the effect of non-local interactions on anti-ferromagnetic fluctuations and competition between the charge order and AFM states. Chapter 5 includes a derivation of the dual fermions diagrammatic expansion and the dual fermions ladder approximation used to compute corrections to single site DMFT calculations. The method is applied to the 2D Hubbard model in order to study the evolution of its spectral function, Fermi surface, and momentum dependent mass renormalization as the temperature, interaction strength, and doping are changed. The great advantage of this method is that we are able to access arbitrary momenta throughout the Brillouin zone, in contrast to the limitation to a few cluster momenta that characterize cluster methods like DCA.
This thesis is dedicated to a theoretical study of the 1-band Hubbard model in the strong coupling limit. The investigation is based on the Dynamical Cluster Approximation (DCA) which systematically restores non-local corrections to the Dynamical Mean Field approximation (DMFA). The DCA is formulated in momentum space and is characterised by a patching of the Brillouin zone where momentum conservation is only recovered between two patches. The approximation works well if k-space correlation functions show a weak momentum dependence. In order to study the temperature and doping dependence of the spin- and charge excitation spectra, we explicitly extend the Dynamical Cluster Approximation to two-particle response functions. The full irreducible two-particle vertex with three momenta and frequencies is approximated by an effective vertex dependent on the momentum and frequency of the spin and/or charge excitations. The effective vertex is calculated by using the Quantum Monte Carlo method on the finite cluster whereas the analytical continuation of dynamical quantities is performed by a stochastic version of the maximum entropy method. A comparison with high temperature auxiliary field quantum Monte Carlo data serves as a benchmark for our approach to two-particle correlation functions. Our method can reproduce basic characteristics of the spin- and charge excitation spectrum. Near and beyond optimal doping, our results provide a consistent overall picture of the interplay between charge, spin and single-particle excitations: a collective spin mode emerges at optimal doping and sufficiently low temperatures in the spin response spectrum and exhibits the energy scale of the magnetic exchange interaction J. Simultaneously, the low energy single-particle excitations are characterised by a coherent quasiparticle with bandwidth J. The origin of the quasiparticle can be quite well understood in a picture of a more or less antiferromagnetic ordered background in which holes are dressed by spin-excitations to allow for a coherent motion. By increasing doping, all features which are linked to the spin-polaron vanish in the single-particle as well as two-particle spin response spectrum. In the second part of the thesis an analysis of superconductivity in the Hubbard model is presented. The superconducting instability is implemented within the Dynamical Cluster Approximation by essentially allowing U(1) symmetry breaking baths in the QMC calculations for the cluster. The superconducting transition temperature T_c is derived from the d-wave order parameter which is directly estimated on the Monte Carlo cluster. The critical temperature T_c is in astonishing agreement with the temperature scale estimated by the divergence of the pair-field susceptibility in the paramagnetic phase. A detailed study of the pseudo and superconducting gap is continued by the investigation of the local and angle-resolved spectral function.