Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:cond-mat/0004269

The choice of the symmetry group for the cuprates

Sher Alam, M. O. Rahman, M. Ando, Mohamed, S. B., Takashi Yanagisawa

Published Apr 17, 2000• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Following our recent conjecture to model the phenomenona of antiferromagnetism and superconductivity by quantum symmetry groups, we discuss in the present note the choice of the classical symmetry group underlying the quantum group. Keeping in mind the degrees of freedom arising from spin, charge, and lattice we choose the classical group as SO(7). This choice is also motivated to accomodate the several competing phases which are or may be present in these and related materials, such as stripe phase [mesoscopically ordered phase], Luttinger liquids, nearly antiferromagnetic Fermi liquids, charge-ordered Fermi liquids, glassy phase, stringy phase and perhaps more. The existence and the behavior of pseudo-gap and lattice distortion are also an important consideration. We have lumped the charge, spin and lattice-distortion ordering and other orderings into the psuedogap.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.cond-mat/0004269

Related papers

Quantum group conjecture and Stripes

Sher Alam

Keeping in mind our conjecture of modelling cuprates and related systems by quantum groups and our claim that the existence of stripes is intimately related to quantum groups and more strongly is a consequence of the underlying quantum group structure we note that a recent claim that {\em magnetic fluctuations} also displays a one-dimensional character makes our conjecture more viable. The recent strong claim by Mook et al., if true further supports our intuition. For the fluctuations associated with a striped phase are expected to be one-dimensional, whereas the magnetic fluctuations are {\em taken} to display two-dimensional symmetry. It is claimed by Mook et al. that this apparent two-dimensionality results from measurements on twinned crystals, and that similar measurements on substantial detwinned crystals of YBa$_{2}$Cu$_{3}$O$_{6.6}$ reveal the one-dimensional character of the magnetic fluctuations thus making the stripe scenario more stronger, in other words there are also magnetic stripes. As noted before in our conjecture that one of the main reason for quantum groups to model cuprates is that they are directly related to the symmetries of one-dimensional systems. Thus now if the magnetic fluctuations are also shown exhibiting one-dimensional behavior that all the more {\em directly strengthens our conjecture}. However we note that our conjecture is more generic and not tied to the one-dimensional character of the now claimed magnetic fluctuations. Simply the one-dimesional nature of magnetic fluctuations as noted by Mook et al., makes our conjecture more {\em obvious} and clearer.

arXiv:cond-mat/0005168•May 10, 2000•5 citations

Aspects of spin-charge separation in high Tc cuprates

Don H. Kim

High Tc, cuprates have a number of features that are anomalous from the point of view of the conventional theory of metals, i.e. the Fermi liquid theory. These include the high Tc itself, the linear resistivity in optimally doped cuprates, the "spin gap" phenomena, and antiferromagnetic fluctuations. Some of the basic features of the high Tc, phase diagram can be readily understood from slave boson mean field theories of the t-J model that yield a variety of phases like the uRVB phase (strange metal), d-wave RVB phase (spin gap), and the superconducting phase. This thesis is concerned with improving this picture by considering important fluctuations around the mean fields. This leads to certain gauge theories in which neutral spin 1/2 fermions ("spinons") and charged spinless bosons ("holons") are coupled to gauge fields. If the gauge field is not "confining", the spin and charge degrees of freedom are separated to some extent, and an unconventional picture for transport and magnetic properties is expected. Following an introduction and overview, the first half of the main body of this thesis analyzes a simple model of a degenerate two-dimensional Bose liquid interacting with a fluctuating gauge field, with the goal of studying the charge degree of freedom in the cuprates. It is shown that the fluctuating gauge field efficiently destroys superfluidity even in the Bose degenerate regime. The nature of the resulting normal state is discussed in terms of the geometric properties of the imaginary-time paths of the bosons. Charge response functions are studied numerically (by path integral Monte Carlo methods); it is found that the transport scattering rate behaves as ... , consistent with the experiments on the cuprates in the normal state, and that the density correlations of our model resemble the charge correlations of the t-J model. The second half considers the magnetic properties of cuprates from the point of view of a gauge theory of spinons, with emphasis on the underdoped regime. Despite the spin gap, there is a substantial antiferromagnetic correlation in the underdoped cuprates, as evidenced by the q-space scan of Neutron scattering cross section and different temperature dependences of the Copper and Oxygen site relaxation rates, features which are not captured well by mean field theories. As a concrete illustration of the gauge-fluctuation restoration of the antiferromangetic correlation and the feasibility of the 1/N perturbation theory, a U(1) gauge theory of id Heisenberg spin chain is worked out exactly, and then perturbatively. The difference between the behavior of uniform and staggerd spin correlation functions is discussed in terms of conserved and nonconserved currents. The 1/N-perturbative treatment of the gauge theory in 2+1D (which can be motivated from the mean field Flux phase of the Heisnberg model) leads to a dynamical mass generation corresponding to an antiferromagnetic ordering, but it is argued that in a similar gauge theory with an additional coupling to a Bose (holon) field, symmetry breaking does not occur, but antiferromagnetic correlations are improved, which is the situation in the underdoped cuprates.

•Jan 1, 1998•0 citations

LUTTINGER LIQUID, SINGULAR INTERACTION AND QUANTUM CRITICALITY IN CUPRATE MATERIALS

C. Di Castro, S. Caprara

With particular reference to the role of the renormalization group (RG) approach and Ward identities (WI's), we start by recalling some old features of the one-dimensional Luttinger liquid as the prototype of non-Fermi-liquid behavior. Its dimensional crossover to the Landau normal Fermi liquid implies that a non-Fermi liquid, as, e.g., the normal phase of the cuprate high temperature superconductors, can be maintained in d>1 only in the presence of a sufficiently singular effective interaction among the charge carriers. This is the case when, nearby an instability, the interaction is mediated by critical fluctuations. We are then led to introduce the specific case of superconductivity in cuprates as an example of avoided quantum criticality. We will disentangle the fluctuations which act as mediators of singular electron–electron interaction, enlightening the possible order competing with superconductivity and a mechanism for the non-Fermi-liquid behavior of the metallic phase. This paper is not meant to be a comprehensive review. Many important contributions will not be considered. We will also avoid using extensive technicalities and making full calculations for which we refer to the original papers and to the many good available reviews. We will here only follow one line of reasoning which guided our research activity in this field.

arXiv:1206.5962•International Journal of Modern Physics B•Jul 26, 2012•0 citations

LUTTINGER LIQUID, SINGULAR INTERACTION AND QUANTUM CRITICALITY IN CUPRATE MATERIALS

C. Di Castro, S. Caprara

With particular reference to the role of the renormalization group (RG) approach and Ward identities (WI's), we start by recalling some old features of the one-dimensional Luttinger liquid as the prototype of non-Fermi-liquid behavior. Its dimensional crossover to the Landau normal Fermi liquid implies that a non-Fermi liquid, as, e.g., the normal phase of the cuprate high temperature superconductors, can be maintained in d>1 only in the presence of a sufficiently singular effective interaction among the charge carriers. This is the case when, nearby an instability, the interaction is mediated by critical fluctuations. We are then led to introduce the specific case of superconductivity in cuprates as an example of avoided quantum criticality. We will disentangle the fluctuations which act as mediators of singular electron–electron interaction, enlightening the possible order competing with superconductivity and a mechanism for the non-Fermi-liquid behavior of the metallic phase. This paper is not meant to be a comprehensive review. Many important contributions will not be considered. We will also avoid using extensive technicalities and making full calculations for which we refer to the original papers and to the many good available reviews. We will here only follow one line of reasoning which guided our research activity in this field.

Series on directions in condensed matter physics•Oct 24, 2013•0 citations

Theoretical modeling for quantum liquids from 1d to 2d dimensional crossover using quantum groups

Sher Alam, M. O. Rahman

Recent experimental and theoretical work in strongly correlated electron system necessitates a formulation to deal with 1d to 2d dimensional crossover and raises several interesting questions. A particularly interesting question is what happens to the 1d Luttinger liquid, as we go from 1d to 2d? The main point of emphasis of the present note is that the transition from 1d to 2d has an underlying quantum group symmetry. This relationhip of 1d to 2d transition with quantum group symmetry ties in nicely with our previous proposal to model superconductivity, antiferromagnetism and related phases arising from strongly correlated electron states with quantum groups. A simple model based on two interacting chains with nearest neighbor and next to nearest neighbor interactions is suggested. It appears reasonable to assume that it is the interaction between the 1d Luttinger liquids which leads to the quantum group symmetry and the transition to 2d quantum liquid. The conditions under which this 2d quantum liquid deviates away from the 2d Fermi liquid is clearly of main interest to us. One of the prime motivations underlying our proposal is the experimental observation of stripe structure [phase] in high T_c superconductivity [HTSC] materials. In short a simple model of two coupled chains 1d chains is considered to answer an important question, how does one couple two 1d chains [Luttinger Liquid] to obtain non-Fermi liquid [NFL] or partial NFL behavior in 2d?

arXiv:cond-mat/9903455•Mar 31, 1999•4 citations

A Critique of Two Metals

R. B. Laughlin

I argue that the conflict between the fermi-liquid and non-fermi-liquid metallic states viewed by Anderson as the central intellectual issue of cuprate superconductivity, and which motivates the recent criticism by Baskaran and Anderson [cond-mat/9706076] of the work of Zhang [cond-mat/9610140], is a fundamentally wrong concept. All experimental evidence points to adiabatic continuability of the strange metal into a conventional one, and thus to one metallic phase rather than two, and all attempts to account theoretically for the existence of a luttinger-liquid at zero temperature in spatial dimension greater than 1 have failed. I discuss the underlying reasons for this failure and then argue that the true higher-dimensional generalization of the luttinger-liquid behavior is a propensity of the system to order. I speculate about how the conflict between antiferromagnetism and superconductivity, the two principal kinds of order in this problem, might result in both the observed zero-temperature phase diagram of the cuprates and the luttinger-liquid phenomenology, i.e. the breakup of the electron into spinons and holons in certain regimes of doping and energy. The key idea is a quantum critical point regulating a first-order transition between these phases and toward which one is first attracted under renormalization before bifurcating between the two phases.

arXiv:cond-mat/9709195•Sep 17, 1997•21 citations
Following our recent conjecture to model the phenomenona of antiferromagnetism and superconductivity by quantum symmetry groups, we discuss in the present note the choice of the classical symmetry group underlying the quantum group. Keeping in mind the degrees of freedom arising from spin, charge, and lattice we choose the classical group as SO(7). This choice is also motivated to accomodate the several competing phases which are or may be present in these and related materials, such as stripe phase [mesoscopically ordered phase], Luttinger liquids, nearly antiferromagnetic Fermi liquids, charge-ordered Fermi liquids, glassy phase, stringy phase and perhaps more. The existence and the behavior of pseudo-gap and lattice distortion are also an important consideration. We have lumped the charge, spin and lattice-distortion ordering and other orderings into the psuedogap.
Keeping in mind our conjecture of modelling cuprates and related systems by quantum groups and our claim that the existence of stripes is intimately related to quantum groups and more strongly is a consequence of the underlying quantum group structure we note that a recent claim that {\em magnetic fluctuations} also displays a one-dimensional character makes our conjecture more viable. The recent strong claim by Mook et al., if true further supports our intuition. For the fluctuations associated with a striped phase are expected to be one-dimensional, whereas the magnetic fluctuations are {\em taken} to display two-dimensional symmetry. It is claimed by Mook et al. that this apparent two-dimensionality results from measurements on twinned crystals, and that similar measurements on substantial detwinned crystals of YBa2_{2}2​Cu3_{3}3​O6.6_{6.6}6.6​ reveal the one-dimensional character of the magnetic fluctuations thus making the stripe scenario more stronger, in other words there are also magnetic stripes. As noted before in our conjecture that one of the main reason for quantum groups to model cuprates is that they are directly related to the symmetries of one-dimensional systems. Thus now if the magnetic fluctuations are also shown exhibiting one-dimensional behavior that all the more {\em directly strengthens our conjecture}. However we note that our conjecture is more generic and not tied to the one-dimensional character of the now claimed magnetic fluctuations. Simply the one-dimesional nature of magnetic fluctuations as noted by Mook et al., makes our conjecture more {\em obvious} and clearer.
High Tc, cuprates have a number of features that are anomalous from the point of view of the conventional theory of metals, i.e. the Fermi liquid theory. These include the high Tc itself, the linear resistivity in optimally doped cuprates, the "spin gap" phenomena, and antiferromagnetic fluctuations. Some of the basic features of the high Tc, phase diagram can be readily understood from slave boson mean field theories of the t-J model that yield a variety of phases like the uRVB phase (strange metal), d-wave RVB phase (spin gap), and the superconducting phase. This thesis is concerned with improving this picture by considering important fluctuations around the mean fields. This leads to certain gauge theories in which neutral spin 1/2 fermions ("spinons") and charged spinless bosons ("holons") are coupled to gauge fields. If the gauge field is not "confining", the spin and charge degrees of freedom are separated to some extent, and an unconventional picture for transport and magnetic properties is expected. Following an introduction and overview, the first half of the main body of this thesis analyzes a simple model of a degenerate two-dimensional Bose liquid interacting with a fluctuating gauge field, with the goal of studying the charge degree of freedom in the cuprates. It is shown that the fluctuating gauge field efficiently destroys superfluidity even in the Bose degenerate regime. The nature of the resulting normal state is discussed in terms of the geometric properties of the imaginary-time paths of the bosons. Charge response functions are studied numerically (by path integral Monte Carlo methods); it is found that the transport scattering rate behaves as ... , consistent with the experiments on the cuprates in the normal state, and that the density correlations of our model resemble the charge correlations of the t-J model. The second half considers the magnetic properties of cuprates from the point of view of a gauge theory of spinons, with emphasis on the underdoped regime. Despite the spin gap, there is a substantial antiferromagnetic correlation in the underdoped cuprates, as evidenced by the q-space scan of Neutron scattering cross section and different temperature dependences of the Copper and Oxygen site relaxation rates, features which are not captured well by mean field theories. As a concrete illustration of the gauge-fluctuation restoration of the antiferromangetic correlation and the feasibility of the 1/N perturbation theory, a U(1) gauge theory of id Heisenberg spin chain is worked out exactly, and then perturbatively. The difference between the behavior of uniform and staggerd spin correlation functions is discussed in terms of conserved and nonconserved currents. The 1/N-perturbative treatment of the gauge theory in 2+1D (which can be motivated from the mean field Flux phase of the Heisnberg model) leads to a dynamical mass generation corresponding to an antiferromagnetic ordering, but it is argued that in a similar gauge theory with an additional coupling to a Bose (holon) field, symmetry breaking does not occur, but antiferromagnetic correlations are improved, which is the situation in the underdoped cuprates.
With particular reference to the role of the renormalization group (RG) approach and Ward identities (WI's), we start by recalling some old features of the one-dimensional Luttinger liquid as the prototype of non-Fermi-liquid behavior. Its dimensional crossover to the Landau normal Fermi liquid implies that a non-Fermi liquid, as, e.g., the normal phase of the cuprate high temperature superconductors, can be maintained in d>1 only in the presence of a sufficiently singular effective interaction among the charge carriers. This is the case when, nearby an instability, the interaction is mediated by critical fluctuations. We are then led to introduce the specific case of superconductivity in cuprates as an example of avoided quantum criticality. We will disentangle the fluctuations which act as mediators of singular electron–electron interaction, enlightening the possible order competing with superconductivity and a mechanism for the non-Fermi-liquid behavior of the metallic phase. This paper is not meant to be a comprehensive review. Many important contributions will not be considered. We will also avoid using extensive technicalities and making full calculations for which we refer to the original papers and to the many good available reviews. We will here only follow one line of reasoning which guided our research activity in this field.
With particular reference to the role of the renormalization group (RG) approach and Ward identities (WI's), we start by recalling some old features of the one-dimensional Luttinger liquid as the prototype of non-Fermi-liquid behavior. Its dimensional crossover to the Landau normal Fermi liquid implies that a non-Fermi liquid, as, e.g., the normal phase of the cuprate high temperature superconductors, can be maintained in d>1 only in the presence of a sufficiently singular effective interaction among the charge carriers. This is the case when, nearby an instability, the interaction is mediated by critical fluctuations. We are then led to introduce the specific case of superconductivity in cuprates as an example of avoided quantum criticality. We will disentangle the fluctuations which act as mediators of singular electron–electron interaction, enlightening the possible order competing with superconductivity and a mechanism for the non-Fermi-liquid behavior of the metallic phase. This paper is not meant to be a comprehensive review. Many important contributions will not be considered. We will also avoid using extensive technicalities and making full calculations for which we refer to the original papers and to the many good available reviews. We will here only follow one line of reasoning which guided our research activity in this field.
Recent experimental and theoretical work in strongly correlated electron system necessitates a formulation to deal with 1d to 2d dimensional crossover and raises several interesting questions. A particularly interesting question is what happens to the 1d Luttinger liquid, as we go from 1d to 2d? The main point of emphasis of the present note is that the transition from 1d to 2d has an underlying quantum group symmetry. This relationhip of 1d to 2d transition with quantum group symmetry ties in nicely with our previous proposal to model superconductivity, antiferromagnetism and related phases arising from strongly correlated electron states with quantum groups. A simple model based on two interacting chains with nearest neighbor and next to nearest neighbor interactions is suggested. It appears reasonable to assume that it is the interaction between the 1d Luttinger liquids which leads to the quantum group symmetry and the transition to 2d quantum liquid. The conditions under which this 2d quantum liquid deviates away from the 2d Fermi liquid is clearly of main interest to us. One of the prime motivations underlying our proposal is the experimental observation of stripe structure [phase] in high T_c superconductivity [HTSC] materials. In short a simple model of two coupled chains 1d chains is considered to answer an important question, how does one couple two 1d chains [Luttinger Liquid] to obtain non-Fermi liquid [NFL] or partial NFL behavior in 2d?
I argue that the conflict between the fermi-liquid and non-fermi-liquid metallic states viewed by Anderson as the central intellectual issue of cuprate superconductivity, and which motivates the recent criticism by Baskaran and Anderson [cond-mat/9706076] of the work of Zhang [cond-mat/9610140], is a fundamentally wrong concept. All experimental evidence points to adiabatic continuability of the strange metal into a conventional one, and thus to one metallic phase rather than two, and all attempts to account theoretically for the existence of a luttinger-liquid at zero temperature in spatial dimension greater than 1 have failed. I discuss the underlying reasons for this failure and then argue that the true higher-dimensional generalization of the luttinger-liquid behavior is a propensity of the system to order. I speculate about how the conflict between antiferromagnetism and superconductivity, the two principal kinds of order in this problem, might result in both the observed zero-temperature phase diagram of the cuprates and the luttinger-liquid phenomenology, i.e. the breakup of the electron into spinons and holons in certain regimes of doping and energy. The key idea is a quantum critical point regulating a first-order transition between these phases and toward which one is first attracted under renormalization before bifurcating between the two phases.