Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Bulletin of the American Physical Society

Causality and noncausal optical potentials in a simple physical model

V. A. Madsen, K. I. Goldman

Published Oct 1, 1993• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The time nonlocal optical potential is derived from first principles on the basis of a model of scattering of a particle from a target with several excited states. The time nonlocal potential involves an integral of the energy dependent potential derived from the model. One is free to choose any lower limit on the energy integration below the ground state of the combined system of target and projectile. For choices other than negative infinity, which gives the Fourier integral and a causal potential, the resulting potential is noncausal. The time dependent Schrodinger equation is nevertheless causal.

Related papers

Deriving the Schrödinger Equation

Steven M. Pascal

The Schrödinger equation was really postulated rather than derived. But we can see why it was postulated. It has been proven to be valid, in that it provides information about small, slow moving particles subject to a wide variety of potentials. The derivation of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation (TDSE) follows rather directly from assuming a free particle wave: Ψ = e i(kx-ωt) . If this wave function is plugged into the classical wave equation, and quantum principles are used, the two sides of the equation are not equal (this means this function does not "solve" the equation). The quantum principles required are an understanding of the photoelectric effect (by which E = ħω) and the de Broglie hypothesis (λ = h/p). Using these relationships, we show that one derivative of time is equal to a double derivative with respect to position, with a few proportionality factors mixed in. Thus, the TDSE for a free particle is just a statement that kinetic energy equals total energy . For a non-free particle (subject to a potential), potential must merely be added to the left-hand side of the equation, to yield kinetic energy plus potential energy equals total energy .

CRC Press eBooks•Jul 12, 2023•0 citations

Analysis of the causal behavior in energy transfer between atoms

Edwin Albert Power, T. Thirunamachandran

A critical analysis of the problem of causality in the energy transfer between a pair of atoms is carried out. One of the pair, the source, is initially excited and the other, the detector, is in its ground state. The probabilities are calculated for the detector to be excited at a later time $t$ under different experimental conditions. In the first, a precise specification is made of the state of the source and that of the radiation field at the observation time $t.$ In the second, the final state of the field is unspecified, whereas in the third, the state of neither the field nor the source is specified at time $t.$ These three cases correspond to predicting the outcomes of different experimental measurements. It is shown that of the three cases, only the third exhibits exact causal behavior. The other two are noncausal. The noncausal contributions to the probability arise from the correlation of vacuum fluctuations at the two atoms at different times in the interval 0 to $t.$ The probabilities for these cases can be significant for times slightly less than $R/c,$ where $R$ is the interatomic separation. Explicit expressions, correct to fourth order in the transition moments, for the probabilities in the three cases are given. A proof of strict causality to all orders is presented for the third case where the final measurement is solely made on the detector. In Appendix A the related problem of the time dependence of the electric energy density associated with the source is analyzed and shown to be causal.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1997•85 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Analysis of causality in time-dependent density-functional theory’ ”

Manoj K. Harbola

By employing the equation derived by Amusia and Shaginyan in their comment on our work, we show that the potential corresponding to a time-dependent density is a noncausal functional of the density. We further strengthen this conclusion on the basis of the exact equation satisfied by the density.

Physical Review A•Apr 11, 2001•2 citations

The Scattering Theory of the Schrödinger Equation

David Park

The Schrödinger equation for the scattered particle is converted into an integral equation, in which the kernel is obtained by the use of the condition that the events described by the solutions of the equation must be causally related, i.e., that causes must always precede the effects which they produce. The integral equation is iterated once, and it is found that its solution corresponds to the usual description of a scattering process in terms of an undeflected wave traversing the system plus a radially scattered wave moving outwards. In the second part, it is shown that a simple relation exists between solutions of Schrödinger's equation of the sort just described and the solution of the initial-value problem associated with the equation of motion for a free particle. By this means a solution of the scattering problem is set up which describes how the wave function develops as the wave which it describes propagates through the system. The series which results was first given by Feynman. As an example, the first Born approximation for the scattering problem is developed by each approach.

American Journal of Physics•May 1, 1952•1 citation

Optical Potentials for Inelastic Scattering from Many-Body Targets

L. S. Cederbaum

The standard text book Green's function possesses a self-energy that is known to be an optical potential for elastic scattering. The introduction of an optical potential reduces the complex many-body scattering problem into a tractable one-body problem. In this paper inelastic Green's functions are introduced and discussed which possess self-energies that are optical potentials for inelastic scattering. If the projectile is indistinguishable from particles comprising the target, intriguing aspects arise even for noninteracting particles.

Physical Review Letters•Oct 9, 2000•9 citations

An Application of Quantum Computing to Modeling Human Decision-Making

Joseph Fluegemann, Jiaqi Adam Huang, Raghavendra Pradyumna Pothukuchi +3 more

We present a quantum cognitive model that can be implemented on a quantum machine. This model uses solutions of the Schrödinger equation to model human cognitive control and decision making in a standard paradigm in psychology: the two-alternative forced-choice (2AFC) task, where participants are forced to choose between two competing alternatives. In the model, the two alternatives map to a multiple square well potential energy function. The depths of the wells correspond to attentional control, while the widths corresponds to features of the stimulus. Using this potential energy, the time-independent Schrodinger equation can be solved for an energy eigenstate basis of the bound states of the system, with higher energies corresponding to higher levels of focus. The full time-dependent Hamiltonian involves an oscillating field that evolves the system from ground state to superpositions of the excited states. The probabilities of the choices in the task are calculated as the probability of finding particles in a particular potential well. Furthermore, the quantum framing of this problem makes this problem suitable for mapping to quantum computing implementations. The state of the system follows the trajectory of a ground state, which can be mapped to a variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) implementation. Meanwhile, the time-dependency and oscillating field can be simulated using current quantum simulation methods and Rabi oscillations. Since our problems can be mapped onto currently-available NISQ prototypes of 2040 qubits, they represent an application domain with tractable near-term quantum-computing resource requirements.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Aug 30, 2025•0 citations
The time nonlocal optical potential is derived from first principles on the basis of a model of scattering of a particle from a target with several excited states. The time nonlocal potential involves an integral of the energy dependent potential derived from the model. One is free to choose any lower limit on the energy integration below the ground state of the combined system of target and projectile. For choices other than negative infinity, which gives the Fourier integral and a causal potential, the resulting potential is noncausal. The time dependent Schrodinger equation is nevertheless causal.
The Schrödinger equation was really postulated rather than derived. But we can see why it was postulated. It has been proven to be valid, in that it provides information about small, slow moving particles subject to a wide variety of potentials. The derivation of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation (TDSE) follows rather directly from assuming a free particle wave: Ψ = e i(kx-ωt) . If this wave function is plugged into the classical wave equation, and quantum principles are used, the two sides of the equation are not equal (this means this function does not "solve" the equation). The quantum principles required are an understanding of the photoelectric effect (by which E = ħω) and the de Broglie hypothesis (λ = h/p). Using these relationships, we show that one derivative of time is equal to a double derivative with respect to position, with a few proportionality factors mixed in. Thus, the TDSE for a free particle is just a statement that kinetic energy equals total energy . For a non-free particle (subject to a potential), potential must merely be added to the left-hand side of the equation, to yield kinetic energy plus potential energy equals total energy .
A critical analysis of the problem of causality in the energy transfer between a pair of atoms is carried out. One of the pair, the source, is initially excited and the other, the detector, is in its ground state. The probabilities are calculated for the detector to be excited at a later time ttt under different experimental conditions. In the first, a precise specification is made of the state of the source and that of the radiation field at the observation time t.t.t. In the second, the final state of the field is unspecified, whereas in the third, the state of neither the field nor the source is specified at time t.t.t. These three cases correspond to predicting the outcomes of different experimental measurements. It is shown that of the three cases, only the third exhibits exact causal behavior. The other two are noncausal. The noncausal contributions to the probability arise from the correlation of vacuum fluctuations at the two atoms at different times in the interval 0 to t.t.t. The probabilities for these cases can be significant for times slightly less than R/c,R/c,R/c, where RRR is the interatomic separation. Explicit expressions, correct to fourth order in the transition moments, for the probabilities in the three cases are given. A proof of strict causality to all orders is presented for the third case where the final measurement is solely made on the detector. In Appendix A the related problem of the time dependence of the electric energy density associated with the source is analyzed and shown to be causal.
The Schrödinger equation for the scattered particle is converted into an integral equation, in which the kernel is obtained by the use of the condition that the events described by the solutions of the equation must be causally related, i.e., that causes must always precede the effects which they produce. The integral equation is iterated once, and it is found that its solution corresponds to the usual description of a scattering process in terms of an undeflected wave traversing the system plus a radially scattered wave moving outwards. In the second part, it is shown that a simple relation exists between solutions of Schrödinger's equation of the sort just described and the solution of the initial-value problem associated with the equation of motion for a free particle. By this means a solution of the scattering problem is set up which describes how the wave function develops as the wave which it describes propagates through the system. The series which results was first given by Feynman. As an example, the first Born approximation for the scattering problem is developed by each approach.
The standard text book Green's function possesses a self-energy that is known to be an optical potential for elastic scattering. The introduction of an optical potential reduces the complex many-body scattering problem into a tractable one-body problem. In this paper inelastic Green's functions are introduced and discussed which possess self-energies that are optical potentials for inelastic scattering. If the projectile is indistinguishable from particles comprising the target, intriguing aspects arise even for noninteracting particles.
We present a quantum cognitive model that can be implemented on a quantum machine. This model uses solutions of the Schrödinger equation to model human cognitive control and decision making in a standard paradigm in psychology: the two-alternative forced-choice (2AFC) task, where participants are forced to choose between two competing alternatives. In the model, the two alternatives map to a multiple square well potential energy function. The depths of the wells correspond to attentional control, while the widths corresponds to features of the stimulus. Using this potential energy, the time-independent Schrodinger equation can be solved for an energy eigenstate basis of the bound states of the system, with higher energies corresponding to higher levels of focus. The full time-dependent Hamiltonian involves an oscillating field that evolves the system from ground state to superpositions of the excited states. The probabilities of the choices in the task are calculated as the probability of finding particles in a particular potential well. Furthermore, the quantum framing of this problem makes this problem suitable for mapping to quantum computing implementations. The state of the system follows the trajectory of a ground state, which can be mapped to a variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) implementation. Meanwhile, the time-dependency and oscillating field can be simulated using current quantum simulation methods and Rabi oscillations. Since our problems can be mapped onto currently-available NISQ prototypes of 2040 qubits, they represent an application domain with tractable near-term quantum-computing resource requirements.